6 ms·
Looking at the ad they placed, I'd have considered this ad as a scam. Starting an ad with [safe] tells me that the product is instead unsafe. Safeapps.io isn't
by jeroenhd 5y ago
Looking at the ad they placed, I'd have considered this ad as a scam. Starting an ad with [safe] tells me that the product is instead unsafe. Safeapps.io isn't exactly a very convincing domain either. The, uh, "design language" the website uses would be the final nail in the coffin.
The entire thing just looks like a badly built scam. Every individual decision can maybe be explained as a branding or design choice, but the end product just doesn't look reliable.
I don't think Google gives a shit about your blog articles about how Google is bad, every tech company has written one of those at this point. They're also not as much anti-privacy, they're anti-anti-anti-privacy. A privacy focused product is fine, a product that prevents Google from stalking you not so much.
It'd definitely be a false positive, but the truth is that if I saw this ad, I'd definitely click the "report" button.
- smoldesu 5y agoI'm 100% behind you on this. Worth noting that while the app does appear to be open-source, there appears to be no way for you to self-host the service at the moment. Regardless of how scammy it actually is, funneling every user into a $60/year subscription service is one of the biggest scamming tactics I've seen on the web.
- dkzlv 5y agoIs it a scam to charge a price for a product? We're freemium. You're not forced to get a subscription right away. You can even use the product without it at all. > there appears to be no way for you to self-host the service at the moment We will provide such an option if there will be any demand. For now it would just waste a lot of our time without any real output. Still, you can do this if you want.
- smoldesu 5y agoConsider this the beginning of the demand, then: I'm not going to use this service unless I can self-host it.
- dkzlv 5y agoIf you're interested in this, please reach me out at dan@safeapps.io. I need some more information to move it up in the backlog, maybe you could help us with that?
- smoldesu 5y agoWhy do I need to help you with this? Your website says that you can "run your own instance", is this false advertising or not?
- alisonkisk 5y agoHuh? The website says "Run your own instance."
- QuercusMax 5y agoYou're not wrong about the look and feel of that website - I would run far far away before I gave money to a website that looks that scammy. (disclaimer: I work for Google, in a division that has nothing to do with ads.)
- dkzlv 5y agoWhat is it that you don't like about the design? I just tried not to follow the common guidelines for the design and make the design more… developer friendly?
- QuercusMax 5y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "developer friendly" (monospace font?) but it doesn't look like a financial services site I'd trust. The rainbow borders which change on hover and that stuff screams "my first time playing with CSS", not "you should trust us with your $$". Also, the name and domain seem like you're compensating for something, or trying to trick people. If a bank has big signs saying, "No, we won't steal your money, promise" that opens up a whole lot of questions. Why do you need to put "safe" all over the place? Is there some reason I should think it isn't safe?
- dkzlv 5y ago> screams "my first time playing with CSS", not "you should trust us with your $$". Lol :) Thanks for your honest feedback! The app looks more traditional, btw. (https://imgur.com/a/KabWkNS https://imgur.com/a/KabWkNS) Based on the feedback here I will probably change the landing page to something more traditional. > Also, the name and domain seem like you're compensating for something, or trying to trick people Wow, that is the opposite thing we were aiming for. There are a lot of other apps that provide the same value while being completely unsafe to use. We're just emphasizing on the core value. Strange to hear that it causes the opposite reaction.
- lesquivemeau 5y agoI think this comic is a good abstract of the problem with writing [safe] everywhere: https://xkcd.com/641/ https://xkcd.com/641/
- crazygringo 5y agoSeriously. The first couple times I read it, anything about "anonymous" "encrypted" "finance" sounds like this is either going to lead to paying for drugs or it's going to steal your money. And Google bans certain types of cryptocurrency ads. After reading it a third time, I realize I guess it's just an open-source version of Mint? But the author provides zero evidence that Google bans ads for "privacy-first services". It was probably classified as a crypto scam or similar. Just write a better ad that's clearer about what it's actually advertising, for goodness' sake. And make the product's website a bit more professional looking too -- it looks like a scam. There's no way I'd trust my finance credentials to anybody who built a site that looks like... a weirdly updated version of a GeoCities page?
- dkzlv 5y agoHi there! I'm the founder of this app. > After reading it a third time, I realize I guess it's just an open-source version of Mint? Well, not a great sigh for us, but at least… you guessed right! > But the author provides zero evidence that Google bans ads for "privacy-first services". It was probably classified as a crypto scam or similar. I made this conclusion based on the information provided by my friends working in Google and Microsoft. Again, there's no way I can reliably say the _real_ reason because all Google said was "Unacceptable Business Practice" linking to this page. (https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6020955?hl=en#36 https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6020955?hl=en#36...) That's actually more or less the point of the article: you get banned for life for no apparent reason. Is that how it's supposed to be? > it looks like a scam What is it that you don't like about the design? I just tried not to follow the common guidelines for the design and make the design more… developer friendly?
- throwaway3699 5y agoIf it looks like a scam, then false positives are unavoidable. These companies are trying to protect average people from being scammed on their services, and I would honestly prefer they keep doing this. I do not want to spend hours on the phone to the bank with a shaken grandparent again (after they get cryptoscammed). Claiming they are against "privacy-first services" is just creating a victim narrative where one does not exist. As people keep saying here on this very website, these platforms do not owe you a microphone. Also, just one bit of advice, most developer types will have adblockers, so you're really not going to have a great time trying to target them with adverts.
- autoexec 5y agoI don't see anything about the overall design of the site that makes it look scammy. It looks pretty clean and even works well with JS disabled. If only every open source project had a site that nice! One red flag I did notice was some awkward phrases/english. "Phones support" "This is why you need an open community that will point at your lies or convinces newcomers this app is safe." "...if you’re not a new kid in the block"
- oehpr 5y agoautoexec was downvoted but looking at the site doesn't strike me as an obvious scam. https://safeapps.io/ https://safeapps.io/ Could someone please elaborate on the aspects you feel are deeply obvious to the point of not pointing them out? I seem to be missing them as well.
- QuercusMax 5y agoThe graphic design on the page is extremely amateurish. Rainbow borders, weird typeface choices, misaligned elements - somebody else said it looks like something from Geocities, and that's pretty accurate. Compared to mint.com, which I guess it's competing with, it looks unprofessional and something I wouldn't want to trust my sensitive data with. Just imagine if there were a new bank which was decorated like... a head shop, or strip club, or something like that. Would you want to bank there?
- wruza 5y agoCompared to mint.com Which greets you with a “please close me” popdown, stutters because of a video, which plays below transparent text, jumps around at vertical scroll and couldn’t prevent it on horizontal carousels. That looks unprofessional. Not to mention nauseous light-light-bleached green colorscheme. (I guess it ought to resemble mint)
- Bjartr 5y agoI think it's more how they aren't following the unwritten "corporate website" aesthetics playbook and looks way more artsy, even fly-by-night (I think that's largely up to the use of a monospace font). Which is technically fine. However if you're told someone you're about to be shown a money management site and show them this you'll get some raised eyebrows, similar to how if you told them they're about to see a bank teller and you showed them someone in a tie-dyed tshirt.
- dkzlv 5y agoHi there! I'm the founder of this app. It's very upsetting that you found us scam-alike. It was never meant to be this way. If anything, we're trying to be the opposite: we open-sourced the whole app, we do not ask for your email during sign up, we wrote a post about our security measures in details (https://safeapps.io/content/security https://safeapps.io/content/security). We'll work on our marketing to be more… convincing?
- jeroenhd 5y agoI don't believe your app is a scam, I think it's just a combination of unfortunate design and language decisions. Your product seems absolutely fine to me, and I have no doubts about the technical measures you've taken. The first thing that comes to mind for building a better reputation is probably your branding. Picking "safe" as a software brand gives off a paradoxical feeling of unsafety, in the "[safe] free Windows 12 download [open source][free!!].dll.bat.exe" kind of way. Adding a tag like [safe] or [free] or (recommended) is something spammers and scammers do to try to convince their victims to click. I don't think you can pull something like that off without being a well-known brand first, not with that brand name. Matrix.org, for example, has the [Matrix] brackets as a brand, but the word "matrix" isn't used for anything dubious. Their links also don't use the [brand] marking in their ads. Because of all this, I think your brand (unintentionally) mimics a lot of scam ads, which is why my first thought would be "this is a scam, report". Your website, "safeapps.io", has a feeling I associate with "securefiles.com" or "freewindowsupdatez.net" for much of the same reasons. Your TLD, .io, is very popular for modern (web) developers but when I think about my bank details, the British Indian Ocean Territory isn't exactly what comes to mind. Perhaps a minor detail few people will fall over, but it's kind of ironic to have the TLD of a remote island nation for a financial software package :) Perhaps I'm not your target audience, but I want any service I trust with information about my finances to be professional. Your website seems inspired by popular, modern, energetic branding, the kind I'd expect from a soda brand or a kids' commercial. I'd personally much prefer a boring, run-of-the-mill Bootstrap theme with some added branding over the artsy website you've created. That's just a personal preference, of course; maybe you want to show that you're not one of those stuffy bankers, and maybe I'm just too boring to get that. Modern marketing has shown that this strategy definitely attracts some people. In the end, I'm just a random voice on the Internet. I'm no marketeer, I've never met any investors, and I don't run paid service of my own. You probably shouldn't base your entire marketing campaign on my ramblings. I do think you should think about your branding, though, especially the way you present it in ads, and consider picking a brand name that's not as easy to confuse with a link that'll install malware. Besides, you can probably use a more recognisable brand name than "safe money". "[SOTANY]" or many other words from thisworddoesnotexist.com probably work a lot better for a software brand than "[safe]"!