10 ms·
Two days before condo collapse, a pool contractor photographed damage in garage
- MattGaiser 5y ago> so frequently that the building had to replace pump motors every two years How long should a pump motor last? Anyone know?
- verelo 5y agoIf it’s anything like a regular house sump pump (which i suspect it’s not, they should be way higher duty in a building like this), I’ve seen the pumps last 10-20 years without too many issues.
- koolba 5y agoThat depends on how often they cycle on/off. In brutal conditions of constant use, I’ve seen them fail after 3-4 years.
- MattGaiser 5y agoBut that would point to this being a case of brutal conditions with constant use. My real question was to try and grasp how much water they were pumping compared to others.
- cratermoon 5y agoYes, which is exactly the problem here. Those pumps should not have been in constant use. The fact that they failed so often means they were being run far more than would be expected under normal conditions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- verelo 5y agoYeah, i imagine in cases where this is to be expected, the sumps themselves need to be much larger (or have more of them) and the pumps need to be higher duty and intended to move more water. Certainly exceptional, but i'd hope anticipated in the design. Our sump here runs all the time when it rains, but then it goes for weeks without moving any water (especially in the winter). When we moved into this house, the pump was broken, but there was also water damage in the basement. First thing i did was replace it and now its a common sound to hear the pump running.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- na85 5y agoI lived in a place in Ontario where the grading wasn't correct and my sump pumps were failing every 18-24 months. It would run for days after a heavy rain.
- sigstoat 5y agocontra the sibling comment, i've seen lots of home depot house sump pumps that just last a couple of years. quality, conditions, actual duty cycle vs designed, etc.
- beerandt 5y agoMiami is making the same mistake New Orleans made 100 years ago. They're trying to artificially lower their water table to improve drainage, but it creates a cycle of subsidence, which makes flooding worse, which makes them pump more, repeat. They luckily don't have large organic deposits (that I'm aware of), so total subsidence will be much less than New Orleans, but same concept. Back to your question, the pumps were probably designed or spec'd for a capacity that they are having to exceed in increasing amounts.
- freewilly1040 5y agoAre there really other options besides evacuating the city?
- mikewarot 5y agoInstead of trying to lower the water level, Chicago raised "ground level" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raising_of_Chicago
- freewilly1040 5y agoInteresting, thank you for the link!
- elihu 5y agoThat also sounds like it would pull in salt water, which as I understand it is a problem at least in Jakarta: a lot of previously fresh-water wells in the area have become salty due to ocean water seeping in to fill the void.
- beerandt 5y agoThat's for deep water drinking wells. Baton Rouge and south Louisiana are going through that now, with salt water penetrating a fault line that was once considered a barrier. The industrial corridor along the Mississippi consume an unbelievable amount of fresh water, so the same lesson might not apply to most areas. Pumping drainage and the ground water table is probably drawing salt water, but at shallow depths. Not deep enough for actual water wells.
- kube-system 5y agoDepends on the pump and the application. If anything, that statement says more about the choice of pump than the issue it was trying to solve.
- jaclaz 5y ago>How long should a pump motor last? Anyone know? Obviously it depends a lot on the specific type of pump, motors are - generally speaking - very long lasting, I would say (proper type of pump, properly dimensioned, used according to specs, and maintained/repaired) anything between 10 and 20 years. The more common issues are outbound leaks (from the axle gasket) in external pumps and inbound leaks (from the outer case or gaskets) in submersible pumps, and of course from time to time you need to change the bearings. In the case of submersible pumps, leaks usually mean also a motor failure (again it depends on the type of pumps) expecially on rarely used pumps as bearings will clog and the motor will then likely need too power, and overheat. On the other hand, external pumps (air cooled) often overheat because of the poorer cooling, if subjected to lots of "start and stop", electrical motors, particularly if large, tend to create a huge drain of power (often 3x to 5x) when starting (as compared to normally running) and this inrush of current translates in a huge amount of heat (and more generally stress to the motor), so many starts in a limited time are not good for the life of the motor, lately things were mitigated by electronic starters that allow for smoother (less peak Amps) starting. The electrical setup/controls may also play a role, a good, well calculated pumping station (such as those used to evacuate leaks in an underground construction) is generally 100% redundant (i.e. two pumps when only one is needed, in some cases 300%), and have automations that alternate the use of pumps (so that each motor and bearings actually run when pumping is required) and use "the other pump" if there are too many motor starts in a given hour, plus there can be a sort of valve that allows to pump the water within the reservoir, so that even if there is no need to pump water "out" pumps are "exercized" periodically, this latter is also often used to avoid too many starts, once a pump is started, it runs for a given number of minutes minimum, part of which is actually used to pump water outside - i.e. responding to the event that triggered the start - and the rest it runs "idle" pumping water within the reservoir through the by-pass valve, so that if a new event re-triggers the start, the pump is already running and only the valve is closed to make it pump water out. But otherwise what you routinely (I would say every two-three years for external pumps and maybe 5 years for submersible ones) do is check gaskets and bearings and replace them if needed.
- irjustin 5y agoThis is so hard for everyone involved. Do these images really mean "the building will collapse in 2 days?" The contractor clearly thought it was "a lot of work" but not to the level of "this building needs to be condemned immediately". So many articles are screaming "look at that paint chipping and concrete exposure, obviously the building was going to go collapse" I don't think it's so obvious or am I just naive?
- 8ytecoder 5y agoThis is media doing the media thing. In fact even small cracks are perfectly fine - it at least that’s what our civil engineering professor told us. In hindsight everyone of these minor ones will be put under a microscope. That said, if the building had a pattern of these it’s probably not very well maintained.
- beerandt 5y agoCracks are actually required for reinforced concrete to work properly. The concretes got to give so the steal can take the tension, and you want big cracks to show up during before and during failure, specifically because it's a warning sign. But it's highly dependant on size and location.
- beerandt 5y agoYou're absolutely correct. RC design is very complex, but very conservative. There should have been 'oh shit' levels of cracking and rebar exposed, and in specific places. That's not what the infamous "inspection" showed. And even then, it should have tolerated multiple complete local failures before cascading catastrophic failure. ETA: It's hard to see in these photos bc of the the quality, but the rebar in the pool pump room is more concerning than anything in the 2018 report, but still doesn't look anywhere close to failure. (Actual structural inspections should be able to clearly show cracks 1/16th" or smaller, at a resolution you can measure them from the picture) Edit 2: The equipment room in that picture didn't even collapse.
- bb88 5y agoIsn't that why you need inspections with competent structural engineers on a frequency of much much less than 20 years between inspections?
- xwdv 5y agoThere really is no guarantee the rest of the building still won’t collapse soon? There’s a lot of first responders walking around the area.
- mtnGoat 5y agoI spoke with an engineer working on a job site near Seattle for a tech company, their soil stability test holes kept failing inspection but they were allowed to keep retrying in other areas. It took 15 tries to get a sample that would pass, and the state inspector was ok with it. They didn’t want to cause issues for such s big company in such a large project. I was cautioned to not go near that building ever. I’ve always wondered how many other buildings are in the same state.
- MattGaiser 5y agoStartup idea. Reliable and effective whistleblowing programs for stuff like this.
- duncan-donuts 5y agoI know absolutely nothing about whistleblowing laws, but, like, shouldn’t this be driven by policy? I get that lawmakers might not have whistleblowers’ best interests in mind but this feels squarely on Congress to me. Might be an interesting space tho. What do I know.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI think it should be on the government as well, but they don't seem to be willing to do it.
- Vervious 5y agoin what world is there a selfish financial incentive for whistleblowing?
- MattGaiser 5y agoReduce the risk and increase the payoff. Not sure how, but those are the levers that need adjusting.
- 5y ago
- endisneigh 5y agoThere’s just so much confirmation bias. I guarantee you one thing - no matter the ultimate observable precursors, I bet there are thousands of buildings across the states that have the same precursors and nothing will be done. Fundamentally maintenance is just not prioritized. This is true both in software and in general. If you want to scare yourself just Google elevator death. Elevators are a perfect example of the issue in that there are regular inspections but inspections do not imply maintenance. I am not even sure how exactly you foster a culture of maintenance at this point.
- overscore 5y agoAfter reading your comment, I did Google "elevator death", expecting to be dismayed. I came away oddly reassured. It seems that fatal elevator accidents are rare, and that you have much more to fear from your fellow elevator passengers than the apparatus itself, if the news articles are anything to go by. I do have a new fear of drowning in an elevator, though: https://www.israelhayom.com/2020/01/05/young-couple-drowns-in-flooded-elevator-in-south-tel-aviv/ https://www.israelhayom.com/2020/01/05/young-couple-drowns-i...
- Lammy 5y ago> In the pool equipment room, located on the south side of the underground garage, the contractor saw another problem — exposed and corroding rebar in the concrete slab overhead. I'm curious if it was a saltwater pool.
- kube-system 5y agoFrom the photos, it looks like it's pretty bog-standard liquid chlorination via a Pentair Intellichem controller. https://www.pentair.com/en-us/products/residential/pool-spa-equipment/pool-automation/intellichem_waterchemistrycontroller.html https://www.pentair.com/en-us/products/residential/pool-spa-... https://www.miamiherald.com/latest-news/28th3w/picture252421758/alternates/LANDSCAPE_1140/Composite2.jpg https://www.miamiherald.com/latest-news/28th3w/picture252421... Notice the feed line marked 'chlorine' on the wall, and it doesn't look like there's any salt chlorine generators in-line with the plumbing.
- hkai 5y agoImagine if the building was not in a wealthy neighborhood. Most news would focus on the contractor being racist and how dare they take their lives of underprivileged communities. As long as the building is in a fancy neighborhood, this is not big news.
- iJohnDoe 5y agoGenerally speaking, I think two things went wrong here. 1. Almost anyone seeing all the warning signs probably didn’t think an entire building could collapse or partially collapse. Things could look terrible, but maybe not enough to say, “I need to get out of here before this building collapses.” Yes, that is said in old building and homes but it just doesn’t compute in building this size. That is why a professional inspector needed to be involved. 2. Time was also a problem here. In the US, a modern city with a 40 year old building just doesn’t compute. It’s actually kind of old in the US, especially with problems like this. Similar to #1, it didn’t compute a building this size could collapse this way. That is why a professional inspector needed to be involved.
- slashdot2008 5y agohow can any engineer or inspector know that what they can see from a surface inspection means a building is about to collapse? How many buildings do they inspect with damage that don't collapse? all of them until this one. So when they see damage they say, this should be repaired, and then when the repair gets underway, maybe people see that it needs more than anticipated, and it all gets fixed. Probably by that point in time the inspector is out of the picture.
- slashdot2008 5y agoin fact: >also, when performing any concrete restoration work, it is impossible to know the extent of the damage to the underlying rebar until the concrete is opened up. Oftentimes the damage is more extensive than can be determined by inspection of the surface. from the HOA letter: https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/miamiletter0628.pdf https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/miamiletter0628...
- hkai 5y agoFunny how the media only mentions that the SWIMMING POOL DID NOT COLLAPSE somewhere in the ninth paragraph.
- 015UUZn8aEvW 5y agoThis wasn't something that flew under the radar. They had done a lot of due diligence on it and were about to start an extremely expensive and complicated project to fix it. I suspect that some of the delay was due to the amount of work it took to get the huge special assessment lined up. It's likely that some of the residents who were killed had been fighting the condo association to avoid paying so much. Here's a long letter that the condo board recently wrote to the unit owners about the concrete repair work. https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/miamiletter0628.pdf https://s.wsj.net/public/resources/documents/miamiletter0628...
- slashdot2008 5y agothanks for the link >that estimate indicated that the concrete damage observed would begin to multiply exponentially over the years, and indeed the observable damage such as in the garagehas gotten significantly worse since the initial inspection.When you can visually see the concrete spalling (cracking), that means that the rebar holding it together is rusting and deteriorating beneath the surface.Please note that the original scope ofwork inthe 2018 report has expanded. The concrete deterioration is accelerating. The roof situation got much worse, so extensive roof repairs had to be incorporated. >Because so muchof the needed concrete/waterproofingwork is underground, we must pull up almost the entire ground level of the lot to access the areas that requirerepair. That means we have to put itall backat the end. This includes the pool deck, the entire entrydriveand ground level parking,north side contractor parking,and planters/landscaping. Electrical work and plumbingare involved almost everywhere. Balcony concreterequires repair/waterproofing,and the railingsrequire repair. And-we have to bring all this up to current codewhen repairs are completed.
- slashdot2008 5y agointeresting they only had $168,000 earmarked as structural repairs out of $15,000,000. Clearly they did not know the extent of the damage. Most of the work was in waterproofing and balcony repairs.