17 ms·
In my experience at least talking to some younger people there is a clear dichotomy: despite all the talk about Gen Z being "digital natives", people new in the
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
In my experience at least talking to some younger people there is a clear dichotomy: despite all the talk about Gen Z being "digital natives", people new in their career are much hungrier to get back into the office because they don't yet have good career networks built up and they're eager for mentorship. It is older, or at least more established workers who are less keen on that.
I don't think FAANGs will have any trouble hiring a boatload of eager, hardworking college grads in September even if they lose multi-digit percentage of their current workers.
- ProjectBarks 5y agoThis is the exact sentiment I hold as well. I think the demographics of hacker news may be slightly swayed towards people who already have established networks and industry experience.
- burlesona 5y agoNot just slightly skewed. Also the HN audience is far more remote-oriented than I’ve encountered among my coworkers over the course of my career, including > 4 years working full-remote.
- briefcomment 5y agoAnonymity probably accounts for a decent portion of the discrepancy (meaning some of your co-workers would probably be anti-WFH in person, and pro-WFH anonymously)
- YinglingLight 5y agoVery few are anti-WFH in person. That would be publicly admitting that you can't be trusted to work independently.
- burlesona 5y agoWe’ll, I can’t prove or disprove that claim, but most of my coworkers have always been very candid with their preferences. I find it difficult to believe that there’s a large number of people who regularly say one thing while secretly believing the opposite.
- TheCanuckster 5y agoIf this is the case, what are the forums people with less established networks and industry experience use? It would seem prudent to be aware of these other "HNs".
- selfhoster11 5y agoReddit would be my guess.
- r00t4ccess 5y agoThis is my experience as well
- bart_spoon 5y agoThe handful of Reddit programming communities I've seen are also very uninterested in returning to work. I have to wonder if the difference isn't so much "established career" vs "newbie" and is more simply self-selection, with people who are comfortable working remotely more likely to engage frequently in online communities, and those more interested in in-person work less represented.
- throwawayboise 5y agoAlso anyone who has been earning a FAANG salary for 5-10 years should have enough FU money to feel a lot less pressure to conform to unreasonable employer demands.
- bregma 5y agoThis week it's TikTok. There is a really funny one where the guy goes back to work and hits his head on a door.
- majormajor 5y agoI think you'd be surprised by how many people don't really engage in outside-of-work anonymous programming forums, vs their personal contacts/friends/coworkers/ex-coworkers.
- some_hacker 5y agoSlightly? If you’re suggesting HN is old and cranky… You’d be correct.
- pm90 5y agoThey might be able to hire boatloads of new/early grads but attrition of senior staff is no joke. Maybe they’re large enough to throw people at the problem and survive, IDK.
- tolbish 5y agoVets with 5+ years of specific subdomain experience within the company's ecosystem (along with experienced engineers who have experience from elsewhere) are much harder to replace.
- ThrowawayR2 5y agoA big part of the rather documentation and process-heavy development model at FAANGs and other large corporations is to ensure that other people can take over a project if any individual leaves. Much as people will hate this analogy, "cattle, not pets" is a concept managers and HR knew long before the software industry stumbled on it. The people at FAANGs are highly-talented but, even at that level, only a handful are truly irreplaceable (and those people were so valued that they were allowed to work from anywhere they wanted even before the pandemic).
- gowld 5y agoIt doesn't really work though, thanks to "move fast and break things". Losing a team member on an important old system is a big loss.
- sgtnoodle 5y agoAs an individual engineer, I think it's inherently valuable to make my projects easy to hand off (in addition to as maintenance free as possible). The company is less impacted if I leave, sure, and it also means I can take a vacation without constantly getting messaged. Long term, it means that I end up working on more bleeding edge "cool" projects, since I'm not bogged down with years of making myself irreplaceable, and folk want new work to benefit from the same level of redundancy and maintainability. I believe that I have a perception of being irreplaceable, but it's because of my future value rather than past value. I've never felt like I was being treated like cattle at work, though, so maybe I've just been lucky enough to work at good companies.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoFAANGs have 10s to 100s of thousands of employees. "Vets" are a lot less irreplaceable than you might think.
- brightball 5y agoYea, this makes perfect sense to me. I had WFH as an option at my first job. After 3 weeks the cool perk wore off and I was in the office by choice everyday. Now I have a family at home and life is much easier working out of the house.
- saiya-jin 5y agoA lot of domain knowledge and momentum might be lost due to such reshuffling. Losing competitive edge and whatnot. But maybe they have excellent documentation, knowledge sharing and mentorship, unlike all multinational corps I've ever worked for (where was generally a cost center and frowned upon).
- throwawaynumber 5y agoMonopolies don't need to be as competitive.
- randcraw 5y agoExactly. This is overlooked to an insane degree when extolling the accomplishments of the FANGs and their founders.
- achow 5y agoFrom a single, young: I miss the office for.. - Free and convenient food. - Social chatter & engagement. - Making friends with employees who I don't know and connecting with new employees. - Work life separation (balance). - Proper workstation, climate controlled environment. - Sense of belonging - team outing, after hours beers.. - Intra and inter company sports and games. - Meeting potential dates. [Not me. Just empathizing]
- ItsMonkk 5y agoI experienced all of these to a much better degree during college. Are you sure you don't just want to live in a city that provides plenty of shared spaces? Relying on your employer for these items seems unwise.
- thatguy0900 5y agoEspecially looking for dates in the workplace as a selling point.
- awsthro00945 5y ago> Relying on your employer for these items seems unwise. Why? Work is where you spend one third (or more) of your time during your adult life. Why the hell would I not want such a significant portion of my life to not also provide great benefits like opportunities to make friends, meet people, eat great food, and have fun? If you scoff at people who want to make their workplaces more welcoming and happier, no shit the workplace is going to turn into anti-social, work-only hellholes that nobody wants to go back to. This attitude is a self-fulfilling prophecy, and a root of the problem.
- stemlord 5y agoBut part of the value of WFH is the ability to lower work-time to something even less than one third. I've always found it extremely difficult to foster worthwhile relationships and have truly fulfilling fun in a corporate PC environment anyway.
- flashgordon 5y agoThis. My observation (and mine alone) is that the FAANGs have commoditized software engineering roles, eg via standardized interviews, disregarding experience - unless you have a "creator" brand etc. This has increased the pool of candidates who are still clamoring to get in (and recent IPOs just made it busier). The FAANG calculus sounds like betting on all this. Infact they are probably calculating this attrition even contributes to some of the unregretable kind!
- nklop 5y agoNot me. My career networks are online. Offices are full of people trying to give each other eating disorders through passive aggression, politics and generally pointless power games. That's the perception we have in our groups. We meet up weekly face to face to share air when possible.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> Offices are full of people trying to give each other eating disorders through passive aggression, politics and generally pointless power games. Seriously, does half of HN work in the real-life equivalent of "The Office"? Yes, office politics exist, but this idea that it's some sort of scheming, back-stabbing environment is a caricature I have never experienced in my nearly 30 year career.
- nklop 5y agoSo you've not seen layoffs? I have. It was a mad scurry of people running around looking busy and indispensible. Bullying? I've had it done to me and another time had to sit in with HR on someone else's behalf. People being performance managed just because? I saw a bunch of 40 somethings get targeted and zeroed out. It got ugly. 30x1 is not the same as 1x30 or 6x5 or 15x2 or 10x3. They all look like the same equation but the experiences can be vastly different.
- gowld 5y agoIs WFH layoff-proof somehow?
- nklop 5y agoWhy would you ask that? I didn't imply that. No guarantees with WFH either. Inserted edit: I notice you didn't comment on bullying. That's awkward over a zoom. At least one boss of someone I know has found out the hard way. Especially on playback. The mind set changes when you start self organising because you're alone in a room. It's a different dynamic. The gig economy has a lot of twists and turns. Less old guarantees but some interesting new ones.
- hintymad 5y agoThis is what I got from 1-on-1s with my coworkers too. Clear separation: Single people want to go back to office. People who have families do not.
- bhub 5y agoI’m 45 and have been working partially remote for 4 years and fully remote since the pandemic. I really enjoy working from home. Spending more time with family and finding a good work/life balance and not having to commute are great perks. I have recently started a new job and was interviewed and onboarded entirely remote. The process was fine and in the future I am not required to be in the office a lot either. However I am eager to get into the office to meet the new people, have them at hand to ask questions (not just on teams) and generally assimilate into the team. The problem with teams and other such tools is that I can’t see if someone is available or not. Their dot might be green, but they might be in the zone or otherwise not easily interruptible. In an office I can see whether or not this is the case. I’m not keen to work in the office 100% but I am also aware of some of the benefits of being in the office at times. Especially planning meetings etc. I also don’t think each case suits everyone and IMO flexible location is a good compromise allowing people to work where they would like. Let people come in when they need or for meetings but also let them work from home as they need.
- zffr 5y agoIMO what's great about slack is that you can send someone a message and they can choose to respond whenever they're free. If async communication is too slow, you can always ask do to a zoom call for a few min. In an office I think it is pretty hard to tell when someone is actually available. If you make a mistake and interrupt someone while they are actually thinking deeply about a problem, you can cause a pretty big dent in their productivity.
- fooey 5y agoIn the office, I was distracted by coworkers massively more often. Maybe if the "office" actually gave everyone enough space to have their own office the push-back against going back wouldn't be so bad, but it seems like no company wants to spend the money to have comfortable and productive working environments.
- zffr 5y agoFor a few months my company had us in single or shared offices (max of 2-3) and I think it was my favorite office environment for productivity.
- InertBrake 5y agoExactly this. The sudden all-remote arrangement last year wrecked my first big summer internship in every possible way. I take responsibility for a good deal of how it affected me emotionally and my subsequent lack of productivity. However, I also wasn't given the physical hardware lab projects I signed up for or any meaningful support. I felt deeply disconnected and unengaged, but pressured to pretend everything was okay. At this point in my life, I'm one of those people who is screaming to get out of the house. It's a place of comfort to me for sure, but also distraction and stagnation. Couple this great start to my career with having a critical third of college plus youth in general being ripped from me, I think its pretty clear why I am against pure WFH. People in different situations and stages with different needs will want different arrangements, but I am not going to apply for remote positions as a new grad.
- zippergz 5y agoMy purely anecdotal experience is kind of the opposite. My friends and co-workers who are eager to get back to the office are mostly the ones who have kids and want to get away from them during the day (which I am sympathetic to).
- TeMPOraL 5y agoFWIW, I have a kid (and a second on the way), and I want to go to an office, my office - not back to the office. That is, I want a separate place to work from, to make work-life balance easier and better insulate myself from the kid-related chaos during work hours. But this can be solved with just renting a separate flat and using it as an office; something I actually considered, except small flats are the new fad for real estate investors (at least where I live), so prices are ridiculous. Going back to the office, the company building, removes a lot of the flexibility and freedom that are important to me, and bring in heaps of crap that I don't want to deal with.
- fooey 5y agoExactly, if I could go back to an office that was even remotely comparable to my home office I wouldn't be so resistant. I don't want to go back to a small room crammed full of programmers shoulder to shoulder, stuck on depressingly out of date equipment, with shitty air conditioning and public restrooms. I'm sooo much more productive and happy working from home
- himinlomax 5y agoI like WFH better, but I wouldn't mind having an office within the company building, even if it's a shared office as long as it's shared with people who work on the same thing as me. What I can't stand, and what I believe many people don't realize how much they can't stand it instead of something else, is having to share a space with people I have nothing to do with. Open floor plans prevent me from talking with my close colleagues, they force me to overhear conversations I have no interest in, strangers walking by all the time, the lack of privacy generates anxiety and so on.
- majormajor 5y agoMy take on HN is that there's a very vocal and fervent anti-office crowd here that cares more strongly about it so will dominate conversations about it, and that the "typical line-level engineer" employee will roll their eyes, not engage, and just continue waiting until they can get back to normal.
- wisty 5y agoI like to bring up the Theory of the Firm - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_the_firm It makes no sense that employees exist, right? Why not just pay everyone as consultants, gig workers, piece-work, etc? But employees do exist, possibly because the best way to manage most people is to pay them to be in a room where all they can do is work. Do you have a great idea to save time? Well you tell your boss, and you're pretty confident that this won't result in you losing billable hours, because you're an employee. Are the requirements kind of bullshit? Not a problem, figure it out, you're paid to be here. Do you need a break? Have a break. Maybe chat to some colleagues, that might even add some value. All the anti-office folk seem very set on believing that they should be paid for the value they add, not the hours they are in the office. This is fine if you're delivering pizza, but for a lot of jobs this just isn't easy to measure. Yes, there's some consultants and B2B, not everything needs to be employees, but for a lot of work and a lot of workers and managers it's paid salary that ends up being fairer and easier. A lot of employees became more productive in lockdown, but I suspect this is partly due to novelty (change often has short-term benefits), partly due to there being nothing else to do, and partly due to all the uncertainty that the business might have mass layoffs.
- tayo42 5y agoWho is doing the mentoring then if only early career people are in the office?
- jackson1442 5y agoAgreed. I'm a college student and have a remote job at a company out of DC, and I don't think I'll be staying there, at least in a remote capacity, after I graduate. While I'm in school, remote work is actually super useful because I can work wherever, whenever, and working around my coursework is incredibly easy. When I'm not in the middle of a term though, it becomes more of a chore. Working 40hrs out of my bedroom isn't ideal by any means (I go out and work at a coffee shop for a few hours each day to combat this), but the work-life separation has been really hard for me to form. I just got swapped from 1099 to W2 so now I'll at least have a work machine that I can keep separate from all my personal stuff, but I feel like it'll still have more of a blurred line than it should have. I might feel differently about this when I eventually have a house with a dedicated office, etc. but living out of an apartment with no formal workspace is really difficult, at least for me. Definition of spaces is incredibly important to how I work.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoMost young one doesn't have experience. Once a good experienced senior tech guy left, there usually a lost of know-how. I've seen this happened where the product development stalled for years because a couple of good one left. It took numerous year to get back to track from mass hiring. And even that was largely helped by 2nd or 3rd best tech persons still left in companies in the first place to mentor the new hires. If a huge chunks of good experience persons gone, development will stall even for Apple. There is a reason why FAANG are competitive even when their pays are insane compare to the lower ranks companies. And nowadays the East actively seek out know-how. None of FAANG IP is enforceable there. Any experienced tech guy can just start a new life over there happily. Give it 2-3 more years and Huawei will be back like pre-Covid.
- kilroy123 5y agoYup, I am glad I worked in office during the first ~7 years of my career. I couldn't even imagine my life not doing that. I've been working remotely since 2015. Do I want to go back now? Hell no.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thatfrenchguy 5y agoCan’t replace senior engineers with a bunch of college grads though ;-)
- brailsafe 5y agoDo they normally have trouble with that? Seems like anyone new to the workforce would at least try a job at a FAANG if they're offered it in a heartbeat unless you're totally full of yourself or somehow have better options. With the exception maybe being deeply held ethical concerns regarding any of them.
- r3trohack3r 5y agoTaking objection to the N in “FAANG” Netflix engineer here. The portion of the company I work in has been hiring remote during the pandemic and we have a company wide permanent WFH policy (well guidance from HR) in place. The policy includes pay tiers depending on where you live, but the pay adjustment doesn’t take place until COVID WFH is lifted. I work on a team that, post covid, has engineers in two countries. I personally live in PHX and won’t be returning to the Bay Area. My salary is currently 100% what my Bay Area was, and will be adjusted down to 80% once the offices fully open.
- kondro 5y agoIs the cost of living in the Bay Area really $100k+ more expensive than AZ? Or does the difference in state income tax offset that?
- genmud 5y agoDepends on what you are looking for and what your lifestyle is. For me, in PHX moving from a 3200 sqft place to a place in SF that was a 30-40 minutes commute (3bd, 1500sqft) would have changed my mortgage by at least 4k/month. But realistically it might end up more like 5-6k/month... because housing in SF is stupid fucking expensive. This is just on the mortgage alone mind you, not including taxes and other expenses. To put in perspective of how little I pay, I pay about 1900/month for mortgage, taxes, insurance and HOA (which is like $150/month because we live in a gated area). I am about 30-45 minutes door to door from PHX airport. On the low end, it would require ~75-80k before taxes just to make up the mortgage difference, and likely be more than that. TL;DR: Yea, it can easily be 100k cheaper in PHX vs SF depending on your situation.
- r3trohack3r 5y agoSorry for the delay. Yes. I’ve run the numbers several times. I have a 2 child family. Treating our house, child care, groceries, etc. as fungible I could take a 50% pay cut over SJC and “maintain” our quality of life on paper. But details matter. I live in a community with 22 miles of maintained trail, some of the best school districts in the country (with no lottery system, we just pick a school), our grocery stores are better (better meat, better produce, better selection), etc. After living both, I strongly suspect my current quality of life in PHX literally does not exist in the Bay Area no matter the price point.