18 ms·
Cryptocurrency Blockchains Don’t Need to Be Energy Intensive
- pattusk 5y agoIt's nice that the IEEE is waking up to this fact in 2021. We've had POS, low-energy requirement for a while now. Some POS chains like Avalanche have nodes that can run on little more than an RPI.
- lahoda-xyz 5y agoavalanche is nice. but it it is solidity. afaik solidity prevents scalability by assumption of global mutable data access in single transaction.
- pattusk 5y agoSolidity is only the language of the C-Chain, which is basically the EVM with better scalability but only constitutes one part of the ecosystem. It is currently the most visible part because most of the protocol's features are still under development. But the Avalanche protocol itself isn't tied to the EVM or Solidity, it is designed to let you run any customized blockchain.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoMore parallelizable execution environments can run on top of the EVM. That's what Fuel is building with its Ethereum-based Optimistic Rollup, with a goal of eventually making the UTXO model Turing Complete (Fuel v2.0): https://docs.fuel.sh/v1.1.0/Future%20Roadmap/Planned%20Features.html https://docs.fuel.sh/v1.1.0/Future%20Roadmap/Planned%20Featu...
- runeks 5y agoThey don’t need to be, but it gives the best security guarantees. PoS is subject to threats that don’t exist for PoW, e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27672759 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27672759.
- lahoda-xyz 5y agowhat qbout zkp or vdf extensions to pos?
- runeks 5y agoPoS relies on the possession (“keeping secret”) of private keys. No matter what you do, private keys (information) can be stolen, including in a covert manner (in a way that no one discovers that anything has been stolen). PoW relies on hardware, for which the same problem does not exist.
- jacoblambda 5y agoThere's been some work done to work around this issue. One of the approaches is to keep an always offline "fallback" key that can be used to "lock" an account and transfer ownership to a new account in the case that a private key is leaked. https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/872 https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/872 This doesn't solve the issue entirely but it does provide a mechanism for recovering in the case of a major attack.
- danbruc 5y agoThey don’t need to be, but it gives the best security guarantees. That is not true, the security has nothing to do with energy consumption, only with cost. If you had to verifiable set a million dollars on fire for mining a block, that would be as secure as proof of work without wasting energy. Also anything like mining is only necessary at all if you want anonymity, if you drop that requirement you unlock a vast space of very cheap solutions.
- ajkdhcb2 5y ago>If you had to verifiable set a million dollars on fire for mining a block, that would be as secure as proof of work without wasting energy Sure, but nobody has found a way to do that, nor has anybody found an alternative to PoW that doesn't have terrible security tradeoffs. It doesn't help to say something magical could have better properties - you need to find something that actually works in practice by satisfying all requirements
- Negitivefrags 5y agoI'm not really convinced. Proof of Stake has a startup issue that Proof of Work doesn't have. If you want to have your coin begin as proof of stake you have to have some mechanism for how the initial coins are distributed and that method is usually going to involve the creators giving themselves a lot of coins. A lot of crypto projects have all sorts of ways of obfuscating this or claiming that the intial coins will be destroyed or whatever, but I don't think that anyone has really succeeded in establishing trust on a large scale for this yet. The other method of getting Proof of Stake going would be migrate an existing Proof of Work coin. This is like what Etherium 2.0 is trying to do. The problem with that is that it's never going to be in the interest of the miners to actually change to it. Etherium 2.0 has been supposedly just around the corner for years and it never really arrives. Proof of Work on the other hand doesn't have this issue. The creator has the same ability to mine coins as anyone else does, so it doesn't have the same initial trust issues as Proof of Stake does.
- simiones 5y ago> If you want to have your coin begin as proof of stake you have to have some mechanism for how the initial coins are distributed and that method is usually going to involve the creators giving themselves a lot of coins. Don't Proof of Work coin issuers do the same? Even Satoshi has a pretty large amount of Bitcoin.
- PeterisP 5y agoThe thing is that PoW "works" even in the case where Satoshi-equivalent has most of coins, as the transactions are controlled by the mining power and new coins will be distributed through mining. With PoS, if founders hold most of the coins, then the scheme does not work as they de facto arbitrarily control the transactions and there's no way for a community to get that control unless they hand over the coins - thus, in PoS (unlike PoW) the founders need to solve the distribution problem before the scheme can become useful.
- aaronhayes 5y agoThere were no pre-mined bitcoin distributed. Satoshi mined his coins in the early days but crucially anyone could participate and mine at the same time.
- nathias 5y agoWe've had PoS for 10 years, PoS and things that make use of the computation for other functions than security are the best ways forward for crypto.
- techbrobane 5y agoHN is generally 10 years behind on crypto news.
- BuckRogers 5y agoCardano is proof of stake and getting a ton of attention lately in being added to Grayscale’s crypto ETF as it’s 3rd largest holding. They even sold other assets, Bitcoin, Ethereum, to do it. It’ll be interesting to watch.
- davidhyde 5y agoHow about a proof of negative energy requirement? Like how much solar electricity you generate or CO2 you scrub out of the air.
- visualradio 5y agoWell human labor is a somewhat renewable source of energy. And when people perform work for us it saves us the energy of performing the same work ourselves in the future. And when people perform work to produce artifacts such as planted crops, structures, machines, buildings, materials, working inventory the work is stored in physically observable material capital held on land. If we want to coin the material capital and place a shared currency into circulation backed by material capital this can be accomplished by having public employees of local land loan offices appraise the minimum labor replacement cost of the material capital which the borrow agrees to hold on site and require the loan to be repaid before the capital fully depreciates.
- danbruc 5y agoMaybe someone has a really clever idea but I do not think anything rooted in the real world can work. You will always need some kind of sensor to record whatever it is that you are doing in the real world and you will have to prevent people from faking those sensor readings. If you had a central authority as root of trust you might be able to build some tamper-proof device that provides cryptographically attested values but I can not think of a way to do something like this without already having a root of trust.
- meowkit 5y agoThis is called the oracle problem. The proposed solutions are in the same vein as security in base layer consensus mechanism: create an economic incentive to be accurate over time. Make sensors/sensor data compete to be designated as roots and gain some sort of revenue. Reputation is hard to build, but easy to destroy.
- danbruc 5y agoI think they are similar but not identical problems. For things like some stock price I can see how you could have several competing oracles that can build trust over time, but if you want to monitor and report the amount of solar energy I am producing for mining I can not see how this could work. Especially not if you want to preserve anonymity which kind of rules out that miners crosscheck each other by placing their own sensors.
- BratishkaErik 5y agoI love DASH two–layer systen
- jayp1418 5y agoWhat about nano and banano?
- Tenoke 5y agoBanano in particular has abused the airdrop (and thus distribution) system. They had an airdrop in Feb (supposed to go out in March) for Nano holders (same team) that they leveraged into a ton of publicity and people buying their coins and then just didn't give it out - in fact the project lead is hostile about it on their discord while doing more separate airdrops.
- jayp1418 5y agoOh.
- janmo 5y agoThe article assumes that PoW cannot be done in an energy efficient way. Last year I wrote an article on how to do PoW in an energy efficient way by using the digital signing capability from the NFC chip of modern passports. The proposal was discussed here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23066477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23066477
- dandanua 5y agoYou don't need PoW mining or any sophisticated consensus at all if you use tamper-proof hardware. Here is my proposal of using FIDO keys https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26214175 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26214175
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y ago> tamper-proof hardware Does not exist. FIDO keys are merely tamper resistant.
- dandanua 5y agoThere is a market of secure microchips and it's evolving. Of course, there are no 100% secure solutions, but we're heading towards practical security. There are no full-proof solutions for anything in life. Even Bitcoin is not full-proof. You just need to capture coordinators of a couple of mining pools. I believe collecting those in China will be enough to gain 51% control.
- pornel 5y agoThat's trusting private keys of passport-issuing governments and makers of the NFC chips. If you can trust an authority like that, then you don't even need a blockchain. The whole scheme will fall apart as soon as value of cheating will be higher than the cost of equipment needed to extract keys from a passport.
- floatboth 5y agoNo matter how many non-PoW shitcoins you make, the main one (BTC) is not going to change and remains the dominant one. You can't solve the problem by creating more shitcoins, only by crashing the whole field into the ground.
- Retric 5y agoBitcoin is far from #1 in terms of transactions per day which seems like the only important measurement of adoption.
- ravel-bar-foo 5y agoFor the purposes of environmental hazard, it isn't number of transactions that matter but number of miners. That in turn is going to depend on the expected payout to miners (either in value of new coin or in transaction fees). New coin mining rate is fixed for bitcoin, so the only parameters one can change to reduce the environmental impact are value and transaction fees.
- laurowyn 5y agoBut as the coin with the largest market cap, greater than the next 9 put together [1], is by far the biggest one. I agree though. Bitcoin isn't the only crypto coin worth talking about. [1] https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/top-10-cryptocurrencies/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/top-10-cryptocurren...
- atweiden 5y agoIf transactional demand were the only useful adoption metric for money, where would that leave gold? The most important factor in a particular asset’s “adoption” as currency is its propensity to act as the unit of account for international settlement between nation-states.
- Retric 5y agoGold has more transactions per day than all crypto coins combined. In terms of value it’s moving ~200 billion dollars per day in exchanges.
- subroutine 5y agoPoW isn't necessarily bad, if the work can be made useful. e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding@home https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Folding@home I vaguely remember hearing about some coin proposing a Folding@home concept. Does anyone know of any novel Po(useful)W coins?
- Kbelicius 5y agoThere is grid coin using BOINC instead of folding@home. There is also primecoin (from the inventor of PoS) that searches for prime numbers. Don't know if either are still active.
- atweiden 5y agoThe ideal proof of work algorithm should serve no other useful purpose besides enabling disparate actors to provably sacrifice resources foreign-to-the-system. Anything the PoW algo does which is useful above and beyond provable sacrifice increases the incentive for PoW miners to attack the network. For example, if you could either use your GPU to mine $COIN for $10/day or to mine $ANTICOIN for $1/day, you could attack $COIN in full knowledge that your GPUs would still earn $1/day of $ANTICOIN afterwards.
- danbruc 5y agoThe fundamental problem that needs to be solved is voting power allocation. You have a group of people that wants to use a cryptocurrency and you want to allow everyone to voice his opinion about what transaction are valid and should be recorded and which are not so that you can determine the consensus. Your first problem is to decide who gets to vote. Does everyone get to vote or do you have to participate in the system, e.g. own at least some coins in that system? Do only humans get to vote or do legal entities like banks and companies get to vote? Does everyone get the same vote or does the number of votes vary, e.g. based on the amount of coins you own? The second problem is the hard one, you want this system to be anonymous which means you can not have a directory of voters but you have to prevent voters from casting more votes than they are supposed to have. That means you have to find some proxy for voters that is ideally impossible but in practice at least hard do duplicate. On the other hand this proxy should be easy and cheap to obtain so that every voter can make use of his vote. For the example of proof of work the assumption is that every human can own and dedicate about the same amount of computing power. It is not too easy to duplicate because you have to spend money in order to buy more computing power and in turn more votes which is better than giving one vote to each username or email address which are much cheaper to duplicate. But it turned out that it does not work all to well, people can own and dedicate vastly different amounts of computing power after all so that now only a tiny fraction of all Bitcoin users make use of their vote. Everyone else now trusts the miners on the basis of aligned incentives, i.e. malice miners would destroy the trust and usefulness of Bitcoin, driving its value down, and with that undermine their mining revenue. Personally I am quite skeptical that one can find something that works well. It has to essentially proof that you are a specific human without revealing your identity and still be unforgeable. Proxys like computing power, storage space, or money are generally duplicable by investing more money, so that it seems hard to come up with a system where voting power is not concentrated on the wealthy. This is not a fundamental problem but there are certainly people that would consider this to undermine the promise of cryptocurrencies to a certain extend because the votes and therefore the power is not spread evenly among the users and so this requires some amount of trust.
- SheinhardtWigCo 5y agoAlgorand solves this by using a verifiable random function, with the output weighted according to the user's stake. It's quite elegant. Paper: https://eprint.iacr.org/2018/377 https://eprint.iacr.org/2018/377
- Glench 5y agoHaven't seen Chia mentioned in this thread and it was only briefly mentioned in the article — Proof of Space/Time seems to have the same security guarantees as Bitcoin without any of the electricity usage. It uses extra hard drive space but a recent report confirmed that a lot of that is using underutilized existing space, not space from new drives: https://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=US47836321 https://www.idc.com/getdoc.jsp?containerId=US47836321 Chia's on-chain language is also a functional LISP called Chialisp that is more secure and auditable than Solidity: https://chialisp.com/ https://chialisp.com/ They're having a $500k prize hackathon for building cool things in Chialisp at the end of July: https://cointelegraph.com/press-releases/sirius-labs-launches-chia-hackathon-in-partnership-with-chia-network https://cointelegraph.com/press-releases/sirius-labs-launche...
- 317070 5y ago> using underutilized existing space, not space from new drives Chia is basically turning wasting electricity into wasting silicium (or whatever tapes/harddrives are made from). Because this "space" needs to be created as well. I don't really see how that is less wasteful in the long run.
- Glench 5y agoWell I mean the market for hard drives is already over 1 zettabyte a year so it seems a little ridiculous to make that comparison without taking into context the whole picture. Although yes, you're right, some resource needs to be consumed for any blockchain or database to work — in this case it's storage space (not necessarily hard drives). To my mind, Chia puts existing underutilized space to work so it's not really wasting anything. The data seems to support that conclusion in the report I linked.
- 317070 5y agoSome resource needs to be consumed, but we have payment systems that are currently multiple orders of magnitude more efficient than Bitcoin or Chia, so that is kind of a baseline. (Think Visa or Mastercard) Secondly, Chia is a small coin, it did not make a dent in the global market yet. I can believe that so far nobody really bothered to invest in storage. However, imagine Chia would be as large as say Bitcoin, then Chinese Chia miners would be filling warehouses with tape drives to the effect of millions per year. The costs they are now making burning electricity would be replaced by the same cost at installing computer memory of some kind. Compared to the current financial system that is really wasteful. But even as compared to most existing proof-of-work crypto, it is arguably more damaging to the environment as there are more toxic chemicals involved in tape than in burning electricity. Overall, you traded wasting time for wasting space. I do not see how that is helpful.
- danlugo92 5y agohttps://endthefud.org/ https://endthefud.org/ There's a Proof of Stake section describing all of its shortcomings compared to Proof of Work. Plus a lot of bitcoin fud debunking.
- jw1224 5y agoThanks for the link — that’s a great site.
- shawnz 5y agoSeems like a nicely researched collection of links, although I think they are a bit too quick to dismiss PoS as a lost cause. Perhaps PoW really is the superior system for now, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't continue to research PoS systems.
- deregulateMed 5y agoPOS might be the future, and if we find that it's impossible to predict which stakes will be doing validation, I'm all for Bitcoin upgrading to POS. Its just not ready today. No one is going to risk their Bitcoin savings on trying POS. Let ethereum test it, then BTC can adopt it after a few years.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- randomhodler84 5y agoBTC will never be PoS. Sorry, PoS is a dead end. Wait until those black swan event start splitting chains. They will be clambering for the PoW lifeboats.
- jcfrei 5y agoThis seems to be a selection of links for bitcoin maximalists. Not an unbiased discussion about pros and cons for different blockchains.
- cryptica 5y agoProof of Stake is superior to Proof of Work because with PoW, it's possible for someone to take over the network and tamper with the data if they control more than 50% of the mining power. The cost of buying new mining hardware grows linearly as you buy more of it. On the other hand, with PoS, an attacker would need to control more than 50% of tokens, the cost of acquiring tokens grows exponentially as you approach the 50% mark (it likely won't even come close) since bids drive the token price up. PoS uses far less electricity than PoW, it's incomparable by orders of magnitude. A typical PoS network uses less electricity than a typical mid-size tech company... PoW uses the electricity of an entire country. With PoS, if the initial distribution is done fairly without ill intent, then it tends to decentralize further by itself over time as early adopters cash out and newcomers buy in. Finally, a lot of PoS projects are focused on interoperability, this means that they aim to grow into an ecosystem with multiple similar PoS tokens (with different use cases). It allows for free movement of value between different blockchains and they develop into a hierarchy connected via a network for exchanges and decentralized exchanges. There is no fairer, more decentralized system (logically, politically and architecturally) than a multi-token PoS ecosystem.
- bitcurious 5y ago> Proof of Stake is superior to Proof of Work because with PoW, it's possible for someone to take over the network and tamper with the data if they control more than 50% of the mining power. The cost of buying new mining hardware grows linearly as you buy more of it. On the other hand, with PoS, an attacker would need to control more than 50% of tokens, the cost of acquiring tokens grows exponentially as you approach the 50% mark (it likely won't even come close) since bids drive the token price up. You don’t need to own tokens to have control over them, you just need to offer staking as a feature. See Coinbase.
- cryptica 5y agoThis actually helps with decentralization since there are usually multiple exchanges and it's very rare for 1 exchange to hold more than 10% of all tokens.
- aazaa 5y ago> The granddaddy of all consensus mechanisms—behind Bitcoin, Litecoin, Monero, and (for the time being at least) Ethereum—is called proof of work. Essentially, PoW makes adding transactions to the blockchain computationally—and therefore financially—very expensive, so as to discourage fraudulent activity. ... This passage reflects a deep-seated, widespread misunderstanding of how/why Bitcoin works. I suspect the author knows, but the brevity of the article prevents actually explaining the issue. This is a recurring problem in this space and has opened up a large fraud opportunity as every bottle of snake oil looks the same to those who don't do the deep technical dive. Proof-of-work has nothing to do with ensuring the validity of transactions. Transactions contain all of the information needed to detect invalid transactions. Hashes, signatures, scripts, and amounts can all be checked and will be rejected if invalid. The validity of every transaction can be tested without proof-of-work. Systems like this had been developed prior to Bitcoin. So it's possible to eliminate every kind of fraud through cryptography alone, except one. The problem proof-of-work solves is double spending, a term you won't find in the article. A malicious actor can try to spend the same coin twice (or more). Both versions of the double spend transaction are valid, but a node can only accept one. Which one does it accept? It accepts the one on the block with the most cumulative proof-of-work ("strongest chain"). In the event of a tie, the node accepts the first version it saw. The strongest proof-of-work chain can therefore change from one moment to the next as blocks are received. Proof-of-work imposes a non-recoverable cost to publishing a block of transactions. That cost and its finality discourage double spending by making the publication of double spending transactions permanently expensive. An attacker needs to out-spend the entire rest of the network to succeed, and loses everything spent if the attack fails. The cost of a failed attack can never be recovered. So any scheme to replace proof-of-work needs to maintain that element of irrecoverable loss of value for a failed double spending attack. It hasn't been an easy nut to crack. A lot of projects claimed to have done it only to discover some flaw in the game mechanics or technology.
- dboreham 5y agoAnother way to describe this is that PoW is a Cybil resistance measure.
- 5y ago
- sktrdie 5y agoOne thing that PoW has for it is this idea of "something outside the system". In essence the miners are somewhat economically forced to sell their mined coins in order to rent the energy/mining-rigs. Hence helping with re-distributing the wealth across the network - presumably in a very fair fashion since it's the free market (exchanges). In PoS this re-sell doesn't happen. Once you are chosen to mine a block (because of your stake) you mine it and that's it. You're not incentivized to redistribute your coins. You can hoard them because you don't have to rent any resources from outside the system. I hate PoW energy consumption as well and I think that its purpose - literally competing to consume more energy - is quite horrible. But so far I don't think PoS offers the same properties as PoW: a fairer system to redistribute coins.
- acjohnson55 5y agoTechnically, the consensus mechanism is the mining lottery, which is how transaction order is finalized, preventing double spends. The scheme for commitment of a scarce resource (e.g. PoW, PoS) is the Sybil resistance scheme, which is what makes lottery participation conform to some notion of fairness. You have to buy your lottery tickets.
- dolmen 5y agoCan you win at the BTC mining lottery with just one ticket? Is it worth mining with a slow machine?
- acjohnson55 5y agoSure, you could. But much like the real lottery, it's not worth playing a game that has negative expected value. At this point, my understanding is that mining BTC with anything other than an ASIC is not going to be worth the cost in electricity.
- rep_movsd 5y agoI cant believe that people still think anything other than PoW can provide the cryptographic guarantees required for a real cryptocurrency. People need to think it through. In PoS - you stake the coin itself, which is initially worthless when a coin is made In PoB - how can you prove that you actually burned coins? In PoC - everyone anyway computes millions of "answers" to store. So you use energy AND and waste valuable disk space too. The guy with the biggest HDD (or maybe 24/7 powered RAM disk) will be the winner always.
- eli 5y agoCryptocurrency blockchains don’t need to be.
- lvs 5y agoProof of capacity, as they call it here, is the same as proof of work for all practical purposes until the network size stabilizes. Plotting space is energy intensive, and a miner must continuously plot to maintain the value of its existing plots as the network grows. If the network size stabilizes or shrinks, then it becomes more efficient than PoW, but in any growth phase it's the same.
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoI can count on Hackernews comment sections to somehow have the most prerequisites yet some of the worst thought out opinions on crypto.