22 ms·
A call to minimize distraction and respect users’ attention (2013)
- cmehdy 5y agoFor other readers: this seems to be an internal google presentation made public to tell engineers to respect users' attention. I guess as a user of the website it didn't respect my attention enough to make me want to click through the whole thing. I dropped out after twenty or so clicks, having read less and less stuff after a few slides.
- chris_wot 5y agoI’m afraid the same happened for me. I just couldn’t get to the end. It was, uh, distracting me.
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoAgreed. Ironically, the slideshow format is extremely 'low density', and frustrates my ability to quickly read what they have to say. I didn't get all the way through it either.
- novok 5y agoIt's meant to be clicked through quickly in a live presentation, like a tv show, not the 'book page' style that most people have a harder time with absorbing. It's not a blog article.
- test_epsilon 5y agoWould be kind of clever if it was actually intended to waste time and frustrate people.
- mountainb 5y agoIt's a great format for reaching functional illiterates, which accurately describes huge portions of the white collar workforce.
- fmajid 5y agoAmen. For more on that, see Edward Tufte's "The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint". It's no wonder Jeff Bezos insists on his subordinates bringing 2-3 page length essays, not slides, to decision meetings. https://www.inf.ed.ac.uk/teaching/courses/pi/2016_2017/phil/tufte-powerpoint.pdf https://www.inf.ed.ac.uk/teaching/courses/pi/2016_2017/phil/... https://mondaynote.com/bezos-a-ceo-who-can-write-2f368ee36599 https://mondaynote.com/bezos-a-ceo-who-can-write-2f368ee3659...
- MaxBarraclough 5y agoRegarding the first link, which (perhaps ironically) I've only skim-read: much of it seems to be attacking bad slideshows, rather than inherent problems with the format. A slideshow isn't meant to be read in the absence of a speaker giving a presentation. It exists to support the speaker in their presentation. If the intent is to offer a resource which can act as a substitute for attending a presentation, a slideshow is an inappropriate choice. A good lecture typically makes effective use of a slideshow. Lectures are mostly non-interactive, but this needs no apology, contrary to what the article seems to imply. Perhaps other kinds of presentations should be more interactive, but I don't see that non-interactivity is always a failing. Similarly, a good slideshow can make effective use of bullet-points. Bullet-points don't always mean you're skipping over important detail, or that you've failed to properly structure the content. > The Board views the endemic use of PowerPoint briefing slides instead of technical papers as an illustration of the problematic methods of technical communication at NASA Right. A slideshow is not a substitute for a proper write-up, it's just a presentation aid. In some contexts you might get away with not doing a formal write-up, but certainly not in a life-and-death context like the one mentioned in the article. > For serious presentations, it will be useful to replace PowerPoint slides with paper handouts showing words, numbers, data graphics, images together. I can see that might work well, but I can see this might degrade into just rewriting a technical paper to fit the flow of the presentation. It might make more sense to just say For more detail, see the formal paper. Certainly a slideshow is not a substitute for a proper paper, but even a handout will presumably lose some of what the full paper has to say. If the full information is already there in the paper, why not refer people to it?
- epivosism 5y agoThe enforced ~500ms loading time between slides is a killer. Why not preload and display them immediately?
- emaro 5y agoOn mobile, the slides switched instantly. On Firefox Desktop it's like from hell.
- epivosism 5y agoWeird, how does that work? Is the mobile browser simulating the click and then noticing the next image to be loaded? Maybe the js is simple enough to prove that it's safe to do so, but wow.
- leereeves 5y agoFor me, using Firefox on a Mac, the slides also switched instantly.
- neogodless 5y agoOn Firefox for Windows 10 - instant slide transitions. Ryzen 7 2700X, 32GB, 300/300 mbps connection.
- anonydsfsfs 5y agoThere isn't a fixed 500ms loading time. It advances slides by changing the background image of the central "pic" element. This is the JS to advance the slide: function increment(){ if(imgNum < 141){ imgNum++; }else{ imgNum = 1; } url = "url('img/vrg_google_doc_final_vrs03-"+imgNum+".jpg')"; document.getElementById('pic').style.backgroundImage=url; } The reason you see a flicker is because it takes time to load the next image, and until it loads you're going to see the black background. As you mentioned, the preloading images would solve this.
- waterhouse 5y agoI resorted to holding the up-arrow key to trigger loading of a bunch of slides, then holding down-arrow to get back to where I was, and finally getting a smooth transition experience.
- ssivark 5y agoAnd it broke the back button! There seems to be no way to go back a slide if you forwarded by tapping accidentally!!!
- david_allison 5y agoThe left arrow key does this
- ssivark 5y agoOn mobile. (Firefox on iOS, in case it matters)
- jrochkind1 5y agoThat was my reaction. Terrible UI with grainy graphics, took a long time to get to the point. Talk about wasting time! I gave up about 20 slides in too.
- bqui 5y ago"Terrible UI", is that a concern for you ? this world should go to shit, that man put himself in a uncomfortable situation to give the world a preview.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- perihelions 5y agoIf anyone wants the plain text transcription of the slides, this site appears to have that: https://digitalwellbeing.org/googles-internal-digital-wellbeing-presentation-transcript-and-slides/ https://digitalwellbeing.org/googles-internal-digital-wellbe... >"A Call to Minimize Distraction and Respect Users’ Attention." >"by Tristan Harris." >"I’m concerned about how we’re making the world more distracted. And my goal with this presentation is to create a movement at Google to create a new design ethic that aims to minimise distraction and I’d like to get your help."
- hinkley 5y agoWait, isn't Tristan Harris pseudo-famous for walking/running away from Google and starting a tech ethics company? He's one of the stars of the Social Dilemma, right?
- eloisius 5y agoHe's the founder of the Center for Human Technology[1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_Harris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_Harris
- musicale 5y agoThat is so much better. Slide shows like this are an annoyingly distracting waste of people's time and attention! Like a simple list of 10 items which is made into ten web pages that you have to click through individually - wasting your time and attention to trick you into viewing more advertising.
- lolive 5y agoAka Death By PowerPoint
- andygcook 5y agoI was surprised to see this is an internal Google presentation. FYI the way to advance it on mobile is to click the slides. It took me a few seconds to figure that out.
- echelon 5y agoThis is great and all of it true, but the needs of these companies are counter to the goals presented here. Ad funded products need to steal time and attention to be profitable. Apple might be in a position to do something, but Facebook, Twitter, and Google depend on ad revenue. Even subscription companies like Netflix are hyper focused on engagement. I was daydreaming yesterday about a national mandate to shut down social media on the first of every month. (Phone calls and texting are okay, but absolutely nothing else.) Something like that will never happen, but I think the world would collectively realize what this stuff is doing to us if we had to step away. We're all addicted and distracted.
- DevKoala 5y agoIt would never happen because social media would convince users to vote against their own interests. Like Facebook did with the Apple debacle.
- agency 5y agoYeah to be honest this feels like a Googler trying to deal with their guilty conscience by starting a "movement" that fundamentally cannot go anywhere because it runs entirely counter to the economic incentives that animate ad tech companies.
- notriddle 5y agoTristan Harris, the author of this presentation, wound up leaving the company. I guess it didn't work.
- rglullis 5y agoI agree with your overall point, but I believe that this could (and hopefully will) change without any top-down mandate. I think we just need a minority group of people who are unbreakable in their intolerance of ad-funded services, much like RMS and the first FOSS developers were intolerant of running any type of proprietary software. It dawned on me with the whole WhatsApp thing of fucking around with the privacy policy: I didn't mind using it before, but that was the final nail in the coffin. I uninstalled it and I told my friends/family that whoever wanted to reach me could do with Matrix, phone or plain email. I also would gladly help set an account for them on my communick group plan. Of course not all of them did, but the ones who did realized that it was not the end of the world to use a new app and were glad to be able to say that they were not enslaved to whatever Facebook had to offer. Some of these friends even signed up for their own plan, so they could invite more people on their own, etc...
- throwaway3699 5y agoIf memory serves, this presentation was created at Google years ago by Tristan Harris, who also had a huge part to play in The Social Dilemma.
- zmix 5y agoOuch! Nothing changed and it got worse, dare I say. He mentions a point, I have had for years, and that is, that these 25-35 year old nerds from the Bay area define too much of out every day's culture. Just look what happened to HTML: once a document system, manageable by everyone, now a more and more complex app system, dare I say WASM, etc.?
- emaro 5y agoFunny enough that the presentation loops (at least on my phone) and just shows the first slide after the last one without any indication of it.
- echelon 5y agoI kind of like it. No complex UI showing forward/back, how many slides deep you are, etc. Just the slides themselves. It reminds me of "minimal" UIs in video games that remove health bars, stats, etc. so that the content is front and center. Ico, Shadow of the Colossus, etc. Almost cinematic.
- epivosism 5y agoIt's pretty easy to just force the browser to preload images a few early, which would eliminate all of the variable, ~2-500ms delay between frames. This would increase the impact of this presentation. function preload(n) var preloader = $('<img style="display:none;" />'); preloader.attr("src","img/vrg_google_doc_final_vrs03-"+n+".jpg'); $('body').prepend(preloader); } the js in the source of the page: var imgNum = '1'; function increment(){ if(imgNum < 141){ imgNum++; }else{ imgNum = 1; } url = "url('img/vrg_google_doc_final_vrs03-"+imgNum+".jpg')"; document.getElementById('pic').style.backgroundImage=url; preload(imgNum+1) //PRELOADING }
- zmix 5y agoVery nice document, speaks from my heart. But the document's format sucks! I do not even get an address in the addressbar in Vivaldi. I would love to download this as PDF or in any other presentation format, but it seems to be impossible, without going through the code.
- Isthatablackgsd 5y agoGo back to the website and append in the address bar "/img/" without the quote marks on the end and boom you get a full list of slide. Enjoy. Very easy to find since it only took 5 sec to load up the console and bam it is right there.
- zmix 5y agoYeah, that's what I said: You have to open up the dev-console. Which sucks for a document download.
- cratermoon 5y agoI generated a PDF using img2pdf. It's 4.8MB.
- ElijahLynn 5y agoThis is a really inspiring presentation and I am going to be spreading this one around!
- ubicomp 5y agoAlso see calmtech.com
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ubicomp 5y agoAlso see the principles of calm technology at calmtech.com
- teawrecks 5y agoI honestly can't tell if this is a joke. It's got some good ideas, but the way it's presented violates all of their suggestions.
- TheJoeMan 5y agoI know right? "Let users know how long of a commitment they're making" and then not one progress bar or slide counter like 1/23,085 .
- aresant 5y agoThis presentation is wonderful for its PR value "people here care" but naïve bordering on malicious in its approach and understanding of Google's business. 11 years ago PG called the iPad the "hip flask" of the internet (1) and it's 10x worse today than it was then. The incentives of every major ad-supported tech platform are the same - maximize engagement to maximize profit. Every dollar of profit, every promotion, every individual incentive is tied to that metric outside of some lip-service like this to keep HRs job manageable. If you don't like it, quit and work for somebody else whos business model is disconnected from engagement. Full stop. (1) http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html http://www.paulgraham.com/addiction.html
- tomaskafka 5y agoThis. In a long term, company will never do anything against incentives their business model sets up. Google is the ad company. Don't work for ad conpany.
- aiisjustanif 5y agoTell that to the many SF tech workers optimizing for profit.
- Swizec 5y agoI am an SF tech worker. Lots of companies here selling pickaxes. Twilio, for example, doesn’t need engagement. Last I heard they were swimming in money.
- aiisjustanif 5y agoOh I agree that there are companies selling pickaxes and not doing business realm of Facebook and Google (if we are sticking to the subject of ads). However, hopefully anecdotally, just go take a look a metrics and sentiments from tech employees on Blind. If Google is paying more than Twilio, there will be droves of people grinding to get in.
- 5y ago
- superjan 5y agoHey Google, if you’re still into this, how about disabling autosuggest and autoplay for anyone on youtube?
- rdiddly 5y agoBeing made to nibble little bites of text one at a time is a distraction. Images depicting clumsy or irrelevant metaphors of easily understood things are a distraction.
- IlliOnato 5y agoI had exactly the same thought. But perhaps the author wanted to drive the point home :-)
- Andrex 5y agoIt seems like this is a leaked internal presentation from Google, not meant for public consumption. That's what I take away from "Google Confidential and Proprietary" in the bottom right. Some more context over what this is and who wrote it would be immensely valuable. Edit- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27764579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27764579
- cratermoon 5y agoSome additional context previously on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27671055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27671055 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27585602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27585602 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27535584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27535584
- titzer 5y agoEndless nitpicking turns everything into infighting and makes everything suck. Can we have a conversation about substance at some point?
- neolog 5y agoIt's a slide deck from a presentation, not an essay.
- rdiddly 5y agoHmm, maybe, presentations are a distraction?
- novok 5y agoThis was made in 2013: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_Harris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristan_Harris
- an1sotropy 5y agothanks for this info. I recognize him now from the Social Dilemma movie.
- soumyadeb 5y agoWatching "Social Dilemma" on Netflix (a movie made by Netflix) was quite an irony. Most people "waste" more time on Netflix than all other social platforms combined. Yet, "Social Dilemma" covered/blamed every company except Netflix :)
- pnt12 5y agoI'd argue that the value you get from a movie or TV show is higher than social media posts or memes, so it's not an apples to apples comparison.
- zestyping 5y agoThis presentation is from 2013. It's a historical artifact that helped kick off the movement to fight distraction in its early days, not the state of the art thinking of the current day. Obviously, a lot of the concerns it expresses are still very relevant.
- cratermoon 5y agoWhat is the state of thinking currently? What's changed? The presentation was created eight years ago and leaked three years ago, but it has never appeared on HN before. What progress has been made?
- throwaway3699 5y agoDigital Wellbeing on Android was one major example of something that seemed to have come from this. I believe iOS also built something similar.
- cratermoon 5y agoOh, a notification that tells me a distracting device has been distracting me for too long, and that I should take a break. That's effectively nothing: it hasn't challenged the attention model itself. It's like if a casino had scantily-clad women wandering the floor offering men at the slot machines a free drink. They aren't doing that to help the gentlemen, they are just adjusting the incentives.
- filleduchaos 5y agoThat's rather uncharitable - Digital Wellbeing has more features than just the notification, which is an entrypoint not the entire product.
- crazygringo 5y agoOh wow, that's from 8 years ago. And then it got leaked outside of Google 3 years ago it seems -- this article [1] provides a ton more context. Just for context, and before people start accusing Google of hypocrisy or anything -- these slides never represented an official (or unofficial) Google position or anything. They're not PR. They're just a single employee's opinion in slideshow form, an opinion he was trying to build support for internally. Whether you think it made any kind of impact is a fun thought question though. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/10/17333574/google-android-p-update-tristan-harris-design-ethics https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/10/17333574/google-android-p...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- azinman2 5y agoI don't see how calling out the demographics of the designers making the decisions has anything to do with the larger implications of societal impact. There are terrible things done by people of every demographic to millions of people, as well as great things. It's also less and less true (tho probably more so in 2013 when this was created), yet the problems still exist because the incentives are there (the real issue).
- cratermoon 5y agoWhy shouldn't that be part of the discussion? The actions of a few people with a certain common worldview having an impact on billions of peoples and the effects of that worldview ought to be examined, what's the objection to that? > the problems still exist because the incentives are there Yes, and who determines the incentives and provides the rewards?
- azinman2 5y agoIt’s worthwhile to note the impact that few people have, but I don’t see how calling out demographics has any impact on YouTube video recommendations as a design pattern. Are we to believe a team of elderly Pacific Islander females wouldn’t make such choices, when the high level business goal is to retain people’s attention for as long as possible? The incentives and rewards are provided by the market in the form of capital returns on clicks and viewership… globally across all demographics.
- cratermoon 5y ago> Are we to believe a team of elderly Pacific Islander females wouldn’t make such choices, when the high level business goal is to retain people’s attention for as long as possible? The business goals were defined by the people in question. Your hypothetical group of Polynesian women might not even entertain that goal. The people who started Twitter, Facebook, Google, and Amazon all had a common worldview which informed the goals they set. The attention economy model is just an expression of that. > The incentives and rewards are provided by the market in the form of capital returns on clicks and viewership… globally across all demographics. That particular formulation is part of the neoliberal economic consensus. It has nothing to do with how a group of people with no particular fealty to that world view would act.
- xk7 5y agoTrite clichés over stock photos, is this parody?
- bingidingi 5y agoI wish. I feel like this is the epitome of a specific type of slide-based presentation. This information could be covered in a single page of text, but ironically no one has the attention span to actually read... so instead we get low-density presentations with memes and cliches.
- lamontcg 5y agoMake junk mail and spam e-mail illegal to start with. Then start doing something about regulating advertising. In an ideal world intrusive advertising would be banned and we'd have to go looking for ads to find them instead of them constantly demanding that we pay attention to them. But that'd entirely blow up Google's whole business model.
- Bjartr 5y ago> Make junk mail and spam e-mail illegal to start with. CAN-SPAM[0] does exactly that for US businesses. Any email from a US business that is for advertisement or otherwise promotional (as distinct from transactional[1]) then it: * Must not have false or misleading from/to/reply-to * Must not have a deceptive subject * Must be labeled an ad * Must include a valid physical postal address * Must have a clear and conspicuous[2] way to opt-out * Must have a working opt-out process within 10 business days of the user opting-out * Must follow all these rules, even if the business contracts out their email marketing Obviously, fly-by-night businesses and scams aren't going to follow these rules, but by-and-large all legitimate businesses do because each individual email that violates this rule can incur a $40,000+ fine The FTC has a site[3] for reporting fraud violations, and CAN-SPAM violations fall under the "something else" category in the generic fraud violation report form according to the FTC's FAQ[4] [0] https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/can... [1] i.e. it's not to inform you a something happened in the app/site e.g. you have a notification or some action you initiated has completed [2] in practice, a link with text "Unsubscribe" at the bottom of the email is sufficient. [3] https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/ https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/ [4] https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/#/faq/faq-search/spam https://reportfraud.ftc.gov/#/faq/faq-search/spam
- cratermoon 5y agoI remember when the CAN-SPAM act was in Congress. All of us who were following the issue looked at it and said, "this just legitimizes spam, puts a nice picket fence around it, and make sure that any company that wants to spam you knows exactly where the boundaries are so they can do so with impunity". As we expected, it didn't reduce spam at all, but now we have and industry and entire companies dedicated to mass unsolicited email. But they aren't breaking any laws.
- ibejoeb 5y agoStarted great, but then veered off into attacking the identity of the purported perpetrators. Might be cool at a conference, but in the real world you're losing lots of people.
- cratermoon 5y agoWhat specifically is the objection? The companies mentioned are the key players, the people that run them determined, and still influence, the product direction. Why shouldn't that be part of the discussion?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- AlbertCory 5y agoIt's funny how almost all the comments are about technical aspects of the presentation or how he said it, and not what he said. He's right, FWIW. How many times have I had to yell "Hel-LO!" at some bozo staring at his phone & not watching where he's walking? However, how would you regulate this? If you created a metric of "attention-sucking" and set a legal limit on it, the web giants would immediately game it.
- iseethroughbs 5y agoIt's easy to be right. But to be right is not the same as being useful.
- AlbertCory 5y ago"Easy to be right"?? Good to know. But why isn't everyone doing it, then? Maybe you have a useful idea on regulating attention-sucking? Please share.
- savingsPossible 5y agoHe/she probably meant "its easier to point a real problem than to find a real, stable solution"
- iseethroughbs 5y agoThat's what I meant.
- iseethroughbs 5y agoEveryone is doing it. At the pub after work. They take turns being right about politics, being right about sports, being right about their boss, being right about the state of society and Susan the receptionist. They're spot-on right about her. And if they skip the pub, they take out their phones and go being right online on Facebook, Twitter, Reddit and Hacker News.
- neogodless 5y ago
- SimeVidas 5y agoIs the presentation un-scrollable just for me?
- baby 5y agoI don’t understand how I can go back one slide
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marto1 5y agoDecentralize so you won't have to beg your master to cut you some slack. Anything else is just talk imho.
- iudexgundyr 5y agoThis presentation distracted me from my work. :))))
- valw 5y agoA shameless-because-related plug: https://www.reddit.com/r/patient_hackernews/ https://www.reddit.com/r/patient_hackernews/ A Hacker News mirror biased in favor of thoughtful discussion, by enforcing that you cannot comment on something in less than 24 hours. This might help you spend less of your attention on Hacker News, by: 1. Showing you a subset of hot posts 2. Enforcing high response delays (thus suppressing the impulse to frantically refresh for new comments). This particular post can be discussed here: https://www.reddit.com/r/patient_hackernews/comments/ofqb6n/a_call_to_minimize_distraction_and_respect_users/ https://www.reddit.com/r/patient_hackernews/comments/ofqb6n/... Please give feedback!
- ottomanbob 5y agoI've been dying for a tool like this. Just want to sort hacker news by week / months. So I could stop checking everyday. Will give feedback
- perihelions 5y ago"Just want to sort hacker news by week" HN has hidden functionality for that: https://news.ycombinator.com/best https://news.ycombinator.com/best https://news.ycombinator.com/lists https://news.ycombinator.com/lists
- CryingSofa 5y agoAbsolutely. I recently switched my bookmark to https://news.ycombinator.com/best https://news.ycombinator.com/best and I get much more high-quality links in the list. Now, I read about 60% of the stories. Previously it was more like 10%. Also, links stay on the page for ~3 days, so I spend much less time scrolling because I already saw almost everything.
- bckr 5y agoAlgolia might do that for you https://hn.algolia.com/ https://hn.algolia.com/
- crackercrews 5y ago
- asteroidbelt 5y agoPresentations like these assume people are dumb animals not being able to control their lives. They need to artificially constrained to help them live. Saying bluntly, they need a nanny. I'm an active user or Google, Facebook, Apple, Twitter and all of them. I turned off GMail notifications for non-important mails. I unsubscribe/report spam promotional e-mail. YouTube autoplay is off (simply because the recommender is not good enough, but I'd happily turned them on otherwise). I unsubscribed from junk groups on Facebook, but the connections on Facebook is very important since I can't meet with most of my friends in person. My Twitter notifications are off, and I do mute often, but the remaining Twitter suggestions are quite interesting. Almost all notifications are off on my phone, but remaining are very helpful. And so on. The largest distraction in my life is a chat app which is used by my employer. But this is not service provider/product problem: it's company decision to use that application instead of e-mail. Other chat apps I'm used for communication with my friends are not distracting. The suggestions by the presentation author is irrational: let's stop business growth assuming it will make people more happy. This is not how the world works: if a company start making less efficient product, it will die, and not because of ads revenue, but simply because users will leave for someone who knows how to retain attention. That guy Tristan Harris who did the presentation is morally dishonest person: he wants to his cake and eat it. He got his millions from Google, and then decided to play good guy by virtue signalling with this presentation and by playing in Social Dilemma: working against the same companies which made him wealthy enough to not worry about money for the rest of his life.
- cratermoon 5y ago> Presentations like these assume people are dumb animals not being able to control their lives You're vastly underestimating the potential to exploit human nature. Just by being here ranting like this shows that the topic bypassed your rational executive function and fired up your sympathetic nervous system.
- asteroidbelt 5y ago> You're vastly underestimating the potential to exploit human nature. Human nature were exploited for thousand years, and humans are still doing fine. I didn't see strong arguments why current megacorp mind control is worse than usual. > Just by being here ranting like this shows that the topic bypassed your rational executive function and fired up your sympathetic nervous system. I didn't get it. Are you stating that commenting here is irrational? Or that my arguments are irrational?
- polynomial 5y agoJTN, this was actually what Medium led with when they originally started* (minimizing distractions) to clear all the rubbish out of sight when you are reading a single article, and not have other content & CTA's competing for your attention. Of course, it turned out that alone doesn't imply you actually respect your users' attention, as we saw what Medium turned into. [*the year before this presentation, actually]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- germandiago 5y agoWould this had ever existed if Apple did not start to protrct users fr the same problems? Apple does not live from exploiting data as much as Google. There is a lot of truth in all this. But there is even more marketing. Google is a corporation, and if Apple is doing something about it it's not bc they are good. It is bc they do not care about exploiting data as much. Because they are competing. This proposal would have never existed without competition.
- Zelphyr 5y agoAll I've heard for the past 12+ years is "engagement". The singular focus on that one word to the exclusion of everything else is astounding to me. As if it is some magic incantation on the part of BizDev (or whatever they're called these days) that instantly transmogrifies users into profits. At one company I worked at, we had a digital product that was part of a suite of services our company provided. It was useful to our customers but it's clear, if you see it, that they want to get in, get done what they need to do, and get out. It's a tool to help them do their jobs and nothing more. You'd think that simplicity and efficiency would be celebrated. The number of times I heard "engagement" and "gamification" used about that product from the marketing team, however... Finally I said, "Look. We shouldn't be trying to make our customers spend more time in this product any more than LG does trying to get us to spend more time in our refrigerators." It fell on deaf ears. I should note that, we didn't make any more money the longer someone spent on that product. There was no advertising model associated with it--it is a per-seat hosted solution. So I never could figure out why our marketing team was all about engagement other than they kept hearing that word said about other digital products and, so, naturally it applies to ours as well and we must do what everyone else is doing!
- KhoomeiK 5y ago> So I never could figure out why our marketing team was all about engagement other than they kept hearing that word said about other digital products and, so, naturally it applies to ours as well and we must do what everyone else is doing! "Cargo cult marketing"?
- dredmorbius 5y agoFads are a sociological information-theoretic emergent dynamic. https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/62uroa/clothing_music_diets_art_management_theory_fad_as/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/62uroa/clothin...
- asteroidbelt 5y ago> we didn't make any more money the longer someone spent on that product. There was no advertising model associated with it--it is a per-seat hosted solution. Are you sure that time spent on product does not affect sales? E. g. is it possible that if people don't spend time with product, they will renew the subscription next year? > So I never could figure out why our marketing team was all about engagement other than they kept hearing that word said about other digital products and, so, naturally it applies to ours as well and we must do what everyone else is doing! Perhaps it is the issue of the marketing department of that organization is that their bonuses are not tied to any performance metrics. In proper organizations (like Google) marketing director get paid if their marketing efforts give the company more revenue than the company spends on marketing, and fired otherwise.
- charleshan 5y agoPDF version of the slides: https://www.slideshare.net/paulsmarsden/google-deck-on-digital-wellbeing-a-call-to-minimize-distraction-and-respect-users-attention https://www.slideshare.net/paulsmarsden/google-deck-on-digit...
- SebastianKra 5y agoThanks. Could you upload it for people without a LinkedIn account?
- ConcernedCoder 5y agoFYI: Title of website reads: "A Call To Minimize Distration", should be: "A Call To Minimize Distraction"
- dang 5y agoThe submitted title is the title that appears on the first slide of the presentation. That's legit.
- gwbas1c 5y agoI think the first thing they could do is make ALL notifications on Android opt-in. Most notifications that I get are SPAM.
- ChrisArchitect 5y ago(2013)? come on plenty of discussion more recently than that about the topic: The growing body of evidence that digital distraction is damaging our minds https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16098847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16098847 We live in an age of distractions, dealing with constant mental stimulus https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26207184 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26207184 My year with a distraction-free iPhone https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8251334 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8251334 The Death of Social Reciprocity in the Era of Digital Distraction https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20643928 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20643928 GhostWriter is a distraction free Markdown editor https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26252472 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26252472
- dang 5y agoWhat's wrong with 2013? Historical material is welcome here, and I assume one interesting point about the OP is how relatively early it was.
- ChrisArchitect 5y agonot the particular year but rather the age; that there's been much development and thought on the topic since then, that particular presentation slide deck referenced multiple times since then as work that inspired things that came etc. Don't want to keep reverting to having the discussions all over again about topics that have been expanded on and discussed in threads afterwards
- vkat 5y agoOff topic: Snakes creep the hell out of me and I can't even look at my computer if there is an image and these slides have 4 or 5 of them.
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoTrace a line from that to this basically https://wellbeing.google/ https://wellbeing.google/ Great technology should improve life, not distract from it (3 years ago) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17023917 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17023917
- dorkwood 5y agoI received a notification from Uber on the weekend. It said something to the effect of "it's a nice day today, why don't you take a ride?" I've never told my phone to fuck off faster. How many people out there were in the middle of an important task, only to have their phone ask them if they wanted to take a car somewhere for no reason? The collective man-hours of distraction being generated must be staggering; years of work and progress lost every day so that Uber can presumably see a small uptick in engagement.
- mindwok 5y agoMakes me wonder what these kind of notifications are really worth. All they do is make me immediately mute the app from ever notifying me again, and leave a bad taste in my mouth. How many people are really seeing this and impulse purchasing an Uber ride somewhere? I suspect close to zero.
- acituan 5y agoI would guess the number of people who have opted-out of the notifications are either not reported, or the aggregate opt-out ratio doesn't make a ding on overall notification conversion rates. In other words, people don't have a uniform frustration tolerance to irrelevant push notifications, and losing the most irritable segment might be 'worth' it if the majority of the population is still getting them. An alternative explanation is opt-out burn-out; people might just give up on the possibility of a high signal/noise ratio notification space.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoYeah, I know this is an anecdote but most people in my life just put up with a constant stream of buzzing and pinging. I’m very much in the habit of not allowing any notifications to begin with, especially in my browser, but I’m in a minority I think. Emails are even worse, I unsubscribe from the vast majority and block the ones I can’t (Hermes are utterly revolting for this noise generation, three non-unsubscribable emails and three texts per delivery!). The pathetic signal to noise ratio of email makes it utterly worthless as a means of communication for me, if it were up to me I’d do away with it altogether!
- ultimoo 5y agoA great thing I did couple months ago was to turn off iOS notifications for email and gmail. I don't quite recollect how email went from an asynchronous mode of communication to a near real-time mode of communication where people often respond within minutes of getting email. Changing my notification settings have reduced a large number of interruptions and I still end up opening the email app a number of times during the day and responding in a timely way. Highly recommend.
- r00t4ccess 5y agoI did this years ago as well, my phone rings when i get a call and texts/imessages from contacts get an alert nothing else does
- rchaud 5y ago>I don't quite recollect how email went from an asynchronous mode of communication to a near real-time mode of communication . When Blackberries and push email took off in the late 2000s.
- nonbirithm 5y agoThe SF product designers have the power to influence billions, but there are no consequences. So long as there are no consequences, we'll keep asking questions and merely propising these hypothetical limiters to prevent the world from being distracted. I have a feeling that the mechanisms of addiction are tied to evolved human instinct, and we will have to essentially fight back against our own genes to have any chance at succeeding. I like to view the author's suggestions as that being a part of that fight. The fact that we were directly responsible for wiping out tens of thousands of species of life while remaining unaware of the destruction we wrought thousands of years ago should indicate that some kind of a limiter against instinctual human reward mechanisms is needed, technological or otherwise. We are going to eat ourselves.
- fmajid 5y agoThey don't have any power in this area. Those big companies hire industrial psychologists and neuroscientists to calculate precisely how often notifications should be issued to give you that little squirt of dopamine and be hooked. The notifications are not an accident, they are by design.
- nonbirithm 5y agoExactly. When we become aware of our instincts and know to take advantage of them, in addition to baseline human ability, it's even worse.
- jeffkeen 5y agoA friend of mine worked at a company that at one point was searching for "that red light feature"— meaning, a feature in their app that would get users to check their phones while they're stopped at a red light. Thanks, I hate it. I wish everyone would embrace the Humane Tech ethos (https://www.humanetech.com/ https://www.humanetech.com/), but it turns out there's a lot of money in being an asshole.
- musicale 5y ago"Red light feature" is an astonishing term that I'd never heard before. It could also be called a "Traffic death feature" - what's a feature that is so compelling that it will increase traffic deaths when users can't help but check their phones while driving?
- musicale 5y agoIronically this slide show wastes my time and attention by forcing me to click through it rather than simply presenting all the slides on one page. I also can't download it as a pdf to read later.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIn the 8 years that have elapsed since this pitch was made at Google, one conclusion is absolutely crystal clear: the industry has as little self-regulatory control over its use of such dark patterns as the public has over avoiding them. Regulation, taxation, and where necessary, criminalisation, are obvious and necessary. I'll note that for once, the patterns are not entirely synonymous with massive tech monopolies, though it is the monopolists who have the greatest resources and capability to tune their attention-diverting practices to the absolute maximum degree. The naivete Tristan reveals here is rather charming, however.
- Artistry121 5y agoI’d say that Apple has done an amazing job combating this and Google has made some strides. This last WWDC shocked me with how tasteful it was in making devices more personal and respectful
- sillysaurusx 5y agoCriminalization of dark patterns? It’s not impossible to imagine — intentionally tricking a user is sometimes called fraud — but I’m not sure we’ve thought through the implications of criminalizing website design. The biggest companies are the ones least affected by regulation, because they can invest resources into complying. Small startups sometimes can’t. A teenager in their bedroom usually can’t. And that’s no small loss.
- spoonjim 5y agoMost regulators do not charge teenagers in their bedrooms except for the most egregious criminal acts. If you are a teenager operating a website from your bedroom, you functionally do not need to worry about ADA, GDPR, etc.
- KeepFlying 5y agoI get what you're saying but that's only because teenagers in their bedroom are unlikely to get enough attention, not because they don't have enough influence. It's totally possible for a bedroom-made startup to grow to the point where the lack of GDPR enforcement could be directly harmful to customers, for example. True it's unlike they'd get noticed, but I don't think that's a strong argument here. I want reasonable widespread application of GDPR, ADA, etc with explicitly carved out safeguards for small operations like this teenager. They shouldn't have to rely on getting lucky
- codeproject 5y agoThe presentation itself is a huge distraction. I understand the good intention behind it. but does it really neccessary to use 137 pages to illustrate a very simple issue? I think 5 pages is more than enough to explain it clearly. I read this minimize distraction slides have been viewed half millions time already, if the maker use the slides carefully, wouldn't it save a millions of hours user's time. And life?
- aiisjustanif 5y ago> but does it really neccessary to use 137 pages to illustrate a very simple issue? No, but the issue wasn't that simple in 2013. > half millions time already, if the maker use the slides carefully, wouldn't it save a millions of hours user's time. And life? hundreds of thousands by that math, it also took me about 20 minutes to read through it. > The presentation itself is a huge distraction. I think Tristan Harris was aware of that and that also probably is the point.
- codeproject 5y ago>I think Tristan Harris was aware of that and that also probably is the point. Then the guy must have a sense of humor. that is nice point. thanks for the comment.
- ypeterholmes 5y agoA simple issue? This isn't a simple issue. I challenge you to cover it in 5 pages. And spending a time on something that could potentially save everyone tons of time, and improve lives? That's exactly what people should be spending their time on. All of us.
- c-cube 5y ago.
- gavanwoolery 5y agoI enabled screentime/parental controls on my iPhone and gave control of the passcode to my wife. At first I could not wrangle it to block the things I wanted (was this an intentional move by Apple or just poor design?). What I ultimately settled for was disabling downloads of new apps, then deleting every single social media app, game, web browser, and other distraction from my phone. Yes, that is right, my iPhone has no web browser capability (why not just buy a dumb phone? Because I often use services like maps, music, etc). Is the problem me? Do I just not have self control? No - I decided its not. These products were carefully designed around the metric of "engagement" - whereas I had no choice over my design. I also blocked other distractions in my desktop / work area via the hosts file. I would like to do it at the router level but use of VPN makes this impossible, unfortunately. This is what it has come to, which...is ridiculous, in my opinion.
- peerless-app 5y agoI wouldn't hold out for the tech titans to stop exploiting us for our attention. I think we each need to be aware of how we're being influenced and protect ourselves. Realizing this is difficult for many, I am building a tool to help people combat the influence of social media and online advertising. We'll soon be beta testing. If anyone is interested, there is more information here: https://becomepeerless.com/ https://becomepeerless.com/
- jwmoz 5y agoI hate what Facebook became and stopped using it years ago.
- madrox 5y agoHaving heard this call for years, I've come to the conclusion that this is the 21st century's "TV rots your brain." We've replaced channel surfing with doom scrolling. TV stations are mostly run by white men, too. At best, I can say that there's a fundamental human need to stare into space for a while. We could delete all technology tomorrow, and we wouldn't magically be less distracted. At least now, there's a hope of seeing things we care about, instead of what we got in the 80s that was designed to appeal to the lowest common denominator. Sitting through toilet paper commercials are actually the worst.
- solaceb 5y agoI think you’re conflating cultural phenomenon (people like to dissociate by losing themselves in consumption) with biological fact. Humans 10,000 years ago may have spaced out and daydreamed. But this daydreaming was probably very different in psychological effect from scrolling feeds. The two are not even close to the same
- madrox 5y agoI don't think I'm conflating them at all. One definitely drives the other.
- acituan 5y ago> I've come to the conclusion that this is the 21st century's "TV rots your brain." We've replaced channel surfing with doom scrolling. The difference with the TV is that TV didn't have individual, high granularity demographic and usage data to conform to its users' most exploitable side that ultimately drives mindless "engagement". TV ratings had coarsely sampled data at household levels and whatever broadcast was what everyone saw. > I can say that there's a fundamental human need to stare into space for a while. We could delete all technology tomorrow, and we wouldn't magically be less distracted. You're right that mild distraction is conducive to insight generation and as such can be thought as a need, but not all distraction is equal. Unlike a walk in the nature which has low-key wonder, expansiveness with a degree of indifference, youtube doesn't want you to be too indifferent at the risk of losing "engagement" and is pretty damn opinionated about what will keep you hooked. The latter is more like the mindless obsessive shuffling of zombies towards brains. In other words, it would be like saying humans always consumed food for pleasure, and equivocating our modern, hyper-palatable industrial food that drives the obesity epidemic with a 14th century invention like kebabs of the Levant.
- ggm 5y agoI would never camp on HN, hoping for tasty feed. Never. That said, FOMO is a very odd emotion. I can relate to it in the past but I increasingly find I would prefer less things not more, so I want more MO not fear it.
- catchmeifyoucan 5y ago“Add a speed bump to the way you work”. I like that a lot. People work better when they pause, and I think one way to do that is being intentional. In fact, it’s not about getting to a place fastest at the cost of leaving it just as fast. A project I’ve been working on is amna. Imagine, before you open your browser, you need to state your task. Just a little bit of friction to slow you down from jumping mindlessly and overwhelming yourself. Feel free to give it a try: https://getamna.com https://getamna.com
- o8r3oFTZPE 5y agoInteresting idea. I had a similar idea for HN comments. (@dang: take note.) Impose a delay from the point when a person first makes an HTTP request for a thread, i.e., first reads a thread, before they are allowed to comment in it. This would prevent "real-time" back and forth but it would also prevent knee-jerk comments. Before commenting, a reader would have time to digest the OP and the comments and think about them. A cool-off period. This might produce better comments. It would also prevent people from just jumping into threads that have activity to post mindless commments. It would provide an incentive to dig deeper into HN than only the first page. Digging depper into HN past the front page would give the reader more potential threads she could comment in, should they become active discussions. HN already has a limit on how fast people can comment, i.e., number of comments in a given period.
- soheil 5y agoHonestly a lot of this is now just being done by Apple eg. bundling notifications, setting different modes like work mode on the new iOS without distractions, one app at a time this has always been the case on the iOS mainly ignoring iPad.
- danybittel 5y agoIsn't it ironic, that google initially beat the competition, by being a distraction free, no bullshit search engine? People DO care about this stuff. It is a question on how much they put up with, if there's an alternative and how difficult it is to change.
- RandomWorker 5y agoThis! I moved to duckduckgo, it also has some very nice features calculating weight/length conversions and time shifts. It's super clean. Type in "Jupyter notebook keyboard shortcuts" and it just gives you the table. It's wonderful. If google would still be that clean and gave me features that I need, I would return. But, 90% of my searches are now with a competitor.
- snailysnooze 5y agohot damn, just try "tmux cheat sheet" and it's nice to see the result. I'll try it for a few more weeks but DDG seems to not have the "tournament widget" at the moment (as in searching for copa america or wimbledon will show recent results and future matches)
- dbtc 5y agoWhen I first read this earlier today, my thoughts were that it was for the user to choose good tools and learn to use them well. But now I've modified that opinion to: Not everyone has 'what it takes' (to guard their flow, etc.), but everyone benefits if those who do help the rest.
- tpoacher 5y agoA lot of these problems would go away if ECMA started charging businesses for any client's use of javascript by the function call :p
- gfxgirl 5y agoThe distraction of notifications, or "sign up for our email news letter" distractions I'm certainly against. But, the fact of having my time wasted (getting a notification I don't care about) has highlighted other things that waste my time such as Movies that start with 1-3 minutes of company logos. An animation of "A Scott Free Production", followed by an animated logo of "Bad Robot", followed by yet another animated logo of "20th Century Fox" and all that is then followed by card that says "Scott Free Production of a Bad Robot movie published by 20th Century Fox". I want to reach and and shake the people silly "QUIT WASTING MY TIME!" The same with both movie trailers and game trailers. I go to see the game trailer and there's 30 seconds to 2 minutes of logos. For games, I want to click the video and see gameplay IMMEDIATELY. I don't want some 5 minute CG movie nor do I want to see the publisher or developer's names. Those are solely there to stroke their own ego. The user/player/viewer as absolutely no need for it. They aren't respecting my time. Of course those things have been around forever but the fact that my devices and apps waste my time in so many ways as highlighted other ways my time is also wasted.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoI think those things nowadays serve the role of easing you into the film, allow everyone to settle down, finish what they're doing, etc - a lot of films start with something important right away. And it's better than it used to be, older films used to have a long reel of credits before the film started. Anyway, services like Netflix should be able to add a skip button for those.
- eru 5y agoNetflix already has a 'skip credits' and 'skip intro' button.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIf you want real old school, films began with shorts and newsreels.
- abtom 5y agoReminded me of this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI7JDTlixb8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI7JDTlixb8
- textmode 5y agoBelow is a short script that downloads and makes a PDF from the image files. No browser required. The script uses a feature of HTTP/1.1 called pipelining; proponents of HTTP/2 and HTTP/3 want people to believe it has problems because it does not fit their commercialised web business model. As demonstrated by the script below, it has no problems. It's a feature that simply does not suit the online ad industry-funded business model with its gigantic corporate browser, bloated conglomeration web pages and incessant data collection. Here, only 2 TCP connections are used to retrieve 141 images. Most servers are less restrictive and allow more than 100 requests per TCP connection. Pipelining works great. Much more efficient than browsers which open hundreds of connections. IMHO. (export Connection=keep-alive x1=http://www.minimizedistraction.com/img/vrg_google_doc_final_vrs03- x2(){ seq -f "$x1%g.jpg" $1 $2;}; x3(){ yy025|nc -vvn 173.236.175.199 80;}; x2 1 100|x3; x2 101 200|x3; )|exec yy056|exec od -An -tx1 -vw99999|exec tr -d '\40'|exec sed 's/ffd9ffd8/ffd9\ ffd8/g'|exec sed -n /ffd8/p|exec split -l1; for x in x??;do xxd -p -r < $x > $x.jpg;rm $x;done; convert x??.jpg 1.pdf 2>/dev/null;rm x??.jpg ls -l ./1.pdf More details on yy025 and yy056 here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27769701 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27769701
- PaulHoule 5y agoGoogle won’t reform, distraction is their business. Lately Microsoft has decided to stuff ‘news’ and similar distractions in Windows and they might listen to criticism because they get paid anyway.
- xtiansimon 5y agoI immediately thought about the workplace. Darn. I was hoping for a flag or at least a logo.
- robmay 5y agoI'm a VC who wrote a post about a similar thesis, and I'd love to chat with anyone working on solutions. https://medium.com/inside-pjc/the-pjc-notification-thesis-we-are-over-notified-and-e357436a78b0 https://medium.com/inside-pjc/the-pjc-notification-thesis-we...
- nireyal 5y agoFor how long are we going to moan and groan about companies doing this "to us"? Come on people, we're not helpless. We're far more powerful than the tech companies. I know all their tricks and literally wrote the book on how they get you "Hooked." These tactics are good, but they're not THAT good. See this article if you want to "hack back": https://www.nirandfar.com/distractions https://www.nirandfar.com/distractions