3 ms·
> The irony is that without the GPL, most likely those folks would be stuck with the commercial UNIX clones many of us used during the UNIX wars. 386BSD (of wh
by hnlmorg 5y ago
> The irony is that without the GPL, most likely those folks would be stuck with the commercial UNIX clones many of us used during the UNIX wars.
386BSD (of which FreeBSD is based) is an independent lineage to GNU and was released under the BSD licence. Thus also independent to GPL. In fact for a period in the early to mid 90s, it was BSD which was used as the free "UNIX" with Linux seen largely as a hobbyist platform and Hurd little more than a pipe dream.
Linux might have since become the dominant POSIX server platform but to argue that GPL was the saviour of open source is a gross misunderstanding of the history of open source (and UNIX).
The reason Linux "won" was ironically because it was seen as more of a hacker OS. It was used more by kids because it was more fun to hack around with. Those hackers then grew up, got proper jobs in IT and continued to use what they were already experienced in...Linux.
- e12e 5y ago> 386BSD (of which FreeBSD is based) is an independent lineage to GNU and was released under the BSD licence. Thus also independent to GPL. Is there a non-gnu c compiler? I could only find: https://github.com/386bsd/386bsd/tree/2.0/usr/src/usr.bin/gcc https://github.com/386bsd/386bsd/tree/2.0/usr/src/usr.bin/gc... People tend to forget that Linux was a small project that provided a gpl kernel for the GNU system - not the other way around (hence GNU/Linux, Android/Linux, GNU/kFreeBSD etc).
- drewg123 5y agoThe desire for a non-gpl compiler is part of what drove the development of llvm. llvm is the default compiler on FreeBSD. Compilers are hard, and it took a while.
- laumars 5y agoI don’t think anyone in this thread would have forgotten that fact. The Op themselves mentioned Hurd (what was and still is intended to be the GNU kernel) so they clearly weren’t obvious to your point.
- pjmlp 5y agoIndeed and it was stuck in a legal battle with AT&T, while commercial UNIXes and Windows NT, were adopting stuff out of it thanks license. Had Linux not happened, most likely I would still be deploying Solaris into production.
- hnlmorg 5y agoThat's an absurdly bold claim even by your standards. You can't predict how the industry might have evolved without Linux -- there's far too many variables. But even if you were to try, the fact that FreeBSD, OpenBSD and others are still thriving while Solaris is slowly dying off should be a massive clue that your statement isn't nearly as much of a certainty as your post makes out.
- pjmlp 5y agoGood to know now I have standards to be measured against. Solaris is dying because of Linux coming into the scene and Sun's mismanagement, being bought by Oracle that most cares about Unbreakable Linux, this wouldn't have happened in an alternative universe without Linux. Plus it was only one example of UNIX, others could be given that were affected in similar ways. FreeBSD, OpenBSD and others are surviving, hardly getting any upstream changes from Apple, Sony or plenty of others that take profit of the license, beyond some charity whenever they feel like, this isn't thriving. It is no surprise that all POSIX clones competition against Linux on the IoT space, by those vendors not keen in upstream updates for Android, are using MIT/BSD and Apache licences. Maybe this isn't up to my standards, yet it is what I believe.
- nineteen999 5y ago> Those hackers then grew up, got proper jobs in IT and continued to use what they were already experienced in...Linux. Honestly by the late 1990's Linux was what was being requested by a lot of employers, with Solaris being the most common system it was displacing (in my experience). BSD simply wasn't even on the radar for most employers/employees.
- hnlmorg 5y agoThe "late 90s" is ~8 years after Linux's release though. So well within the time frame for uni students to have grown into hiring managers.