6 ms·
I'm not convinced. Take current 100/20 Mbps speeds. An average Zoom call uses 0.6 Mbps upstream, while a super-HD 1080p one uses 3.8 Mbps up. (And virtually no
by crazygringo 5y ago
I'm not convinced.
Take current 100/20 Mbps speeds. An average Zoom call uses 0.6 Mbps upstream, while a super-HD 1080p one uses 3.8 Mbps up. (And virtually nobody videoconferences from home in 1080p anyways, who wants coworkers to see your skin blemishes in maximum detail?!)
So a connection or 20 Mbps upload supports 33 users in theory, or 5 at super-HD. Even allowing half that in practice... seems fine to me.
The 100 Mbps download is necessary when you've got someone watching an 8K VR video on their headset, and a few 1080p movie streams going as well, which is more reasonable in a family setting.
But most people just don't have any use for upload speeds anywhere near as fast as download. Or at least certainly not until we start doing 8K 3D video calls in front of massive 3D displays, which isn't anytime soon...
[1] https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/201362023-System-requirements-for-Windows-macOS-and-Linux#h_d278c327-e03d-4896-b19a-96a8f3c0c69c https://support.zoom.us/hc/en-us/articles/201362023-System-r...
- rsynnott 5y ago> which isn't anytime soon... I mean, it depends what you mean by ‘soon’. Infra subsidised today will largely still be there in 20 years. To be honest, I’m shocked that they’re considering subsidising anything other than fibre at this point.
- wyager 5y ago3.8Mbps 1080p is hardly 1080p. Decent quality starts at several 10s of Mbps, and high quality 1080p is in the 200-400Mbps range. Ideally in the future you would A) be broadcasting directly to other participants, not going through zoom’s servers, which might multiply upload bandwidth needs B) be broadcasting at several 10s of Mbps per stream. I definitely prefer higher bandwidth vconf. I’m not worried about blemishes, but I want to see people’s minute facial expressions better.
- gsich 5y agoNo. Even Blurays don't have that. A high quality rip has somewhat 20Mbps and thats on the high end with H264.
- magila 5y ago> Decent quality starts at several 10s of Mbps, and high quality 1080p is in the 200-400Mbps range. What? No. 10 Mbps is already plenty for high quality 1080p with the latest codecs. Even 1080p Blurays only run 20-40 Mbps and they're typically very conservatively compressed.
- wyager 5y agoBR is different because the encoder doesn’t have to be real-time. It’s also just medium quality. 1080p60 264 or 265 encoded at 200+Mbps is what you get out of decent video cameras.
- fomine3 5y agoI believe such high bitrate for 1080p is I-frame only. It's useful for video editing, but not suitable for this context.
- wyager 5y agoMany mid range video cameras support “long GOP” which means P-frames. They still spit out however many hundreds of Mbps you ask for.
- gsich 5y agoYou can be conservative and assume that a live-encoding will require double the bitrate for the same quality. So for very high quality 15 Mbps you need 30.
- topranks 5y ago60fps looks disgusting though.
- wyager 5y agoI agree it looks weird for cinema, but I prefer it for video chats. It feels more authentic.
- 5y ago
- crazygringo 5y ago> Decent quality starts at several 10s of Mbps, and high quality 1080p is in the 200-400Mbps range. That's so incorrect I don't even know where to begin. I regularly record my own "talking head" in 1080p from OBS in h.264 at CRF 14 in "ultrafast", which is extreme crazy quality/space overkill (literally indistinguishable image from original, extremely low CPU usage), and that's an average of 34 Mbps. I then immediately recompress the resulting enormous file to a still extremely high-quality CRF 21 in "veryslow" to be suitable for editing and subsequent recompression later, and that results in an average of 2.4 Mbps. For comparison, high-quality 1080p h.264 movie and television releases on torrent sites are usually around 5 Mbps. The difference is that half my frame is a plain/stationary background while movies and TV have complex backgrounds, hence double the bitrate. I have to ask -- where did you get the idea that "high quality 1080p is in the 200-400Mbps range"? That's off by two entire orders of magnitude. It's almost all the way to raw uncompressed 1080p, which is 1,500 Mbps.
- wyager 5y ago> high-quality 1080p h.264 movie and television releases on torrent sites are usually around 5 Mbps. BRRips are frequently 30+GB for a 1-2 hour movie. Do the math. You’re off by like 5-8x. > I have to ask -- where did you get the idea that "high quality 1080p is in the 200-400Mbps range"? From actually filming and editing video. Keep in mind that real-time encoders (such as the one in a video recorder or that zoom has to use for reasonable latency) are pretty constrained and will generally achieve worse ratios. If you need to get 3Mbps in real-time on a laptop your only option is basically to quantize the shit out of the video. Releases that can encode slower-than-real-time can use longer GOP, B-frames, etc. > It's almost all the way to raw uncompressed 1080p, which is 1,500 Mbps. 10bit 444 1080p60 is 3.7Gbps.
- crazygringo 5y ago> BRRips are frequently That's something entirely different, not what I was talking about. Also, if a Blu-Ray gives you the space, there's no reason not to use it. That doesn't mean you need it. Which is precisely why the rips that people commonly share don't. > From actually filming and editing video. That's for recording frames independently for editing on a professional camera. Not for anything you'd ever transmit live to a consumer in a million years. > will generally achieve worse ratios Worse than 200-400Mbps? What are you even talking about? Even an iPhone encodes to just 16 Mbps. Which is definitely not greater than 400. > basically to quantize the shit out of the video. Looks fine to me. It doesn't need to be lossless. It just needs to be good. I've never heard anyone complain about an iPhone "quantizing the shit" out of their video. To the contrary, people love iPhone-quality video. > 10bit 444 1080p60 is 3.7Gbps. Obviously I'm talking about 8-bit 30fps (444).
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> while a super-HD 1080p one uses 3.8 Mbps up. (And virtually nobody videoconferences from home in 1080p anyways, who wants coworkers to see your skin blemishes in maximum detail?!) I posit the real reason is because no-one makes a decent webcam for desktops and laptops, not even Apple.
- crazygringo 5y agoHuh? The Logitech 920 has been around for years, and produces a crystal-clear 1080p image in regular office lighting conditions. Apple uses a lower-quality webcam in laptops because of the thinness of the lid.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoI have a 920. It’s awful when compared to my 12 year-old DSLR’s video-out or my 6 (7?) year-old iPhone 6. Logitech needs to stop using cheap plastic lenses and excessively compressing video. USB3 has sufficient bandwidth.
- crazygringo 5y agoThat's not my experience at all. Crystal-clear and virtually zero sensor noise in regular light conditions. Maybe you got a bad one...? Also it's just compressing to MJPEG, which is far higher quality than any subsequent h.264 compression your CPU would ever do. The Logitech Brio transmits raw data over USB3 like you're asking, but the resulting image quality is identical -- I've tested them side-by-side. (Ancient 920's performed on-camera h.264 compression which was later removed -- if you have one of those, be sure to select the MJPEG stream instead.)
- reassembled 5y agoI used to work on a commercial live streaming software app and we routinely had C920s fail from the actual USB wire shorting out. The Brio is overall a much better camera, particularly with the detachable USB-C cable.
- sneak 5y ago
- jayd16 5y agoWe won't start doing 8K 3D video until its actually possible to do so.
- colechristensen 5y ago>But most people just don't have any use for upload speeds anywhere near as fast as download. Or at least certainly not until we start doing 8K 3D video calls in front of massive 3D displays, which isn't anytime soon... Most people don't have any use for upload speeds because very few have upload speeds that can be used in an interesting way. If lots of people had lots of upload, you might start to see widespread commercial products for home-hosting what currently goes in cloud providers and social media sites.
- treis 5y agoHard to imagine what in the home would need 1 GBPS of bandwidth. What could possibly generate that much data?
- feifan 5y agoThe world isn't constrained by your imagination :)
- 10000truths 5y agoA self hosted website with high traffic? Maybe you’re hosting high quality video, or a high tick multiplayer game server? Perhaps those specific examples are niche use cases, but the idea is that they‘ll stop being so niche if symmetrical upload/download becomes more commonplace.
- treis 5y agoPeople have 1 GBPS connections today and hardly any of them do those things.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cartoonworld 5y agoFull-resolution VR immersion telepresence with haptic data.
- jw14 5y agoIn practice it's not that great. I hosted meetings on Zoom with 4-5mbps up (based on my tests and my recollection since it's been a year-ish). It was fine until my wife connected separately. So 0.6mbps is optimistic... or for people with very high pain thresholds. I always mentally equate low upload limits with "the ISP wants to make sure you don't run a server". Or "this internet connection is just a way to watch TV". Which I find very sad. You can do a lot more than just consume other people's creative work on the internet. Some creative things don't need much upstream bandwidth (cough cough github) but there are also a lot of things (e.g. sharing videos of your craft projects) that are much more pleasant with more upload speed.
- an_opabinia 5y agoIt is worth looking at the obstacles typical end users face. In my experience, the #1 issue is poor WiFi deployment. Then, users of cable broadband use Ookla for speed tests instead of Fast - Ookla is scammed by Comcast and Frontier. What if you want fiber on your block? In California, Comcast and AT&T will not touch the poles to protect their incumbency, and PG&E who owns the poles lies and says it’s the ISP’s problem that the poles aren’t ready for fiber. Based on my canvassing of fiber users in the Bay Area, pole improvements came from the cities’ commissions forcing PG&E to do the maintenance work, because it is supposed to anyway. The EFF does not identify the real antagonist here: public utility companies.
- novok 5y agoIt's a chicken and egg issue. Webcams are crap partly because nobody has a good upload bandwidth to make it matter. Video software uploads at low bandwidth because everyone's connection is crap, etc, etc. Also more than one person lives at a household typically. Imagine 3 or 5 zoom calls going at 4mbps simultaneously. That's 20mbps right off the bat, which over saturates most people's upload, so zoom goes conservative by default. Or imagine in a remote learning, you could see the pupils laptop screen , their desk and their face simultaneously so you can help them with their issue quickly, in 60-30fps HD+ per stream. And then do that for 3 kids + 2 adults and now you have 60mbps. For the adults, simultaneous face, desk & slides would be a form of seamless white boarding at a presentation. Many applications are limited by shitty internet.