4 ms·
Because there's nothing interesting about them. They're just another variation on the same ol' "we peg our value to the dollar(*)!" pitch. The interesting stuf
by pavel_lishin 5y ago
Because there's nothing interesting about them. They're just another variation on the same ol' "we peg our value to the dollar(*)!" pitch.
The interesting stuff happens when they fail.
- aqme28 5y agoI think they way they peg their value to a dollar is interesting, because there are so many different strategies now. Some are via reserve dollars, some via collateral based on an oracle, some via collateral not based on an oracle, some are tightly coupled, and some are a bit looser.
- bvaldivielso 5y agoYou can be dismissive about literally anything that way. Computers: another variation on the same ol' "input in, output out" pitch. You find stablecoin's failures interesting. Crypto enthusiasts (which admittedly are a tiny fraction of the people holding cryptocurrencies) do too, while at the same time finding the pegging mechanisms interesting as well
- lazzlazzlazz 5y agoI couldn't disagree more. All of the projects I listed have radically different mechanisms, failure conditions, capital efficiencies, and value capture abilities. It's a fascinating space that is in its infancy. And you're missing projects that aren't pegged to the dollar, but instead have dampened volatility floating price targets — like Reflexer and OlympusDAO. It's a rich, beautiful corner of a rapidly growing space.
- Aperocky 5y agoIt's a rapidly inflating bubble like NFTs and subprime mortgages.
- xur17 5y agoWhat aspect of stablecoins makes them a bubble?
- shkkmo 5y agoA rapidly rising market cap that depends on the expectation of continued growth of demand. Some stablecoins are more protected than others against drops in demand. However, without a compete backing the the currency a stablecoin, there is a point at which sufficient supply of the stablecoin cannot destroyed and the peg will break as supply outstrips demand. When the bubble pops there will be a lot of broken pegs but it most likey won't wipe out every stablecoin.
- xur17 5y agoBut that's not how the decentralized ones work. They aren't relying on "a rapidly rising market cap". Most of the stablecoins are backed by volatile assets (ETH, BTC, etc), but have automated systems to liquidate the collateral when price drops occur. The only real problem would be a very large drop in a very short period of time, and the big stablecoins already have already survived 50% drops in pretty short time spans.
- Aperocky 5y agoIt only really works on good times (read low interest rates). Good thing that the national debt is also out of control, which kind of restrict Fed's ability to raise interest rates without bankrupting the government.
- xur17 5y agoI'm confused. Why are low interest rates required for stablecoins to work? If anything, for centralized stablecoins, high interest rates would mean more revenue for the corporation holding the assets.
- Aperocky 5y agolow interest rates means there are abundance of US dollars floating around for people to engage in things like stable coins. high interest rates means less growth for any assets as liquidity gets tied/dries up. Interest rates are cyclical, all high interest rates cause a period of pain and death for semi-ponzi schemes that works during periods of low interest rates.
- BrissyCoder 5y ago> It's a rich, beautiful corner of a rapidly growing space. I can't imagine what kind of mindset/value-system one has to have to find this stuff rich and beautiful. It's ponzis all the way down. I would call it disingenuous and grubby.
- manquer 5y agoIf they have drunk the cool-aid instead of just selling it, then they really believe in the ecosystem with faith that is unshakeable. All Ponzi scheme needs some level of that faith, without that it hard to sell to somewhat knowledgeable audience. Some of this tech sure eventually will become mainstream in a lot less glamorous and likely more centralized way than crypto enthusiasts like to think, current systems are not perfect certainly, they can leverage more tech, however they also have the benefit of evolving over a long period of time and have gone through the learning curve all the coin markets are going through.
- manquer 5y agoNewsworthy would be more accurate description. It is newsworthy when stuff blows up. Same reason SpaceX gets more coverage for its rocket development than say SLS or Blue Origin ( among other reasons). A lot of people watch car racing for the crashes. thats just human nature.
- xur17 5y agoThey all do the same thing (peg to the dollar), but in different ways with different tradeoffs. That's the interesting part that you're completely missing. Some are more centralized than others. Some rely on governance more than others. Some allow themselves to drift further from the peg than others. Some are more complex (and therefore more at risk of failure). There's actually quite a lot going on, and I personally find it pretty interesting, but yeah, at the surface, it's a bunch of coins that trade fairly close to $1.
- jMyles 5y agoI have to say, it seems to me that OP specifically started the list with two different, interesting, novel approaches that are not as you describe. It's as if the comment was designed to repel lazy, karma-farming comments like this one, and yet you still delivered one. Why? What else can you suggest in order not to prompt this response?