5 ms·
Ancient weights helped create Europe’s first market more than 3k years ago
- boomboomsubban 5y agoCouldn't it also be that a king intentionally sent unequal weights to different parts of their domain? It allows unequal taxing without an obvious bias, and exchanging between kingdoms could have been a part of diplomacy.
- mc32 5y agoSure, but as far as we know, there wasn't a king or emperor that ruled from Anatolia to Great Britain at the time but they have these weight samples from all over this area from c. 1000BC.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt traveled over a period of two thousand years, easily possible through the diplomacy I mention.
- t-writescode 5y agoAt least in the Middle East, unequal weights were very disapproved of and I can’t imagine citizenry tolerating their leadership doing that, for long.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoIt's a fact that the weights were unequal, the only question is why. And it's not like it'd be an easy thing for citizens to notice.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoThe weights only have an error of 5%, which is a standard deviation of about a gram at any particular point in time. Manufacturing error is a far more parsimonious explanation.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoThe article's argument is that a state run distribution would have eliminated those manufacturing errors, but they could have just used them to their advantage.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoThe principle of parsimony applies here. Explanations that don't require centralized bronze age kingdoms everywhere, formal standardization of weights, and thousands of years of no one conducting long distance trade are more parsimonious than those that do. One of the issues with archaeology is that it's easy to come up with thousands of plausible explanations for any particular set of data. Parsimony and other tools are essential to winnowing things down a bit.
- boomboomsubban 5y ago>Explanations that don't require centralized bronze age kingdoms everywhere, formal standardization of weights, and thousands of years of no one conducting long distance trade are more parsimonious than those that do. We have ample evidence of all three of those existed to some degree, and that's why the idea that the measurements were decreed has been the predominant explanation for a while now. I think this one piece of evidence could be explained within the current hypothesis.
- User23 5y agoInteresting how closely this tracks the geographic dispersion of haplogroup R1b. It’s practically certain this innovation spread by migration and conquest, which implies a certain level of central authority.
- sudosysgen 5y agoIs it? R1b is also in Central Africa and Central Asia, while at the same time the weights were coming originally from Mesopotamia/Anatolia where haplogroups J and E are more common. Also, Kings don't always bring their haplogroups, I come from a place where haplogroup E is crushingly dominant yet we were ruled by kings with groups J and R for over a millennia.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoWhy do you think that conclusion is 'practically certain'? R1b diffusion in most of continental Europe predates these dates by thousands of years and as the paper notes, there's no evidence of conquest or unified governance across this region in this time period.
- User23 5y agoHow is the extirpation of the indigenous Y haplogroup by immigrant R1b people not evidence of conquest? We’re talking several millenia BP it’s not as though we’re going to find formal declarations of war. As for the timing, it lines up just fine under the hypotheses based on Reich’s genetic data instead of inaccurate proxies like potsherds.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoAre you perhaps mixing up events? "Extirpation of indigenous european haplogroups" is a phrase I'd associate with the WHG/EEF boundary. Clearly we're not talking about that. I don't think I need to point out that extirpation of EEF-associated populations didn't occur either and isn't particularly relevant since one of the main areas these weights were found was Sardinia. The paper is also talking about a period that begins in the eastern Mediterranean around 3k BCE, moves through southern Europe, and eventually ends up in Northern Europe and Britain around ~1k BCE. It's clearly not associated with WSHs.
- samatman 5y agoIt seems pretty clear how something like this comes about. Merchants dealing in precious goods would travel with their own set of weights. Either party to a transaction would use their own weights, if the eyeball test suggested the other party was low or high balling the weight. End result is that everyone in trading radius has standardized on the same size, within the precision of visual inspection and the beam balances in use at the time. Chunks of bronze and silver in that standard weight co-evolved to also be the medium of exchange. So if someone wanted to buy 10 shekels of peppercorn, or was receiving 10 shekels of silver for a lamb, it's the same thing: if the weights/money look light you can check them against your reference set. Pressing them into disks with writing and a face came later. The human drive toward standardized goods for exchange is truly ancient. Rare shells of a consistent size, with a hole for threading, have been used as money by many peoples well into historical times, and have been found as grave goods as much as 80,000 years ago.
- michaelscott 5y agoThe standardisation of medium of exchange is not only ancient, it's also universal. Shell currencies are found in isolated North American tribes and standardised silver ingots have been found in ancient Chinese digs. Fungible currency seems to be an absolute fundamental in any human economy.
- QuesnayJr 5y agoThe final quote in the article is weird: : The idea of the market standardizing itself “fits a little too well into our modern neoliberal discourse,” he says. “Should we really be using these terms to talk about societies which are so foreign to us?” It's an example of an apparently self-organizing market, but we can't call it a self-organizing market because that might accidentally help someone they don't like politically?
- imtringued 5y agoIt's an example of globally optimal and locally optimal behavior being the same. There is no guarantee that this is always the case. It's exactly when the two differ (global vs local optimum) that the free market starts failing.
- QuesnayJr 5y agoWhat does that have to do with the quote, or my comment?
- legulere 5y agoHistorians are completely right questioning using modern ideas on historical things. For a long time historians used the idea of nations to explain history even though that idea just originated in the 19th century. You can see this especially in how the views on the migration period are slowly changing. Saying ancient people trading was free market capitalism is on the same level as saying ancient people living together without money was communism.
- QuesnayJr 5y agoCommunists actually do say that. Marx called it "primitive communism". The trend in economic history has been the opposite of what you say. In the 70s it was fashionable to emphasize how different ancient economies were from modern. See for example Moses Finley's Ancient Economy. The trend of recent scholarship has been to show that things in the old days are more like today than we thought. It's made the Industrial Revolution harder to explain, because all of the institutional details that seemed like they were important get pushed further and further back in time. Anyway, I thought the quote was odd because it was such a large worry for such a small point. It's interesting that standardized weights and measures didn't require a central government. I have trouble believing that this would radically change anyone's perception of the trade-offs between governments and markets, but the authors are clearly worried that their research is going to give ammunition to someone they don't like.
- perihelions 5y agoNote the +/-5% variation spans 2,000 years of Bronze Age history, so explanation doesn't need an explicit mechanism for "let's change the weights". (Although debasement was also a thing -- at least it was in the Roman Empire, and presumably people thought of it long before that). I'd speculate there was no tendency for foreign trading partners to reconcile unequal measure systems, since neither party had the flexibility to change the weights used in their local markets. Or the markets of different foreign counterparties they also trade with. So regional differences could persist permanently, and would be recognized as such. On the other hand, if merchants went out of their way to harmonize their standards (i.e. "let's take the arithmetic mean of our two weights and use that"), something like a network consensus could emerge. Non-systemic drift would scale down as 1/sqrt{ size of trade network }. (I wonder if Bronze Age traders ever tried analysis of algorithms? They probably lots of time of to think about things, on their endless trade roads).
- streamofdigits 5y agoAlso remarkable how universal the subdivision of time (egyptian 24 hr day, babylonian 60 min hr et) But adoption of the metric system has stalled so clearly in the short term there are various competing forces
- detritus 5y ago> But adoption of the metric system has stalled so clearly in the short term there are various competing forces Presumably this is from an American perspective? Even here in Ye Olde Englande we mostly defer to metric, even if there are some deeply embedded imperial measures, such pints of ale and milk or miles on pathways... .
- refurb 5y agoThe US adopted the following long ago: metric fasteners for vehicles, metric for scientific research, metric for a lot of engineering. The only places I know it’s not commonly used in business is machining and civil engineering. And obviously consumer facing measures, but that’s a domestic issue.
- cyberpunk 5y agoThere’s what, only 300m-ish Noth Americans? You’re the only ones not using it as far as I know, that’s not exactly stalled.
- boomboomsubban 5y agoLiberia also largely uses it, and Myanmar has their own thing, but you're largely right.
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoThere has, if you aren't in the US, Liberia, and Myanmar. Sure, you get a few small outliers (Canada and probably Great Britain still have a mix of measurements)... but mostly, the world uses Metric. This winds up being in the background in the US. Medicine uses a lot of metric. Sciences generally use it to be standardized. Soda is sold in liter bottles. But there hasn't ever really been a push to actually adopt metric, which basically needs to start from the government. Road signs do not list metric and standard distances or speeds: Food is still sold in pounds and gallons as no labeling law has been made. Weather reports don't mention celcius. Without a push from the government itself, I can't say there was ever really and adoption at all.