11 ms·
Internet outages in Cuba following widespread anti-government protests
- oxymoran 5y agoAnd just the other day the media was telling us how prosperous and successful Cuba is after they developed their own vaccine. If that was true, why in a period of days are there now “widespread anti government protest”? Also, why do people feel the need to flee the island on boats?
- sudosysgen 5y agoBecause they can't make enough of them. How long did it take between the end of Phase 3 trials and you getting your first dose? Beyond that, Cuba's economy is in shambles as there is no tourism to make money from and as covid restrictions are incredibly strict while cases are increasing. If you've never had the chance to live as an average citizen in an average developing country it's hard to understand, but actually fleeing on boats is really not uncommon. Where I'm from people that can't even swim take discarded water bottles, stuff them under their t-shirts, and swim 40km to richer countries, for purely economic reasons. When you don't have enough money for a plane ticket, you don't have the choice, and it's a lot more common in the world than you think. Cuba doesn't even have emigration rates that are out of the norm for poor countries close to rich countries.
- hooplah 5y agoCuba isn't in shambles because it's a developing country, it's in shambles because of it's communistic repressive regime. Cuba's government sends doctors to other countries for the money while ignoring their own citizens. Just as Venezuela's collapse was due to Maduro's communistic regime and led to the influx of immigrants to the US, Cuba suffered the same fate since the Castro regime. Yes people from poverty stricken countries do sometimes flee to richer countries for a better life, but oppressive regimes cause fleeing on a massive scale. Look at what's causing the poverty. Is it developing and getting better, or is it oppressed by a corrupt government and getting worst. -- edit for other's saying it's the embargo's fault -- The sanctions are in place because of their human rights violations. We cannot condone their corrupt government. With truly democratic elections and a capitalistic system they'd allow their citizens to gain wealth without taxing them into poverty and they'd also gain sanction relief because they allowed the freedom to pursue happiness. Lots of communism apologizing in this thread. Pointing the finger at the embargo like the regime always does, while pointing it away from the human rights violations. Cuba fell because of communism. Venezuela fell because of communism. Both were economic powerhouses in the region before. Sanctions came after the fact.
- etc-hosts 5y agoThe sanction are in place because of the US's long time hatred of the Cuba government. We're still mad about the 1959 land reforms.
- hooplah 5y agoThat is a lie. We're "mad" about Castro seizing power and nationalizing everything under his oppressive regime. Human rights violations: https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2020/country-chapters/cuba https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2020/country-chapters/cuba Cuba sanctions: https://www.state.gov/cuba-sanctions/ https://www.state.gov/cuba-sanctions/ Are you suggesting JFK had an ulterior motive?
- etc-hosts 5y agoMost of the valuable agricultural land that Castro nationalized was owned by US businesses. The people working the land did not own the land. The US businesses ended up owning the land because of the Spanish American War.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> The sanctions are in place because of their human rights violations. We cannot condone their corrupt government. The regime can end the sanctions at any time: simply allow for democracy and return the stolen property. It's that simple. That they would prefer their people risking their lives on rafts and starving should tell us all something about the Castros.
- sergiotapia 5y agoCuba is in shambles because of communism and communist ideals.
- sudosysgen 5y agoPerhaps. I've lived in capitalist developing countries that were even poorer - hence people stuffing water bottles in their shirt - so I can't honestly conclude that it is the reason.
- seanicus 5y agoYou're taking way too much of a good faith reading that comment. There's way more nuance than "communism bad," though it is very true that sanctions and the Castros and their cronies have both done great harm to Cuba.
- seanicus 5y agoCuba has been in shambles since, at the very least, Batista came to power in a CIA-backed coup with monetary help from organized crime. After his government was overthrown all of that money dried up and the sanctions imposed (with no attempt at diplomacy) have choked the country out until this day. Yes, what little money comes in is siphoned off by the crooked Castro government, but there's a lot more to the history of Cuba and Latin America than "communism bad."
- loloquwowndueo 5y agoRight, with a capitalist system they’d laugh in the face of the economic blockades.
- jollybean 5y agoIt's not a 'Blockade', which would normally mean someone trying to stop anyone/anything from entering or leaving. US Embargo against Cuba would surely be a drag on even a 'regular capitalist economy' - but at they same time they'd do just fine with it. They can trade anything with any of the other 180 nations of the world. Most prosperous nations don't trade that-that much with the US. And if they were open and fair, there'd be no embargo. Stop defending this murderous regime there are no excuses for them.
- alentist 5y ago> fleeing on boats is really not uncommon To escape a country, or to enter a country? The example you gave is the latter. Do you have any examples of the former?
- pjc50 5y ago... how do you propose escaping without then entering somewhere else? Same thing, surely?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoExcept for motive. Consider the saying "People don't leave jobs, they leave bosses." Sure, you're getting a new job, not just leaving an old one. But what they're really doing is leaving that jerk of a boss. In the same way, you can be "going to America", or you can be "escaping from Cuba". Same thing in terms of actions, but not at all the same in terms of motive.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI don't exactly follow. When my family emigrated from an impoverished North African nation, we were escaping poverty and dysfunction just as much as we were going to richer countries.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoSure, it can be both at once. But it doesn't have to be. Let's say I'm in Venezuela, and I'm tired of the "Maduro diet", i.e., borderline starvation. I'll go to Colombia or Brazil, or Guyana. Or I'll go through Colombia to Panama or Peru or Ecuador. Any of the above. I'm leaving Venezuela more than I'm going to somewhere. In contrast, consider the caravans that show up at the southern US border. They're often from Honduras. But the people in them didn't stop at Guatemala or Belize or Mexico. No, they're coming to the US, not just leaving Honduras.
- 5y ago
- jollybean 5y agoCuba is only a 'developing economy' because of Castro's oppression. Otherwise, it should probably be above Brazil and Argentina in terms of standard of living. It would be the highest in central/south America alongside Chile. Nature maagazine had a bit on their vaccine here [1]. It's not unreasonable or 'bad journalism' at the same time, it's biased towards them with no hard questions, making excuses, and soft-balling them questions on the embargo etc. and finally it doesn't address or put into context the overwhelmingly negative outcomes which are a result of the regimes power. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01126-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01126-4
- sudosysgen 5y agoPerhaps it would have been, perhaps it wouldn't. There is no way to know, most likely it would have reverted towards the norm. Cuba has always been in very dire situations politically, I see no reason why Castro wouldn't have been replaced by someone else and then someone else etc... As far as the embargo I don't think you can really separate it. Countries with more oppressive dictatorships have been able to develop economically if given the chance to trade.
- TheAceOfHearts 5y agoYou don't think the US embargo on Cuba played a significant role in stifling their economic growth and development?
- jollybean 5y agoThe embargo is not the driving factor really. Castro is a ruthless despotic killer. The entire economy is under his thumb, most of the prosperous larger scale enterprises are run by the Army. He purposely forbade minor economic activity (i.e. shops, trades) that would normally form 1/2 of the entire economic base. Some of this has loosened up. You can't blame a blockade for not having mechanics available to fix cars when being a mechanic is defacto outlawed. If Cuban were an open economy, even with crappy authoritarian leadership and and embargo, it would probably prosper. Trading with other nations has some 'essential' aspects, but mostly it's not necessary, it's just advantageous. And there's no reason to have to trade with any one nation, generally. Cuba might need very specific equipment from in order to advance some parts of the economy - for example, many factories need equipment only made in Germany as one example, the same thing applies to US sourcing. This would be acquired through intermediaries. But by and large, trade would come in commodities, tourism etc. none of which is 'essential' between US and Cuba. Not having the US to trade with is a drag, but anything that Cuba would actually need (i.e. specialized tech) would be purchased through intermediaries. Definitely foreign direct investment and tourism would hamper things, but not by some kind of existential amount. Castro Inc. is 100% the problem there, that people continue to defend them in some way is astonishing and shameful frankly.
- kjaleshire 5y agoCastro annihilated the land-owning middle class in the first years of his premiership [1], using the same playbook as Lenin wrt the Kulaks after the October revolution [2]: do away with the financially and thus politically independent asap. Cuba consistently required Soviet subsidies to survive through the end of the 20th century [3]. That's all gone now. [1] http://revolutions.truman.edu/cuba/aboutme.htm http://revolutions.truman.edu/cuba/aboutme.htm [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekulakization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dekulakization [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_Period
- sudosysgen 5y agoMore accurately, Cuba traded with the Soviet Union and received food in exchange for its exports. I don't think Cuba was ever fully self-sufficient in food before, either. Other than that you are correct about land reform in Cuba.
- etc-hosts 5y agoBefore Castro took over, almost half of all agricultural land in Cuba was owned by US businesses. The agricultural workers almost all lived in shacks without power or plumbing. There's a reason Castro was so popular at the time. In exchange, Castro offered long term bonds, but I don't think anyone accepted.
- 908B64B197 5y agoAnd yet, you look at Hawaii, what was in a very similar situation, and a very different scenario occurred during the last century. Pretty sure if you offered Hawaiians and Cubans the possibility to switch places, many Cubans would want to do it, but not many Hawaiians!
- sudosysgen 5y agoI don't see what's your point, that the US should invade Cuba against the will of their residents and incorporate it as the 52nd state so that eventually 50 years later the kids of the current generation may be favourable to it?
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Because they can't make enough of them Or because they don't work. The only ones to claim that it worked were the state owned media, regime and regime-controlled hospitals. There's a pretty good chance it either doesn't work and the regime is trying to save face or that they copied a western vaccine and are trying to replicate it. They need US dollars from tourism so they have to get the population vaccinated as soon as possible or else the food shortages will get even worse.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI think this is fairly unlikely. If that was the case, Cuba wouldn't be negotiating with Vietnam to manufacture it. I think it's almost certain that it is an effective vaccine.
- imstate 5y agoBecause the media is willfully lying.
- blacktriangle 5y agoConan O'Brian and his bullshit "Everything is great in Haiti!" stunt seriously should have convinced even the most trusting that yes, the media, from "news" to entertainment, is lying.
- seanicus 5y agoYes, well known journalist Conan O'Brien is who I seek when I am forming my opinions on geopolitics Also I'm guessing the purpose of the Conan piece was to 1) rebuke Trump for calling it a shithole - rude, unproductive, and should be below the station of the POTUS - and also help drive tourism, which I'm assuming is the nation's main source of income, by showing a fancy resort, as opposed to what's usually shown on news; a destitute country leveled by natural disasters seemingly yearly. Not on Conan to show the other side of the resort.
- lupire 5y ago> Your search - Conan O'Brien "Everything is great in Haiti!" - did not match any documents.
- pjc50 5y agoI've got to say I missed that announcement entirely?
- seanicus 5y agoNo sarcasm: can you point me to a mainstream news outlet referred to Cuba as prosperous? Both things can be true; Cuba successfully developed it's own vaccine, which is impressive for a country is said to be economically far worse off than most of the Caribbean. It's not on journalists to bring up the plight of Cubans in an article where the subject matter is totally unrelated to the issues of food shortages. You'll be hard pressed to find any mention of cutting of social welfare programs, food deserts, lack of jobs, or a failing school system in an article about weekend shooting numbers in Chicago's South Side because that's not germane to the stats. Certainly things are and have been bad in Cuba for a very long time. Much of the country is destitute and it's notable that the people demonstrate against the gov't over (amongst other things) food shortages, which had been endemic to life in Cuba since Castro came into power. A well-known joke in Cuba goes like this: "What were the first 3 sacrifices to the revolution? Breakfast, lunch, & dinner."
- long_time_gone 5y agoCould you please share some of these stories from "the media"?
- hooplah 5y agoHN frontpage 15 days ago, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27653868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27653868 The propaganda hit MSN, Nature, NYTimes, and many other media outlets and those hit social media (FB, HN, Reddit, etc.) https://www.msn.com/en-xl/news/other/cubas-covid-vaccine-rivals-biontech-pfizer-moderna/ar-AALuCEK https://www.msn.com/en-xl/news/other/cubas-covid-vaccine-riv... https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01126-4 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01126-4 Really easy to see: https://search.brave.com/search?q=Cuba%27s+COVID+vaccine+rivals https://search.brave.com/search?q=Cuba%27s+COVID+vaccine+riv... edit: I see the top comment was flagged and deleted. It violated no rules and was simply pointing out the propaganda that hit the media that I listed above. Sad state of discourse on this site, regardless of who is moderating, dang or the users who abuse flagging.
- tus89 5y agoBecause it's a brutal communist dictatorship?
- graeme 5y agoVaccine research isn’t food. Cuba is good at vaccine research. They are not good at producing food or material goods, and living standards have taken a further hit during the pandemic as tourism fell off. It shouldn’t be hard to separate simple ideas. Communist countries were usually good at some things even though bad at most. The soviets produced good research, sports, film, and artistic talent. And atrocious living standards.
- avereveard 5y agoIt just became another "it wasn't real communism" country but at least the protesters have had great dental care.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paganel 5y agoThe Americans did it better on their home turf by targeting and banning specific hashtags and I guess location check-ins. They also have an advantage over the Cubans because they nicely outsourced all this to private entities like Facebook/Google/Twitter. I'm talking about the whole Trump election bruhaha and the accompanying Capitol protests (conveniently and almost immediately labeled as an "insurrection").
- jdavis703 5y agoThere are instances where government agencies have shut down communications during protests (e.g. BART). But I’m not aware of any US government orders shutting down internet access on Jan. 6. Care to share some sources?
- sudosysgen 5y agoI think they refer to private companies using moderation tools to prevent communication, coordination and encouragement of riots and insurrection that effectively achieved what other governments by blocking access to apps or forcing the moderation. Depending on your ideology, it may be a good thing that the companies did it by themselves without requiring government force to do it, but I think the argument that these are similar actions in their purpose and effect is fairly accurate.
- not2b 5y agoNo, your comparison is not accurate; the most dangerous insurrectionists' communication means were not disrupted. They were mainly using platforms that weren't moderating them and made key plans using end to end encryption and direct messaging. Only a total Internet shutdown would disrupt that. And forcing a private company to facilitate violence to keep a defeated president in office against its will would itself be totalitarian.
- sudosysgen 5y agoNot really, the most powerful tool of the insurrectionists were definitely mass-media. The attempt was to draw sympathy amongst politically receptive groups and to amass numbers, not to have a small but very well organized group conduct a coup. As far as common-carrier mandates being totalitarian, as I said, that's just one ideological viewpoints. Most European countries were quite shocked that the US allowed Trump to be banned.
- tehjoker 5y agoEnd the embargo on Cuba. Support the Cuban Revolution. If Cuba is missing material goods, it is because the US government has been strangling them for decades by shutting them out of the system of international trade. During the early pandemic, Cuba has sent doctors to Italy when the US did nearly nothing. They have produced their own vaccine candidate on a tiny island nation. Imagine what they could do if we lifted the embargo and they could flourish. Don't be too confident that the protests are not simply right-wing Cubans eager to take back their lands, casinos, and slaves. I'm sure the pandemic has put pressure on the people and government however. The main thing Cuba has done to anger the US government is violate the Monroe Doctrine, which states that the US should control everything in its backyard. The Cuban people took matters into their own hand and charted a different course. We should not seek to interfere in their affairs.
- nickff 5y agoCuba experiences shortages because the economy is in shambles. Australia is far from its trading partners, yet it remains rich. Distance from rich trading partners is not the problem here.
- pjc50 5y agoIsn't it still subject to sanctions?
- nickff 5y agoCuba is closer to rich trading partners (like the EU) than the Australia is to its rich trading partners (like the USA). Each also has poorer trading partners nearby (SE Asian countries and Central American countries respectively).
- pjc50 5y agoDistance is kind of irrelvant. What is more relevant are the sanctions, maybe? https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2020/10/united-states-expands-cuban-assets-control-regulations https://www.hklaw.com/en/insights/publications/2020/10/unite... https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/sanctions-programs-and-country-information/cuba-sanctions https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/financial-sanctions/... "WARNING: TOUR PACKAGES FOR SCUBA DIVING, BICYCLING, HUNTING, FISHING, HIKING OR OTHER TOURIST TRAVEL IN CUBA ARE ILLEGAL" https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/126/cubatrav.pdf https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/126/cubatrav.pdf (from the previous page)
- up_o 5y agoShout-out to the CIA contractors raising awareness online. You'll get em this time for sure.
- adolfojp 5y agoHow condescending do you have to be to attribute any act of dissent from Cubans towards their own government as an act of interference from the USA? Do Cubans have no agency of their own? No free will? No intelligence to determine for themselves whether their own political system suits them or not? Do you think that Cubans who don't agree with your political beliefs are too stupid to know better or corrupt and bought?
- nyczomg 5y agoI'm not sure, but the person you're replying to might be implying that the CIA is busy online "raising awareness" and by that they sarcastically mean that the CIA is conducting an online misinformation campaign to discredit the people on the ground protesting. I might be wrong though.
- snypher 5y agoIf they had true agency the US would drop the sanctions and let them do as they please. Unfortunately the US loves to have a finger in every pie, and blaming the local population isn't the answer.
- adolfojp 5y agoEmbargo bad doesn't make Cuban government good and the Cuban people can rally against both. The embargo is not responsible for Cuba's repression of the press, their repression of political dissent, their single party political system, the unchanging leaders from 1959 to 2018, or of Cuba's government own mismanagement of things. No one is talking about blaming the Cubans for their woes. We're talking about the right and capacity of the Cuban people to rally against their own government if they wish.
- deleted 5y ago
- 908B64B197 5y agoIt's interesting to see what's happening in Cuba when, thanks to the pandemic, foreign tourism grinds to a halt. The Castro regime just can't cope without having USD coming in the country via the state owned resorts. Starvation, riots, empty stores and people risking it all on makeshift rafts just so they can land somewhere better and send remittances to their family still stuck on the island so they can buy medicine. These protests might finally be the start of a true Cuban revolution where the island will propel itself forward toward prosperity.
- sudosysgen 5y agoI'm not as hopeful as you are. I shared your hope but recent revolutions as well as history have shown that the most likely result of a revolution is things becoming even worse. Cuba has been slowly but surely allowing more democracy and more economic freedom. I think that by far the best outcome for Cuban residents is for this process to continue peacefully without the massive destruction as well as the definitive end of the embargo.
- 908B64B197 5y agoThe current regime could end the embargo right away by choosing a democratic future.
- sudosysgen 5y agoNo, it could not. The real standard for ending the embargo is aligning with American geopolitical goals. The US doesn't embargo undemocratic states, it embargoes geopolitical enemies. That's the one and only standard. The US is quite happy to trade with undemocratic states if they do align with US interests though.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The current regime could end the embargo right away by choosing a democratic future. Not if a basically Communist (or otherwise ideologically oe geopolitically unacceptable to the US, but that's the most likely example in this case) regime won democratically, as the US has shown time and again (and also shown that right-wing authoritarian-capitalist anti-democratic regimes are not ideologically unacceptable, and are tolerable if willing to geopolitically align with the US.)
- rmanolis 5y agoWhy do they need the communist party? Democracies can do far better jobs for example Norway, Sweden, Germany, Singapore etc. And if the embargo is the only problem, why then the Communist Party does not step down? It is not like they wanted to import capitalist goods like Coca Cola, iPhones, Nike etc. Communist party likes the embargo.
- aaomidi 5y agoAll of those examples you listed rely on a the global south to keep their lifestyles going. Embargos aren't just for "capitalist goods". "Communism" isn't against trade. There are some raw materials that a country the size of Cuba can never get without meaningful trade.
- rmanolis 5y agoWhy should USA trade only raw materials, when it does not need any?
- aaomidi 5y agoIt's not the US. The US threatens to sanction any country doing business with Cuba. It also heavily limits who can do business with Cuba. The US is a massive economic force basically pushing Cuba to adopt a political model that the US wants.
- hooplah 5y agoHave you spoken to any person who escaped Cuba? I bet you haven't, because they'll all tell you they escaped because the oppressive regime, not because of poverty. The sanctions are there for the same reasons we have sanctions against North Korea, trading with murderous regimes is condoning their actions. Listen to the protests and the Cuban people, you may learn something. Hint: they're chanting "freedom", not "relieve sanctions". They're protesting their government, not ours. But please tell me more how the Cuban people are uninformed and you understand the conflict better.
- etc-hosts 5y agoIf you want more back story... or actually just the story of how much the US has pushed Cuba around for decades, please listen to Season 2 of Blowback https://blowback.show/ https://blowback.show/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/blowback-podcast-cuban-revolution-interview-1156205/ https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-news/blowback-p...
- ErneX 5y agoCubans deserve freedom after 63 years under the Castro regime, regardless of whatever fanatics of such regimes living in modern democracies say.