3 ms·
I can't tell if you're really mad about the article and think the author is unreasonable, or if you think I'm being unreasonable, so I'll just respond as if you
by refulgentis 5y ago
I can't tell if you're really mad about the article and think the author is unreasonable, or if you think I'm being unreasonable, so I'll just respond as if you're looking for evidence that this, at least somewhat, ambiguous:
> “Cat Person,” and the cultural reception to it, feels connected to the broader literary debate over “autofiction”—writing that, in its raw and confessional style, seems to blur the boundaries between the real and the invented.
- tptacek 5y ago"Fiction" is literally in the word "autofiction". The term means "fictional autobiography". You may have confused it with "roman à clef", which nobody says Cat Person is. We do have a term for "fiction inspired in part by real stories"; it's "fiction".
- refulgentis 5y agoYou're right, I can see it from that perspective. I find it somewhat zen in that it then becomes befuddling the author of this article injected herself into the Cat Person author's story...I do then give up & weep for the poor girl whose life this was who needs to be told she has no business injecting herself via a story about the story someone wrote about her life, this line of argument is far too meta for me for midnight EST. Cheers.
- tptacek 5y agoDo you weep for every member of John Updike's family? The same stuff happened to them! The reality is, you don't; you never once thought about how Updike used his own relationships and those of his family and acquaintances as fodder. You care about this particular story for reasons other than principles. That's fine, but we should start by being honest about it.
- whatshisface 5y agoI'm not sure what inconsistency you're pointing out; if I was related to John Updike I would not be happy if I ended up as a villain in one of his books. Wouldn't anyone not enjoy that? As a relatively famous silicon valley person, it might actually happen to you some day, and although it would probably never happen to me I can imagine empathizing with you if you ever ended up as the bad guy in a short story.
- tptacek 5y agoI assume whomever bases a fictional character after me will at least get the detail right that I live in Chicago, not Silicon Valley.
- d110af5ccf 5y agoJust to clarify - if someone wrote a fictional autobiography whose subject was obviously you, would that not bother you? I would certainly be bothered if a close friend or family member did that to me in a manner that could ever lead strangers back to me. Nor would I ever publish such a piece about one of my acquaintances without their permission. I find the notion that such behavior could be socially acceptable quite strange.
- tptacek 5y agoAgain: the problem I have with this argument is that it's just coming up now, despite literally centuries of fiction built out of just these kinds of stories. I don't believe this is a real concern; it's a fake concern that we're being asked to have by a Slate article. It's interesting, and I'm happy to bounce the thought around, because that's what we're here for. But, come on.
- slg 5y agoI am guessing you aren't a fan of Citizen Kane. Or how about stories that even bill themselves as based on real events like Accidental Billionaires/The Social Network? Those must be even worse if they bill themselves as the truth. Could you imagine if most people judged your personality off made up dialogue and stories told by someone who was suing you for billions of dollars?
- prvc 5y ago>I am guessing you aren't a fan of Citizen Kane. William Randolph Hearst certainly wasn't one!
- barrkel 5y agoFiction isn't the binary you are asserting here. In fact, libelous material is by definition fictional - imputing someone's character by making stuff up. Now I think that this is fiction, but it is definitely skirting the line and the author should probably have changed a few more details.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoLibelous material is typically presented as fact.
- barrkel 5y agoOh yeah, I agree. I do think a thinly disguised essay passed off as fiction could be libellous, though. And to reiterate, I don't think the Cat Person piece is libellous.