6 ms·
How safe is Colin Furze's tunnel?
- rwmj 5y agoFor context, British Youtuber/celebrity engineer Colin Furze[1] is digging a tunnel at a depth of 3.5 meters under his garden using hand and hydraulic tools. He previously built an underground bunker. [1] https://www.youtube.com/c/colinfurze/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/colinfurze/videos
- agumonkey 5y agoI'm surprised he didn't make a rig to dig dirt before hand. His next project will be an exoskeleton to relieve his broken bach :) ps: oh I was just before he starts to make hydraulic arms ..
- rasz 5y agoFor even more reference going under is pretty popular in UK https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2012/nov/09/billionaires-basements-london-houses-architecture https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2012/nov/09/billion... https://www.theguardian.com/money/2018/may/07/pool-basement-wealth-super-rich-digging-down-london https://www.theguardian.com/money/2018/may/07/pool-basement-...
- d_theorist 5y agoAs long as he wears his safety tie I am sure it will be fine.
- kortex 5y agoI think the one commenter hit the nail on the head with, "the stuff Colin does looks off-the-cuff and spontaneous, cause that's his bit, but there is almost certainly planning and engineer review going on before hand." England tends to be even more tightwad about this kinda stuff than America, and with multimillion followers, it's not like he can do these big projects surreptitiously. There's the 360° swing, giant iron man mecha, underground bunker, and a few others which would absolutely draw ire from inspectors had they not been done aboveboard. Pretty sure "we have to dig the tunnel stealthily so the neighborhood doesn't know!" is a bit. I bet all the neighbors are subscribers.
- nathanael699 5y agoIn the original bunker video, he applied for planning permission /after/ it was built https://planning.southkesteven.gov.uk/SKDC/S16-0017/1288446.pdf https://planning.southkesteven.gov.uk/SKDC/S16-0017/1288446.... It's also quite funny he names "Mr Malcolm" as the person who gave him advice before hand. He's also been arrested for other projects. I feel like he's very much "do first, ask later" type of person. And at least with both of these projects they're sponsored. So it's not costing him anything.
- 542458 5y agoAlso, in his “final” videos he never wears a helmet on his motorized bikes or carts - but he does wear a helmet in behind the scenes footage, which says the helmet is omitted for image reasons. On the flip side, I don’t think he’s all that completely cautious either. For example during testing in the absurd salad knife belt video (which features a whirling belt of knives) from one shot to another a very large bandage appears on his arm (and is never acknowledged) which suggests to me that that thing was exactly as dangerous as it looked.
- kortex 5y agoHe's definitely trying to preserve his original image, of twenty-something spontaneous punk-rock welder making crazy inventions with little regard for safety. I've been following his channel for years (fiveish) and watched a lot of his earlier stuff and those vids are definitely safety-third. He's definitely still no Captain Tightpants by any means, but as a fellow former crazy maker / fire performer, you never fully grow out of it, but you mellow out over time and take less crazy risks (in favor of calculated risks).
- CydeWeys 5y agoHe definitely did a few things in this most recent video that made me cringe, like using an angle grinder to make a notch in a steel pipe that he's holding up with his other hand. Some pipe clamps would've been advisable there vs holding by hand the object you're cutting into. Felt like something you'd see on /r/OSHA. The tunnel generally feels safe, but I can't say the same for the methods employed in digging it.
- zeronine 5y agoi assume this type of endeavour would require some kind of permit and in turn a degree of engineering approval that said, i stopped watching collin's videos a long time ago because of an apparent (however edited) blatant disregard for basic safety principles
- ryan93 5y agoWhy do you care that he’s not safe?
- sjansen 5y agoAn ethical argument could be made that by watching we are encouraging the behavior and therefore share any blame if something goes wrong.
- baremetal 5y agowhat about driving cars. are you against that as well?
- frosted-flakes 5y agoCars are necessary in modern society. Furze's stunts are not. We might reach a point in the far future where we are no longer reliant on cars, but we're not there yet.
- ryan93 5y agoHe’s a grown man. And clearly intelligent. It’s disrespectful to be that patronizing towards him
- AareyBaba 5y agoThen you missed the video where he farts at France. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ydv9Ef-99I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Ydv9Ef-99I
- aaron695 5y agoCompared to most of the worlds current working tunnels dug by the other 6 billion, or all tunnels 70+ year ago it's a mansion in the tunnel world. In the first world corporate mining industry I'm sure it'd give a safety person a heart attack. Going 10 meters down an artisan mine [1] (most of the worlds miners work in these) is scary. Straight down a narrow hole, then sideways into soft dirt with a few tree trunks holding up dirt doesn't fill you with confidence. Then I got stuck trying to climb out because my longer western legs couldn't step up. The fact this blogger uses welded supports on an outer layer shows he's on probably top of it for the hobby world. [1] https://imgur.com/a/hUgEblt https://imgur.com/a/hUgEblt
- lmilcin 5y agoLet's just say that if the ground decides to give the puny adhoc steel structure is not going to pose much opposition. Forgetting for a moment how thin everything is, the arch only works if it is supported on the sides. It isn't, there is a bunch of space on both sides for the arch to get flat and give completely. But the structure may prevent full collapse. Also it is going to be relatively unlikely anybody gets hurt. It isn't like he is going to be sitting there 24/7.
- indigomm 5y agoThe steel is only temporary. Of course one could argue any temporary structure should be up to scratch, but anyway it's not the final solution. He's building a tunnel within the steel structure and then filling the void with concrete.
- lmilcin 5y agoWell, that's what I understood from the last vid. But until then he is standing under structure that is definitely not safe. The trouble with these kinds of things is that everything looks fine until it doesn't. The way engineering solves these problems is through body of knowledge and experience in understanding of material properties and interaction of forces of both ground and the structure. The ground my start slipping slowly or it might decide to give in one go. It might happen after a particularly heavy rain or for no apparent reason at all. Unfortunately, I am not an expert in the type of ground he is facing. So either he is working with professionals (and hiding it to make the video more entertaining and in spirit of his other projects) or he isn't. In either case I think it is bad because it promotes the idea other people can do the same. Which is extremely dangerous in irresponsible to do on your own.
- baremetal 5y agowhat if i said i think its dangerous that you operate a car, and worse, you encourage others to drive cars when they see you driving a car.
- sega_sai 5y agoThat reminds me of this story https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/17/us/daniel-beckwitt-bethesda-fire.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/06/17/us/daniel-beckwitt-bethes... Being non-expert it's hard to judge the safety of the tunnel, but still it doesn't sound to me like a good idea.
- DrBazza 5y agoWe've had other people in the UK that have been rather less 'cautious' probably, sadly, through mental health issues, the Mole Man of Hackney: "Lyttle, originally from Ireland, inherited a 20-room property in the London borough of Hackney. In the mid sixties he dug out a wine cellar under his home. Having done so, he said that he had "found a taste for the thing" and kept on digging, for some forty years.[2] He created a network of tunnels, wide and narrow, on several levels. Tunnels led in all directions, some of them up to 18 metres (59 ft) in length, and reaching as far down as the water table.[3] One excavation connected with the Dalston Lane tunnel, and the railway line.[3]" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Lyttle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Lyttle
- indigomm 5y ago"After this, Lyttle was moved to a hotel for three years, before being rehoused in an apartment in a high-rise building. He was put on the top floor, to discourage tunnelling. While there he knocked a hole in a dividing wall between two rooms." :-)
- CarelessExpert 5y agoCrap... I clicked the link to the Wikipedia page on "Hobby tunneling" and now I'm getting lost in a rat hole of my own: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_tunneling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hobby_tunneling Edit: And in doing so, it reminded me of this story I ran across a while back: https://armeniadiscovery.com/en/articles/levons-divine-underground-cave-museum https://armeniadiscovery.com/en/articles/levons-divine-under...
- manquer 5y agoThere is this guy [1] Dashrath Manjhi spent 20 years digging 110m long tunnel through hills to reduce the travel distance from his village after his wife died. Apparently he used only used hammer and chisel [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dashrath_Manjhi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dashrath_Manjhi
- andai 5y ago> When asked by journalists why he had excavated the tunnels, he said "I'm just a man who loves to dig" and that he just wanted "a big basement". He also said that "There is great beauty in inventing things that serve no purpose."
- tweetle_beetle 5y agoI hope he makes enough money from the video to be able to write-off the value of his home. I suspect that it will be impossible to sell. See also Fred Dibnah's attempt to build replica coal mine (with 30m shaft) in his back garden, using only techniques and machinery contemporary to the period[1][2]. Sadly he passed away before he could complete it and the property has had a strange history since then. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqAbMbRQ3jE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tqAbMbRQ3jE [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Dibnah#Dig_with_Dibnah https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Dibnah#Dig_with_Dibnah
- nathanael699 5y agoHe declared over £1million last year, and I'm 99.999% sure that house is just used as a studio/business address rather than actually living there now. He's done way too many projects that involve just generally making your life a bit difficult.
- pixxel 5y ago> I suspect that it will be impossible to sell. Genuinely curious to why that would be? Subsidence?
- XorNot 5y agoIf the bunker is permitted then he's going to have no trouble selling it - though the market does tend to get weird when stuff looks weird. That said, I have trouble believing in the current insanity of urban property markets that anything could make a regular house hard to sell. It won't make it more valuable (nobody's shopping saying "I really need that underground bunker") but I seriously doubt he'd have any trouble beyond that.
- ufmace 5y agoAny unusual or one-off traits that seem "unique", "fun", "quirky" etc tend to do very badly in the actual real estate market. Often, they are poorly engineered and will be a maintenance nightmare in 20 years. Inspection expertise to be able to tell whether it will be a maintenance nightmare will be very tough to find. Most sane buyers will just pass on it rather then try to sort it out. Even if the market is super hot right now and it seems like people will buy anything, anyone who looks at buying this will definitely be thinking about how hard it will be to sell in 10 years when the market isn't so hot. Most likely 90% of them will either back out or demand discounts that basically assume the whole thing is a mess and will need to be ripped out by professional contractors.
- otikik 5y agoColin Furze. The "S" stands for Safety.
- baremetal 5y agosafety furze. i like it.
- stuartbman 5y agoMy concern would actually be the ventilation. It looks like the access hatch goes straight down from the floor of the workshop. He often seems to have various machinery in there and I'd be concerned that a gas leak could flow into the tunnel and push out the oxygen, making it an asphyxiation risk. I hope he's mitigated this because there are documented cases of unaware first responders trying to save those in enclosed spaces and themselves asphyxiating.
- laurent92 5y agoOn this topic, I love the (too rare) CSB videos. I’m baffled that 1L of liquid nitrogen expands in 700L of gas, and despite being inert, can kill in a minute.
- cantrevealname 5y agoThe tunnel I would love to see is the espionage tunnel built in complete secrecy under the then Soviet embassy in Washington DC constructed by the FBI and operated by the NSA, costing hundreds of millions of dollars, and about which we learned only because it was exposed by an FBI double agent in 1989[1]. I'd pay to watch a movie about that tunnel's construction. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27793359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27793359 (Operation Monopoly)
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoColin's channel is entertaining but it's as synthetic as TV. He has a team of people, probably has planning permission for the whole thing, and so on.
- nathanael699 5y agoHe's done work for "minstream" TV before, but in reality, as with a lot of Youtube, it's only him, his wife and a few friends. The original bunker had to retroactively apply for planning permission: https://planning.southkesteven.gov.uk/SKDC/S16-0017/1288446.pdf https://planning.southkesteven.gov.uk/SKDC/S16-0017/1288446.... Of course it's way more organised that it first seems, because it is sponsored after all, but he does seem rather fly-by-night o all his things. He said he was going to do a load of other projects with that bunker (including ventilation systems) but they never happened.
- manquer 5y agoWhile he does maintain a persona for the channel, it not all fake, He is fairly transparent about some of these things he did mention about permissions etc, his behind the scenes videos show a bit more usually. I would say it is more artistic license in the story he is saying rather being artificially synthetic.
- davidbanham 5y agoHe has himself, Rick and Tom. He’s said before he’s a one man band when it comes to filming, editing and the business.
- sschueller 5y agoWe assume from what we see that this tunnel and his shed are at his house but he is big enough of a youtuber that this whole thing could be on a sound stage somewhere.
- Theodores 5y agoWhat I want to know is how he explains the skip that will inevitably be in his driveway. English people always look in skips. Allegedly the neighbours are not to know. Maybe he times skip delivery and collection accordingly.
- db48x 5y agoDidn’t you see in the previous video that he is surreptitiously leaving bags of dirt at pubs and in grocery stores? There was even a flyer behind him at one point. The neighbors will never know.
- russellbeattie 5y agoThis guy is a reckless idiot who is going to get someone killed. The video he posted about digging an underground cave at the beach, in sand, was the sketchiest thing I've ever seen. If one of the sand walls collapsed, he would have buried alive, and no one could have helped him. One of his millions of followers is bound to try something similar with tragic results, guaranteed.