18 ms·
Google no longer requires AMP, but the replacement might be worse
- BigBalli 5y ago"some arbitrary set of performance standards"? Less than 3s load time, reasonable DOM size, and low FID are all widely accepted as a "good UX". Just another veiled article criticizing Google's dominance rather than a technical one.
- Spivak 5y agoLook, you're right that this is essentially Google making everyone eat their vegetables but isn't it a little wild that this single company has so much control over the internet that they can basically make sweeping decrees like this?
- rchaud 5y agoNo, I don't think so. There are hundreds if not thousands of unique domains for nearly every single query. Very few of those are providing first-hand, unique information. Take Apple product announcements; there are hundreds of high-traffic blogs basically creating identical content rehashing a press release or writing posts about newly announced products. There has to be a way of prioritizing some of these sites over others. Same goes for sports, celebrity/gossip, news, etc. That would be most of the open web right there. Google also moved to mobile-first indexing some years ago. Was that unfair to mom-and-pop shops that didn't have a responsively designed site? Perhaps, but if the website is something that brings you business, it's a tool that should be sharpened when dull, and replaced when its rusty.
- pradn 5y agoYou're absolutely right that UX should have precedence for equal info. There's a reason why I like going to the slickly-made Verge instead of every other site for routine news like what was announced at a particular company's event. That, and I like their short summary videos.
- rchaud 5y agoI like their summary videos as well. Unfortunately I'm less of a fan of the website. The design is messy; they're trying to do the "website as magazine" style, but they're dependent on Google Ads so the experience feels disjointed.
- pradn 5y agoI can see that. It's still a far cry from a website with interstitials and auto-playing video, but perhaps I'm setting the bar too low by comparing to like CNN.
- raxxorrax 5y ago> There has to be a way of prioritizing some of these sites over others. Those that display fewer ads and trackers? Many people would like that but somebody would really not.
- rchaud 5y agoYou will need to use millionshort.com or a similar niche-based search engine for that. Otherwise, it is the equivalent of asking Apple to let you filter out apps that use Facebook SDK; completely futile. The overwhelming majority of websites being created today include some kind of tracker, even if it's a single analytics script. And knowing the HN audience, that's still one tracker too many.
- raxxorrax 5y agoYes, it is, especially if a user doesn't want to be tracked. Flag the website as malicious and the problem would go away quickly. It doesn't serve any purpose anyway. Companies as advertising consumers just want to be on equal footing.
- wpietri 5y agoI think that's a fair point. I'd love to see more of this done in coalition. Google doing solo not only can bend the web toward Google's corporate interests, but it undermines the growth of other social structures (e.g., citizen movements, nonprofit advocacy groups, regulators, governments) to solve problems like this.
- tomjen3 5y ago3s load time is crazy high. You need to get below 0.1 second before it feels instant, which would be a huge upgrade compared to most websites (it should still feel instant if you load the ads after that, just so long that you don't change the layout on the page at all). I have a gigabit connection, so it is not a question about not downloading fast enough, I can browse wikipedia this way. It is a matter of not using so much javascript.
- DamonHD 5y agoYes, I was prompted to plan turning off AMP for next month, even given CWV weirdness in GSC... http://www.earth.org.uk/note-on-site-technicals-49.html#2021-06-28 http://www.earth.org.uk/note-on-site-technicals-49.html#2021...
- cunthorpe 5y agoSo the problem is that “Google is in charge.” Sorry but I don’t think that’s “worse” than AMP at all. Google was in charge of that and it hijacked URLs. Clickbait.
- blacktriangle 5y agoIt's not just Google, it doesn't matter if the company in change is all sunshine and rainbows today, who knows what they will do tomorrow (looking at you freenode). Centralized level of control like this is anathama to the whole future of the web.
- Spivak 5y agoI feel like you picked a bad example because while Freenode is a centralized service the community immediately routed around the crazy in the span of like two weeks. Centralization isn't really that big of a problem in practice, it's lock-in.
- swiley 5y agoThe replacement they're whining about is "core web vitals" IE the metric you can view at[1]. This is what AMP should have been in the beginning and I was surprised they did something else, it made Google search unusable on mobile. [1] https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9205520?hl=en https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/9205520?hl=en This means that your hand-coded-in-vim static pages will rank near the top.
- jeffbee 5y agoThat’s an extreme claim that requires some backing evidence. Mobile search quality is the main metric google uses to judge its search products. The idea that google search is “unusable on mobile” is pretty silly, if you’re literally the only person who ever noticed.
- swiley 5y agoYou probably did what I did and mostly missed what was happening the past couple years by using duckduckgo the whole time. I formatted my phone at some point last year and the search engine reverted to google, it really was unusable but not something people who wouldn't know better would get too upset about.
- swiley 5y ago(by last year I mean 2019.)
- nonbirithm 5y agoI also don't understand why more people aren't making a firestorm over how user-hostile Google search is at times. They don't even follow their own rules. The "People also searched for" popup causes layout shifts nearly every time you go back to the search page. It's infuriating. I know this is only orthogonal to AMP, but it sounds like the kind of thing Core Web Vitals was meant to disincentivize.
- closetohome 5y ago
- partiallypro 5y agoI find "Web Core Vital" to be fairly useless (outside of trying appease Google.) I can make a page load slower and feel worse for anyone visiting the site...and the "Core Vitals" score will increase. So, how is this about the user experience? You can inline all of your CSS to increase your score, but what about users that visit more than one page? Now they have larger payloads per page. Then at that point what is the point of rewarding all inlining, but then throwing a fit about not using a CDN with a long caching parameter? It's not consistent. Why not just use overall page size and ttfb instead of this nonsensical metric that isn't a great measurement, in my experience, of website performance/user experience; outside of keeping everyone guessing what Google might do next, what's the point? I also find it extremely ironic that many of Google's own products are complete failures on the metric. I've even found that you can trick the metric by essentially loading a blank page where a browser will feel the page is fully loaded, then having a delay that loads the page.
- nextaccountic 5y ago> I can make a page load slower and feel worse for anyone visiting the site...and the "Core Vitals" score will increase But there's a metric specifically for measuring load times. https://web.dev/lcp/ https://web.dev/lcp/
- tyingq 5y agoI vehemently disagree that "Core Web Vitals" would be worse. I'm as wary of Google as the author, but Google's page performance tools have a reasonably good history of staying in their lane of just measuring performance. Having "page performance" as a non-trivial weighted factor in how pages are ranked just makes sense to me. Even if CWV is somewhat flawed, I'd much rather optimize for that than give control of my pages to Google ala AMP.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- judge2020 5y agoIn case you're trying to find what the replacement is: > Unfortunately, there are problems with AMP's replacement as well. And those problems go right back to what was wrong with AMP in the first place: Google is in charge of it. So the problem isn't core web vitals nor AMP itself, but the fact that everyone uses Google and they control the results on google.com. We can now go back to our regularly scheduled discussion about how this is bad.
- ehsankia 5y agoThe article is also surprised that people are still using AMP now that it's no longer required, because in the author's mind, AMP is so god dang awful that when given the chance, everyone would immediately want to get rid of it. Some people are so deeply lost in their hatred of AMP that they cannot even consider for a moment that maybe, just maybe, AMP actually does work well for some people. I'm glad it's no longer required, and if people are correct that AMP truly sucks, then surely it'll slowly fade away over time.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoMy opinion is regularly "unpopular" here on HN, but I happen to love AMP. Sometimes constraints can be a blessing. Don't want to over engineer? Use AMP. Of course you can over engineer anything, but why would you when [almost] everything you need is easy to grab a la carte.
- corty 5y agoI would like to introduce my set of constraints called "cortyNet": - no JavaScript - you get 100kB for HTML and CSS - all decorative and non-essential images are included in those 100kB Happy hacking!
- tssva 5y agoI'm not a web developer but as a user I love AMP. For whatever issues it has it did significantly help mobile performance. Could developers have solved that issue with AMP? Yes Did developers solve the issue prior to AMP forcing them to? No.
- eli 5y agoHere's a better criticism: the Core Vitals metrics that affect SEO rank on Google are sourced only from Chrome browsers. So an even more disproportionate amount of site performance work will now be focused just on what makes Chrome happy. Experimental Chrome features that boost performance metrics will be embraced in the name of SEO. Safari and Firefox can't offer that. It's another way Google uses their control of the search market to cement their browser as the de facto standard.
- dannyw 5y agoI hope the EU competition authority gets Google to change this. At least inside the EU.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoI hope not. Regional based internet could become the next major factor when it comes to inequality. For example, don't hire people from Region A because they can't access the best resources located in Region B.
- wyager 5y agoThis is the future the EU chose when they started imposing EU law on foreign internet companies.
- lwhi 5y agoNo. This the future foreign internet companies chose when they put profits above all else.
- elliekelly 5y agoForeign internet companies aren’t obligated to operate in the EU. If they don’t like the rules they can choose not to participate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 5y agoI've decided that while Google ostensibility makes it possible to search the world's knowledge*, that's just the bait. Google's main product is selling ads in what amounts to a glorified yellow pages. *In reality, about 1% of human knowledge, by some estimates.
- tomjen3 5y agoYou make it sound like searching 1% of human knowledge is not a fucking big deal. The Harry Potter books created an awesome series of magic, with instant teleportation, flying objects and invisibility coats. Yet they had nothing comparable to Google, which would have destroyed the plots to at least 3 books since the answers could have been found trivially that way.
- cratermoon 5y agoIt's not that 1% isn't astounding, it's that choices, human and automated that go into deciding which 1% is cataloged. Are the Harry Potter books really more valuable than 99% over everything else humans know? Or does Google simply provide a catalog of the things that can be pressed into service to generate revenue, either for themselves or their ad-buying customers?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jakelazaroff 5y ago> The logic behind AMP goes like this: web developers suck at making fast websites, let's strip out all the stuff people don't need and cache it on our super-fast servers. Web developers don't suck at making fast websites. Publishers demand tons of ads and tracking scripts. If the person signing the paychecks wants the page to have 15MB of sketchy third-party JS, then the page will have 15MB of sketchy third-party JS. AMP succeeded because Google brandished a stick that publishers cared about more: exclusion from the Top News carousel. I'd also note that the whole reason this ad tech explosion even happened is a race to the bottom that Google itself facilitated. Google is selling us solutions to a problem that Google had a huge hand in causing.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoYou just have to browse the AMP pages on Google Assistant to see how easily they can be devolved into slow dumpster fires despite the rules to maintain speed.
- wutwutwutwut 5y ago> If the person signing the paychecks wants the page to have 15MB of sketchy third-party JS, then the page will have 15MB of sketchy third-party JS. I was asked by management to add Google Tag Manager to the company site. When I saw that GTM included 15-20 tracking scripts I told them that unfortunately we can't include it until we have ensured that all of them act in accordance with GDPR. Legal was involved and agreed. Marketing gave up. You're technically correct, but people who write pay checks often can be argued with. They often don't want to be on record taking decisions which can cause issues, and legal typically don't want to sign of on including 15MB unknown scripts on your site accepting credit cards.
- jakelazaroff 5y ago> You're technically correct, but people who write pay checks often can be argued with. That's true, but the proliferation of ad tech junk is strong evidence that this is the exception rather than the rule. Capital will persuade labor to do its bidding far more often than not.
- justinph 5y agoFun think about core web vitals and amp: AMP pages will _always_ win core web vitals, because they're measured from google's CDN, where they can be pre-rendered. Unless the page is motherfuckingwebsite.com, the AMP version is going to score better in every metric than a non-AMP version. Core Web Vitals just cements AMP as a shortcut to performance.
- SquareWheel 5y agoThat seems pretty unlikely. Do you have any information that backs this up?
- justinph 5y agoYes. Years of experience with AMP and measuring website performance on a very high traffic website.
- SquareWheel 5y agoHave you directly compared the live version against that in the AMP Cache? The idea that PSI preloads the page before starting the test doesn't make much sense at all, and doesn't mesh with my own experiences (in the same space).
- topicseed 5y agoAMP was great for those with very low speed internet. The philosophy and implementation of AMP can be questioned (URL masking, content stored away from the origin) but it did show that users really wanted to click on pages that loaded fast. Core Web Vitals, as a publisher myself, are a nightmare. But at least we know what goes wrong as it's clearly laid right in front of the developer's eyes. So we go and fix thing after thing. And some pages just won't get fixed because of some ads. The point is CWV do make the web better. Those vital metrics are actually making sense (CLS, LCP). I understand the reticence and reserve at who is behind both these efforts that AMP and CWV are, but they forced me to make my websites faster, cleaner. Was it a panicky few months trying to get this sorted? Yes. Did we have to speak to ad networks so they fix up some ad delivery? Yes. Will Google really rank us better thanks to that? Maybe. Couldn't we have done it from our own accord? The incentive wasn't big enough I guess. But today, the fact is, the experience on all of our websites is very much clearly improved.
- rozab 5y ago>it did show that users really wanted to click on pages that loaded fast. How? No user has ever chosen to open a link as AMP.
- topicseed 5y agoWell, my click-through rates on mobile for many of the same pages without AMP have dropped for the same position. Yes, after fixing CWV I removed AMP as keeping two layouts optimised was draining as a small publisher.
- fddddd 5y agoadblockers like uBlocker Origin was even better for low speed internet than amp.
- topicseed 5y agoWell, I do appreciate my ad revenue to pay my team members and myself so I won't be the one recommending that.
- djtriptych 5y agoI've been working on core web vitals for the better part of a year at a major news outlet. I have seriously mixed feelings. There's probably an hour-long talk about this in me but briefly: - It's really nice and maybe unprecedented to have an alignment of business, user, eng, and seo goals. Google is using it's monopoly to change roadmap priorities across the industry. The web vitals themselves are unquestionably good for the user. - Google's guidance on how the scores work and when changes will be incorporated into rankings / carousel eligibility has been overall poor. The info is out there but changes constantly and comes from myriad sources. - Similarly, the way these scores are measured are a bit of a secret sauce. It's impossible really to model user behavior / devices in a way that ensures you will hit your performance targets. Google provides a lot of tooling/instrumentation, but the measurements sometimes conflict with one another. I could go on. I'm the mst senior FE guy at this company and it's really consumed most of my work hours since last June, but that's kinda par for the course in publishing. Google swings it's weight around and publishers react.
- dang 5y agoIf you want to write something about your experience with this, I'm sure the community here would appreciate a fact-based third-party article. If you wrote it in the same style as your comment here, we would put such an article in the second-chance pool (https://news.ycombinator.com/pool https://news.ycombinator.com/pool, explained at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26998308), so it would get a random placement on HN's front page. Email me at hn@ycombinator.com if you'd like some tips about that.
- djtriptych 5y agoThanks! I'll run it by stakeholders internally and see if I can de-anonymize :)
- eli 5y agoGetting wildly different numbers from different tools is super annoying but I'm pretty sure the data they'll actually use in rankings is crowdsourced from Chrome users: https://web.dev/chrome-ux-report/ https://web.dev/chrome-ux-report/ Which of course you can only see weeks in retrospect.
- logicalmonster 5y agoI hate this idea that the technology needs to be dictated by Google. If it's displayable in a web browser, that's all that should matter to a good search engine. Just change the algorithm to reward fast websites even more. If page speed currently counts for say 5% of a site's value in the algorithm, bump it up to 10%, 15%, 25% etc, whatever it takes until sites that pump in piles of garbage JS trackers and monstrosities start removing that stuff. Sites that insist on leaving in garbage trackers and bloated designs will not show up as much. Problem solved without dictating technology.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gentleman11 5y agoSearch.brave.com is surprisingly good, at least for me so far. I haven’t had to use google in the last week for anything, my results have been on par
- asadkn 5y agoIt's funny that Google says they care about performance, yet the number one reason for bad performance on many site is Google Adsense ads. Did no one in Ads team get the memo to optimize performance?
- perryizgr8 5y ago> Did no one in Ads team get the memo to optimize performance? They were too busy raking in the billions.
- celestialcheese 5y ago100% this. Maybe I've missed something in their documentation, but it's been incredibly frustrating getting their ads to not kill performance
- walshemj 5y agoNope its not the major issue
- HWR_14 5y agoIt makes sense. People only tolerate so bad a performance overall. The faster the rest of the page, the more room is left for Google AdSense.
- al2o3cr 5y agoThe power of the web lies in its decentralisation, it lies with its messiness, it lies with its edge nodes – that is, with you and me. The only reason I've ever seen a news site take more than 2.5s to load was when it was stuffed to the gills with adtech and trackers; caping for them is literally the _opposite_ of "the spirit of the web".
- vehiclesuggest 5y agoLol! Just setup and optimized AMP on our website and now I am hearing this news.
- captn3m0 5y agoMaybe browsers should accept the text/markdown mimetype natively, instead of AMP. Covers 80% of the usecases, with a drastic reduction in complexity and pageload times.
- tomjen3 5y agoWhich Markdown though? Common mark, Gitlab, etc? Do we get any extensions? I like tables. HTML is not bad and it is easier to parse than markdown, the trouble is javascript and the ways ads abuse them. Strip that out, set the size of images and you can create a better experience for your users without changing all browsers. However if we can get wild requests for new content types, then I would love text/latex, so that I could create a website that fits the real size of your browser and render a gorgeous output.
- captn3m0 5y agoAccept headers can negotiate extensions I suppose, but browsers can decide what they’d like to support, same as the rest of HTML standards. In the last decade, I’ve seen browsers drop content types (FTP) and adopt media formats (WebP). But no new publication formats. If my browser can render PDF, why shouldn’t it render Markdown?
- bingidingi 5y agoFast pages are good for the web generally, but Google treats the entire internet like pages of search results and this can punish some people who aren’t building search results. There are lots and lots of good experiences on the web that are optimized for multiple page views because they’re communities, educational, or some other kind of application - they’re designed for people who stick around. I worry that if core vitals becomes too strong of a signal it will over homogenize things to the point that we’re further ostracizing parts of the web that aren’t built like fast results pages to get an answer and bounce off of. We need more differing alternatives to Google.
- willio58 5y agoIs there anything official from Google saying Amp is no longer affecting mobile search result rankings? I haven't been able to find anything.
- abraham 5y ago> As part of this update, we'll also incorporate the page experience metrics into our ranking criteria for the Top Stories feature in Search on mobile, and remove the AMP requirement from Top Stories eligibility. https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2020/11/timing-for-page-experience https://developers.google.com/search/blog/2020/11/timing-for...