9 ms·
Blender and the Rabbids
- hashhar 5y agoNice to see more professional commercial projects picking up Blender. It helps to see what are the things missing or suboptimal for "expert" users of the system. Blender and OBS Studio are very good examples of FOSS software that are the best at what they do and can easily offer competition to even the commercial alternatives. Most of all their design and UI language is consistent - something very rarely seen in FOSS software. And they have incredible depth of features 90% of which are overkill for the casual user but the experts sure do appreciate them. And the best part is the well-thought of extensibility and API story. Both of them have a very good community of plugins and extensions which add very useful features without feeling out of place.
- blooalien 5y agoI first learned 3D graphics on Lightwave 3D on Commodore Amiga ages ago, and since then have tried many other 3D applications, many of which (like Lightwave) cost hundreds or even thousands of dollars. True Fact: Blender beats every single one of them hands down in every way that I can think of. :)
- regularfry 5y agoFunny, there are UI affordances I remember from Lightwave 8 and 9 that I still miss when I'm using Blender. Capability-wise the set of functionality is streets ahead (although if I could find a reasonable approximation to LWCad I'd be deliriously happy), but the UI just doesn't click as nicely for me.
- blooalien 5y agoDon't get me wrong; I did really love Lightwave. It was prolly my favorite by far before I got my brain wrapped around the Blender workflow. You can thank YouTube (and some amazing tutorial creators there) for me bein' able to finally grok Blender enough for it to replace all my other 3D tools properly. I think one of my favorite things still to this day about Blender is how heavily customizable the UI is. How easily you can recreate your favorite workspace layout from whatever software you're most comfortable with. I still tend to set me up a tab with a Lightwave-like 4 pane 3D view just because it's sometimes still useful to me. :)
- rjzzleep 5y agoIsn't the reason why 3DSMax is so popular(or at least was haven't followed this in decades) because of the abundance of plugins? I never used any of these enough to understand what the advanced differences were, but 3DSMax definitely seems easier to use than Softimage and Maya. I'd assume one of the reasons why softimage died was precisely for that reason.
- wlesieutre 5y agoThe thing I miss from 3ds Max is that you could have a non-destructive workflow for basic primitives because the geometry of simple objects like a cylinder just lived at the bottom of the modifier stack and you could change them later. Once you need to edit the mesh you have to “apply” that geometry and lock it in, but it’s handy to be able to go back and say “When I merge these objects the topology flows better with 24 faces around the cylinder instead of 16.” Haven’t used it too recently, but in blender I think that still means deleting the object and making a new one to replace it.
- jtxt 5y agoBlender also has modifiers and can do many things non destructively. (Been a while since I've used Max heavily though.)
- wlesieutre 5y agoYes, but the geometry is not a modifier. The “how many rings/segments” configuration shows up during primitive creation, the geometry is generated, and that’s your geometry unless you want to delete it and make a new one. You can see what I’m talking about in 3ds here: https://youtu.be/Dp9Ozs3HjzY?t=120 https://youtu.be/Dp9Ozs3HjzY?t=120
- jtxt 5y agoYes, I know what you mean now. (Perhaps they could add primitives to the modifiers for a similar workflow.) You can setup parametric primitives other ways though, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaHL7jRo6mM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaHL7jRo6mM Or putting a screw modifier on a curve... ( torus, sphere, any lathed object...) Or there's likely a number of different ways using geometry nodes. Granted it's not currently simple and intuitive though.
- wondenderboy 5y agono you haven't - coz if you did - you know that there were no yt or pdf/html tuts around + the manuals were rly terrible. so you had to tinker with each and every program and ui from scratch yourself to see how it works. my basic test with every 3d package since then was to create a plain scene, add simple objects, textures, lights and camera to see how it behaves - and the only program that failed this test since 1988 is blender. I simply was not able to create a simple scene and render it with this program without hours spend on stupid tuts and learing keyboard shortcuts. and yes, the basic 3d principles are the same since then. So if u were around back then u would knew that even with the original lw & cinema 4d in 1989 on amiga or maya 1.0 on pc you could get results easier than with blender... ...and yes I refuse to use this crap ui for this reason. where blender shines tho is as a converter for some rare object formats, using the free plugins.
- fsloth 5y agoHave you used the latest iteration of Blender? The UI is about two orders of magnitude less user hostile now. It's like three clicks to create a scene such as you described. I hated the previous UI:s but now the whole system in Blender is really coming together.
- pksebben 5y agothis is simply not a universal experience. For myself, having no background in using other 3d software, I found blender 2.8 to be incredibly intuitive. I'm aware that the previous versions ui had a bad rap, but if a total newbie like myself can get the hang of it, it can't be all that bad
- ChrisClark 5y ago>no you haven't
- jtxt 5y agoThere are ways it's not better over other tools, but many of those are being addressed, because it's a strong open source project with increasing resources. Maya has a one up on the character animation tools, with addons like Studio Library for a pose library, though now Blender 3.0 in October(ish) will have a very similar feature. And there's others like lattice in the graph editor that Blender does not have yet. Houdini is awesome for node based procedural animation and simulation, now Blender has Geometry Nodes, as a step in that direction...
- blooalien 5y agoGeometry nodes are fun as hell. You played with them yet? I wasn't a fan of all the node based stuff at first, but it's really grown on me…
- capableweb 5y agoIf Blender comes close to Houdini in the future in terms of procedural workflow, especially with physics, then Blender has a real chance at conquering the space.
- cthalupa 5y agoThe "Node Everything" project is producing such exciting stuff. Animation nodes and now geometry nodes have made some really amazing things possible. Geometry nodes have been iterated on so quickly, too! Pretty sure Blender is going to be best in class, or very, very, close for basically every portion of 3D cg work within the next 5 years.
- plufz 5y agoBut does it really beat every single one? I’m a blender user myself and really like it but I was under the impression that most professionals use Maya. And I guessed for some reason?
- failrate 5y agoIt is what they are frequently trained on in school. That is one reason for it to be an industry standard.
- MathYouF 5y agoI'm also a sort of amateur at 3D modeling (though my background is in VR programming so I have a lot of exposure to it) so take my knowledge with a grain of salt, but afaiu there's a few different steps: Modeling: Maya is best, Blender is a good substitute Sculpting/topology: Zbrush is best, Maya is runner up, Blender is a good substitute UV Unwrapping: All the above are good at this Texturing: Substance Painter is best, Blender is a good substitute Animation: Maya and Blender are comparable So as far as I understand the cool thing is, aside Blender is essentially a nearly as good replacement for Maya, and can do everything to an adequite degree for high quality production. The only things Blender is decidedly not an equal substitute for is Sculpting compared to Zbrush and Texturing compared to Substance Painter. Again, I'm not an expert, but I think the above is roughly accurate.
- blooalien 5y agoI keep hearing really good things about Substance Painter from a ton of folk. I'ma really have to prolly have a proper look at it sometime soon-ish.
- Tomte 5y agoIt's now Adobe's, though, so no more lifeteime licenses, only subscriptions. 50 dollars a month (with introductory price of 25 dollars).
- 5y ago
- animal531 5y agoI have one big problem with Blender, and that's all the upgrades its been through. As a result when you're trying to figure out how to do something you can't just google a youtube video because inevitably it'll be of a different version. So you'll see a guy telling you, "now click the little x button" etc. Of course in your updated version the x button has long since been replaced by something else.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think in most cases it is relatively easy to find the button in the new version, there are exceptions though. Hotkeys didn't change for ages I think. But I would still recommend to use the version of Blender from the tutorial. If you get familiar with the rendering pipeline, you will find those buttons more easily.
- raxxorrax 5y agoBlender has become so awesome in the latest versions. I think switching from other software is quite easy, even if some things work differently. It also has an industry standard preset for hotkeys... I use it as an amateur, but there are really good tutorials that allow you to render high quality scenes in a day or two. I use the occasional 3D model on a website, and the pipeline from our industry CAD software to the web with an short detour through Blender works flawlessly.
- aliasEli 5y agoBlender is a very good piece of software. The main problem I usually have with it is finding documentation. Although the official documentation is fairly good, Blender is a huge program, and it can be hard to find the info you need. Also the documentation is not always up-to-date.
- valine 5y agoBetween the official documentation, blender stack exchange, and YouTube I've never had a problem finding what I need.
- mkl95 5y agoThis is a common issue in large free software projects. For instance Godot has hired some contractors specifically to write documentation. Personally I usually end up using Youtube when I need to do something with Blender.
- prox 5y agoYoutube is best I found. Just find tutorial for your area of interest and do the basic tutorial a couple of times till you get fluent in it.
- sowbug 5y agoI stumbled across Ian Hubert's Blender-focused channel (https://youtube.com/c/mrdodobird https://youtube.com/c/mrdodobird) even though I have no interest in CGI production. His one-minute lazy tutorials are fun to watch and funny. My favorite: https://youtu.be/imkSdlbXB_U https://youtu.be/imkSdlbXB_U
- Popegaf 5y agoI find it great that they're using Blender, but > This episode is named Rabbids Invasion: Mission to Mars and it will be released at the end of the summer on France Television and on Netflix worldwide in 2022 3-6 months between releases? I get that it's a licensing issue - France Television probably knows more people will watch it on Netflix than on their own network - but this is just asking for piracy.
- opencl 5y agoIt's entirely possible that the slowness is on Netflix's end, especially if they're doing the English dub themselves. They frequently take 6+ months to release English versions of anime they license.
- smoldesu 5y ago> this is just asking for piracy If you're desperate enough for entertainment to pirate the... checks notes Rabbids Invasion: Mission to Mars special, I think you deserve to watch it.
- Zababa 5y agoFrance Television is the French national public service for television, so it'll probably be free to watch.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- marcodiego 5y agoTLDR: Conclusion This production on Blender was a great experience for us. We were able to integrate the application into our in-house pipeline and connect it to the other applications quite easily thanks to the strength of the Python API. In spite of some features that would need some maturity we had the confirmation that Blender is production ready and comes with tools that can really push up our way of working in terms of creativity.
- Springtime 5y agoTheir comment just prior about what they saw as a lack of guides for workflows in a studio environment is worth noting, too, as they felt that could be expanded upon for helping Blender reach more. Though frankly the article isn't that long a read anyway.
- robomartin 5y agoIt wasn't clear from the article whether or not the released their Shot Manger plugin as FOSS or kept it an internal tool. I found a plugin called "Shot Manager" but it seems to have been authored by an unrelated Australian company (although some of the features sound very similar). I am not saying they are obligated to release their custom tools. It would just be very interesting if they did. I am not in this space at all other than my kids are learning Blender and love it. Tangent: Completely unrelated to this, I am truly hoping that a large company takes interest in KiCAD and helps push development to the "production ready" stage that Blender seems to have achieved. The EDA market is in serious need of a solid FOSS tool that isn't driven by the latest shinny thing companies go after. To be clear, KiCAD is absolutely fantastic and I am looking forward to version 6.0. We are planning on migrating our work from Altium Designer to KiCAD, likely starting around the end of this year. I'm sick and tired of what has been happening with Altium and the other tools are just as bad or worse.
- the__alchemist 5y agoAnd something suitable for (non-EDA) CAD would be great. KiCad's surface area is small enough that its rough edges can be worked around. FreeCad's isn't.
- smoldesu 5y agoOne of the biggest problems I have with professional software (eg. Bitwig, Ableton Live, Sony Vegas) is that I lose interest in learning how they work after the initial learning curve. All of those programs have a featureset that can be fully explored and understood in a few weeks, or perhaps months for the more complicated stuff. I have been using Blender for 6 years, and still have seen less than half of the features. It's not for lack of searching, but Blender's density is hugely under-appreciated in the industry. If you're a creative or artist in any capacity, Blender has features that you can take advantage of right away. Familiar with NLEs? Hop into the video splicer and play around! Comfortable mesh editing? Stay in the modelling view! Wanna get your hands dirty? Sculpting is just a tab away! Perhaps the most impressive part of Blender is that it's provided for free, in a tiny download, with a deeply caring userbase that maintains it. Here's to another decade of Blender releases!
- chacha2 5y agoThe industry doesn't appreciated that blender can mesh edit and sculpt? What can it do that their existing software can't?
- justinclift 5y agoMaybe 2D vector animation?
- avhon1 5y agoBlender can do that, too, with the "Grease Pencil". https://www.blender.org/features/grease-pencil/ https://www.blender.org/features/grease-pencil/ Here's a short film produced as a grease pencil showcase. At the end, it shows what working with it looks like. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pKmSdY56VtY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pKmSdY56VtY
- justinclift 5y agoYes, that's why I suggested it to a question asking what Blender can do. ;)
- comfyinnernet 5y agoIt's great to see a story about people not getting sexually assaulted at Ubisoft.
- noobermin 5y agoBlender has gone from being a tool professionals scoffed at to one that professionals are stressing over themselves to learn by binging tutorials. It is quite the sight, I remember in 2008 wanting to get into game development and being poopooed on forums from picking up blender and instead pirating maya instead. I obviously dropped the idea completely because of it. Idk, I think there might be a larger lesson somewhere in there but regardless it's amazing to see the shift that has occurred.
- a1371 5y agoThe larger lesson might be that most people see a product's status and not its momentum?
- cthalupa 5y agoI'm a daily blender user, but I'm a daily modern blender user - the pace of development is rapid, but 13 years ago, you might very well have been painting yourself in a corner if you wanted to do 3d work in the games industry and learned it instead of maya or max
- brewtide 5y agoholds true for people, too.
- edanm 5y agoYou can't use momentum if you want to get work done today. Blender's advancement has been an amazing thing to watch, and it is deserving of enormous praise. Today it is afaict a really legit option for learning 3d. That doesn't mean that saying it was a bad idea to use it 13 years ago wasn't correct.
- lvl100 5y agoBlender is a great tool beyond typical 3D applications largely due to its Python scripting and ability to run it headless.
- open-source-ux 5y agoAn example of what a single person can achieve in Blender - the work of Ian Hubert. This is a split-screen comparison of a green screen shoot and the final video rendered using Blender. Seriously impressive: VFX Breakdown - Dynamo Dream Teaser: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFJ_THGj72U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFJ_THGj72U If you prefer watching the teaser in full screen, it's here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qG31WSioSxk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qG31WSioSxk
- chrisseaton 5y agoHow is Blender managing to reposition the camera from a 2D recording (at 30s)? Is it building a 3D model completely automatically from the 2D source?
- mrspeaker 5y agoThat's Ian Hubert magic - he explains it in this (very entertaining) video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxD6H3ri8RI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RxD6H3ri8RI
- adammenges 5y agoBlender is insanely great, and honestly one of the best fully open source software projects out there. The only thing I wish from it is Apple M1 support. Personally, I’m just not sure I’m going to own a big desktop computer with an Nvidia gpu ever again.
- smoldesu 5y agoThis would be a lot easier if MacOS supported a graphics API other than Metal. As it stands, I doubt many people are excited to reverse-engineer a nigh-undocumented iGPU to patch in support for features that it's overarching API doesn't support in the first place (eg. true RT, proper SIMD optimizations, etc.)
- arp242 5y agoIt looks like M1 support was added in 2.93, released last month. It's not super-clear from the release notes (in fact, it's not explicitly mentioned at all), but the requirements are listed as requiring "macOS Version 10.13 or newer for Intel processors on supported hardware. Version 11.0 for Arm-based processors (Apple Silicon)." You can download binaries for "Apple Silicon" as well.
- TheNewAndy 5y agoI have 2.93 and it is native Apple Silicon. Your wish is granted.
- slezyr 5y agoNever mind the other answers. GPU rendering is not supported on macOS. Generally CPU rendering is quite slow. https://docs.blender.org/manual/en/latest/render/cycles/gpu_rendering.html#supported-hardware https://docs.blender.org/manual/en/latest/render/cycles/gpu_...
- doctoboggan 5y agoI have a small startup that sells custom 3D printed jewelry (https://lulimjewelry.com https://lulimjewelry.com) I use blender and the blender python API to automatically generate 3D models from my customers engraving images. It’s a great piece of software. Highly capable and the scripting interface is great. You can pop up a window that shows the python command for every action you are doing in the GUInso it’s easy to automate anything you can do manually.
- syntaxing 5y agoI remember you posting on another post! Did you ever manage to figure out how to use ML to clean up the prints? Also, can you point me towards how to see the python command for everything you do in the GUI?
- doctoboggan 5y agoI had some success running this model[0] but I think the training data doesn't sufficiently capture the variety of inputs my customers give me. I don't currently have nearly enough training data to retrain the model. [0]: https://towardsdatascience.com/fingerprint-denoising-and-inpainting-using-fully-convolutional-networks-e24714c3233 https://towardsdatascience.com/fingerprint-denoising-and-inp... To see the python commands add a Scripting > Info window to your workspace. I like to change the animation timeline in the "Layout" tab to a Scripting Info section. To do this hover over the Editor Type tab in the top left of the timeline area (should be a clock icon). Select the Info type under Scripting. You can also turn on python commands in tooltips in the blender settings.
- 2fast4you 5y agoVery cool! Did you look at tools like OpenSCAD before choosing Blender?
- doctoboggan 5y agoI did initially try to tackle this problem by constructing procedural solid models, but that solution wasn't sufficiently general. I ultimately went with blender's displacement modifier, which works by using a UV mapped bitmap image that displaces the model's vertices as a function of the pixel intensity. This workflow adapts well to arbitrary geometry and customer images.