8 ms·
Choosing a bad password, the Rebekah Wade way.
- thaumaturgy 15y agoSo, there are more and more murmurings about this in comments on posts like this one. I guess I'll kick this one off this time: Passwords make for terrible security. Non-computer folk just don't want to devote the necessary headspace required to do it right. Hell, I handle this stuff for other people all the time, generate on average a few new random passwords of varying lengths every day, have memorized tons of the buggers -- including some rather ugly ones -- and I'm still not doing it right. No, I don't know what would be better than passwords. But I'm looking forward to it when it shows up.
- eik3_de 15y ago> No, I don't know what would be better than passwords. I'm quite happy with Google's Implementation of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-factor_authentication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-factor_authentication called "2-step verification".
- CodeMage 15y agoAnd if Mozilla's BrowserID proves as secure as it looks and becomes widespread, we can combine those two and breathe a lot easier.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- ig1 15y agoHardware tokens you can carry in your wallet or on your keyring. Yes it means you have to carry it around all the time, but you also have to carry your house keys around. And in reality your online accounts at this stage may well be worth more than the stuff in your house.
- apgwoz 15y agoWhat would be better than passwords? Public-key crypto. The password/phrase is only used to protect the private key, so there's only ever one password to remember. Of course, validation of the owner becomes the troublesome point here.
- davidw 15y agoI think phones might be an interesting possibility. Granted, you can lose one or have it stolen, but for most people that's probably less of a risk than using bad passwords that are the same over multiple sites. Of course, there are all kinds of things I'm not thinking of, because... it's not my area of expertise. It just seems like it might be something that's potentially doable and a decent compromise between security and usability.
- archgoon 15y agoIf you have a smartphone, chances are your account to whatever is already compromised by the ability to reset via email, unless you are good about signing out of your email application. So a phone solution sounds like a pretty good solution, since it's not any worse than the current situation. However, a fair number of people still have a 10 cent/message SMS plan, and would be unhappy if they had to start paying $1+ a day to log into all their accounts, so using SMS seems less than ideal in that respect.
- davidw 15y agoI'm thinking something a bit more high tech, like using NFC or Bluetooth so that you have to have the phone in range of the computer.
- JonnieCache 15y agoI predict that these problems will be finally solved when commodity webcams are good enough for secure retina/iris scanning.
- robtoo 15y agoUnfortunately, this doesn't solve the problem: To do iris-scanning security, there must be a back-end database with the characteristics ("fingerprint") of each user's iris. This database will be secured as strongly/effectively as a password database because it contains authentication credentials. Unfortunately, password databases get broken into, and similarly iris databases will also get broken into. The attacker then has to simply convert the iris fingerprint back into an image to replay to the authentication process. This is probably easier than reversing a password hash (because the fingerprinting algorithm is unlikely to be optimised against reversing), and certainly no harder. (This is assuming untrusted client-side hardware.)
- jbri 15y agoIdeally, you wouldn't store the iris fingerprint itself - that's just as bad as storing a cleartext password today. Rather, a good solution would involve deriving a (site-specific) token from the fingerprint and handing it off to the remote service, which then deals with it in much the same way we expect sites to deal with passwords. This, of course, presupposes that we can retrieve a consistent and unique fingerprint from the same iris from various different images of it, and breaks down if all we can do is check an iris image to see if it matches a fingerprint.
- robtoo 15y agoYou appear to be suggesting that the real security benefit would come from off-loading the authentication process onto a third party, but we can already do that with password authentication by using OpenID / Facebook Connect / whatever. It's not clear how using iris fingerprints rather than passwords really adds anything other than to increase the risk of a false negative, and introducing a third party dependency. (I do take your point about storing a hash of the iris fingerprint, though. How this would intefere with the matching process is, I guess, outside of both our areas.)
- DanHulton 15y agoI don't have the solution, but I have part of it: http://www.emailambush.com http://www.emailambush.com I started this just a short while ago in response to all the Lulzsec email/password combo DB dumps that were released. In short, you keep an email in your inbox that looks tempting for hackers that - if any images are loaded or links are followed - sends a text message immediately to your phone, allowing you to quickly change your password and/or alert your administrator.
- eneveu 15y agoReminds me of John Graham-Cumming's email canary: http://blog.jgc.org/2011/06/my-email-canary.html http://blog.jgc.org/2011/06/my-email-canary.html ( discussed at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2636685 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2636685 )
- DanHulton 15y agoIt was actually the inspiration. I'd been doing this myself for a while, but hadn't thought about making an actual product out of it. When I saw the incredible response from the HN community to email canary, I realized I should really take a swing at this.
- crocowhile 15y agoAnd still this is yet another hacking that has little to do with choosing a bad password but with the use of the wrong algorithm to store it (md5) and poor implementation of security on the server.
- robtoo 15y agoChoosing (one of) your phone numbers as a password really is all about choosing a bad password. The back-end could be using bcrypt with a ridiculous work factor, and server security could be state of the art, but choosing your phone number as a password will always be a poor decision.
- crocowhile 15y agoThe point is very very very rarely you actually hear of hacking stories where someone has actually "guessed" a password. Most of the time it's either social hacking or a db dump. Password choice is important to avoid password reuse but I am pretty confident that password guessing is a hugely overestimated risk.
- sesqu 15y agoThe News of the World scandal going on now is, to some extent, about guessing the password. However, they were guessing passwords like 0000, which probably isn't quite what you had in mind.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>but choosing your phone number as a password will always be a poor decision Always? OK, I've reset my HN password to [one of] my phone number. So you can log in as me now? No of course you can't. You don't even know how many digits it is, did I include + for an international number, did I use brackets, hyphens, dots (comme une gars Francais)? How will you connect my online ID with my phone number¹? Once you have my password what are you going to do? Right flames and lose me karma? I can just start a new account if needs be, nothing lost really. For many accounts a phone number is probably a good enough password IMO. For accounts that handle money? No way. For email accounts that receive reset passwords? Not a chance. For posting drivel on tech chat forums ... it'll be fine! -- ¹ If you can I'd prefer you didn't print it.
- 16s 15y agoI find in talking with people about passwords that most have the "it won't happen to me" syndrome or the "I'm not that important" syndrome and thus they feel it is OK to use weak passwords. The last person I spoke with about this used this logic, "It's not like I work for the CIA. So why bother?" And always, after their account becomes compromised, they understand that the bad guys may just want access to resources so they can send spam, or do other illegal things. Sadly, it seems to always take something like this to make the point fully understood and after that the person is fully on-board with password security. Just my experience.
- genghy 15y agoThis is a great way to choose a password. If her password was selected because of the tip line displayed in bold at the top of the page, then this is probably the ONLY site she uses the password for. Assuming the site isn't holding any sensitive information, the most someone could do by accessing her account here is comment under her username. If the passwords are stolen (as happened here) the passwords are worthless in that they won't give access to any other sites she may have accounts at, including her banking and other sensitive accounts.
- StavrosK 15y agoI'm sorry, but when was the last time anyone heard of anyone guessing a password? Sure, it's a very easy password to brute force, but it doesn't matter that it's the number of the paper, because nobody would have thought to try it, along with the thousands of other things it could be, each spelt in a variety of ways. It's much more probable that they brute-forced it in microseconds from the md5 hash, which is where the actual weakness is. I will go so far as to say that, had they used bcrypt, this would have not been broken, because people don't usually go around gathering personal data about you to try by hand (unless you have the CIA interested, that is, and then they can get in in easier ways).
- younata 15y agoI pulled a machine out of a garbage pile once. Booted it up, it required a password, I guessed "password" and it logged me in as the CEO of the company. So, in your case, the last time you heard of anyone guessing a password was about a second ago.
- klbarry 15y agoA college student I know likes to play a certain online game. Some accounts have items and status symbols that are valuable in-game, but the accounts are abandoned for years. Some names are even intrinsically valuable (names like "Sun" or something like that). This college student, at least once a month, guesses the correct password for these old accounts based on information the users provided years ago.
- younata 15y agoThat is far cooler than what I did: your friend actually engages in an intellectual exercise, I just got lucky with a guess.
- klbarry 15y agoYour story is certainly one to remember though (and lucky that it was a business owner!) I have to say though, it's quite fascinating to watch my friend work. She would make a gifted detective...
- jwcacces 15y agoWhy was the salt her name?