11 ms·
I'm gonna be honest I don't know what the audience is for a product where you risk losing your entire life savings because you typed a wrong word in a smart con
by Barrin92 5y ago
I'm gonna be honest I don't know what the audience is for a product where you risk losing your entire life savings because you typed a wrong word in a smart contract rather than paying a middleman a fraction of a percent.
It's almost like a sort of willful ignorance of division of labour and the concept of pooling risk.
- brianwawok 5y agoDoing illegal things, mostly. If you are working a w2 job and paying taxes and paying your mortgage / auto loan... crypto doesn't really help you. Blackmail? Awesome. Buying illegal substances? Awesome. Gambling? You got it...
- WanderPanda 5y agoYou said it, when you are a debtor fiat with its constant debasement is great. For creditors fiat doesn't work that well.
- UIGYUIUYG 5y agoYou can literally say that about cold hard cash. Blackmail? Pay cash. Buying illegal substances? Cash. Gambling? Get your cash out. It's all in how you use it. https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2021/05/moon-mission-paid-entirely-with-dogecoin-set-for-2022-launch-with-spacex/ https://eandt.theiet.org/content/articles/2021/05/moon-missi... Anything is a store of value, wood, gold, water, dogecoin ect. If people want to accept something for something else this is a way of life. It's just sad that people only see the bad use cases. How about if I transact only in crypto (Monolith card), now every purchase I make is via crypto, nothing different to using a bank card with US dollars backing it, just you have the full control over your own money.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoDo people who had SafeDollar have control over their own money? Did the people whose money got locked in the DAO because of a software bug have control over their own money? > How about if I transact only in crypto (Monolith card), now every purchase I make is via crypto Do you in fact do this? > nothing different to using a bank card with US dollars backing it There certainly is if you read Monolith's fine print, and it's wildly disingenuous to pretend otherwise: The Monolith account and Visa Debit Card are electronic money products which are not covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme or the Deposit Insurance System of the Republic of Lithuania. The funds will be safeguarded by Contis Financial Services Ltd or UAB „Finansinės paslaugos „Contis“. For any disputes, the Financial Ombudsman Service and the Bank of Lithuania consumers disputes resolutions institution are available.
- UIGYUIUYG 5y ago> Do people who had SafeDollar have control over their own money? Did the people whose money got locked in the DAO because of a software bug have control over their own money? Nope, because they didn't do their due diligence. Do you deposit your savings to a new bank that's not had a single audit done? Are there any specific banks that you won't do business with? It's the exact same in the crypto sphere. > Do you in fact do this? I do indeed. I use it as my daily spending card. Should Contis Financial Services Ltd collapse it'd be a bummer, but I've lost more on a night out by dropping a paper note. I will agree it's not like using a bank card, I should specify more like a pre-paid card. Whilst you don't get the financial protection that you do with standard institutions it's the price you have to pay to start working towards a different financial future.
- pavel_lishin 5y agoValid points, but the financial future crypto like this paints is not a future that seems better to me, not like a future I want to live in, or work toward.
- umanwizard 5y ago> Do you deposit your savings to a new bank that's not had a single audit done? Sure, because banks in my country are regulated, and deposits are insured, so I trust literally any bank.
- rednerrus 5y agoThe difference is you can't use dollars to do digital transactions. Good luck with sending a suitcase full of cash to SatoshiDice. Even better luck getting a suitcase back. The only value add for crypto right now is that it's pseudoanonymous and you can use it for black market transactions. Other than that why not just use Venmo or CashApp?
- andai 5y agoThis is one reason cash is being phased out in many countries. It took me most of a week to deposit money on my account -- the bank literally would not take my money! They told me to find a machine, and they were either out of order, removed, or did not take cash. Well, that's the noble explanation. Another consequence is they can now have an electronic record of every single purchase almost every citizen makes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ncann 5y ago> It's just sad that people only see the bad use cases Yeah, when 95%+ of the actual things that people use crypto for are those things, it's hard not to. Can you honestly say the "valid" uses for crypto take up more than 5% the total volume in any possible metric you can think of? It's always ransomware, extortion, blackmail, money laundering, drugs, you name it.
- admiral33 5y agoDo you have a source for '95%+'? https://www.forbes.com/sites/haileylennon/2021/01/19/the-false-narrative-of-bitcoins-role-in-illicit-activity/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/haileylennon/2021/01/19/the-fal... https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/24/overall-bitcoin-related-crime-fell-last-year-but-one-type-of-crypto-hack-is-booming.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/01/24/overall-bitcoin-related-crim...
- UIGYUIUYG 5y agoOne I personally know of - https://cryptoslate.com/another-big-cardano-ada-deal-is-in-the-works-in-africa/ https://cryptoslate.com/another-big-cardano-ada-deal-is-in-t... There is many other cases for blockchain / crypto technologies far beyond the world of ransomware, extortion, blackmail, money laundering. > The country will implement a national, blockchain-based student and teacher ID and attainment recording system to digitally verify grades, remotely monitor school performance and boost education and employment nationwide. > IOHK’s Atala PRISM identity solution will enable authorities to create tamper-proof records of educational performance across 3,500 schools, 5 million students, and 750,000 teachers to pinpoint the locations and causes of educational under-achievement and allocate educational resources effectively. You've got Walmarts chinese subsidy investing in vechain for logistics: https://cointelegraph.com/news/walmart-china-subsidiary-teams-up-with-vechain-to-trace-food-products https://cointelegraph.com/news/walmart-china-subsidiary-team... These are just two off the top of my head, let alone all the partnerships in the works that we haven't heard about yet. There's big money getting into crypto whilst simultaniously lots of news and opinions regarding the fact it's used for nefarious acts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brianwawok 5y agoTotally true. That said, to deposit 10k of cash in a bank you need to fill out some forms. I also don't have a great way to send you say 100k in cash. Suitcase full of dollars? But I can send you 2 BTC much easier. The big hole in demanding giant ransoms was always taking delivery of the suitcase full of money. Not so hard to do with digital currency.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- darepublic 5y ago> Gambling? You got it... I had high hopes for betsofbitcoin but after making a bet on the 2014(?) superbowl the mtgox scandal occurred and my last bet was never redeemed.
- swiley 5y agoOr just small experimental things. I can pay for jmp.chat with bitcoin, the dev doesn't have to deal with paypal and I don't have to worry about my credit card being stollen.
- slg 5y agoTo be fair illegal is not the same as immoral. For example, cryptocurrencies can also be used to transfer money out of financial system controlled by oppressive regime which is largely a positive use. The problem is that "oppressive regime" is a matter of opinion and therefore these transfers are indistinguishable from tax evasion and other financial crimes. Techno-libertarians see that as a feature, I think most of the rest of us see that as a bug. There is no economic or technical solution there. It is almost exclusively an issue of personal politics.
- brianwawok 5y agoRight, I am not passing judgement. I am not saying gambling in certain ways is immoral, but I am saying that it is illegal and thus bitcoin is often used to try and stay hidden.
- rawtxapp 5y ago> If you are working a w2 job and paying taxes and paying your mortgage / auto loan... You forgot to add "and live in a stable country with a stable currency and relatively functional contract/justice system".
- r3trohack3r 5y agoI’m making an assumption here that “crypto” means “crypto coin” and, perhaps further, any form of blockchain based, consensus maintained, public ledger. I don’t understand this “crypto is good for doing crime” narrative. When I’m doing crime, I strongly prefer there to be no record of the transaction. The closer I can get to an assurance there is no permanent record of the transaction, the safer I feel in deviating from the law. Conducting any illegal business in a permanent public ledger is a non-starter for me. Even with a public ledger that ”guarantees” privacy, I’m staking my freedom on the underlying cryptography not being broken before the statute of limitations for my crime passes. I’d go as far as reversing this narrative. Crime moving to a permanent public ledger strikes me as any regulating body’s dream.
- woodruffw 5y ago> When I’m doing crime, I strongly prefer there to be no record of the transaction. The closer I can get to an assurance there is no permanent record of the transaction, the safer I feel in deviating from the law. You're exactly right about this, which is why it's important to remember that a plurality (majority?) of those who speculate in cryptocurrencies don't seem to be especially aware of the whole "immutable, irrefutable public ledger" aspect.
- roflc0ptic 5y agoThose considerations notwithstanding, people are actually using crypto for criminal behavior. However great your arguments are against it, the reality is that it's happening. Reasons it might be happening: You can say they're being shortsighted and taking on unnecessary risk, but then, people who make criminal livings tend to have a higher appetite for risk than e.g. I do.
- mox1 5y agoThe thing about Bitcoin right now is that it is being used for good AND nefarious purposes. So you get some level of "hiding in the noise". Add in the ability to move it around the world easily, its liquidity and transaction volume and you have just about the perfect grey / black activity currency.
- ipython 5y ago
- humbleMouse 5y agoWhy would any of those things be better bought with crypto? If anything, better to buy all of those things with fiat cash, no? Why would you want a permanent record recorded every time you buy something? (Crypto)
- ognarb 5y agoThe only audience are people who don't know about that or have more to win than to loose.
- bopbeepboop 5y agoOne interpretation would be that they view the risk of poor transactions as less than the misdeeds of the current system. Eg, fiduciaries who structure transactions to reap fees, like Bank of America, or places like Comcast who routinely mischarge. I’d be curious to see a study on bank fee abuses or rental scams and how much the public loses each year to racketeering by entrenched players.
- olah_1 5y ago> rather than paying a middleman a fraction of a percent. Having a middle man doesn’t ensure safety. It just means that you have someone to blame if it all goes wrong. And even if you blame them, they most likely won’t see any negative repercussions anyway.
- LudwigNagasena 5y agoThe audience is the people who don’t want to deal with the government for whatever reasons, the most obvious one is doing something illegal like buying drugs or costly like sending money overseas in developing countries.
- teawrecks 5y agoFirst world citizens like to complain about how little they trust their govts, but I find it very telling when those same citizens can only see crypto as a benefit to nefarious actors. It's like complaining about Facebook and continuing to use Instagram.
- imtringued 5y agoI think it is because we are allowed to complain in the first place. Free speech is free (monetarily and legally).
- ljm 5y agoOr where you do the equivalent of stuffing cash under your mattress by hiding the password to your cryptowallet inside a safe, or using one of the various incantations of writing your password on a post-it note. Sure, the vast potential of reward justifies the added risk. But I'm also not in the US, I'm not rabidly anti-government, and I don't want to store my money under my floorboards. Good, old-fashioned, regulated banks serve a valuable purpose.
- UIGYUIUYG 5y ago> by hiding the password to your cryptowallet inside a safe, or using one of the various incantations of writing your password on a post-it note. This is the scariest bit about crypto by far and that I will not deny. This is why whilst I don't trust banks, they do have big safes with locked boxes in. Using these with shamir backups is what protects my assets, and worst case scenario my private key is also split in two and engraved in two seperate countries. If it's ever at the point where I can't access any of these, there's bigger shit going on in the world.
- ljm 5y agoIt's also why I think crypto is suffering a bit of the Dunning-Kruger syndrome. We've had well over 2000 years of banking and it's always the case that protecting your money then becomes a legit business-case. The business plan is ages-old and always the same: take the money under protection, ensure a certain percentage in reserve, and profit off the venture by using a percentage of funds for investment and speculation. Just, not so much that you can't pay people back. The latter point is a stickler, so get regulation in there and ensure anyone doing banking is protected up to a certain sum. Any money beyond that... you put all your eggs in one basket, sorry. Other people need to be made whole, too. Use the same regulation so that banks that embezzle protected customer funds can be prosecuted, too. This equally applies to insurance, credit cards, loans, and other industries that make money out of offering money. You can't stop a run on the bank if everyone loses confidence at the same time, as we saw in 2008 (Northern Rock in the UK) or in 1929 (Wall Street). But as you say... that's when bigger shit is going on. But now... to me crypto feels like a group of upstarts thinking they can reinvent millennia of economics and come up with something better. All I've seen so far is a skeuomorphism to a scarce resource, essentially treating silicon as if it were gold. It's making a handful of people filthy rich, people who would have been well-off in the first place, but it's not changing the world for the better. It's siphoning another resource for a wealthy elite.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- grape-eater 5y agoLong term people are going to flock to DeFi services that have centralized discretion to compensate victims of exploit. One way to do this is to have a token that people can lock up and vote for/against a bailout.
- rchaud 5y ago> I'm gonna be honest I don't know what the audience is for a product where you risk losing your entire life savings because you typed a wrong word in a smart contract. Some of crypto's loudest voices are young, college-aged people who've recently read Atlas Shrugged or Catcher in the Rye and are certain that they will never be the ones to lose their keys.
- jk7tarYZAQNpTQa 5y agoAs of today, the audience is "people trying to get rich fast".