7 ms·
If you’re going to put your preschooler in front of a screen, choose a TV
- bloniac 5y agoWe did zero iPads iPhones computers for kids until 8 years old. Tv only.
- calcsam 5y agoHuge plug for Daniel Tiger, the successor to Mr. Roger's Neighborhood. Our kids (4, 2) love it -- it has great lessons, talks about the topics relevant for them, and never uses the tactics discussed eg overexposed colors, rapid cuts, etc.
- otkfutufjfh 5y agoI just typed 'Daniel Tiger' into YouTube to have a look and then I watched some Mr. Rogers samples. It really strikes me as nothing like Mr. Rogers. Daniel Tiger is animated, it does use fairly rapid cuts, the overall pace and feel is much less calm. Mr. Rogers has a peaceful adult voice, the effect of extended listening is a bit more like watching Bob Ross paint. It's soothing, relaxing, and calming. Daniel Tiger has constant loud child voices. Also, because Mr. Rogers is an actual human being with actual human facial expressions, he can provide healthy modelling to children for how to be a decent human being. Many children these days grow up in broken homes with parents who scream and fight and then divorce. Divorce rate is like, what, 40%? My parents certainly screamed and fought and divorced. But watching Mr. Rogers as a child gave me an important experience of a human who is Not An Asshole. Is there really some compelling reason to use the "successor" to Mr. Rogers as opposed to the original? Mr. Rogers sample: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tkJduDu1JM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tkJduDu1JM Daniel Tiger sample: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m08BrNDkJjw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m08BrNDkJjw Bob Ross: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLWEXRAnQd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLWEXRAnQd0
- antiterra 5y agoTo me, especially as an adult, the in-person Mr. Rogers segments are irreplaceable. However, I absolutely hated the puppet sections as a kid, aside from the model train aspect of the trolley. In comparison Daniel Tiger is much more accessible and offers really good tools for emotional regulation. The main gap is a kind of the ‘everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face’ problem— it’s very hard to use a relaxation tool from TV when the feelings are real and intense.
- calcsam 5y agoTo answer the question you asked, the show is based on a neighborhood of Mr. Rogers, with permission from the Fred Rogers foundation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tiger%27s_Neighborhood#Premise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tiger%27s_Neighborhood#...
- Clewza313 5y agoThis seems like a pretty myopic view. I'll take Minecraft (aka building virtual endless Lego) any day over what passes for children's TV programming these days.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoSure, the author’s point is only that you should put Minecraft on a large screen you can see, not a small tablet which you cannot. So maybe get the Xbox version of Minecraft—or the Raspberry Pi version—instead of the iOS one.
- homarp 5y agoor you know, the 'original' minecraft with all the mods, on a PC... so the kids can learn stuff can be modded, not just 'buy a skin'-ed.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoAbsolutely, as long as you have a PC connected to a TV!
- FearlessNebula 5y agoThat’s as cheap as a Raspberry Pi 4 for $35 and a Bluetooth keyboard and mouse for $35, or an old game controller for even less.
- Qerub 5y agoFWIW: Minecraft: Pi Edition is discontinued. It only saw a single release (0.1.1 alpha) in 2013. More info over at https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Pi_Edition https://minecraft.fandom.com/wiki/Pi_Edition.
- CameronNemo 5y agoMinetest probably runs on a pi. It is open source.
- davidgerard 5y agoOne key point is that this is from the UK, and BBC CBeebies is a lifesaver. Perfect toddler-friendly television of varied and interesting decently-written non-claptrap with no ads that isn't there to sell you toys, that you can leave your kid watching without worries.
- OJFord 5y agoEven channels with advertising here are nothing compared to what US readers are probably used to/imagining.
- orls 5y agoThe article doesn’t even mention UK broadcast television content – it’s more about big-shared-screens vs small-personal-screens. And the author is an American, resident in New York afaict. Even though the Guardian is a UK-based paper, not all it’s content is not exclusively UK-focused.
- rob_c 5y agoOne of the few great things the BBC has saved. Not a massive fan of the license but understand the massive need for this!
- Tenoke 5y agoI'm glad I managed to go behind my parents' back and use the computer and internet when not allowed. Overall, I learned a lot more than I would've by just watching TV or being bored or whatever else those people recommend. I hope the kids whose parents read this stuff manage, too
- long_time_gone 5y agoI too hope they read the article and find out what it actually suggests. Raising your kid based on headlines isn’t ideal.
- acituan 5y agoThe difference is, in 2021 internet is a wildly different and heavily monetized place with lots or perverse incentives. It is not the internet we've checked APOD on nasa.com
- FearlessNebula 5y agoMe too. Who knows if I ever would’ve learned how much I love computers if I wasn’t tinkering with the family computer trying to get a torrented game installed (my parents never paid for games because they thought they were bad).
- Andrex 5y agoWhen I had to sneak internet use, I had to get my videos from AnimeMusicVideos.org (and wait an hour for a 3 minute Realplayer file to download.) I never used chat rooms so the only other thing I could do was browse Geocities. YouTube existing at all changes the calculus for parents and children these days, I feel.
- jjeaff 5y agoNot to mention how the internet and computers just work, now. I spent countless hours tinkering with settings and drivers and phone lines and Windows 3.1 just to be able to get online sometimes. A dial up modem and dodgy phone lines taught me a lot about how computers work.
- arpa 5y agoTV? hell naw! plex with reviewed content and timer? hell yea.
- FearlessNebula 5y agoPlus no ads on Plex
- TonyBagODonuts 5y agoWe only let our children have screen time on non-school nights, so Friday from about 6 to 8, and Saturday from 4 to 8. They almost always choose computers over tv. Minecraft, digital art, etc. The rest of the time they play or read. The once a week trip to the library as become a core part of our routine. Edit: these restrictions include summer. Same times.
- leodriesch 5y agoSounds like a very good idea. I’m not a parent myself, but I’d be worried the kids might get left behind socially in school if they miss out on certain digital content other kids talk about. Not supposed to be criticism, just a thought of mine :)
- annamargot 5y agoBut please don’t subject your children to commercials. They don’t need temptation to eat/get garbage thrust upon them by high production value propaganda from giant corporations /rant
- FearlessNebula 5y agoSeriously, I don’t pay for YouTube premium but I absolutely would if I had children. That plus PiHole and a browser ad blocker.
- piyh 5y agoYoutube premium with kids pays for itself in the reduced spending/whining for things they saw on ads. Embedded advertising is another thing entirely. SponsorBlock is the way to go there.
- 3grdlurker 5y agoLet’s not forget, though, that parents can be mouthpieces of propaganda too—religion, bigoted views, even preference for certain brands produced by giant corporations.
- blacktriangle 5y agoYes so lets hand our kids over to advertisers and the state, that's always worked out wonderfully.
- largbae 5y agoThe premise of this whole article is that kids learn what you put in front of them, which I disagree with. They learn what they pursue. I have been enjoying a technology arms race with my daughter. She likes full youtube for content that is still benign, but beyond what's available on the kids platform. She started finding ways to circumvent our time limitations at age 3 using Siri and Safari to bypass screen time, and later concealed that she had worked out my unlock password on mine. I eventually make another move to defeat, but I am secretly proud of her and now I'm simply placing another level in the big game.
- choeger 5y agoThe thing is, tablets and phones are interactive, TVs normally are not. There are fantastic apps for learning on a tablet (reading, writing, counting, simple calculations, reading the clock, etc.) The kids love it to spend some tablet time and they benefit from it. And even if they just toy around in these virtual worlds (Tokka), it's much more creative than just watching the next episode of my little pony. On the other hand, tv shows, like aforementioned, my little pony, gives them excursions into dramatic topics: friendship, betrayal, pride, ... Even the most trivial cartoon will have some form of story telling and I think kids need story telling that they choosen freely.
- celticninja 5y agoTV is th most passive medium, you can turn it on and let it fill your time with whatever someone else decides to show you, including adverts. Gaming is usually a conscious choice about how to spend your time and requires input and decisions from the player, the same is not true of TV. At least Netflix/prime etc require you to make a decision about what to watch.
- wccrawford 5y agoThere are tons of games these days, for PC, console and mobile, that are designed to just be time-sinks. MMOs, village sims (Harvest Moon/etc), Match-3, infinite runners... Even sports games and multiplayer shooters. They designed to be played for many, many, many hours without only slight changes most of the time so that you just keep playing. Yes, they're interactive, but you're doing the same thing over and over and it's largely non-educational, just a time-sink. Entertaining, but otherwise useless. They're the sugar of the game world. I've played plenty of them myself, but there was a long time there that I played way too much of them. A great one will still reel me in, but I prefer experiences that have a built-in end now instead. Anyhow, my point is that both TV and games can be things you can fill your time with mindlessly.
- rasz 5y agoYes, put them in front of History Channel so they can learn about Alien abductions, reptile overlords, hollow/flat earth and ghosts.
- selfhoster11 5y agoLocking down channels on TV is trivial. Decent set-top boxes have parental controls options, so you can lock out those types of channels with a PIN.
- motyar 5y agoipad working very well for us. They are learning very fast.
- seppin 5y agoAre they going to be able to focus on anything in 10 years that's not flashing lights and casino-industry user hooks?
- xondono 5y agoThe author realizes that you can also use an ipad with your kid right? And if that’s too little screen to share comfortably, you can use a PC…
- PaulHoule 5y agoI find it scary that preverbal children can use phones and tablets. You can train animals to do that too.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- liberalbias998 5y agoI remember we felt guilty that we sometimes sat our small children on their bouncy chair and let them watch the repeating intro from Super Mario Brothers or Mickeys Castle of adventure on the Nintendo or Megadrive console. When they grew up they both went into games development.
- neodymiumm 5y agoI've been very impressed with the volume of quality shows for kids (mine are four and two) from different studios: PBS Kids -- Daniel Tiger (based on Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood), Peg + Cat -- Amazon Prime: Tumble Leaf, Stinky and Dirty -- Hulu: Curious George -- Disney+: Bluey (I enjoy watching this one myself). Common Sense Media has also been helpful to find quality shows. I'd never choose TV as an educational tool over screenless options, but for those times when you need to have your kids occupied, there's good stuff out there and not all screen time is equal.
- baryphonic 5y agoI'd probably rather have my kids play a creative game like Minecraft on a tablet than TV. I'd rather have them watch Pokémon on TV than YouTube Kids on the tablets. TV is entirely passive. Games on the iPad are at least interactive, though games are not all created equal. I have some concerns that touching glass all the time will be damaging for kids, as much as if not more than the lack of mental stimulation or social growth or physical activity. But I also think that encouraging creative play (lots of building with different materials), playing outside, role-playing and even being "bored" to invent new games and new play is highly beneficial. Reading and even trying to make up stories is also good. The worst part of screen time is that it crowds out so many other beneficial activities, but I'm not convinced that it's horrible as a "treat" alongside those activities. It's probably better than zero stimulation or interaction at all.
- jgalt212 5y ago> Research shows that children under the age of five have an exceedingly challenging time learning from a 2D screen and translating that into the 3D world without help Numbers and letters are 2D. Any word on learning about 2D objects on a 2D object?
- jimmygrapes 5y agoAll these comments and not a single one has yet to mention books. Not a good sign imo.
- blooalien 5y agoI saw a comment further up-thread where someone mentioned regular visits to the library bein' part of their routine with their kids.
- robertlagrant 5y agoOne word for those with young kids: Numberblocks[1]. It is one of the best-constructed things I've ever seen: constant amazing songs; great animation; and it teaches kids numbers. No violence/slapstick/jump cuts/toy empire to buy all of. Just amazing. [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/cbeebies/shows/numberblocks https://www.bbc.co.uk/cbeebies/shows/numberblocks
- blacktriangle 5y agoCan't mention numberblocks without Alphablocks as well. The BBC did something awesome with both of those shows.