5 ms·
Reinforced concrete structures are known to have a relatively short lifespan. Wood easily lasts several times as long with proper care.
by Retric 5y ago
Reinforced concrete structures are known to have a relatively short lifespan. Wood easily lasts several times as long with proper care.
- neals 5y agoIs there no proper care for concrete though?
- Retric 5y agoKeeping it dry and sealing large cracks helps, but reinforced concrete breaks down on contact with air so not really. Best option would actually be keeping it in a vacuum, but that’s just not cost effective.
- bilbo0s 5y agoIf concrete is reinforced, even with proper care, physics will get you eventually. It'll happen faster if you're near a coast. It'll take longer if you're inland. But eventually, the inevitable will happen. Our reinforced concrete structures will never last as long as, say, the Pyramids. Wood will last longer [than reinforced concrete], again, with proper care. But in the end, entropy wins against wood as well. [And again, wood will never outlast the Pyramids]. In civil engineering, there really is no such thing as a free lunch. All materials come with drawbacks. EDIT: To clarify wording.
- maayank 5y agoWhat timespans are we talking about here? 30 years until reinforced concrete starts failing? 100?
- ska 5y agoAs usual "it depends". Basically rust is the problem, so if you are scrupulous on upkeep (read, spend money) it will last much longer than if not. How long is also enviroment dependents (temperature swings, salt air, emiisions etc. can make it worse)
- stonemetal12 5y agoAbout 100 years is the max life span of reinforced concrete. If not done to a high standard half that.
- renw0rp 5y agoWhat about prefabricated houses in post-communist countries? You definitely can't accuse them of using highest quality materials nor spending loads of money on maintenance, but I haven't heard about major failures and there are probably millions of such blocks of flats out there, built mostly between '60-'80 using a couple of different variations of the technology (some involving pre fabricated pieces of reinforced concrete connected with steel joints). I think they were estimated to last 50 years or so, but there is still large proportion of the population living in such houses in some countries nowadays.
- stonemetal12 5y agoSorry, I only got curious and started looking into it after the condo collapse in Florida. Every reference I can find on the subject says 100 years is the max life span of reinforced concrete. Not being a structural engineer I took it at face value.
- pmontra 5y agoThat bridge in Italy collapsed after 51 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponte_Morandi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponte_Morandi
- afiori 5y ago51 years and criminal care. But if we are comparing concrete and wood as construction material we should use buildings that can be built with either.
- lolsal 5y ago> Our reinforced concrete structures will never last as long as, say, the Pyramids. > Wood will last longer, again, with proper care. I'm curious to understand why as this seems completely counter-intuitive to me (someone with no expertise in materials science or building things!). Can you elaborate? What does the caveat of "with proper care" actually mean? Isolation from all the elements? Does routine maintenance count (replacing deteriorating materials? replacing fasteners? reinforcing?)? A wood structure properly taken care of does not seem like it would last longer than a pyramid or a reinforced concrete structure, if each of those is taken proper care of. But this is a hunch, not data, and based on nothing remotely scientific. I'm fascinated by this kind of thing; I appreciate any tidbits you can share!
- bilbo0s 5y agoSorry. Perhaps my wording was poor. I meant that wood will last longer than reinforced concrete, even when you are properly caring for both. Neither will outlast the Pyramids. I'll reword my comment so that people understand it better.
- wongarsu 5y agoConcrete is strong in compression, but weak in tension or shear forces. To solve that you reinforce it with rebar (basically steel bars). But concrete is porous to water, and steel rusts. When it rusts it expands, which damages the concrete. The only ways to escape that is with coating the rebar (hard to do well) or reinforcing with something else (not many options we know of). You can try to prevent or patch cracks in the concrete to slow down the process, and you can use more rust resistant steel. Both of them prolong the lifetime a lot, but they only delay the inevitable. Wood is simpler, because it isn't a composite material. You have to prevent it from rotting and from being eaten, but on a timescale of a couple decades we can do that quite well. Also with wood structures it's often easier to replace small parts as soon as damage occurs, which prolongs the overall lifetime (similar to steel structures, but unlike reinforced concrete).
- chongli 5y agoAs iconic as the pyramids are, they're not very useful. A better comparison may be the Pantheon in Rome. Nearly two thousand years old and in continuous use throughout its life. There are a number of other Roman structures that have seen continuous, heavy use for over a thousand years. There are actually quite a number of ancient temples, churches, bridges, castles, and roads still in use throughout Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. Hōryū-ji [1] in Japan is a 1300-year-old wooden Buddhist temple that's still in use today! [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hōryū-ji https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hōryū-ji
- abecode 5y agoIn Marina Del Rey, the rebar in the concrete sides of the marina are fed a trickle of electricity to prevent corrosion. I'm not sure how common this is though outside of marine environments.
- Scoundreller 5y agoMaybe not electricity, but sacrificial anodes are otherwise a thing on bridges, boats, water heaters…
- bdamm 5y agoIt's called cathodic protection and it is common.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aspaceman 5y agoRebar reinforced concrete rusts. Non-reinforced concrete has to be built bigger, but can last a long time. The coliseum is still up - Hoover Dam will also probably last awhile. And that's without much maintenance. Smaller non-reinforced structures are harder to build. You have to use the concrete to hold itself up which requires a larger structure. So you're left with reinforcement. There are options for non-rusting rebar, and non-rusting coatings, but I believe they're expensive. Also, any nick or scratch in a coating ruins it. There's also unique and novel research for non-rebar reinforcement - again expensive. Here in US most buildings are built to last X years. So long as the rebar lasts longer than X, they'll use rebar. Increase X via regulations, and the quality (and cost) of the buildings in that area increases. Otherwise the bidder with the lowest cost of materials is most competitive. Anyone know what it's like in China?
- aksss 5y agoSmall nit not to take away from your larger point - I'm not sure the colosseum is a good example of a concrete structure for comparison to the concrete buildings of current age being discussed. The colosseum did use concrete for the arches, but was primarily built of limestone block secured with metal clamping. Then plenty of brickwork was used. Concrete was integral to the colosseum, but (I believe) a relative minority of the material on the whole.
- Retric 5y agoSkyscrapers use a great deal of steel, but their still reinforced concrete structures.
- baybal2 5y ago> There are options for non-rusting rebar, and non-rusting coatings, but I believe they're expensive. Galvanised rebar is omnipresent around the world. I believe even mandatory in some countries. > Otherwise the bidder with the lowest cost of materials is most competitive. Anyone know what it's like in China? Just as you said. Construction companies save on everything. GFRP rebar got adopted in China not so much because of advantages, but because of code allowing for lower concrete cover with it, as I heard.
- ak217 5y agoReinforced concrete is easier to maintain indefinitely than wood, because it's easier to seal against moisture, especially in harsh environments. Just because there are plenty of poorly built/maintained reinforced concrete structures, doesn't mean that it can't be built for longevity.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI wonder if wood construction is more forgiving than concrete once you get to a point where it was neglected for some time. Wood will rot and need replacing, but if your concrete is ignored and the rebar starts crumbling, you can’t just slap fresh concrete over it and call it a day, right?
- iratewizard 5y agoI'm no expert, but repointing concrete is essentially doing just that
- Retric 5y agoNot for reinforced concrete, the rusted rebar is still rusted after repointing. Which causes ever increasing internal stress and lower strength over time. The only way to fix it is to remove existing rebar and replace it which isn’t viable on most structures.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mcguire 5y agoSteel rebar doesn't crumble. Rusting steel expands, causing more cracks, which then allow more water intrusion and more rust.
- Retric 5y agoRust isn’t load baring, it’s effectively replacing steel with a powder which is a huge issue if you needed the steel in the first place. Cracks from expansion make both this worse and make it obvious, but even without that it would still be a critical failure.
- kiliantics 5y agoDepends on how the wood is used. Timber frame structures can last centuries or even millennia. Stick-built is not as durable.
- ekidd 5y agoI would imagine that a lot comes down to maintenance, especially roof and siding maintenance. If you keep the water out, there's no reason why 2x4 and sheetrock shouldn't last a good long time. I live in New England, and there's plenty of old post-and-beam construction that's held up for a couple of hundred years. Some houses still have their original interior trim and softwood floors, and if that holds up, I can't think of any reason why 2x4s shouldn't. But old New England construction lasts because it's maintained. New roofs, new clapboards every 50 years, regular painting, interior repairs and renovations. With land costs what they are in many regions, it's cheaper to take care of a good house rather than just letting it fall apart over 50 years.
- greedo 5y agoThe timbers in those old post and beam houses is far different than almost any wood you can find commercially today. Old growth wood from 200 years ago grew slowly, and the rings are compressed due to this. Unless you're building a new P&B home from reclaimed timbers, I doubt it will last 200 years.
- galangalalgol 5y agoWhat about stone/brick dry laid or with mortar? A lot of roman stuff is around, but there was so much to start with it could easily be selection bias.
- Retric 5y agoSome of this is selection bias, but many structures where removed because people desires change over time rather than some issue with the structure it’s self. Large dry laid stone can easily last thousands of years as long as the foundation is solid. Consider the pyramids both in Egypt and South America plus a host of other very old structures. However, you need to avoid tension, earthquakes, and unstable ground, can’t build very tall etc. High construction costs, slow build times, and serious limitations in what structures are viable shows just why we mostly abandoned the technology. Mortar is basically indefinitely replaceable with constant maintenance and has lower upfront costs. So it’s generally a much better option.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoMost houses last basically forever with "proper care", the question is how difficult/likely is 'proper care' Regular reminder that stainless steel reinforcement exists, is used bridges and it's use outside is growing, and it will last a thousand years. Also there is Basalt, carbon fiber and even reinforcement out of used wind turbine blades, which is used in Britain for HS2, and other non-steel reinforcements, which can give you a structure nearly impervious to weathering. On wood: In Europe we've been using Mass Timber for decides, and it's really good from Carbon perspective and outperforms RCC for small to medium residential and office buildings. Probably not going to replace RCC in infrastructure and industry, but what do I know
- lazide 5y agoStainless reinforcement is definitely not guaranteed to last 1000 years. Most grades of stainless are susceptible to stress corrosion cracking in any environment containing chlorides (even at relatively low levels), which is pretty much any bridge, industrial, or habitated structure - everything from road salt, to bleach, to chlorinated tap water can be a problem over a long enough period of time. This has been a big issue with stainless steel climbing anchors and hangars, as it leads to sudden catastrophic failure with little warning, as you don’t get rust like normal steel. Some areas near the ocean have had failures in as little as 5 years - faster than if they’d used normal steel.
- wcarron 5y agoRegarding climbing anchors: Anybody expecting to use steel near the ocean and having it last, is in for a really bad time. Ti glue-ins are really the best way to go near water. Plus, I'm sure you're aware of how many variables there are. Even 316 rusts and corrodes, and that should be fairly obvious to most users if they actually look at the bolts before trusting them.
- lazide 5y agoAgreed, what got people for awhile is that while there is sometimes visible rust - sometimes there isn’t - and even then nothing like normal steel or iron. Then it fails. Or doesn’t. Not what you want in rebar (or climbing anchors!)