8 ms·
Mouse lungs after long-term exposure to atmosphere predicted by climate change
- azinman2 5y agoScary. Or does everyone just carry oxygen tanks with them in the future?
- guntars 5y agoJust for the babies. The babies stay in a little bubble with the correct atmosphere and it's a big party when they come out the first time!
- netr0ute 5y agoIf so, then Spaceballs predicted the future exactly.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoIts not about O2, is about an excess of CO2. All of these schemes about CO2 capture don't make sense atmospherically (we're physically digging out too much carbon to put it back into the ground economically) - But CO2 capture makes sense inside buildings. Of course, all of this is just an extra burden on the individual - buying air filters, CO2 capture, expensive ventilation, CO2 monitors - when we could just restrict our coal and oil usage in the first place, much more economically.
- perihelions 5y agoWould be relatively inexpensive to scrub CO2 in indoor spaces (in developed countries), with NaOH for instance [0]. (I wonder why this wouldn't already be a thing: normal indoor CO2 [1] is in the same range as the global CO2 in the OP mouse paper. Indoor air pollution is underappreciated). [0] see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_scrubber https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_scrubber (The amine methods wouldn't be a good idea, because the smell is reportedly extremely vile. It's what nuclear submarines' life support uses -- I forgot the link but there was interesting article about this). [1] https://www.dhs.wisconsin.gov/chemical/carbondioxide.htm https://www.dhs.wisconsin.gov/chemical/carbondioxide.htm edit: I guess plants work too
- toomuchtodo 5y agoCould use (renewables produced) hydrogen and the Bosch process (consuming CO2) to have your scrubbers spit out graphite, water, and heat.
- nitrogen 5y agoedit: I guess plants work too You'd basically need to fit the entire food production capacity for each person inside a building to counteract the CO2 from breathing. Exhaled CO2 comes from food, so the same mass of carbon would have to be converted back into food or other plants. Chemical scrubbing seems more viable, and might be a thing we start seeing in HVAC systems of the future.
- ajmurmann 5y agoDoes all the CO2 from food get exhaled or does some get passed with stool?
- ben_w 5y agoCO2 is a gas, stool isn’t. More specifically, the CO2 has to get out of your blood to make way for the next load of oxygen, and that happens in your lungs not via your digestive tract.
- ivalm 5y agoHe slightly mis-wrote, he meant percentage of carbon from food that gets converted to CO2 and then exhaled. Not all of food carbon becomes CO2 therefore you don’t need exactly equivalent biomass growth to offset food consumption.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoBut stool is gassing out too. Sometimes very noticably so...
- ben_w 5y ago
- secondcoming 5y agoonly going by the abstract, it seems not, but there may be a business opportunity for oxygen hotels catering to pregnant women. Go long oxygen!
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoYes. Perry, err... Perrier Air!
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoThese higher CO2 levels (890ppm) are already a problem indoors. Ventilation systems become less effective as outdoor CO2 levels increase. Many houses and apartments around the world have no ventilation systems at all. Its... mind boggling, or collectively insane, that we are doing so little. We risk stupefying ourselves into inaction since CO2 also has negative cognitive impacts. For starters we need to shut down all coal plants and thermal coal mines (physically occupy them if necessary), cease manufacturing new ICE vehicles, and tariff any countries that don't impose carbon prices. I highly recommend that everyone reading this buy an air quality monitor (CO2 + Pm2.5) so that you can at least monitor your own indoor CO2 levels.
- throwaway894345 5y agoIf people aren’t going to combat climate change on the bases of mass extinction and threat to all advanced civilization as we know it, I don’t expect they will be persuaded by ill health effects.
- legutierr 5y agoFalse. It’s not that hard to fool yourself into thinking that you will be able to navigate the societal disruption that will be caused by climate change, especially if you have money. If you have the resources you can move north, pay more for food, hide behind the security services. But no one wants to imagine living inside a literal bubble or seeing their grandkids crippled by CO2 poisoning. Escaping the heat and its effects is one thing—it’s entirely a different thing to have to escape the atmosphere.
- radford-neal 5y agoHere's how they handled the exposure vs. control group: Mice in the CO2-exposed group were housed within a semi-sealed, custom-made 393-L exposure chamber... the exposure chamber was also fitted with two 80-mm fans that ran continuously... Mice in the control group were housed in the same type of cages in the same room, but not within the exposure chamber. So the exposure group were in a semi-sealed chamber where other toxins might have accumulated, and were subjected to continuous fan noise. Whereas the control group were not in a chamber and were not subjected to fan noise. I don't think one can draw any valid conclusions from this experiment. They should have put both groups in the same type of chamber, both with fans, but just not introduced CO2 into the chamber for the control group.
- VectorLock 5y agoSounds like someone could simply recreate that experiment if they felt those variables had any bearing on the result.
- throwaway316943 5y agoYes and they should do so before anyone draws any conclusions from this.
- Etheryte 5y agoI don't really see how this hand-wavy dismissal invalidates anything about the study. Both groups of mice were in the same room, and while they would be exposed to somewhat different levels of noise due to relative distance to the fans, the difference would be negligible. Same for the toxin buildup, the very reason the fans were present was to circulate the air, which was constantly both monitored and regulated. This was a core part of the whole setup and the main focus of the study. Unless you find it more likely that the small background noise difference had a starker effect on the lungs than the mixture of gases going through the lungs constantly, I don't really see how any of the criticisms hold.
- radford-neal 5y ago
- codenesium 5y agoGuess we have to turn human evolution back on. Could this be the cause of the childless dystopia we see in books and movies?
- ravenstine 5y agoThis is an interesting study, but I wouldn't yet draw any conclusions about the potential effect of a future atmosphere on human physiology based on the mouse model.
- leereeves 5y agoWe shouldn't draw any conclusions because this study doesn't support any conclusions. They measured 48 variables and found two were "statistically significant" at a p<0.05 significance level. But that's exactly what you'd expect to find purely by random chance if there's no real effect.
- guscost 5y agoWhile this is interesting research, the effect of posting it here is to smuggle a political argument onto HN (and of course, attempt to freeze out disagreement/create an echo chamber), and I cannot endorse that by engaging.
- feoren 5y agoSo when Republicans start denying the existence of electrons, we can't post about computers anymore?
- long_time_gone 5y agoIsn’t commenting the definition of engaging on HN? Maybe the real question is why do you reflexively assume it is political?
- bruce343434 5y agoSo basically, bigger lungs?
- tiktokspyware 5y agohttps://www.ucsusa.org/resources/each-countrys-share-co2-emissions https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/each-countrys-share-co2-emi...
- peter303 5y agoNatural selection will help rodents. They could have 200-300 generations by 2100. Big mammals not so lucky. Just 4-6 generations
- robomartin 5y agoThis is junk science on so many levels it's laughable. First of all, the population of large modern cities is already exposed to CO2 levels equal to or greater than the test level (900 ppm) nearly 24/7. I just took my CO2 meter and walked around the house. The levels range from 980 to 1165 ppm, the garage having the lowest levels. Atypical? I don't think so. Not at all. I'll go measure my neighbor's homes and the office when I get a chance. It only stands to reason that a sealed environment would have higher CO2 levels. Modern buildings, in order to be energy efficient, are sealed-up fairly tightly. This makes both air conditioning and heating more efficient. Therefore, without constant air exchange program (which nobody does) CO2 levels indoors are going to be higher. In fact, outdoor CO2 levels right now are 425 in my backyard and 613 in the front of the house. Measurements taken about 30 cm from the ground and away from any vegetation. Are people dropping dead? NO Are people ending-up in the hospital with horrible respiratory system problems? NO If these numbers were statistically significant one would be able to point out equally significant pandemic-like respiratory and other issues across a massive portion of the population. What's even more interesting is that 2020 caused everyone to lock down indoors FOR A WHOLE YEAR! This means billions of people were exposed to potentially higher CO2 concentrations than normal. The assumption here being that a more active population moves between indoor and outdoor environments, at least on a transitory basis while going to work, market, etc. People are not dropping deal like flies at CO2 levels in the 1,000+ ppm range. This also brought-up another question: We spend hours in our cars. What's the CO2 level in there? I measured three vehicles, small, medium and large. I took measurements with the air conditioning system set to bring in outside air as well as recirculate (what you might do on the highway to avoid sucking-in fumes). The levels ranged from 680 ppm to 1264 ppm. Now I am interested in getting numbers while driving on the highway with a full load of people in the car. I'll get those numbers tomorrow. Back to the junk science experiment. First, as someone pointed out, the size of the test chamber was, objectively speaking, ridiculously small. 60 x 50 x 140 cm. Since it is somewhat difficult to visualize volumes sometimes, I went and measured a couple of household items to get a sense of proportion. All measurements in cm Refrigerator: 91 x 83 x 174 volume: 1314 liters Dishwasher: 60 x 50 x 75 volume: 225 liters The test chamber's internal volume was 420 liters. Here's what's odd. They list the internal dimensions as 60 x 50 x 140, which is 420 liters. In the article they claim the internal volume was 393 liters. I'll assume they used-up 27 liters with equipment. That being the case, the volume of air the mice had available to them was in the order of 1/3 of the volume of a refrigerator and 75% greater than that of a dishwasher. AND THEY KEPT 53+ MICE IN THERE FOR ELEVEN WEEKS! Go stand in front of your refrigerator right now and imagine 53 mice in that volume. Go do it. I'll wait... What's the ratio of air available? 393/53 = 7.4 liters per mice What's the ratio of air available per human, for a family of four, in, say, a typical 2000 square foot (186 square meter) home? 113,267 litters per person What's the weight ratio between a mouse and a typical person? About 2,700 to 1 Scaling the air available per person, this would translate into a requirement of nearly 42 liters of air per mouse. The test chamber had SEVEN. While my calculations are not meant to be precise, the idea is to get a sense of proportion here. If you wanted to conduct an experiment that truly simulated free space exposure to any given level of CO2 concentration you would have to have a chamber of a volume sufficient to eliminate the possibility of creating deficiencies as well as contaminating the very air you are relying on to test for exposure. I mean, what do 53 mice farting for 12 weeks do to a chamber 1/3 the volume of a refrigerator? Their control loop had a single variable, CO2 concentration. Nothing else triggered an any kind of an adjustment to the environment in that chamber. I could go on, but I'll stop here. There's a whole segment of society --government, academics and zealots-- who are going way out of their way to attempt to create FUD powerful enough to scare people into doing things we should not be doing. Yes, yes, yes, climate change is real and we contributed greatly to atmospheric CO2 concentration. None of that is in doubt at all. This isn't about denying any of it. This is about suggesting we need to start having the right conversations and stop lying to each other. It is probably fair to say hundreds of millions of people have been living a great deal of their lives in >1000 ppm CO2 levels inside of cars and buildings for decades, maybe 50 or 100 years. Maybe more. Last I checked, the sky hasn't fallen yet. Of course, one might say: Well, when outside levels get to 900 ppm what will inside levels be? This is interesting. The test was conducted at the predicted atmospheric CO2 levels in EIGHTY YEARS. In other words, not any time soon. For a sense of proportion, anyone born today will likely be dead by then. So, yeah, a while from now. This exposes a level of dishonesty (or hubris, if I want to be kind) that is far too common for those wanting to push junk science: Reality is reduced to a single variable. In this case, for a whole 80 years nothing, absolutely nothing changes in the world and the one-and-only variable --atmospheric CO2 concentration-- climbs and climbs and climbs. Like I said, dishonest. I'll add ignorant and manipulative to that. We know, without a shadow of a doubt, that the planet --because this IS a planetary scale issue-- reacts to CO2 concentration through changes in weather. In fact, we know, also without a doubt, that the two things that happen are: Lots of "water events" (rain, hurricanes, cyclones, etc.) and lots of vegetation growth (trees, forests, etc.). Do you know what indoor farmers add to their environment in order to promote rapid plant growth? CO2. Exactly. And so, reality isn't a single variable problem. It's a complex multivariate machine. Will outdoor atmospheric CO2 concentration ever get to 900 ppm? Who knows? Nobody knows. And nobody can say one way or the other. What is far more likely to happen is that the planet will continue to react to increased availability of CO2 --as it has been for millions of years-- and possibly prevent this. Of course, I think we can expect to have shifted almost entirely away from fossil fuel for ground transportation. I can see that being the case in, say, 25 years or so. In other words, anyone who bought a new car today and keeps it for, say, ten years, will likely have lots of good options by that time to buy an electric vehicle. I am doubling that and adding five years to my electric conversion estimate. The scientific and technical communities need to start pushing for honesty in this field or we are going to waste valuable time and resources on things that will be utterly pointless for the future of humanity. For now, plant lot of trees and stop cutting down forests. That seems like the most proactive and harmless things we can do without requiring massive government spending programs.