6 ms·
The point of crypto currency is to do the exact thing money laundering laws try to prevent: to transfer large sums of cash untraceably across the globe, with no
by jeroenhd 5y ago
The point of crypto currency is to do the exact thing money laundering laws try to prevent: to transfer large sums of cash untraceably across the globe, with no way for the government to do anything about it.
Recently it's become a game of baseless investment, but anyone actually wanting to use crypto currencies as payment should've seen this coming from miles away.
- dash2 5y agoIt's not just money-laundering laws. It's also more general "financial repression", i.e. being forced to hold local currencies while the government inflates them and/or holds the interest rate down. The two tend to blur into each other, I guess.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> two tend to blur into each other Not entirely. Capital controls and currency bans are distinct from AML. South Africa's proximate problem is capital controls. Cryptocurrencies make those controls easier to circumvent. If you look at the countries that are responding forcefully to crypto, it's the ones who want a sovereign monetary policy and relatively fixed exchange rate [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zionic 5y agoExactly. 350+ million people get screwed when the government triples the money supply, but relatively few people use crypto to buy coke and that’s suddenly what it’s all about.
- tablespoon 5y ago> 350+ million people get screwed when the government triples the money supply Not necessairly if those people have a lot of debt, or the inflation fears turn out to be a mirage.
- mhuffman 5y ago> or the inflation fears turn out to be a mirage We have many examples throughout history where dumping large amounts (multiples) of money into an economy causes inflation. And to my knowledge, we have no examples to the contrary (ie, it being a mirage). What would make you think that this time it could be a mirage?
- tablespoon 5y ago> What would make you think that this time it could be a mirage? Because people have been wailing about hyperinflation fears for the last decade at least, and it hasn't happened.
- octopoc 5y agoYou can delay the consequences of bad currency management, but eventually the consequences will hit you, hard. The normal rules are on hold because the USD is the world reserve currency. When USD are manufactured, a huge chunk of them is bought by wealthy foreigners to store value. That means that we haven't felt the consequences of printing lots of money because we've been sharing the consequences with a huge and growing number of wealthy foreigners. But the only reason the USD is the world reserve currency is because there's nothing better. When something better enough comes along, all that USD will come flooding back and we'll suffer all the inflationary consequences of printing money for decades. Those consequences will be compressed to a very short amount of time.
- JetSpiegel 5y ago> The normal rules are on hold because the USD is the world reserve currency. As it has been for more than 50 years. Entire people's lives happened between those "consequences". On the long term, we are all dead.
- yuvadam 5y agoAll cryptocurrencies (sans the ones that are privacy-preserving) are more traceable than fiat money. As for "baseless investment", you might want to read up on hard money properties.
- imtringued 5y ago>As for "baseless investment", you might want to read up on hard money properties. How does hard money ensure that a decay in real investments does not erode the real value of the currency in the long run? It doesn't. You're relying on the rest of the world to make those real investments to maintain the real value of your currency. Having a currency be a store of value just shifts the medium of exchange function to a different currency. The idea that you make a profit off of making it harder to do real investments is absurd. It's equivalent to letting a plot of land sit idle for 20 years while the population grows and then expect the future generation to work hard for it even though you did nothing to improve the value of the land, nor did you help people get higher paying jobs so they can afford your expensive land.
- conanbatt 5y agoThe main interest of governments to ban crypto currency is to levy taxes and have more information on citizenry.
- ineedasername 5y agoAlso to maintain control of monetary policy.
- conanbatt 5y agoIm not so sure. Most countries do not ban foreign currencies.
- infamouscow 5y ago> The point of crypto currency is to do the exact thing money laundering laws try to prevent No. That's not the point of cryptocurrency. > to transfer large sums of cash untraceably across the globe Wrong again. You can trace all transactions across the globe with cryptocurrency. > with no way for the government to do anything about it Why is that a bad thing?
- ethbr0 5y ago> You can trace all transactions across the globe with cryptocurrency * Assuming KYC laws are enforced and account holders are listed
- gorgonzolachz 5y agoKYC only helps to an extent, right? My understanding of crypto is minimal, but if you run your own miner I assume you don't need to verify anything to anyone. You should be able to send out transactions to the network and have them be accepted anonymously, which is what most people who would be interested in money laundering would do.
- ethbr0 5y agoFor proof of work, I think that's true. When things start moving to proof of stake, less so.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Why is that a bad thing? It inhibits tax collection, which funds common goods. It also thwarts law enforcement, which is counter to public benefit. We can debate whether taxes or laws or governments should exist. But they do, and most people seem to favor that. Debating a thing and actively subverting it are different. Just as subverting a thing and expecting such subversion to have no consequences or response are different.
- axx0 5y agoHow exactly does this inhibit tax collection?
- imtringued 5y agoYes, let's be real. The vast majority of people who use cryptocurrencies for payments use them because they have no legal alternative. It's the same problem that all privacy focused technologies "suffer" from. When the law is wrong then you have no choice but to break the law but there is no way to distinguish people escaping from an oppressive government and people laundering money from criminal sources. The oppressed and the criminals both take the same bus.
- ineedasername 5y agowhen the law is wrong Yes, although on a volume basis money laundering for criminal (as in organized crime) is likely much larger than refugees fleeing their country & attempting to take some of their money with them.
- ajkdhcb2 5y ago>but there is no way to distinguish people escaping from an oppressive government and people laundering money from criminal sources Is there a difference? Which governments aren't oppressive so their definitions of criminal sources don't count? I think they are exactly the same thing. A meaningful split might instead be funds derived from violent crime vs victimless crime.
- kerng 5y agoThe whole crypto is bad, reminds me of the crypto wars where governments to this day try to outlaw encryption technology because bad guys can use it also. You know ransomware encrypts data to make it inaccessible - we should ban encryption also. Funny how it even shares the name with cryptocurrencies
- matheusmoreira 5y agoCompletely agree. Money laundering laws are just the financial version of global surveillance. This cryptocurrency debate is just the financial version of the crypto wars. History just keeps repeating. I find it interesting how the government is a lot more heavy handed when money is involved...
- DistantCl3ric 5y agoAccording to Chainalysis, in 2020 only 0.35% of crypto transactions were associated with illicit activity. Cash is still king when it comes to crime. Crypto can help make it harder for criminals.
- mrzimmerman 5y agoHow does Chainalysis claim to know the intent behind all of the crypto transactions they studied?
- DistantCl3ric 5y agoGood question! I am not sure! I had a brief look at their 2020 and 2021 report but I havent been able to see how they got the data and reached their conclusions. Its worth noting that their entire business is built around detecting blockchain based illicit activities.
- mrzimmerman 5y agoThat’s interesting! I’ll search it out and see what I can find.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoI thought money laundering laws were trying to prevent money laundering, not transferring of cash.
- tim333 5y agoThough the article isn't really about that - it's about South Africa's capital controls which long predate crypto.