5 ms·
I’m skeptical about counting international immigrants here. International immigration is a function of a very specific thing, in California’s case a measure of
by rayiner 5y ago
I’m skeptical about counting international immigrants here. International immigration is a function of a very specific thing, in California’s case a measure of H1-B sponsor companies. If Indians come to California so they can get an H-1B from Facebook, but their kids them move to Tennessee because of poor quality of life in California, then that’s consistent with the “exodus” theory in my opinion.
I’m an immigrant from Bangladesh and quite a few people in my family moved to NYC. It has lots of support for people with limited English skills, lots of service jobs, etc. But they moved to Long Island as soon as they got their feet under them. It was a proud moment for them when they made the move!
I also wouldn’t count births or deaths. People don’t choose where they’re born. The exodus theory is generally supported by reference to “net internal migration.” (People coming from other states minus people moving to other states.) That’s really what illustrates people voting with their feet.
- thetrb 5y agoMoving from NYC to Long Island is slightly different than moving from California to Tennessee, so I don't really understand your point.
- nodesocket 5y agoI did just this, left San Francisco for Nashville. Anecdotally I’ve been seeing a huge uptick in California plates here in Nashville. Great, I did the same thing, welcome, but now don’t ruin it.
- lr4444lr 5y agoOther than the raw comparative distance, how is it different?
- rayiner 5y agoThe point is that they didn’t move to NYC because they love NYC as a place. They moved there because a Bangladeshi network can help you get a job at Dunkin Donuts and sign up for various social services. Once they had their legs under them they left the city.
- bin_bash 5y agoWhat about family visas for folks from Mexico and the Philippines? I’m suspicious H1-B would even be the majority of international immigration in California.
- random314 5y agoThis unfairly discounts the immigrants that California attracts , while counting folks who leave. To be consistent we must look at population growth as a whole, possibly split by age group. California will typically attract younger folks looking for work.
- deep-root 5y agoWell said. CA immigrants paid ~$50bn in taxes in 2018, ~50% naturalize, a million are business owners.[1] Almost 40% of Silicon Valley is immigrants. Half of all immigrants that come to the US land in California. Most from Asia and Europe. On paper this is an exceedingly productive population, and represents 25% of California. [1] https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/immigrants-in-california https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/research/immigran...
- rayiner 5y agoIt discounts international immigration in from every state, so California isn’t especially penalized in that regard. It’s not unfair—all it does is separate the question of what makes a state a good destination for international immigrants (which involves very specific factors) and the question of what makes a state a desirable place to live for Americans who have unrestricted choices about where to live.
- random314 5y agoDiscounting international immigration from every state is obviously unfair. United States is a country built by immigrants. It is true that most American states are unable to attract immigrants. However, they do reap the benefits from the powerhouse states that keep America competitive in the global economic sphere.
- dv_dt 5y agoH1b approvals were severely curtailed by the Trump administration. https://insights.dice.com/2020/10/27/h-1b-policy-how-trump-and-biden-compare-to-each-other/ https://insights.dice.com/2020/10/27/h-1b-policy-how-trump-a...
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoIt’s not really weird that immigrants start in California and then wind up elsewhere. That’s normal, and they are quickly replaced with new immigrants anyways. California (and originally New York) as waypoints in immigration before dispersal elsewhere is a very old concept. > That’s really what illustrates people voting with their feet. If you Google “California population”, you get a graph where Texas and California start at the same population in 1940, then you just see California absolutely booming vs the other, with a meteoritic rise in population. Finally, at the end, you see the boom taper off. If one were to just look at that graph, you’d think something like “no one goes there anymore because it’s too crowded.”
- xyzzyz 5y agoIt is in fact weird. The entire question is, why don’t these immigrants stay in California? What do the find so repellent, or what do they find so attractive elsewhere that is not available in California?
- modo_mario 5y agoi don't even live in the US but my first guess would be cost of housing.
- tomjakubowski 5y agoIs there any evidence that international immigrants are actually fleeing the state at such a high rate?
- senormenor 5y agoIf you believe conservative media and "anti-woke" Twitter, California is an unliveable wasteland where you can't walk two paces without stepping over homeless people, discarded needles and human feces, where crime (violent and non-violent) is skyrocketing, where people don't feel safe in their own homes, and where the only response by "progressive" politicians is to double down on their same bad policies that created the mess in the first place. Is any of that true? I have no idea; I've never been to California. But it's what a large percentage of the country believes about the Golden State.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I’m skeptical about counting international immigrants here. International immigration is a function of a very specific thing, in California’s case a measure of H1-B sponsor companies. Most years, California has had more net inbound (not gross) international migration than the national H-1B cap. You are greatly exaggerating the role of the H-1B in California stats. > If Indians come to California so they can get an H-1B from Facebook, but their kids them move to Tennessee because of poor quality of life in California, then that’s consistent with the “exodus” theory in my opinion. Lots of California international immigration is family-based, often with sponsors who themselves immigrated and went through the whole process in CA.
- rayiner 5y agoImmigrants face unique constraints in their choice of where to live. Places that have lots of immigrants will attract more because of family-based migration and people’s desire to be closer to support networks. But that still indirectly comes down to the availability of jobs that will sponsor immigrants. My dad sponsored other members of our family to immigrate. They settled in New York City, because it’s a great place for immigrants without strong language skills and domestic networks to get menial jobs. But that doesn’t make it a great place. My cousin has a foreign master’s degree and works in food service. He’d be way better off doing the same job in North Carolina, where the low pay would go a lot further. But there’s not many Bangladeshis in Asheville who could help him get a job. I’d argue that those same features actually make New York and California kind of a shitty place for people who have more options. The inequality and segregation in those places is soul crushing. My family members that came here in more advantaged positions, e.g., getting a U.S. college degree, settled in places like Colorado and Texas. Those are the same places where native born Americans are going.
- random314 5y ago> Immigrants face unique constraints in their choice of where to live. What you are saying is that California and New York are where the jobs are - hence the immigration. An H1B is equally valid in California and Tennessee. You can flip this argument for those leaving California as well. Out migration out of California should be discounted because the folks moving out are the ones who are no longer productive or competitive in states with higher productivity. The out migration is simply a form of semi-retirement to a cheaper location with low economic activity. Just as expats retiring to Colombia doesn't make Colombia "better" than USA, migration out of California to other states can be discounted. This comment also privileges the choices and constraints faced by 2nd generation immigrants over the choices and constraints of 1st generation immigrants, which is unnecessary. 2nd generation immigrants also face constraints , primarily monetary. Most folks moving to Texas are moving to find a cheaper home, not because they love the politics or the electricity grid or the weather. IMHO, it is best to not add any nuance when numbers give u a fairly unbiased picture.
- tomjakubowski 5y agoWouldn't international immigrants who enter the United States in California and then relocate to another state be counted in the domestic emigrants statistic? > People don’t choose where they’re born. To varying degrees people choose to have children.