4 ms·
This is called unschooling and has been around for decades. My friend is a big believer in unschooling. You basically just give kids resources and then let th
by jedberg 5y ago
This is called unschooling and has been around for decades. My friend is a big believer in unschooling. You basically just give kids resources and then let them learn whatever they are interested in.
There have been long term studies done on kids that grew up in unschooled households. They tended to do fine in college, but were no better or worse off. They tended to score slightly higher on emotional evaluations and also tended to be slightly more predisposed to entrepreneurship and the arts (and less interested in careers with more rigid structure like science and engineering).
- nostrebored 5y agoCompletely agreed that this is just unschooling. I'd be interested to see the data on outcomes though. From the (fairly large) number of unschooling people I've met, the results seem to be much more extreme. People are either working upper-class white collar jobs or chronically unemployed.
- jedberg 5y agoThis is a good summary: https://www.kqed.org/mindshift/37091/how-do-unschoolers-turn-out https://www.kqed.org/mindshift/37091/how-do-unschoolers-turn...
- actfrench 5y agoI absolutely love the unschooling community and that approach to raising and educating children. However, I think this is a misnomer in many instances and a better word to describe a specific type of learning as necessary. As I understand it unschooling mostly applies to an approach that heavily emphasizes self-directed learning. In other cases, uschooling is a broad word which ranges from families who have no structure to their children's education to ones who have a full schedule with lots of academics. Modular Learning is an educational movement of parents who want greater flexibility, but also a rigorous and challenging education for their children which their composing through modules (tutors, learning apps, classes, skill shares) Modular learning doesn't preclude going to school either. In many cases, Modular learners go to school but complement that with afterschool activities, apps and tutors. The studies you refer to also show that families who use pure unschooling do mostly the same , but those with some structure do better academically. It's hard to really give credit to these studies because they apply to such a small sample of kids whose families are actively involved in their learning. More research is definitely needed.
- actfrench 5y agoAlso, part of this is I think there's a need for a new word that is not a negative one, not anti-school, but pro-learning and pro-education. Homeschooling, unschooling deschooling and most of the terms I hear don't really define this innovative group of pioneers. I think words are important and the word should not be in opposition to something but proactive. If there's another word you think could work, I'd love to hear it.
- runawaybottle 5y agoIf we just apply some of what we have learned about WFH in knowledge professions to, ironically, another knowledge profession (students), we can can easily see how physical attendance can be a distraction. If a lot of kids are behind, or struggling, dealing with the social aspects of school (do you fit in? Do you have friends?) and rigor of work (wake up at 8am, power through a 8 hour a day, 40 min lunch break), then there’s no point in saddling them with that extra burden. We don’t give kids the flexibility that we ourselves need to distance ourself and focus on things from time to time. When you don’t provide that, they will do what all of us do, disassociate and approach things in a ‘whatever, life sucks’ way.
- jvvw 5y agoAs somebody who has read more than average about home education and unschooling and certainly contemplated it, but ultimately decided to send their children to school (and can see the pros and cons!), that is interesting. It must be hard to control for the type of parents who decide to unschool and I'm curious as to how they did that. I guess there might also be a bias in terms of which types of children parents are inclined to home-educate, although I imagine most families do home-ed all their children. I sometimes wonder if mine had been the other way round if the decision might have gone the other way - I think school suits my oldest much more than my youngest.