6 ms·
> Eight hours of hoeing in a ditch supplies him with enough fuel to ride his vehicle for 20 km Hmm, this is an art project but you can cycle 20km fairly leisur
by helsinkiandrew 5y ago
> Eight hours of hoeing in a ditch supplies him with enough fuel to ride his vehicle for 20 km
Hmm, this is an art project but you can cycle 20km fairly leisurely in an hour.
8 hours of toiling in the ditches probably might be better used growing vegetables so your food isn’t being driven in?
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoMaybe, maybe not. It isn't like most folks can live off of a garden plot of a normal house, if you even have a garden plot. I cannot cycle 20km fairly leisurely in an hour: I live in a mountainous area, but lived most of my life on flat ground and going uphill is freaking difficult, even if I'm going at a leisurely speed - and sometimes, downhill is brakes all the way down. And I don't know how much this person drives. Most places I go to are within walking distance, and I'm pretty sure 8 hours of ditches would be less work than an entire summer of gardening (where I'd have to rent a plot, since I'm an apartment dweller). The majority of my foodstuffs are going to still be driven in, too.
- Hendrikto 5y ago> I cannot cycle 20km fairly leisurely in an hour: I live in a mountainous area Not a good counter argument. In this case, the moped will also use more fuel.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoSure, it isn't the best, but I know lots of other folks cannot either, and reasons vary. The point really is that cycling 20km isn't realistic for a wide swath of population. And sure, it might use more fuel... when you go uphill. Downhill, you might not even need the power.
- helsinkiandrew 5y agoFair enough, but my main point was that cycling or walking 20km probably consumes less energy than the “hard work” of harvesting methane for 8 hours.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoPossibly, but this isn't really the tradeoff. It is using energy when you have time to reap the benefits when you actually need the quick travel. 20km is going to take hours to walk in one trip.
- toomanybeersies 5y agoNow I'm imagining an alternate history/sci-fi planet where a neolithic society manages to effectively harness swamp gas (and eventually develop anaerobic digesters to produce it) as an energy source, instead of relying on timber/biomass.
- Scoundreller 5y ago> It isn't like most folks can live off of a garden plot of a normal house The trick is to grow for value and flavour, not staples/calories. Probably still a terrible $ yield. Nonetheless, I think the 1 abused apple tree is going give me months of apples.
- Xophmeister 5y agoOne could easily walk 20km in 8 hours.
- ChrisRR 5y agoAt an average pace you could walk 20km in half that time
- bbarnett 5y agoWhen I was growing up, we walked that to school each day, uphill, in a snowstorm!
- krab 5y agoOh, you lucky bastards! I could dream of walking to school. We were taking lessons in the snowstorm.
- King-Aaron 5y agoLuxury!
- Markoff 5y agomore like 3-4 hours at max, this seems terribly inefficient
- sdiq 5y ago5km per hour is easily doable, I believe. A group of us in high school once did that and covered about 105kms in 3 days. We walked just about 7 hours every day for those 3 days.
- photojosh 5y agoMy great-great-grandfather in the late 1800s got a land grant. I'm trying to work out how he got the farm started, because apparently he used to catch the train from his labourer job in the bit city, then walk 70km to his land.
- tyingq 5y agoI imagine he could improve it a lot. All that wood is making it pretty heavy. And it's a late 70s-era 4-stroke 50cc scooter. Something newer is probably more efficient.
- adamius 5y agoIs it just me or did anyone else see an opportunity for automating this? He seemed to be working up and down. A fully mechanical / hydraulic actuator could do this.
- larrydag 5y agoI would imagine a good use of a windmill could be use to pump and accumulate.
- ashtonkem 5y agoFor moving a single human being 20km, you could easily use a solar panel and an electric bike.
- adamius 5y agoI was trying to stay within the non-electric aspect of this. Solar isn’t exactly something you can make yourself. Methane however is vaguely doable given a bit of effort and skilling up. Edit: when I write "make" I don't mean "install".
- jhgb 5y agoYou can very easily do a solar installation yourself. But even more interestingly, even biomass-derived methane is more efficiently burned in a CCGT plant (>60% efficiency) to generate electricity for charging an e-bike than in an ICE engine on a moped (~20-25%?). And even better, a smart charger can charge an electric vehicle from an electric mix (NG/wind/solar/nuclear) optimally, so you can run from whatever is best at that moment.
- ashtonkem 5y agoFrom a global warming perspective, harvesting free methane and burning it is probably a net benefit given how much stronger methane is of a warming agent than the CO2 it burns into.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI know HN comments have a knack for trying to min/max and optimize something posted, but honestly that's not the point here. He's proving that it's possible to harvest methane from ponds, enough to power a moped. OF COURSE there's more efficient ways to get around, this isn't an attack on anyone's intellect or common sense and there's no need to react to getting nerdsniped by going "well ackchyually" and reinventing combustion engines and fuel from first principles. It's fine to just go "that's cool" and move on with your life. The guy that made this knows it's not the most efficient use of his time.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI agree with you, but I think part of the reason people have the reaction they do is that they start with the headline, which teases people into thinking this is something that is actually semi-viable, and then when they go in to read the article they find it is basically an art project, so there is this dissonance between expectations and reality. I almost feel like we need a "Show HN an Art Project:"-like headline prefix.
- geoduck14 5y agoSerious question, why would you use a throwaway account for a comment like this?
- NegativeLatency 5y agoMaybe the name is just a joke? user: hn_throwaway_99 created: February 20, 2017 karma: 28836
- ineedasername 5y agoReally any account with less than 100k karma is practically a throwaway account.
- coding123 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]