5 ms·
At least as it currently stands, this case seems to mostly have to do with difficulties of eviction, especially when the house is in a weird ownership status. H
by _delirium 15y ago
At least as it currently stands, this case seems to mostly have to do with difficulties of eviction, especially when the house is in a weird ownership status. He hasn't been living on the land nearly long enough to actually have any real rights through adverse possession (roughly, "squatter's rights"), and could be evicted by the owner at any time. He just seems to think, possibly correctly, that eviction is unlikely for a variety of reasons, and so hopes to stay long enough that adverse possession will become relevant, if he de-facto lives in the house long enough without being evicted.
The main thing that keeps him "legal" in a certain sense is that, due to particularities of Texas law, once he's filed that document, it's a civil dispute over ownership, not a criminal case, so police won't evict him for trespassing unless a court resolves the civil dispute first, and orders eviction. He's betting that nobody is going to get around to pursuing that case, even though they would probably win if they did (since he does not in fact own the property, either de jure or through sufficiently long de-facto possession).
- dctoedt 15y agoUnder Texas law it likely will take 10 years for the squatter to acquire title via adverse possession.[1][2] In the meantime, whoever is the true owner can sue in civil court at any time to have the squatter evicted. I can see why the police didn't want to get involved when it was only the neighbors who complained. If the record owner were to complain (the one who walked away), the police might well arrest the squatter for trespassing. [1] http://www.lonestarlandlaw.com/Adverse.html http://www.lonestarlandlaw.com/Adverse.html [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession
- tptacek 15y agoIn Illinois you get 20 years, and must possess the property continuously, in actuality, open and notoriously and exclusively. The occupation also must be hostile. In all these regards, the burden of proof is on the person trying to claim adverse possession. My question for you, as a lawyer who might know this: can you beat an adverse possession claim simply by giving the squatter permission? Would a written notice permitting occupation for, say, 60 days, reset the clock on "continuous hostile actual occupation"?
- dctoedt 15y ago> must possess the property continuously, in actuality, open and notoriously and exclusively. That's pretty much the law everywhere in the U.S. (save perhaps Louisiana, which has a system rooted in Napoleonic law and not English common law). The mnemonic is ONCHA - open, notorious, continuous, hostile, and adverse. > can you beat an adverse possession claim simply by giving the squatter permission? I don't recall any cases off the top of my head. I doubt that an owner could unilaterally transform hostile possession into non-hostile possession; it'd be too tempting for the owner to try to fabricate backdated evidence of consent. (Your question brought to mind a line from Henry Fielding, which my torts professor used to illustrate how consent is sometimes a defense: He in a few minutes ravished this fair creature, or at least would have ravished her, if she had not, by a timely compliance, prevented him. [3]) [3] http://quotationsbook.com/quote/35415/ http://quotationsbook.com/quote/35415/
- fleitz 15y agoGiven the article it sounds like he's satisfied all of the conditions, everyone wants him out (hostile), he's filed the paperwork (open), he's had it written about in the paper (notorious), and he's established residence by camping in the living room. Even if he doesn't get the house he's still living rent free.
- Estragon 15y agoRent free, but living without water and electricity (not to mention the respect of your neighbors) has got to suck, especially in Texas.
- stcredzero 15y agoIn South Carolina, I met a cabbie who was renovating a big Federal style house in the north part of town. No furnace, and certainly no AC. He was also camped out in the living room, and doing all of the work himself. Got a $20,000 community reinvigoration loan from the government to help him out.
- derleth 15y ago
- espeed 15y agoCould this ignite a Texas land rush to occupy foreclosed homes? Possibly. But what would happen if the new occupants struck deals with the owners for them not to complain?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- datboi448 15y agoRight of redemption laws allow the original owner of a foreclosed house to seek redemption on the property if they are able to come up with the money they need in a specified amount of time. The redemption is transferable and in essence is just as powerful as having the deed of the property itself.
- barkingcat 15y agoI think his assumption is that the owner wouldn't want to "out" themselves as they are on the lamb from tons of mortgage back payments. Once the owners emerge from "MIA" to try to get him off the property, the bank would sick their lawyers on the owners. So in this case, it's a matter of "I dare you to come clear me out from your house - but if you do, here are some banks that would be really interested in your current phone number"
- enjo 15y agoI'd bet that they could get the court records sealed in this instance.
- tankenmate 15y agoWhich would last all of about 15 minutes when the banks file against "John Doe" with a motion to unseal.