3 ms·
This is baffling. Is this supposed to provide above market returns (after adjusting for risk)? If not, what's the point? If yes, how's the counterparty to this
by gruez 5y ago
This is baffling. Is this supposed to provide above market returns (after adjusting for risk)? If not, what's the point? If yes, how's the counterparty to this (insurance companies) coming up with the returns? After all, they're just investing the money so they can pay out a few decades later; it's not like they can print money to do the payouts. Are they just betting on the insurance companies mispricing their insurance products?
- oefrha 5y agoAccording to the Forbes article I linked, they selectively invest in policies that will likely see a payout (old people with health issues) and ignore the rest. They then pay the premiums to keep the policies alive until they can cash out.
- hogFeast 5y agoEither the person who bought the policy wants to sell or the insurer who wrote the policy wants to sell. The person selling wants cash today, and the person buying wants cash tomorrow. Same as anything else. EDIT: I will add, there is a lot of this kind of thing going on in insurance now because no-one expected rates to stay this low for so long. This drives cash out of insurers who, often, have a massive stream of liabilities and no way to generate cash to pay them. And this specific market is driven more by individuals who took out huge life insurance policies, lived longer than they expected, and are now stuck paying huge premiums they can't afford (so they sell the policy to someone else, who pays the premiums, and collects the final value). Again, this is basically how financial markets work. Risk is shifted towards those who are most able to bear it. The alternative here is a bunch of old people having to declare bankruptcy and being stripped of all their assets because there is no-one who will cash their policy.
- jcheng 5y ago> Are they just betting on the insurance companies mispricing their insurance products? Sort of. First, the investors are betting that the information they have now (when the insured wants to sell) is better than what the insurance company had then (when the insured purchased the policy). Second, life insurance policies have a “cash surrender” value, basically an amount of money that the insurance company will pay to the insured to give up the policy. These days those cash surrender values are extremely low, as the insurance companies rely on the difference to boost profits; they can do this because many policyholders don’t know there are alternatives to surrendering the policy if they can’t make the payments. What’s attractive about this from an investor’s perspective is not outsized returns, but returns that are uncorrelated with the market. I was pretty grossed out when I first heard of this kind of investment but then learned that it first became popular during the AIDS epidemic. Selling their life insurance policies was a way for the terminally ill to benefit from an asset that was not going to have any value to them after death (if they had no family to benefit from the payout). Without investors providing a market for these policies, they’d have to settle for the cash surrender value.