4 ms·
robots.txt, or a copyright notice saying the code can't be used to train AI which bots will ignore and open their corporate masters to liability. on edit: fixe
by bryanrasmussen 5y ago
robots.txt, or a copyright notice saying the code can't be used to train AI which bots will ignore and open their corporate masters to liability.
on edit: fixed typo
- woodruffw 5y agoThis kind of learning needs to be opt-in, not opt-out. I would also be extremely surprised if most open source copyright holders didn't already expect their licensing terms to protect against this kind of code/authorship laundering. Speaking individually, I know that it certainly surprised me to hear that GitHub thinks that it's probably okay to regurgitate entire fragments of the training set without preserving the license.
- ezoe 5y agoBad news for you. Japanese copyright law, article 47-7 explicitly allow using copyrightable works for data analysis by means of a computer(including recording a derivative work created by adaptation) It should be considered as fair-use of USA except we don't use Common Law system so we explicitly state what exempt from the copyright protection.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoThanks for the bad news! Not glad to hear it but glad to know something I didn't. That said - so they would be able to sell some things in Japan that they couldn't other places.
- amelius 5y agoWhat if a Japanese software company uses it to write software, which is then sold in the US? It's still copyright laundering, if you ask me.
- blihp 5y agorobots.txt is a convention for those who want to be good 'web citizens' rather than legally binding. It does absolutely nothing to stop someone who ignores your wishes. For example, there are tons of bots that ignore robots.txt entirely or even go straight for the thing (i.e. 'hey, thanks for telling us where to look!') you're telling them to avoid in robots.txt. While copyright is a mechanism that can be used if you can make the case, and have the means, it will only work for entities that have something to lose and are within a jurisdiction where it matters.