4 ms·
You've fallen into the trap of assuming things need to have copyright. It was only 1978 (in the US) when things got copyrighted automatically on creation, befor
by ZeroGravitas 15y ago
You've fallen into the trap of assuming things need to have copyright. It was only 1978 (in the US) when things got copyrighted automatically on creation, before that you had to register it to receive monopoly rights from the government.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>You've fallen into the trap of assuming things need to have copyright. It's not a trap. In a capitalist society it's inevitable that copyright protection be required to ensure things run smoothly. Artists, content creators, IMO deserve to earn a living in return for the richness they add to life. Without art and literature my life would certainly be poorer. Of course artistic works (as defined in copyright law) don't necessarily require copyright in order to be made. But what of those who write or paint or sculpt, or what have you, when there is no protection. Yes they can "get a job like the rest of us" but for some this will greatly limit their ability to create (for others the converse may be true I'll accept). But, I hear someone splutter, "a painter will get paid!", "a writer will get paid!" for the work they do ... Suppose as a writer I release a new novel. It took me 2 years to write, many hours of work. The novel takes a slow start but the initial print run sells after a month or two and less editor costs and print costs I'm only slightly in debt for the project. I send for a second run. Thing is the print house gets my order and refuses to print for me. See they're selling my novel now, altered the author, rewrote some of the autobiographical parts to put me off claiming it as my own. Oh well, there goes the house to pay off my debts. The print house of course rings some book sellers to pass on the book, "no thanks we don't want it" they say; next day they're selling the ebook on their website. What loss though? That book is pennies now when it was pounds before. The question is will the author still write? Will they have time to devote to writing without reward. Some will but I think we'll all come out of such a situation worse off. Is copyright perfect? Not by a long shot. Should we ditch it bathwater, baby and all? Definitely not.
- icebraining 15y agoRegardless of the 'inevitability of copyright' (which is disputable, but not relevant here), not every single thing must have copyright. There are still exceptions, and this might well be one of them. While IANAL, attributing the copyright to the camera owner seems like attributing copyright over the color patterns of a flower to the guy who watered it. Just because there was human intervention somewhere in the process doesn't mean it's an human creation, especially if there was no intent of creating it.
- ZeroGravitas 15y agoWhen I said "assuming things need to have copyright", I meant that not everything needs to have copyright (e.g. most government works, mere duplications of public domain works, things created by animals or nature, random posts on message boards or tweets, etc.) not that nothing needs to have copyright. Simply having to ask for copyright and then having to positively respond a few years later when the government asks "are you sure you want to pay a small fee to secure our backing of your copyright monopoly on this?" would be fine. But yes, now you mention it copyright law is balanced far too much towards "the creators" (by which of course I mean the corporate owners of the creations, not the artists themselves).
- nate_meurer 15y agoIt appears that you replied to the wrong comment. The parent comments specifically on the automatic assignment of copyrights, not on the merit of copyrights themselves.
- Cushman 15y agoI don't think I have. I'm just asking the question— Should I be supported in selling the abstract art produced when my Roomba knocks over my paints? Yes seems like as reasonable an answer to that as no. Also, considering that we are now well past 1978, there's an extent to which things kinda do need to have copyright. You'd be surprised how difficult it is for it not to, even if you're trying.