6 ms·
Sorry for your loss. This is one of the things that tends to get overlooked when discussing how awful the US health care industry is. You always hear: "US healt
by ryandrake 5y ago
Sorry for your loss. This is one of the things that tends to get overlooked when discussing how awful the US health care industry is. You always hear: "US health care is terrible unless you have insurance!" But, it's also terrible when you have insurance! There are all kinds of ways doctors, hospitals, and insurance companies conspire to drain your pockets or your loved ones' estate's pockets, and they're all likely documented somewhere in a 100 page policy. The system is irredeemably beyond repair.
- nrmitchi 5y agoIt more and more feels like the difference between not having insurance, and having insurance when something bad actually happens is "do I get a massive bill that I can't afford now, or do I get a massive bill that I can't afford later?". The only real benefit of having "insurance" in the US is having reasonable access to basic preventative care. Don't get me wrong, it is a massive advantage to have default access to basic preventative care (without it being a cost-benefit tradeoff each time), but that is in no way/shape/form "insurance" in the typical meaning of the term.
- majormajor 5y agoMost of the time the system works for people who have good coverage. The tragedy is that "having good coverage" is a hard-to-control combination of luck in employer and/or wealth. It's terrible that these things happen at all, and we CERTAINLY need to improve the US healthcare system, but exaggerations like "the only benefit of insurance in the US is access to preventative care" doesn't help. If people were regularly getting fucked like that the system wouldn't have the entrenched support it does from the "but I want to keep my insurance" camp, and so speaking in generalities like that just makes you appear uninformed to the millions who regularly see doctors, get treatment, have surgery, etc, without these problems. It also cheapens the inequality problem: the gap isn't just "has access to preventive care" vs "doesn't have that access." The gap is "has hundreds of thousands of dollars, or even millions, of bills turn into nothing" vs "bankrupt if they seek treatment for any serious problem."
- NationalPark 5y agoI've had "good" coverage for my 15 year career and it does not work most of the time, or even half of the time. I've paid bills out of pocket because I didn't have time to untangle payer/insurance situations. I was taken to the ER unconscious once after a freak accident and ended up paying thousands for the ambulance. I've had to do provider paperwork myself and submit it to insurers myself because they refused to help me help them get paid. The system is simply not functional for people who don't have huge amounts of free time, patience, and money.
- pkaye 5y agoThat is why I like the Kaiser HMO system. Most of the rates are pre-negotiated since the hospital and insurance are under the same company. Its typically $20/40 copay for a doctor visit. Even for me with my kidney failure and health issues, the OOP is minimal.
- pavlov 5y ago> “If people were regularly getting fucked like that the system wouldn't have the entrenched support it does from the "but I want to keep my insurance" camp” I don’t see how that follows. The “I’ve got mine” camp doesn’t care that it happens to those other people, and also doesn’t understand that it could happen to them in their old age (or simply after bad luck) because they’ve only made short visits into the system.
- ohazi 5y ago> Most of the time the system works for people who have good coverage. I'm sorry, but I just can't see how this is true. Do you only go to the doctor for a yearly checkup, or something? I've had "good" coverage (paid for by big employers with cushy all inclusive packages), and I've also had the cheapest option on CA’s exchange, and the only difference was whether I had to pay the receptionist $25 or $150. The "we won't cover this" and the "surprise, this costs 50x what you were told!" billing nightmare comes six months later. This has happened with every insurer I've ever had.
- 5y ago
- usefulcat 5y ago> The only real benefit of having "insurance" in the US is having reasonable access to basic preventative care What insurance do you have where the cost of the annual premium is less than what the out of pocket costs would be for annual checkups for the covered individuals? I have the cheapest insurance I can get. Yes, it pays for basic preventative care (basically a checkup per person per year), and it also costs more than my mortgage.
- ryandrake 5y agoWhen you have insurance, a claim should become purely a discussion between your insurance company and the health providers. It seems the current system needlessly inserts the patient into the middle, for the purpose of torturing him/her with paperwork, threats, bills, threats of bills, and the need to learn the intricacies of in-network, deductibles and co-pays, lifetime maximums, covered vs. uncovered procedures, etc. Instead of the insurance and health companies privately fighting it out between each other, they stick you in the middle, fighting through you as the proxy/punchingbag. Wouldn't it be better if you went to the hospital, gave them your insurance information, and that's the last you ever were involved with anything regarding payment? Isn't that one of the reasons we have insurance?
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>There are all kinds of ways doctors, hospitals, and insurance companies conspire to drain your pockets People also want cutting edge care from some of the smartest and most highly educated people in the world (which is in short supply) for cheap.
- heavyset_go 5y agoWhen I lived in Manhattan and worked with some really wealthy clients, they'd fly to France, Israel and elsewhere for care when they could have easily gotten the best care the US has to offer right down the street.
- Arrath 5y agoThere is a pretty large continuum of potential value between the 'cheap' care that people want, and the ruinous bills that get charged.
- Goronmon 5y agoThere is a pretty large continuum of potential value between the 'cheap' care that people want, and the ruinous bills that get charged. That can't be true, everyone knows that people are only greedy and stupid, and it's really the citizens' fault for the prices of the current healthcare setup. The industry itself is all made up of kind-hearted super heroes who would never think of manipulating prices to syphon more money from patients.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoRuinous bills are frequently used to cover the costs of routine procedures. It’s another situation where 10% of the healthcare consumes 90% of the resources. It’s the person who needs 6 months in the hospital, the 2 month premature baby in NICU, the hemophiliac that needs $1M medication that balloon all the costs. And no one can really afford that, but instead of spreading the costs around to all taxpayers, we were spreading it around by inflating everything else. ACA helps with this, but today’s announcement about out of network care will help more too.
- Goronmon 5y ago
- dave_aiello 5y agoMy wife is a primary care doctor in the United States. Saying that disqualifies me in some people's minds from having an opinion about the quality and cost of health care in this country. But I am willing to give an opinion regardless. There are plenty of medical practices and institutions that function well and deliver good value to the patient. But there are many that do not. As someone who doesn't have friends inside the health care industry, it can be extremely difficult to figure out what to do in an emergency. Quite often your options are limited especially if you are caring for a loved one rather than yourself. The best advice I can give is to find good doctors before you need them, and when conversations come up about someone else's medical care, be willing to ask, who is your doctor and how good are they? Or, which hospital did you go to, and do you feel you had a good experience? Often there is little out-of-pocket difference between the cost of excellent medical care and lower quality care, if you have good insurance. If you don't have good insurance and you are looking at a potentially significant medical procedure, ask to speak to someone about financial assistance. Good practices and good hospital systems are not looking to bankrupt their patients.
- lmeyerov 5y agoam hàppy to see HHS moving forward, long overdue! most US doctors are part of a bigger group in order to provide more comprehensive coverage (and due to systematic buyouts), which in turn have preferred insurance providers and additional out-of-network providers, and emergency services are generally for wherever an ambulance takes you. your physician may be great, but they are just a tiny cog in a broken machine one of the only outs, afaict, is something like working & living near a big & strong HMO like kaiser. but that comes at the cost of pretty firm boundaries on what services they allow: capped care (my SO is also a physician at one of the nation's best hospitals, and despite that, patients struggle w the broader system outside of her practical daily control)