4 ms·
Only for billing cost of procedures. It's still a mess. Did you know that hospitals make money by using name brand medications? They will get a contract with a
by giantg2 5y ago
Only for billing cost of procedures. It's still a mess.
Did you know that hospitals make money by using name brand medications? They will get a contract with a brand, like Motrin, and charge you full price at $8 a pill. Then Motrin will will evaluate how much the hospital used and give them a big rebate to bring the hospital's cost down under $1 per pill. You can literally buy a bottle of ibuprofen for what they charge for a single pill, but of course in the name of safety (and really kickbacks too) they won't allow the cheaper outside medication. It's effectively an internal monopoly.
- revscat 5y agoI’m not sure what your point is. These contracts between seller and merchant were voluntary. There are other hospitals available should you choose, and if not then you have no one to blame but yourself.
- alisonkisk 5y agoAre you trolling? A hospital has even more lock in than the App Store. They can literally legally lock you in.
- raspasov 5y agoAt least in the US, that would have to go through a court. I don't think a hospital can force you to stay in.
- giantg2 5y agoThey mean lock you in to their services only. Once you're in there you're forced to pay for whatever services they provide, which could be a lot in an emergency or if your unconscious. I think they were also referencing the idea that you are forced to pay a high amount for Motrin, when an alternate source would be much cheaper.
- giantg2 5y agoNot everywhere has multiple hospitals to choose from. Even if there are multiple hospitals, your insurance might influence your choices too. And at the end of the day, if you're incapacitated, they will just take you to wherever is closest. The point was that the hospitals are doing things behind the scenes that are not well known that affect the pricing. In this example, they charge you more for using name brand medication and then get a kickback to make money for themselves.
- ModernMech 5y ago> These contracts between seller and merchant were voluntary. I'm guessing you've never been placed on an involuntary psych hold, or woken up at a hospital after an accident left you incapacitated.
- dralley 5y agoThe hospital you end up in is not a free market and usually it's not even a choice. Anyone who who gets in a car accident, falls off a roof, has a heart attack will be lucky to still be conscious when the ambulance picks them up, much less in a state of mind to be considering the relative merits.
- dantheman 5y agoYet emergency care is relatively small portion of health care costs - so maybe deal with that last. It'd be hard for hospitals to make the case that emergency care is substantially more costly than similar procedures they offer.
- unishark 5y agoEven for ER visits alone, it's not true that patients are "usually" incapacitated or on the verge of death. Something like a third aren't even urgent and only a small percentage are admitted to the hospital. And the most common reasons for visits are mostly pain complaints with a conscious patient. On average people get triaged to the waiting room to wait for 40 minutes or whatever. There was a thread here a while back about something like an emergency-mode uber for replacing ambulances for most ER trips. Something similar might also be done for shopping for cheaper urgent care too perhaps. Say a clinic that is open late and will check out your scary rash/cough/pain without charging so much.
- vletal 5y agoIn Czechia we have sufficient capacity of ambulances and other emergency services. What happens is that off peak they serve to help move old people to hospital, like a super expensive taxi. In these cases I can see how "emergency Uber" could help. On the other hand the doctors serving in these ambulances are usually extremely well prepared, the best MD students go to study to serve there. Even if it is one in a hundred cases, they will recognize the stroke from a random chest pain. Replacing them would surely increase the death rate in these cases...
- LimaBearz 5y agoI love how conservatives still make this argument. You're arguing for the free market in a system that literally isn't, and doing it in such a way that it tries to be a thought-terminating cliche. If you get into a car accident tomorrow driving to work, the ambulance/paramedics aren't going to ask you to do your research prior to shuttling you to a hospital to get life saving treatment. Even if you could how would you be able to tell which hospital has what price structure, what services you'll actually need given your medical condition, and what arrangements they have with various drug manufacturers and how that relates to what you require to help your condition. Save it.. "no one to blame but yourself" is so incredibly idiotic is comical. Take something even more benign, like someone falling and breaking/straining something. Wanna still do your research first? Is it a sprain, fracture, break? How do you know? Is it clear cut? What pain medication will you need? Will you require surgery? What lab work will you need? How many tests will you need? X-rays? CAT scan? MRI? What kind of surgeon? How many nurses? Will you require blood? Whats the recovery like? What about follow up visits? Do you expect us all to practice free market principles and know all that crap in advance for price discovery before deciding to seek treatment? True free market principles require an asymmetry of information for the system to work, and even "fathers" of the theory understood that and acknowledge the need for regulation when its absent.
- Karsteski 5y agoI agree with the premise of your argument, but why did you have to start it with "I love how conservatives still make this argument"? You have no idea what that person's thoughts or beliefs are...
- ozfive 5y agoBecause this is the premise of the conservative argument. The thoughts are clearly conveyed.
- visualradio 5y agoPrice transparency regulations could also be used to implement public price controls or public fines on monopolies engaging in price discrimination. For instance if a provider billed a patient over 100% of their stated price or over 120% the minimum price for the same item published by comparable providers, there might be some public fine or tax on the biller and rebate to the patient in proportion to the entire amount by which the patient was over-billed regardless of their insurance status. This would possibly amount to something similar to universal public price negotiation. But yes the idea of using pricing transparency to suppress over-billing by monopolies could possibly be interpreted as suggesting a rejection of the alternative idea of centrally fixing all consumer facing prices using a public office and then determining all government facing prices from external suppliers providing necessary inputs for the public healthcare system through minimum bid.
- pfisch 5y agoIs this supposed to be satire or are you so disconnected from reality that you think this makes sense?
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y agoI’ve actually tried to “shop around” for hospitals and it’s basically impossible. Just about everything is hidden behind some barrier and there’s just no way to effectively compare prices. Additionally, you really have no idea what products or services you’ll end up receiving while at the hospital. Most importantly, ALL of this planning and sense of choice goes out the window when you have a true emergency. When that happens all that matters is getting to an ER, fast.
- lumost 5y agoNot to mention that for scheduled procedures nearly every doctor will require their own imaging for 40-50k a pop at list price before even discussing treatment options and cost.
- giantg2 5y agoWhat kind of imaging? That seems really high.
- to11mtm 5y ago> Most importantly, ALL of this planning and sense of choice goes out the window when you have a true emergency. When that happens all that matters is getting to an ER, fast. Yep. I was a victim of this in the -worst- way. 11 years ago I was hospitalized, and it 'just so happened' that the only doctor that would take me while I was admitted was out of network. BCBS of Michigan in fact later settled out of court in a class action over this behavior, although the 50 or 100$ I would have gotten certainly did not make up for the hundreds of dollars that the out of network provider cost me.
- jwilber 5y agoThis may be the most uninformed comment I’ve ever read in this site. Ever. Just completely clueless as to how things are/operate regarding healthcare in the real world.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoAs far as pricing goes I view US hospitals basically as money grabbing scam operations. What they are doing is just insane. It’s hard to believe Americans are putting up with this nonsense or even defend it.