4 ms·
I'm sticking to my "Who knows what inflation will do / be like." when after the 2008 financial crisis and subsequent stimulus it was pretty much accepted there
by duxup 5y ago
I'm sticking to my "Who knows what inflation will do / be like." when after the 2008 financial crisis and subsequent stimulus it was pretty much accepted there would be a fair amount of inflation (ranging views from 'yes' to your typical end times predictions) and .... not so much.
- BitwiseFool 5y agoI'd like for history to repeat itself but the economy is in a much different place now than it was post 2008. There simply is no way to know how things will go down.
- paxys 5y ago> There simply is no way to know how things will go down. Which is..exactly what they are saying.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deadalus 5y agoU.S. Core CPI, which is thought to represent the real rate of inflation consumers experience is up 0.7% since April 2021 and 3.8% since May of 2020. This is the highest jump since 1992.
- CPLX 5y agoYeah but May of 2020 was a pandemic induced deflationary spiral. That's the problem with this methodology.
- mikeyouse 5y agoRight.. if you use March 2020 instead of May 2020, Core CPI has increased 40% less than OP just claimed.. (2.5% vs. 3.8%)
- dragontamer 5y agoAnd yet, our inflation is only 5.3% since 2019 (2.6% yoy) If we go back two years (because 2020 was certainly an abnormal year) and take a look at the trends, things don't seem so bad.
- standardUser 5y agoI'd add that the economy is in a fantastically different place than it was 40 years ago, which is the last time inflation was a serious issue in this country.
- base698 5y ago2008 is barely a blip on on the chart when looking at the scale of what was done in the last year.
- nabla9 5y agoInvestment bankers are not completely objective commentators. It's their interest to keep inflation down. (I'm not talking about asset prices but core inflation). If you want to see what markets really think, look at daily Treasury Real Yield Curve Rates https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates/Pages/TextView.aspx?data=realyield https://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/i... Real yields are negative. ps. Fed changed their inflation targeting. The target is still 2% core PCE but now it's average targeting. They will allow inflation go above 2% and start to act only after the average inflation reaches 2% (over some unspecified timeline). I believe Fed will have real fight to keep the inflation not going below 2% for the reasons Hartnett probably knows but don't wan to say.
- nickysielicki 5y agoThe problem I have with this take is that you're looking at 2008 as a discrete event with a discrete recovery. Look at a chart of the national debt (which is what we have to monetize, which is the whole reason for inflation) and you'll see that we weren't able to reduce debt meaningfully at any point over the past 15 years. If this is still the same event then all those people still could be right.
- duxup 5y agoI think I see what you're saying, but there's no real obvious end ... may not ever be if it is all one event. Most folks I think read these as predictions of pretty soon to come events... not "never mind we meant over the next 20 ... 50 ... 100 years". And at that point that's not 'right' IMO.
- alisonkisk 5y agoInflation happens when money grows more than economic activity. National debt is only one piece of that. Banks could also raise (private loan) interest rates, or be forced to maintain more reserves, leading to fewer loans.
- imtringued 5y agoInflation happens when demand exceed supply. Interest rates have to be raised when we run out of the ability to expand production capacity (primarily by hiring people) to catch up with demand. Having enough work to hire everyone is not a bad thing.
- spamizbad 5y agoBiggest problem I see: Is low inflation actually good for normal people? The financial crisis of 2008 was an absolute slog, lots of normal people suffered... BUT inflation was low and stocks soared -- but the blowback was significant.
- duxup 5y agoI feel like that question raises the issue of trying to orchestrate some things that can't be all orchestrated at once. Like "Well I'd like to see moderate inflation but control the stock market, oh and ..." Usually I think governments just flip a lever in hopes of getting one thing done, maybe, hopefully.
- imtringued 5y agoLow inflation (far below 2%) actually makes it easier for stocks to soar as people are willing to save more money which then subsequently gets lent out in a way that ends up in housing and stock valuations. The lower inflation, the more desperate the central bank and the more exotic the policies it has to come up with. Decent inflation makes it easier to manage the economy as people cease selfish behavior.
- ethdkreuoreuc 5y agoInflation increases asset prices and increases inequality. Deflation reduces asset prices and reduces inequality. Keynsians do not like deflation because people save money during a deflationary period, and saving money reduces aggregate demand. They will tell you that deflation is equivalent to a recession for that reason, and point to the great depression as an example. I would point out that after the deflationary period of the great depression, the US became a much more equitable society, and was followed by three decades of healthy growth (until bretton woods ended...). Money has a natural ebb-and-flow. When people have no savings, they are less willing to part with money. The price of money (the interest rate of borrowing) increases. When people have lots of savings, they are more willing to lend it out. The price of money decreases. These ebbs-and-flows were small when commodities stood for money. Fiat currency allows banks to practice price controls with money, so the ebbs-and-flows are more extreme, and last for longer periods of time. Deflation rewards those with savings, because their savings can purchase more over time. Inflation rewards borrowing, because borrowers can repay a loan with money that is worth less. Understand, then, that the US government is a debtor. A deflationary period would be intolerable to them, because they would not be able to make payments on their debt. Expect inflation to continue apace, regardless of its effect on normal people.
- jnwatson 5y agoSeveral economists, including Paul Krugman, predicted low inflation. Printing money doesn't create inflation, circulating money does. Notably, Krugman is not predicting low inflation this time around.
- oramit 5y agoYeah this is what has been really bothering me about the inflation narrative being pushed everywhere. The same people crying about inflation now have been "warning" about it forever and have been consistently wrong. I'm totally open to the idea that "things are different this time" but an inflationary spike after the deflationary collapse of COVID isn't surprising at all. I definitely see some prices increasing but most of them are the same or less. It's really difficult to untangle what is inflation and what is just a lingering supply shock from everything being shut down. I just wish the inflation people would have more humility in their predictions.
- duxup 5y agoYeah crawling out of a pandemic, it's kinda new territory. Had you described the actual pandemic to some folks before it happened I would think they would have predicted things would be way worse than they are. I'm kinda surprised things are the way they are. I would have expected serious economic disaster type stuff.