9 ms·
This is I believe the first time in human history that AI video cameras have been widely deployed, inside private homes, for the purpose of enforcing laws. Neve
by perihelions 5y ago
This is I believe the first time in human history that AI video cameras have been widely deployed, inside private homes, for the purpose of enforcing laws. Never mind the banal details: this is an incredible milestone.
- userbinator 5y ago...a milestone towards the totalitarian dystopia previously only encountered in science fiction.
- isatty 5y agoThis shit is so utterly unacceptable and yet there will be no significant mass behind protests against it. Why won’t you think of the children?
- skocznymroczny 5y agoNah, the new argument is "we need this to prevent spread of covid"
- Proven 5y agoThey don't enforce anything, they just spy/record. Also those aren't laws, they are merely legislative acts.
- ashleyn 5y agoThe real clever kids will eventually realise you can just tape a post-it note to your head with "ADULT" written in sharpie.
- fridif 5y agodraw on a fake beard ERROR: CANNOT BEGIN PLAY SESSION UNTIL PLAYER SHAVES FACE
- AussieWog93 5y ago>ERROR: CANNOT BEGIN PLAY SESSION UNTIL PLAYER SHAVES FACE I know you're joking, but a law was passed in Xinjiang back in 2014 preventing people with beards from riding public transport. You literally had to shave before you could board a bus.
- egeozcan 5y agoWhy? Was it an anti-Muslim thing? Disgusting anyways. Putting the discrimination aside (well that sounded insensitive but bear with me), very sorry for those poor people who are like me, who get a red face for DAYS after shaving.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>Was it an anti-Muslim thing? Officially, no. But in reality, yes. They want to make the Uyghurs more Han to reduce feelings of separatism.
- Symbiote 5y agoThey wish to completely eradicate all Uyghur culture. "One China" means one Han race and culture.
- londons_explore 5y agoThere are very few countries worldwide that can look through their history and not find a single culture that has been eliminated or at least marginalized.
- yonaguska 5y agoThere are very few countries worldwide actually presently engaged in attempting to eliminate an entire culture.
- w0de0 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nirui 5y agoThe real clever kids will eventually realize that those games from Tencent are just stupid money grabbing time wasters, and then stop playing. Sadly, most people are not that smart. Which is one reason why so many people are willing to give up their privacy AND money in exchange for the "permission" to use those services.
- gentleman11 5y agoThis company has a stake in many American companies. How chilling
- fooker 5y agoReddit, for example. Do you know that anti-CCP comments occasionally get users banned from Reddit nowadays?
- russli1993 5y agoTencent is doing this to comply to Chinese laws. They won't do this if there is no such law. And the law says: "internet gaming companies have responsibility to not provide internet gaming service to minors between 10pm and 8am". I am sure tencent won't want to do this if they had the chance. 1) it limits their ability to get play time and sell to kids. 2) its more work on their end. So the main problem here is the law. Not Tencent. But many Chinese people support and even called for this law. The supports for this law is cultural, circumstantial and societal. In the US, Tencent should adhere to US laws and cultural customs. First, for this specific case, Tencent won't implement it outside of China because 1) why would they limit their own ability to make money 2)why would they not align with US culture? Second, If US has a law that bans using facial recognition, all companies will comply and these issues will not exists. You can enforce practices and values through laws. Also this is Tencent specific system. They are using facial recognition to verify the current user is who they say they are. Just like IPhone has face ID. Because for other verification methods, kids just bypasses them. And I believe they only do verification ones during the banned hours. It doesn't consistently monitor you. The law targets online gaming providers, and fines them if they provide service outside the allowed hours. It doesn't incarcerate kids. Law enforcement doesn't track kids playing games and when they play. And Tencent doesn't share kids data with law enforcement.
- HideousKojima 5y ago>Tencent is doing this to comply to Chinese laws. Tencent, like all major Chinese corporations, is just a thinly veiled extension of the Chinese state. And I'm sure someone will try a "no u" about Facebook etc. effectively being extensions of the US government but that doesn't change the reality of how all major corps in China operate.
- ev1 5y agoThe chinese app wechat already does this in private homes for the purpose of enforcing KYC and "misinformation tracking" - you are required to repeat after it, repeat every phoneme/syllable to form a voiceprint (and coincidentally enough to basically train something to replicate your speech), look straight ahead, rotate around your head, and follow its instructions to sign in again. Also, asking two verified-ID mainland china users to "vouch" for you and be responsible for your activities if you are a foreigner. Almost every service in China requires "real name verification" - you can't play games without it, for example. This has been place for several years, https://i.imgur.com/FBrCwuX.jpg https://i.imgur.com/FBrCwuX.jpg
- rvnx 5y agoThis verification process exists in Europe as well (it's called liveness verification), example: https://www.jumio.com/technology/live-detection/ https://www.jumio.com/technology/live-detection/
- throwaway744678 5y agoThe technology exists, right. But have you experienced it anywhere outside of China? I, for one, have not (at least in the UE). I strongly believe that the average western customer is not be willing to go through such a process.
- rvnx 5y agoYes in Estonia is quite common
- egeozcan 5y agoIt's common when applying for a credit online. They also make you hold your ID towards the camera, show the hologram, read some text etc.
- hobofan 5y agoBasically every modern "mobile-first" bank/stock brokerage app, etc. is built on that. With a lot of them there is still a human in the process giving you the instructions (usually from a call center), but it's gradually shifting to tech-only solutions.
- ezoe 5y agoNot inside the private homes, but in 2008, Tabaco vending machines with facial recognition feature to verify the age(20+ years old) are deployed in Japan. The result was amusing. It was busted by picture of adult face, or by kids moving facial muscles.
- amelius 5y agoOf course it was. They want minors to buy the stuff. The facial recognition was just a distraction to evade law enforcement. I wouldn't be surprised if it's the same with these games. In fact, I would be surprised if a company went to great lengths to reduce their potential consumer base.
- skhr0680 5y agoI think they exist mostly to make busybody moral guardians STFU. They don’t actually buy smokes at vending machines or alcohol at 7-11 so have no idea if the measure work or not.
- skhr0680 5y agoTaspo and the “I am truthfully and honestly over 20” button at convenience stores aren’t meant to stop anyone. They only exist so the government and industry can claim they are cracking down on underage smoking and drinking, not to actually stop underage people from smoking and drinking, because how boring would that be?
- herbst 5y agoThey did that to verify your age to buy cigarettes on a vending machine a short amount of time in Austria. Obviously everyone was tricking it with paper masks. Today they use banking cards, which still work for age verification after they expired so they are just shared between the youngsters
- hulitu 5y agoIt's not the first time. All smartfones have a microfone and a camera. And if you think that they are used only for making pictures and talking on the phone - dream on.
- nickysielicki 5y agoDon’t you think someone — possibly a user of this site — would have noticed the network traffic? Not only are you implying that there is a back door in the phone operating systems, but also in every other device on the same network as the phone to hide such traffic. What you’re suggesting is certainly possible, but the idea that it’s been rolled out to the average person doesn’t seem likely.
- wizzwizz4 5y ago> Don’t you think someone — possibly a user of this site — would have noticed the network traffic? Given how much analytics garbage phones regularly spew out, you'd have to perform HTTPS MITM attacks to check this – and that's the kind of thing that alters the behaviour of the system you're measuring. I still don't think it's likely, but if somebody were to find some suspicious code, I have no real reason to doubt that it's doing something like this.
- rotebeete 5y ago> Given how much analytics garbage phones regularly spew out Thank god¹ android is open source. ¹ Not religious, I just don't want to thank google :\
- toomanybeersies 5y agoI wonder how Linus Torvalds feels about God taking credit for Android being open source?
- rotebeete 5y agoI wonder how all the other contributors feel about Linus getting all the credit :D
- doublejay1999 5y agoIt's amazing! Hundreds of SciFi writers predicted such surveillance, I dont think many predicted it arrive by invitation - i expect many parents will support this. Same for smart speakers. It's a hairs breadth away from complete audio & video surveillance.
- wrycoder 5y agoDo Androids Dream of Electronic Sheep?
- Seirdy 5y agoSemi-coherent and very subjective thoughts about my favorite book follow. Sorry, I just have to gush. Eh, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep was more about empathy, the meaning of humanity, how we justify segregation, etc; its perspective on the human condition was at a much more fundamental/introspective level than the issues discussed in this thread. Though I suppose there might be parallels between the empathy box and the Mountain-Dew (TM) greentext in the top comment. The subjugated population--the andys--were used not to critique subjugation itself as much as the analyze the implications of the justifications behind that subjugation, especially given the the fact that andys don't feel empathy and had to break the law to be where they are (and the protagonist + POV is a law enforcement officer). It wasn't about the what as much as it was about the why and its implications. Books that critique the existence of norms/institutions are great, but my favorites are books that choose to accept their presented status-quos but analyze what the implications are and what accepting that status-quo means about ourselves; readers can then look inside themselves and make their own calls. It's the epitome of "show, don't tell".
- MereInterest 5y agoThe word "incredible" usually has a positive connotation, of something impressive being achieved that benefits society. Those case is incredible, but has such severe privacy concerns that there is no such positive effect present. AI has a great deal of promise if used responsibly, but gross invasion of privacy shows promise of a different kind. This is a horrific milestone.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Abishek_Muthian 5y ago>first time in human history that AI video cameras have been widely deployed, inside private homes, for the purpose of enforcing laws Knowingly maybe. But all those IP Cameras have had face detection for almost a decade, They've been deployed extensively in homes around the world, They've been phoning to their home to provide even basic features or at least the DDNS based features and are riddled with vulnerabilities. One could use firewall, custom firmware to fix this to an extent but not everyone has the means or intention to do it.