11 ms·
Canada battles more than 180 wildfires with hundreds dead in heat wave
- k12sosse 5y agoWe will still find a way to fight with ourselves through it, luckily.
- elric 5y agoAnd yet we'll continue to treat climate change as an inconvenience that can be addressed in 20 years, when - to quote Alex Steffen - we're not yet ready for what's already happened. https://alexsteffen.substack.com/p/were-not-yet-ready-for-whats-already https://alexsteffen.substack.com/p/were-not-yet-ready-for-wh...
- curiousgal 5y agoMeanwhile some EU nations are opposing the classification of nuclear energy as green for ESG purposes.. https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germany-four-others-oppose-classing-nuclear-green-eu-2021-07-02/ https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/germany-four-others-...
- hhfxxdfg 5y agoWithout more nuclear power the hope of having a modern world without fossil fuels is futile https://reason.com/2021/07/02/to-stop-climate-change-americans-must-cut-energy-use-by-90-percent-live-in-640-square-feet-and-fly-only-once-every-3-years-says-study/ https://reason.com/2021/07/02/to-stop-climate-change-america...
- xroche 5y agoThis is even more hilarious: Germany oppose nuclear, which is the greenest energy source in terme of emissions, but managed to get funding to use "green" gas: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_2042 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_21_...
- whoknowswhat11 5y agothat is comical - funny to see how climate change doesn't really drive direct action even with environmentalists - looking into this they appear to be against nuclear while claiming carbon emissions are biggest issue?
- Syonyk 5y agoThat's about the shape of it, yes. They grew out of movements opposing nuclear power in the 60s, for various reasons (some of the weapons proliferation concerns were valid enough then, though a detailed understanding of fuel cycles and what does/doesn't generate usable weapons material seldom factors into the objections). As the concerns shifted, the environmental groups seem to have simply added on various new concerns without re-evaluating old points. So you end up with a lot of the groups now being in a weird state where they're against nuclear, opposed to carbon emissions, and don't actually seem to care much about the actual environment beyond "We have to find a way to keep industrial civilization powered without carbon, and without nuclear." Blowing off mountain tops to extract materials to do this doesn't seem to be a huge concern anymore, and that certainly seems it should fall somewhere under the banner of "environmentalism" - but you mostly hear crickets these days. If you're looking for something resembling a self consistent environmental group, you can read some of the stuff by the Deep Green Resistance people - their latest, Bright Green Lies, is a decent enough read on their position. That position, simply, is that industrial civilization is incompatible with the planet, and they do a decent job of arguing their position, which is that it doesn't matter how you power an industrial civilization, it does massive and irreparable damage to the planet as a result of the focus on energy and exponential growth. They look at the resource requirements to implement some of the forecast green futures ("We need 3M windmills? Ok, what does that look like in terms of steel, copper, rare earths, and how does that compare with the global production during the timeframe required to build them?") and come to some depressing conclusions. But even if you disagree with them, they show their work decently enough throughout and it's an interesting set of problems to think through. But in general, you'll find an awful lot of "Climate change is a huge problem; someone else really ought to do something about it!" style thinking in the environmental groups, and I'm pretty comfortable saying that if the last decade hasn't done much useful on this front, continuing the same thing for years to come will accomplish roughly the same "almost nothing." I'm also not at all sold with the "You can buy your way to green!" solutions that are peddled constantly by those who are interested in ensuring that, no matter what happens, the core of the modern consumerist economy won't be bothered. I'll gesture in the direction of the standard "worried about the climate" somewhat senior tech worker who has a million dollar home, a six figure car, absurdly expensive solar that offsets at least a bit of their power use on their roof, and who feels that they've consumed their way to green, without having really considered any of the resources that actually go into the vehicle, or lower energy/material alternatives to meet their needs. You can directly reduce emissions by simply using less, but this isn't really discussed these days. I don't see a good path out, sadly. It's very possible we've accelerated growth in a direction that is simply a dead end canyon with no valid paths out that maintain a lot of what we've developed.
- sandworm101 5y agoNuclear isn't truly green. It still involved mining, and industry that as of today does burn lots of hydrocarbons. Nuclear is certainly better, but it isn't 100% green. It could become green if we can manage to electrify mining and/or get uranium from alternative sources such as water. While I am a fan of nuclear power I don't think it is perfect nor totally carbon free. True renewables, when they are working, are still better than nuclear. Nuclear's niche is that 24/7 reliability that we need to gap-fill wind and solar.
- curiousgal 5y agoI mean obviously it's not green but this particular classification is about financial investment. The bar for what is considered green could be lowered to encourage investment into those sectors.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoSpain, Denmark, Austria, Luxemburg. Spain/Germany: https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int https://www.siemensgamesa.com/en-int Denmark: Much Wind and other 'greenery' Austria: Water, never did nukes, has one complete NPP without the hot-stuff as museeum now. Luxemburg: yawn?
- ipaddr 5y agoThere is an inconvenient truth we all avoid when we throw out climate change. There is nothing you can do to stop climate change. If you stopped all Canadians from producing any greenhouse gases the wildfires will continue and no one will have noticed. When two countries are producing the vast majority you are at their mercy. If Canada wants to bully, bribe or shame a country into submission it has to get bigger and have a much bigger army. On the other hand you can't produce all of your products in China and try to shame when they have higher co2 levels. In the end anyone who has a cellphone supports climate change.
- goodcanadian 5y agoThere is such a thing as leading by example. It is imperfect, to be sure, but it does have an effect. At the moment, Canada is one of the worst countries in per capita greenhouse gas emissions, so perhaps, we can try to do a bit better before blaming other countries. Someone has to go first.
- poutine 5y agoLead by example? If you think China gives a crap about your example you’re horrendously naive.
- jhgfddjn 5y agoEspecially when you consider the economic impacts of "going first" it puts the CCP in a position where they're likely to gain the economic output you've banned, and then use that to gain even more of an upper hand against you
- 0xB31B1B 5y agoWhat are you talking about. China has already “gone first” they drove solar costs down below fossil fuel energy production cost. The change to green energy and decarbonization is a huge Keynesian economic stimulus. Decarbonizing is not about impoverishing yourself it’s about modernizing everything with tools that are demonstrably better in almost every way using government backed debt. It’s going to be a huge driver of GDP growth for the next 25-50 years. The political blocker here is that a lot of members of the capital class are very invested in the current fossil fuel energy production paradigm and will have relatively less wealth on the other side of this transition. The reality here is we can and should use a nearly infinite amount of debt to finance decarbonization. Debt is “borrowing money from the future” and do you think anyone 50 years from now will be saying “I think we should have spent less money on decarbonzing?”, absolutely not. There is no world in which we can muscle the political will to spend that much money today, so for all intents and purposes consider it an unlimited credit line.
- fouc 5y agoNice read. Covid-19 is another example of discontinuity, I'm surprised the author didn't mention that. Perhaps covid-19 prepared us for dealing with the larger discontinuity of climate change.
- dukeofdoom 5y agocovid-19 was a test run for communist shortages. If you like waiting in lines, because the shelves are going to be empty. Then I suppose its good prep. Nobody except ideologues want that. Regular people want prosperity and abundance. Shortages tend to make life harder and kill people. When you need to jerry rig solutions to simple problems due to lack/restrictions of availability of products. Ontario locked down the dollar store during covid, so you couldn't buy even things like a flashlight. I can't imagine how many poor people ended up hurting themselves as a result. Also the terrible erosion of civil liberties, and empowering of authoritarian mandates.
- Woberto 5y agoIf anything, I saw shortages as a failure of the capitalist system by which shortages are caused by greed, particularly by those with more money. From my understanding with a more socialist system in place, people would be limited to purchase only what they need to make sure that there could be enough for everybody (which there definitely was)
- dukeofdoom 5y agoA free market will take care of shortages, the higher price of a particular commodity will mean higher profits and incentives the production of that good. So it's actually opposite. Look for videos from the communist block countries, people were waiting in line to purchase things like bread and toilet paper daily. Its not the Utopia you have in your mind. Take air travel, right now there are extra costs of tests, and quarantine hotels in Canada, can add thousands to a potential trip. Making it financially impossible for many people to afford it. The rich and connected are not nearly as affected, they can still afford it. Or the government will leave loop holes for them to get around the laws. Litteraly
- Black101 5y agoDo you think that it's bad enough that it will do some major population control?
- macinjosh 5y agoIt is difficult to care when we’ve been told since the 90s that the brink is only x years away and then nothing happens. Canada is huge 180 wildfires is nothing. The fact is that there is no peer reviewed scientific study that proves there are increased wildfires due to climate change. Assuming it is makes you the same as the folks who just assumed the pandemic was fake. It is anti-science.
- xwolfi 5y agoBut this is not climate, it's weather. Like you look like a fool on a cold winter mocking global warning, maybe wait a bit to call summer fires in Canada hottest summer in recent memory a direct climate change effect, or it'll just be invalidated next coldest summer in recent memory... I remember forest fires in my country decades ago and they reduced a lot recently, so what, positive result of global warming and climate change, or good application of forest management ? Temperatures changing or ... anyway you get the point :D
- alkonaut 5y agoThere is no meaningful distinction between "average weather" and "climate". Enough weather observations is a climate observation.
- bckr 5y ago> it'll just be invalidated next coldest summer in recent memory that's why scientists are using terms like global climate disruption or global heating. Hotter hots and colder colds fit the model.
- firestarter223 5y agoNeither heat waves nor forest fires are a new thing.
- itsoktocry 5y ago>And yet we'll continue to treat climate change as an inconvenience that can be addressed in 20 years According to the EPA, wildfires over the past 40 years are slightly down. Can you point to different data that ties these wildfires to climate change? https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indicators-wildfires https://www.epa.gov/climate-indicators/climate-change-indica...
- cbsks 5y agoAre you just looking at the total number of fires in Figure 1? Figure 2 shows that annual wildfire-burned area has been increasing in the last 40 years. Figures 3, 6 and 7 also back that up.
- tokai 5y agoI guess the larger the wildfires are the lower the number of individual fires are. When everything is burning there will be only one fire.
- garyrichardson 5y agoAnec-data: I’m in my 40s and live in the Vancouver area. The first time in my life that I ever experienced a smoked in summer was about 5 years ago. Actual data: the link you posted shows a decrease in fires overall, but the size and damage of them increasing. I guess when the fires are so big and start merging your overall count goes down.
- itsoktocry 5y ago>but the size and damage of them increasing Is your assertion that climate change is causing bigger fires, or could there be other contributing factors ie controlled burning, development etc?
- jbay808 5y agoThe #1 contributing factor in this case is the western pine beetle, which exploded in range when winters stopped being cold enough to kill them off, and left stands of dead forests in its wake. Climate change is a direct culprit.
- canadianfella 5y agoWhat does climate change have to do with wild fires?
- heron88 5y agoOne practical solution to climate change may be to shut everything down for one day each week, kind of like some places did in response to the pandemic. Close all non-essential business, restrict all non-essential travel, etc. In addition to giving our planet a much needed day off each week, it’d probably go a long way towards improving our mental health.
- tekstar 5y agoToo many big carbon emitters don't shut-down easily, and the cost to start them backup is likely higher (steel processing, container ships, power plants, etc)
- gruez 5y agoSo basically earth hour but 168 times longer?
- twobitshifter 5y agoOr incentivize companies to implement remote work. Talking office commuter cars off the road would be a great step but everyone is rushing back to the office to go back to emitting huge amounts of CO2.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y ago> Close all non-essential business I think the last year and a bit has proven that every business would quickly decide itself essential.
- MattGaiser 5y agoGiven that emissions did not drop that much during the pandemic, this wouldn't be sufficient. https://www.carbonbrief.org/global-carbon-project-coronavirus-causes-record-fall-in-fossil-fuel-emissions-in-2020 https://www.carbonbrief.org/global-carbon-project-coronaviru...
- alkonaut 5y agoWe didn't really stop industry. It did show how little effect flying and cruises have (which is good because I like flying) but it also shows that the emissions aren't just coming from luxuries that are easy to live without. Actually shutting down everything one day a week (giving 1/5 to 1/7 theoretical savings) isn't really going to work. Practically a lot of industry can't shut down, or would pollute a lot more by starting and stopping.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoI've been in that part of BC where the fires are happening. It's the dry region beyond the Rocky Mountains. Clouds coming in from the Pacific Ocean rain themselves out when the wind forces them rise above the mountains. So the other side of the mountains range gets very little rain. Grass is dried yellow in the summer. Easy for fires to start.
- dc3k 5y agoThe Rocky Mountains are hundreds of kilometres east of the Fraser Valley. The mountains between the coast and the Fraser Valley is the Coast range.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoyou're right
- jbay808 5y agoYou mean the coastal mountains, right? Beyond the Rockies is Alberta. Generally the grass goes yellow here in the summer, even right on the coastline in Vancouver Island and up the sunshine coast.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoyes, you're right
- foolzcrow 5y agoWhat is operation Popeye?
- fatsdomino001 5y agoThank god I don't even believe in runaway Anthropogenic Global Warming, otherwise I'd be worried.
- newleaf 5y agoAs an insurance policy, where would be the best places to live or buy land now given forecasted trends? I’m primarily thinking of the US, but interested any idea (well, maybe not Siberia…)
- choeger 5y agoGermany. Seriously, I don't know of any other country with such a combination of industry, education, social security, and absence of natural disasters as well as poisonous animals.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y agoUltimately, anywhere that is relatively wet and/or not located in a forest is probably decently safe from forest fires. In terms of safety from heat waves, there are a few good hedges: a very well insulated house, ideally with some sort of reflective roof. A backup battery system that allows you to run independently in the case of a grid failure. Solar panels that work when the grid is off, which have excess capacity. Redundant cooling systems? If you really wanna go crazy, build a small underground bunker like Colin Furze did. With these things in place I think you'll be safe enough during any foreseeable heat waves. You still wouldn't be able to go outside on really hot days, but you wouldn't likely die due to overheating.
- fy20 5y agoI think it's worth remembering that climate change isn't just heat waves. The same will also protect you well from cold spells, but you should build a home that fairs well with other extreme weather too. It didn't get much publicity, but last weekend there was an F4 tornado that destroyed a number of villages in the Czech Republic: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-57605651 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-57605651
- Y-Bopinator 5y agoHeat wave? Those are Covid-19 deaths
- rm_-rf_slash 5y agoI suspect in the coming years that Canada will have more trouble with wildfires than the U.S. For one, the population of all of B.C. is just a smidge over 5 million, or less than the SF Bay Area, which can strain emergency response and stability services if the active personnel is low to begin with. Secondly, B.C. is much less developed inland than the other west coast states, so many fires will be difficult if not impossible to reach by anything but air travel. Also, B.C. is HUGE, larger than the west coast states combined. Lot of ground to cover, lot of fuel for the fires. Canada doesn’t have a lot of great options here. Building infrastructure to respond to events would be prohibitively expensive, given the land area to cover. The least good option may likely be clear cuts on a massive scale to prevent fires from spreading too much. Current environmental legislation reflects the mood of places like California, where a knee jerk reaction to previous eras of logging has resulted in a “let it grow” mentality, which looks good on paper but only makes more fuel as far as the next fire is concerned. That being said, the costs may end up outweighing the benefits and Canada may end up finding ways to export an awful lot of lumber in the coming years.
- 908B64B197 5y agoCanada is directly contributing to these events by exploiting some of the dirtiest oil on earth. Of course, the current regime will deny any connection between forest fires, heatwaves and dirty oil. [0] [1] Good thing the US divested out of the mega pipeline project they were trying to push out. [0] https://www.nationalobserver.com/2016/05/04/news/fort-mcmurray-fires-related-global-climate-crisis-says-elizabeth-may https://www.nationalobserver.com/2016/05/04/news/fort-mcmurr... [1] https://www.macleans.ca/politics/ottawa/why-didnt-justin-trudeau-want-to-link-the-fort-mac-fire-to-climate-change/ https://www.macleans.ca/politics/ottawa/why-didnt-justin-tru...