5 ms·
Is Amazon’s Stock Price Justified? What It Means If It Is (2017)
- ytNumbers 5y agoThe author of this 2017 article is probably shocked that Amazon's PE ratio has since gone from 184 to 70, while the stock price went from about 1000 to 3700. The author should have realized that there was still a huge untapped market for cloud services in 2017. It would have been foolish to short the stock four years ago, but, with the departure of Bezos, one has to wonder how much longer AWS can continue to keep the big profits flowing for the company. Rather than focusing on PE, the author should have focused on whether or not there is still a huge untapped market for cloud services. I'd focus on that metric before deciding to short AMZN.
- cjbenedikt 5y agoGreat analysis. Now do tgexsame for the other FAANGs.
- iambateman 5y agoQuick gripe with this article: it assumes that Amazon’s primary market will always be the US. All of the numbers peg Amazon to our market, GDP, and growth. But there’s reason to believe Amazon could experience long-term growth in the rest of the world, even if growth in the US reaches equilibrium.
- ratsmack 5y agoIf Amazon doesn't fix their horribly astroturfed review system, they will be worthless in a few years after enough people get burned.
- dazc 5y agoHave to agree, not just this but multiple versions of every imaginable product - most of which is complete junk. Many times I have just given up and gone elsewhere. I thought they made a smart move with their own branded stuff but a lot of this is just as bad quality.
- sokoloff 5y agoI’ve generally found Basics products to be in the solid B+ (at worst) to A- (typically) level of quality. It’s not going to be junk in my experience.
- NeutronStar 5y agoYou've totally changed my minds on how shitty they Basics products are, thank you!
- pessimizer 5y agoI've found them to range from unusable, to adequate, to simple and perfectly designed for purpose (and readily available from dozens of Chinese manufacturers through other channels.)
- dazc 5y agoAmazon have multiple own-brands besides the Basics range though.
- MattGaiser 5y agoSo many Amazon reviews are clearly purchased and they purchase the reviews by putting cards in the packages with their products.
- mcv 5y agoI wish that was true, but Amazon is huge and ubiquitous, and even if everybody aware of this issue decides on a hard boycott, that still leaves the majority of the world's population. There is much more wrong with Amazon, but they survive and thrive simply because of their scale.
- tmpz22 5y agoAgreed at their scale the number of customer churn that falls into the acceptable category is colossal.
- anonuser123456 5y agoWhat do you think is easier, for Amazon to fix their ratings system or for a competitor to implement the worlds most sophisticated vertically integrated logistics operation? If customer really start caring, they will fix it. The ratings thing is a blip for them. Only sophisticated customers are aware of it... and sophisticated customers are the exception, not the rule.
- spoonjim 5y agoGrocery stores, Walmart, Target, etc have an equally sophisticated logistics system. After getting one counterfeit product from Amazon I shifted all of my purchases of kids products (diapers, lotion, sunscreen, etc) to brick and mortar retail.
- pessimizer 5y agoMe, too. Locally you get to inspect the product, which eliminates most Amazon-class difficulties, and also there's somebody who has to physically hide from you if you have a complaint.
- sjg007 5y agoTarget and Walmart are the most likely. They just have to work on their search and recommendation engines.
- pessimizer 5y ago> Only sophisticated customers are aware of it. It doesn't take an extraordinary amount of "sophistication" to notice that the products that you ordered are cheap, broken and/or counterfeit trash when they arrive. They don't deliver any more quickly than anyone else anymore either. Unless you're on Prime; I think they prioritize Prime.
- jefftk 5y ago> notice that the products that you ordered are cheap, broken and/or counterfeit trash My experience with the products I've received ordering from Amazon has generally been very good, comparable to products I bought in person. Things are generally as advertised, and work correctly. My guess is that Amazon is doing well because mostly people have an experience similar to mine, and are happy to keep ordering?
- fnord77 5y agoI think that ship sailed. don't know a single person who is happy with amazon. only thing missing is a substitute
- sokoloff 5y agoI am generally happy with Amazon. Most times I can get something from Amazon tomorrow or the next day for a competitive price. I’d say that 97% of my orders are delivered on-time and to-spec. When they’re not, it’s almost never been a hassle to get it fixed. I had one order last year where I was unhappy with Amazon’s treatment on the issue. They were willing to give my money back without hassle, but that wouldn’t fix my wife’s car’s charging system, so I had to make something work.
- colinmhayes 5y agoamazon is one of the most rusted institutions in America. 70% of americans view it favorably. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OgPzcB75uxXiFmTjUUb-ITIr7BFdFFhw/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OgPzcB75uxXiFmTjUUb-ITIr7BF...
- sokoloff 5y agoAmusing typo inverts the meaning (rusted vs trusted).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fnord77 5y ago> This implies that in 2027, Amazon’s annual sales will be just a bit less than 10 percent of GDP. The author is using 2021 GDP numbers to compare to amzn's projected sales in 2027
- oezi 5y agoThe main reason that the analysis is flawed is that Amazon just funnels their profits into R&D which hides it in plain sight. Last year they spend 45 bn USD on R&D which is 10% of their total revenue and double their profit.
- quickthrowman 5y agoIt’s not hiding profit, it’s reinvesting in growth… Amazon is saying to investors that they think they can give investors a better return on cash by reinvesting it into Amazon than distributing it to investors to put to work elsewhere.
- rightbyte 5y agoAre there not tax reliefs on RnD? It is more likely they hide operations as RnD.
- oezi 5y agoI don't think they are. Operations are reported separately. They are just having R&D 50% bigger than Google.
- cs702 5y agoAn equivalent question: If you had $2T in cash, and you were to buy all of Amazon's outstanding shares, taking it private, to own it forever, earning your money back from the company's profits year after year, after subtracting all amounts reinvested in the business -- in the same manner you would do it with, say, an apartment building, would you ever recover your $2T investment? What kind of annual return do you think you would you earn over the remaining life of the business?
- economusty 5y agoI really like your way of thinking. Would we take any growth into account?
- nakedlunch 5y agoIsn’t that a bit of a silly question? The share price should reflect future earnings. If you are a shareholder, you believe that amazon will continue to grow and that other people will continue to value its future earnings higher than the price you purchase at. Amazon’s strategy is not (solely) to make a profit. It’s strategy is to invest in growth, sometimes in such a way that makes a loss or scant profit, to dominate markets in a way that gives them sustained competitive advantage. If you bought Amazon and asked them to switch to simply profit making, then they could can a lot of the future growth stuff to get your trillions back. Comparing them to an apartment building which can only grow in line with a wider market (ignoring subdivision of apartments etc) is just a weird false comparison in my eyes.
- pessimizer 5y agoWhat part of the comment you replied to implied that Amazon would never grow? The entire OP is about the growth that Amazon would have to do to fulfill certain scenarios (that would result in expected profit for investors.)
- nakedlunch 5y agoWhat I’m trying to point out (maybe I did a bad job!) is that it doesn’t make sense to try to run the numbers of how long it would take to return an investment in purchasing Amazon in profit, considering if returning investment capital in profits was Amazon’s goal they would behave in a profit maximising way rather than a growth maximising way. I just don’t think it’s the right question to ask (how long would it take to pay off buying Amazon from Amazon’s current profit margins) because the answer wouldn’t tell you anything interesting about how to value Amazon.
- gentleman11 5y agoAre stocks (and real estate) just an appealing store of value for wealthy people? Are changes in typical price to earnings ratios over time just a marker of inflation? Edit: looks like the P/E ratio almost doubled in 2021 from 20-25 to 40-45. Is that just because revenues were down during COVID, or is it where all the stimulus spending ended up? https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio/table/by-year https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio/table/by-year
- heavyset_go 5y agoWe never really let up from the quantitative easing implemented a decade ago, with QE4 being conducted in response to the pandemic. Interests rates are already low, and it seems like a conscious choice not to raise them because of the potential negative implications. Everyone seems to be buying assets, whether financial or real, as a result.