3 ms·
However, the UK has a lot of Combined Cycle gas turbines. Almost all of them in fact. CCGT is more efficient but not so much in the spin-up/ spin-down phase. I
by tialaramex 5y ago
However, the UK has a lot of Combined Cycle gas turbines. Almost all of them in fact. CCGT is more efficient but not so much in the spin-up/ spin-down phase.
I suspect that it's much cheaper to spin a CCGT down to idle power output for a while than switch it off and soon after back on again. Which is fine so long as the difference between idle power and peak power needed in the UK matches the range of our CCGTs. A ramp of 5GW output, over two hours is something they're doing every day. But what if it was 10GW in thirty minutes? 15GW in twenty minutes? Something has to give.
You can definitely see in the data on a night with strong winds, it isn't the CCGTs that stop first. As winds pick up, the CCGTs reduce power output, but at a low point they continue where they are and the UK stops importing power instead. To a considerable extent that's cheap French nuclear power, which means low carbon. There is no way gas is cheaper than that. I'd guess the CCGTs would rather lose money for an hour (or two?) selling electricity for less than the gas cost to make it, than switch off and start again cold in a few hours.
- liketochill 5y agoThere can be other system operation concerns such as stability and spinning reserve. If the intertie to France is lost and 3GW of nuclear power disappears and you are left with 100% wind then the severed system probably will be out of balance without something ready to go that can quickly. Also yes stopping and starting the machines are often when things go wrong. Things that are stopped tend to stay stopped and things that are running tend to stay running. Keeping a machine hot and spinning avoids thermal cycles and issues with stopping and starting oil pumps, brakes, bearings, etc that can occur.
- Retric 5y agoThat’s a very good point. Modern CCGT’s can ramp down to 20% without causing thermal cycling issues. As you point out that’s not zero, but you can very accurately forecast wind over the next 12 hours to only turn on an appropriate number of CCGT’s. Traditional gas’s turbines cost less and turn on and off in minutes and are therefore ideal in more supplemental role. Some designs can actually operate aim either mode, which seems to cover the downsides of each system though of course at higher costs and slightly lower efficiency. The market isn’t infinitely adaptable, especially in low population areas, but margins end up surprisingly consistent.