9 ms·
Apple's camera design choices from the iPhone 6S Plus to the 12 Pro Max [pdf]
- SilverRed 5y agoKind of interesting but the good stuff is blurred out. Makes me wish that these big tech companies would release the full uncensored data for their obsolete products. How nice would it be if Apple shared a huge archive of technical info on the original iphone. Surely there is nothing left on that device that is secret or of any use outside of curiosity.
- aberatiu 5y agoIf you select the blurred section in a browser, then paste it somewhere, you can view the text/information. Worked for me in most of the sections, but not all.
- unglaublich 5y agoAh, accessibility features! Classic example of why you need to check all meta-data from PDF documents before releasing.
- londons_explore 5y agoYou can remove the blur from the images by editing the source code of the pdf with a text editor...
- CamperBob2 5y agoLooks like 4 MB of Perl. What's a good string to search for?
- Cipater 5y agoHow are you able to copy and paste the blurred sections? I can't even select them.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoWould be nice, but it’s virtually impossible. Products like the iPhone are a combination of many different suppliers’ parts and many different vendors’ work, all with various contractual requirements. There’s almost zero upside for companies to go through all of the effort of preparing and releasing that information, however trivial it may seem from the outside.
- ethbr0 5y agoThis is why an EOL right to repair law covering devices would be progress. Alter the expectation from "Apple would have to ask" to "Apple expects their suppliers to comply with the law."
- dehrmann 5y agoAll the rear cameras have been 12MP since the 6s?
- BoorishBears 5y agoX Megapixels lost all meaning a while ago. The size of the sensor and the smarts behind it matter a lot more
- nicolas_t 5y agoEven during the megapixels wars, Fuji released some great point and shoot cameras that had less megapixels but better image quality due to having a bigger sensor. For example, the f31d was great in its time and showed that megapixels weren't the only measure to look for.
- peanutz454 5y agoWhy don't manufacturers advertise that more clearly? I've never seen that information on the simple specs that most models list out.
- BoorishBears 5y agoIt's not easy to qualitatively represent your fancy HDR algorithms and focus finding, especially in the realm of phones where there are fewer standard terms to play with (even something as simple as OIS means nothing to 99% of buyers) That's why you see a focus on showing off the end results now, like Apple's rebooted "Shot on iPhone" campaign or Samsung's current photo competition restricted to photos taken with a Galaxy S21
- einr 5y agoFor a long time it was very easy to advertise cameras by the number of megapixels, and consumers supposedly like easy to understand numbers where bigger is better. This used to be kind of true back in the day of <6MP but raw megapixel numbers have been fairly useless for fifteen years or so. It's a slow process moving away from this once you've drilled it into people's heads with marketing. It's just like how MHz used to be an easy and fairly reliable way to compare CPU's in the 90's and it took a really long time for the general public to understand that clock speed isn't all that matters.
- Faaak 5y agoIf you are interested in reverse engineering and cost analysis, Munro associates does the same for cars. Their youtube chain is really interesting, you should check it out: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj--iMtToRO_cGG_fpmP5XQ https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCj--iMtToRO_cGG_fpmP5XQ
- aspenmayer 5y agoThat’s a great channel, thanks for the recommendation. It speaks to their reputation that they got a one-on-one interview with Elon Musk.
- JoBrad 5y agoWatched the video about reducing the VW ID.4 battery tray yesterday; it was really interesting to hear how they collaborated with so many groups to redesign it. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cjJUpqo1YDM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cjJUpqo1YDM
- justapassenger 5y agoIt’s pretty good content, but you should know some history. He first trashed Tesla model 3, but after huge Internet outcry realized that there’s a lot of money in catering to fans. He’s now a proper Tesla fanboy, making money on Tesla stock and selling sticker to the fans. A lot of credibility is gone. But content is still pretty good to learn basics of stuff like that works, just keep in mind bias in it.
- avalys 5y agoHow can you tell the difference between the events you described, and Munro genuinely changing his mind about Tesla and the Model 3?
- bsaul 5y agohas anyone else got the impression that default compression ruined the image quality on very recent devices ? i moved from iphone se2 to 12 pro and took pictures of trees and grass, and was wondering why all my pictures looked blurred. Then i activated the uncompressed pro format and got much better results (with images weighting a ton more of course) i still have to get back to the se2 and see if i have the same problems but it was the first time i was completely unimpressed by the camera when upgrading my phone.
- nicolas_t 5y agoI've noticed the same, it's frustrating that the defaults would be this extreme especially given how much storage those phones have nowadays.
- berkut 5y agoIt has (or at least aggressive denoising) since the 6S I still have. If you look at the images at 1:1, they sometimes look like watercolours with regards to edges.
- pletnes 5y agoThis is very true in dim lighting. Take a photo in low light and any skin imperfections are washed away. Less true in daylight conditions, which is when mobile cameras shine, in my opinion.
- berkut 5y agoJust as true for the 6S (and friends' more modern iPhones) in bright sunlight which should be at ISO 100 in my experience...
- formerly_proven 5y agoOh no, a small sensor like the iPhone's is quite noisy at ISO 100. The base ISO for these is around 20-25.
- 5y ago
- shadilay 5y agoSo this is basically just an advertisement?
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoPretty much, but that isn’t an instant disqualifier. Lots of “Show HN” links are basically ads. If people think it’s interesting (ad, or not), it will be promoted. If not, it won’t live long.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoNot quite because some useful infos can be viewed. Unfortunately the full pdf is available after payment. By the way I’m absolutely not involved in any way with the site/producer of the report!
- kumarvvr 5y agoI wonder if anyone can reverse blur images in the PDF.
- bobiny 5y agoIn my experience with dual camera it does portraits and HDR with sky good, but not so great with greenery. I’m enthusiastic about larger sensors like in Sharp Aquos R6 https://www.phonearena.com/news/sharp-aquos-r6-camera-samples-1-inch-sensor_id132511 https://www.phonearena.com/news/sharp-aquos-r6-camera-sample...
- kwanbix 5y agoVery cool I hope it catches up. I prefer one excellent camera over 3 or 4 average ones.
- bobiny 5y agoI think it’s similar to analogue vs digital filmmaking. Analogue is harder to do, but can be uniquely amazing.
- rjzzleep 5y agoI just can't understand why the Japanese companies manage to create these amazing devices with absolutely niche pricing and subpar software. It seems like Chinese companies figured out a while back that they need to make their software at least seem good if they want to capture the global market. Obviously the price is an even bigger aspect of the equation.
- bobiny 5y agoMaybe the are happy selling to Japanese market’s geeks exclusively. By geek I mean this kind of tech fans who don’t mind figuring out the interface. As for this particular device I think Japan is a perfect test market: they seem to love DSLRs and this phone is sort of a pure camera experience vs neural network enhanced multi-camera setup. I hope it catches on so more companies make such phones and drive prices down.
- dzhiurgis 5y agoWow @ how badly this site is broke with ad blocker and even more wow when you disable it.
- londons_explore 5y agoFor a reverse engineering company... Applying the blur as a PDF postfilter that can easily be removed with a grep on the pdf source code seems not very smart...
- nickparker 5y agoHas anybody reverse engineered the interface for Apple's camera modules, particularly the front modules with LIDAR? They can be had for $10 a pop on Alibaba now, and they're much nicer than similarly priced webcams let alone LIDARs. Seems like a part that's ripe for a raspberry pi interface board.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 5y agoAre they available for $10 or is that the price some "iPhone Teardown!!" article wrote? Because I tend to be sceptical of those articles. They start with the premise of "everything is worth as much as the sum of its component parts", which is already hit on their credibility (if they did the same, recursively, they'd notice that nothing is worth anything). Then, they guess some random values for Apple's purchasing costs.
- rowanG077 5y agoI'm not sure why you asking this. The poster quite obviously indicates you can trivially buy them on Aliexpress. You can verify this yourself in less time then it took to type this comment. And indeed the front-facing camera can be had for very cheap. The back module with Lidar is more expensive though.
- starky 5y agoI would be very surprised if the camera modules put out anything different than the standard image sensor interfaces such as SPI, MIPI, and SLVS. Anything else would require extra circuitry that is too big. Then it just becomes a case of figuring out the control for the lens module.
- braincode 5y agoI'm actually surprised that nobody tried to poke into those lines yet and built something similar to https://hackaday.com/2021/07/05/how-to-drive-smartphone-screens-over-hdmi/ https://hackaday.com/2021/07/05/how-to-drive-smartphone-scre... but for the camera. Actually, since that project above links to a iPhone 4 screen as an example, I'd perhaps err into probing for MIPI signals on an iPhone 6S camera first, perhaps using sth like https://hackaday.com/2018/11/29/mipi-csi-2-implementation-in-fpgas/ https://hackaday.com/2018/11/29/mipi-csi-2-implementation-in...? This post is fascinating, btw: https://www.circuitvalley.com/2020/01/spi-mipi-bridge-fpga-verilog-hdl-ipod-nano-nano-lcd-iphone-mipi-lcd.html https://www.circuitvalley.com/2020/01/spi-mipi-bridge-fpga-v...
- achow 5y agoFull Report: Euro 6490 https://www.systemplus.fr/reverse-costing-reports/camera-module-comparison-2021-vol-2-iphone-evolution/ https://www.systemplus.fr/reverse-costing-reports/camera-mod...