12 ms·
The Broken Promise of Retirement
- sonograph 5y agoOff topic: Is it normal for NYBooks to publish things early? Shows as July 1, 2021
- sonofhans 5y agoMagazine dates are typically the date the issue is removed from shelves, not the date it first appears. So they likely synchronize with the actual date of print availability.
- ElViajero 5y ago> July 1, 2021 issue I guess that they published the July issue some days early. I guess that if the month issue is already finished, it makes sense to publish it. Here you can see the mail-date cover-date relationship for the physical publication: https://www.nybooks.com/publication-schedule/ https://www.nybooks.com/publication-schedule/ The magazine with cover date "July 1, 2021" is mailed on "June 8, 2021"
- chrisseaton 5y agoMagazine issue dates are usually for the month they are on sale, so realistically a month ahead of when you'd buy it if you're buying it as it comes out.
- greyface- 5y agohttps://archive.is/B7Mgq https://archive.is/B7Mgq
- Etheryte 5y agoI'm not up to date with the nuance of the US pension system, but this article seems highly loaded: > For decades, conservative governors and state legislators [...] have worked to undermine public employee pensions. > Last year, as the Covid-19 pandemic raged, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell denied governors’ appeals for federal emergency aid because he saw an opportunity to punish states for their pension debts. And so forth. Granted, I don't know the history behind all of this, but even with the benefit of the doubt these seem very stark takes without any additional context.
- _red 5y agoNot only that, but undoubtedly they also support the modern neo-liberal Globalist system....so they want to offshore all jobs to slave factories in China, allow millions of 'undocumented' workers to depress salaries, AND bemoan that we can't have multi-decade retirement systems fully funded. Its astounding how the democrats have gone along with these ideas for so long...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jmclnx 5y agoIn the US there is a "fund" that is suppose to be paid into by Private Companies, Unions and others that is like a Pension Insurance. That fund is Extremely underfunded. If your Company goes bust or the Union implodes, last I heard (many years ago), that fund could only cover a bit less than 50% of your benefits, so you will get a massive cut. Also in the past, if you worked for the Federal or State Gov, you did not get Social Security because you paid into a pension. I do not know if that is still true. But the Federal Gov through cuts (we all know who pushed those cuts) and Union Busting, is causing the whole pension system to go bust since pensions work only if the Company or Union is growing and people are there to pay into it. Now that union membership is optional in many states, money is not flowing into the fund.
- bradleyjg 5y ago> since pensions work only if the Company or Union is growing There’s a name for a scheme like this—-pyramid.
- tolidano 5y agoWell, that’s a pretty interesting connection. If you look here, besides one or two states, every state is much much larger than it was 70, 60, 50, 40, 30, and 20 years ago. So, it’s not shocking or absurd to imagine state populations continuing an upward trend and therefore, more people, and therefore, without anyone passing union busting or other anti-union laws and regulations, you would expect union membership in most sectors to grow and have plenty of data to back it up. This isn’t like Mary Kay or Noni Juice or whatever where you have to sell someone on the promise very hard or demand some upfront investment to pay the current membership. Just wait around and people will be born. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territories_by_historical_population https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_terr...
- themodelplumber 5y ago> 80 percent of the tax benefits go to the top 20 percent of taxpayers. I hope someday we can all see why this is both amazing and ridiculous... > In Rescuing Retirement, Ghilarducci and James promote what they call a “Guaranteed Retirement Account” (GRA), a system of federal retirement savings accounts that would combine features of defined benefit and defined contribution plans. Nice to see a proposal in the article. > GRAs would be professionally invested and would, Ghilarducci and James argue, generate greater returns than existing 401(k)s by taking advantage of access to the more profitable investments and lower fees that large pools of assets can offer. The accounts would follow workers throughout their careers, even if they changed employers. When the time came, the GRA would be transformed into an annuity, which, alongside Social Security, would pay out a consistent and lifelong income. I don't know anything about 401(k)s but do they really operate on some foundational condition of less-profitable investments and higher fees?
- tclancy 5y agoI am guessing the last part means on average. As a sole investor, the fees on any fund will always be higher than what is available to an institutional investor. And this would make quite a big institutional investor.
- namdnay 5y agoI don’t see what investment is more profitable and lower fee than a bog standard vanguard ETF
- themodelplumber 5y agoVanguard ETF recommendations, the last-ditch concealed weapon of every contingency-focused investor in online discourse for like the last 20 years. :-) Funny to see that here.
- jimhefferon 5y agoYou need the money to be there in forty years. What happens if, say, US stocks did in that time what Japanese stocks did in the past decades, and you bet wrong? Asking average people to be good at finance is potentially a big ask.
- MarkusWandel 5y agoIs it really as political as that as in "the big bad republicans ate my pension"? Juicy pensions are on the decline everywhere. The company I started working for at age 23, so many years ago, in all its vertically integrated, multinational glory, provided, at the time, pensions you really could continue living a middle class lifestyle on. I duly got into that pension plan, with the huge pension adjustments that entailed (greatly reduced ability to pay into your RRSP) but that future defined benefit pension was worth it. Except that $bigco went bust, and when the dust settled, we got cash payout of the some percentage of the deemed value of the accrued pension that they could recover from the financial wreckage, and that was that. No pension at all. Now I and everyone else is just on defined contribution plans, where between your own and the company's contribution you put in maybe 10% of what it would take to live on, per year. The rest is supposed to miraculously come from compound gains, using the old wisdom that anyone can get 10% per year without effort. What does that mean in real life terms? Live cheap, far below your financial means - one basic car instead of his & hers SUVs, a basic house in a decent neighbourhood instead of the latest 5K square feet monstrosity and so on, and try to save a good 1/3 of your income for the future. Barring a financial meltdown or runaway inflation, I think we'll make it. The fact that "runaway healthcare costs" are not a factor here helps a lot, though without a company plan, you're on your own for all dental work and (up to a certain age) all prescription drug costs. Anyway the economics is simply this: Work for 40-45 years and accrue enough to live another average 25 years after you retire. The $$ have to come from somehwere. You see a lot about super juicy public sector pensions in the USA where people can retire in luxury before age 50... probably outliers, as is the "evil people stole the pension fund" situations. On the whole, it's just that people live longer.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoThe US workforce (at the time) was sold on 401ks as a replacement for pensions, when they’re really for only the highest compensation earners as a tax dodge [1]. Predictably, very few made enough to contribute to a 401k in a manner that would replace the safety of pensions, and now large cohorts nearing retirement are left with little while shareholders captured profits that previously contributed towards funding pensions. Tada! [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21827154 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21827154
- drdec 5y agoGiven that the current government bailed out private pension plans to the tune of $86 billion dollars as part of the latest COVID-19 relief bill [1], I am not concerned that they will soon tackle the government pension funds which have also have shortfalls. According to the article, the private pension bailout was "paid for" by ending the enhanced unemployment program in August instead of September. Of course, you don't pay for new spending by "cutting" other new spending. [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ebauer/2021/03/10/the-covid-relief-multiemployer-pension-bailout-is-completenow-what/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/ebauer/2021/03/10/the-covid-rel...
- bradleyjg 5y agoNote that the bailout came with absolutely no strings attached. Apparently nothing went wrong that caused an $86 billion shortfall so no changes need to be made going forward.
- tolidano 5y agoNow do college tuitions, bank bailouts, auto bailouts, solar subsidies, oil subsidies, farm subsidies, and all the other nearly countless ways that the government plays around with your tax dollars to put the money into the pockets the current administration and Congress decided was the most important.
- bradleyjg 5y agoAfter the bank bailouts they passed Dodd-Frank. We could discuss whether it was adequate but at least it was something.
- bradleyjg 5y agoEveryone wants a bailout. The multiemployer pensions got one in the third Great Covid Helicopter Drop. But what confidence do we have that we won’t be exactly in the same spot a couple of decades? Mayor Kilpatrick signed a terrible deal and separately (?) was corrupt and went to prison. Have the voters learned anything? Have their voting patterns notably changed since then? What about the union representatives elected by the Detroit municipal workers? Don’t they bear some culpability? Have there been a seismic shift there, or are the same old cronies still passing off power one to another?
- wcunning 5y agoOn the same vein -- look at how many Big Three UAW senior people have been indicted on corruption charges just in the last 5 years... I haven't kept up with all of it but the number is at least in the tens from Chrysler UAW alone.
- ArkanExplorer 5y agoProviding retirees with cash, which they then use to independently procure good and services across millions of individuals, is fundamentally inefficient. Instead, we should treat each retiree as a ward of the state, and provide them with Government housing, cell phone and plan, food (cooked or ingredients), and a limited amount of electricity/water - plus a small stipend for private purchases. The other fault of the current system is that we link retirement to age - instead, it should be linked to health: if you can continue working, you should be expected to do so. With the savings, we can eliminate regressive taxes like sales taxes (or just enable the currently totally unsustainable system to keep functioning.)
- chrisseaton 5y agoI don't think many people in the US look forward to spending their last years with 'a limited amount of electricity/water'.
- gruez 5y agoCan't you replace "retiree" with citizen/employee and use the same argument to advocate for a planned economy and/or company towns? ie. "Providing citizens with cash, which they then use to independently procure good and services across millions of individuals, is fundamentally inefficient. Instead, we should treat each citizen as a ward of the state, and provide them with Government housing, cell phone and plan, food (cooked or ingredients), and a limited amount of electricity/water - plus a small stipend for private purchases."
- tuxinator 5y agoIf you can continue working you should be expected to do so? That sounds dystopian honestly.... that's not the future we should be striving to build.
- seattle_spring 5y ago> The other fault of the current system is that we link retirement to age - instead, it should be linked to health: if you can continue working, you should be expected to do so. Please no. People should not have to work until they cannot work anymore. Our incredibly flawed system of today is still miles ahead of your proposal.
- birdyrooster 5y agoI’m so tired of hearing about the “middle class” because it excludes a huge amount of people that actually make this world work while pretending to be inclusive. It’s super gross.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> I’m so tired of hearing about the “middle class” Well then don't read articles about middle class concerns like retirement, in middle class publications like the New York Review of Books.
- xf1cf 5y agoRegardless of your feelings you're missing the point. The middle class is the bellwether of the economy. Though, I don't think you're truly interested in the economy at large. When middle class wages go up, small businesses open, they employ more people, creating more middle class people, and the cycle continues ad infinitum. The middle class pays the bulk of the taxes since they lack the finances to avoid them, and additionally is responsible for creating the bulk of the jobs in small business. The middle class also leads consumption. See the previous point for why this is important. If the middle class fails everything below them fails. The only people that win in all scenarios are the ultra wealthy. If the middle class cannot retire, effectively no one can retire. Since their suffering is magnified in the lower economic strata.
- birdyrooster 5y agoThe point of the middle class is to create a distinction from the bottom casted in America. The middle class is mostly white. The bottom cast is mostly ADOS or Mexican. This was by design.
- ed25519FUUU 5y ago> Pensions represent more than their economic value. They carry a powerful moral recognition: workers deserve financial stability and the freedom it brings throughout their lives. Municipal and state employees contribute to their pensions with every paycheck, and employer contributions supplement their savings. I don’t know how it came to be that politicians could promise impossible things to public employees in exchange for power, and when it turned out to indeed be impossible, somehow the taxpayer foots the bill. I’m under no obligation to carry forward an unsustainable promise. It should have never been promised in the first place. The taxpayer, who gets NONE of this, is not the one who should pay the bill.
- Spooky23 5y agoThe taxpayer benefits by paying tomorrow for a sandwich today. Government employees trade lower cash compensation for stability and more secure benefits. I’m sure you get upset when you read about some big company charging billions for some mismanaged project. That’s generally the alternative. You may not feel an obligation for your government to follow the law and responsibly manage its obligation to pay some 70 year old former librarian her modest pension. Hopefully your understanding about government not meeting obligations holds when you can’t get to work because a highway bridge is closed due to deferred maintenance, or your parents don’t get adequate care because your state health department fails to effectively regulate nursing facilities.
- mbg721 5y agoThose failures are all going to happen anyway, because the underlying promises were always unsustainable. The question is whether or not we're happy declaring today's 70-year-old public officials the winners and today's kids the losers.
- cortesoft 5y agoThe voters elected people who made that promise. Of course taxpayers are on the hook for promises made by politicians. The taxpayer DID get something for this. They got public employees who took less money up front in return for a good pension. This saved the taxpayers money in the short term. Under your argument, is the government not required to keep ANY promise? “The government should never have promised to pay back these treasury bills. Taxpayers don’t get anything from redeeming them, we shouldn’t pay off any of the government debt!”
- baybal2 5y agoUnfortunately, our generation of nineties, and later will have to work until our deathbed. That's the brutal truth.
- bradleyjg 5y agoYour generation has embraced FIRE in a way a lot fewer in mine ever did. Some people are clearly making it work. Others are taking out more student loans for their third masters degree because their other careers weren’t an authentic manifestation of their inner identities.
- nickd2001 5y agoFor some people, work almost until death might be OK, health permitting. Biden, Trump, Pope Francis (to give a politically balanced mixture ;) ) are all happily working hard well beyond retirement age. For an elderly couple with home paid off, if one still worked part-time in a decently paid job, they could be OK financially without much pension (with some caveats including healthcare costs particularly in US) . I guess, to protect ourselves in old age, we can try to maintain healthy habits, and try to manoeuvre our career to a place with decent part-time opportunities in old age, just as much as save money. This doesn't give any guarantee, but then, saving tons of money doesn't address non-treatable health problems, nothing is certain. I guess in a nutshell, my argument is (a) people might not as screwed financially as they fear, with a little imagination, health permitting (b) OTOH the bigger issue, much bigger than pensions, is healthcare costs and a lack of support for those who fall ill, which could actually happen at any time not just in old age
- papito 5y agoI really don't understand what people think when they choose to ignore retirement contributions. What do they think is going to happen when they get old? Seriously, what to they expect to happen? A Government man showing up at their doorstep with a fat suitcase filled with dollars? Also, IRA, SHMAYARAY. Max out your Roth every year, and then do whatever. I don't see how the taxes for the rest of us are going to go down with the aging population.
- xf1cf 5y agoYou're missing the point of the pension and social security. There are, and has always, been a large portion of society making "just enough". Maxing out your 401k requires 19,500 dollars of pre-tax income you can dump into an account you can't touch. A little less with a match. So do the math: Median income in 2019: $65,712. $19,500 is almost 30% of your pre-tax income. Not a whole lot left to save for a house, buy a (old, used) car, or any number of other things. I say pre-tax because the situation is even more bleak if you look at roth post-tax. After contributing to your 401k as above your remaining take home after taxes (assuming you do not pay state taxes) is $23635. So you max out your IRA at $6,000. Now you have $17,635 to live on. Almost nothing. Maybe in the 90s this would've worked but even in my low CoL town renting an apartment will still run you $1,100 for a single room 600 square foot shack. You could do it, but you would be living on ramen and beans towards the end of the year assuming there weren't any medical emergencies, car problems, or any number of other things that could effect you (rising food costs, gas prices, electrical costs in summer, etc). The purpose of a pension is that it provides a simple, easy, and guaranteed retirement plan for people in this situation. They can't afford to utilize their 401k for maximum benefit, and they can't afford to utilize an IRA to it's maximum benefit. 401ks were one of the greatest magic tricks ever pulled on Americans. While I agree they're great if you have the extra income, they do a lot of damage to the retirements of people who cannot afford them.
- gizmo686 5y agoRelying on pensions is not ignoring retirement. It is assuming that you will receive the benefit you were promised as part of your compensation. Not getting your promised pension is the same as your 401k balance being confiscated by your broker to cover for their own financial shortfall. The main difference is that the 401k is a much more transparent product, so this outright theft is not as possible. The flip side of that is that your exposure to the market is more direct (which may not be that much of a flipside, as pension funds are still exposed to the market, but that exposure is more obscured). > I don't see how the taxes for the rest of us are going to go down with the aging population. Who says taxes are going to go down? Reading the political winds, the grass roots support for raising taxes is the highest I have ever seen it, and seems to be growing. We are leaving the political era of low taxes independent of the actual fiscal need to raise them.
- supernova87a 5y agoI cannot get to the entire article (paywalled) -- but I will point out an issue I know is plaguing US municipal and state pensions. Aside from the permanent administrative staff, many funds are in the hands and political control of people generally wholly unqualified to understand and manage them, and who have at most their elected positions on the line if it goes badly. It's not their money, so what does it matter if they just apply expertise to the fund's management with all the part-time attention of a high schooler? The amount of rank amateurism in deciding the fate of many, many billions of dollars is incredible. Like less-than-Excel spreadsheet sophistication. Take a couple of general examples: -- Many state/local funds estimate or forecast some optimistic annual return % when they set the benefits level. Then they never revisit or adjust contributions to account for when the market returns fall. Or they do absolutely stupid things like increase benefits when a certain year looks better than average ("our hard working state employees deserve to participate in gains in the market, blah blah blah") -- They'll set labor contracts with no eye towards what the promised benefits will cost 25 years from now. Who cares? The elected officials now won't be around when the bill comes due, and the incentives to not get tossed out of office for being responsible and clamping down on the expensive party are much more real than paying a few dollars more decades from now. -- My favorite example: under years of mismanagement of rank amateurs (as I named above), Detroit discovered that its pension fund had been habitually paying out "13th paychecks" each year -- an extra check in December above what was planned, as a xmas gift to employees/retirees, because "it looked like our fund was doing well, and these people need that money to make ends meet". You may be surprised at how bad the situation is in every state and city (with few exceptions) thanks to the bad incentives that these systems create. And few rewards for people who are responsible enough to try to fix it before it becomes critical. People have been pointing to waves of bankruptcy and spiraling costs in the near future, for years now. And you wonder why we can't fund infrastructure and other nice things.
- danbruc 5y agoHave the currently working part of the population pay a tax on their working income, hand this money out to the currently retired part of the population, to some extend proportional to their contribution during their working years.
- wmf 5y agoCan't tell if trolling. This is called Social Security.
- thrill 5y agoJust like your healthcare, if laws and incentives affecting your retirement are dependent on someone's else's decisions about where to allocate and how much of the resources you worked so hard to obtain, then you're living under an illusion of independency.