16 ms·
Windows 11, Amazon, and Uncomfortable Questions
- deadalus 5y agoFirst thing to do after installing Windows 11 : Disable Telemetry
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoWe live in a hell world if we need to take extra steps to NOT be spied by your operating system
- lazide 5y agoAlready here - I’ve had windows 10 auto updates re-enable it at least 3 times over the years. I’ve given up frankly. It’s really crazy they get away with it.
- marderfarker2 5y agoWindows 10 still respects the Group Policy on Windows Update . If you’re on Home edition, there’s a powershell script that can enable gpedit for you.
- sneak 5y agoI use WPD to block and disable it all. There's a lot more than a few settings to change.
- Jonnax 5y agoThen don't use Windows. If you aren't happy with Apple's telemetry, then use Linux. If you aren't happy with bug reporting tools remove it.
- beebeepka 5y agoIndeed. Regular people I get but developers voluntarily using it make no sense. But UI, but telemetry, but appl... As if there are no viable options out there
- SQueeeeeL 5y agoI'm glad the standard we hold ourselves to is to just not use shitty products that spy on their users instead of expecting/requiring them to be better
- Jonnax 5y agoTheir QA process is based around their telemetry. They're not going to change it. Also exaggerating by saying "spy on their users" is just misrepresentative. And muddies the water when discussing actual spying on users computers.
- qwertox 5y agoIt's also an exaggeration to say that they have QA process. They keep shipping faulty updates again and again.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIt's not really a quality assurance process anymore if you wait for things to go wrong in the field. More like a quality remediation process.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- darksaints 5y agoAnd then update your software because you need security updates. And then disable telemetry again. And then update your software again. And then disable telemetry again. And then update software again. And then disable telemetry again. And then install Linux and never install Windows ever again.
- marderfarker2 5y agoI have since relegated to totally disabling Windows update due to this. As a bonus, my PC stays the same way, goes to sleep and stays asleep as expected without new unexpected features clogging my desktop every month.
- dhruvdh 5y agoI've rarely ever seen any discussion of Windows Telemetry actually discuss how it violates their privacy. Is it not possible that the telemetry exists only to collect data on how to improve software? Do we know it's being used for advertising?
- johannes1234321 5y agoThere are other risks than advertising/privacy. They can for instance analyse what applications from other vendors are frequently used and build in alternatives.
- rovr138 5y agoDo we know it’s not? Is it illegal for them to switch to using it for advertising in the future? What I know is that they collect huge amounts of data and we don’t have protections on how that can be used.
- bogwog 5y agoAnd what that means is that it comes down to trust. And anyone who trusts Microsoft (or any of the tech giants) is naive or uninformed/ignorant.
- wintermutestwin 5y agoIt has become quite clear that user data is the goldrush that the majority of the world's biggest tech companies are feverishly mining. Whether they sell it today (advertising) or not is the smallest concern compared to a myriad of society-harming ways that it could be used in the future. A company like MS could sit on your data for a decade and then decide that can get away with far more data abuse than they could today. It seems like a good bet that the ways that our data can be used will continue to expand. We probably can just watch the tea leaves of China to see what our data use future looks like. How long will it be until we have a social credit system like China's? >actually discuss how it violates their privacy The privacy violation is the collection itself.
- criddell 5y agoUnwanted surveillance is itself something that many of us object to. For example, I run uBlock Origin to reduce tracking, not because I think ads are evil.
- shadilay 5y agoDid you check your firewall logs to see if it actually disabled it?
- encryptluks2 5y agoIt is near impossible. There are probably in excess of 30 or more group policy settings that would be needed to try to disable it. Even something as simple as signing into the Microsoft Store seems to enable additional telemetry like sending app launches to your Microsoft account history.
- binarybanana 5y agoBest way to thoroughly block all telemetry on Windows is actually the built in firewall. Just block all outgoing connections and only enable them for your browser and whatever else you need. According to a tcpdump running on the host of a Windows VM this blocks absolutely everything, even connections originating from kernel drivers. I tested this with LTSC though, so YMMV.
- FiddlerClamp 5y agoAccording to an MS engineer, you will be able to sideload APKs to Windows, which solves the problem for any app that doesn't need GMS: https://twitter.com/ajonoguy/status/1408221001951809539 https://twitter.com/ajonoguy/status/1408221001951809539
- kaszanka 5y agoYou will be able to install the software you want on the computer you own without going through some corporation's central "store"? The fact that this is surprising or noteworthy is just sad.
- canadianfella 5y agoWho said it was surprising?
- least 5y agoIf APKs were normal Windows executables I'd agree with you. But given that they're not, there's not really an expectation that they'd just work.
- klodolph 5y agoExactly—also given that side loading was, for a brief moment, a Windows Enterprise-only feature, if only for Metro apps.
- IshKebab 5y agoWhat does the fact that they are not PE exes have to do with expectations about sideloading? Would you not expect to be able to side load a .jar either?
- klodolph 5y agoMicrosoft previously disabled side loading of Metro apps. This happened in the Windows 8 era. You either had to purchase a side-loading key (per machine) or use Windows Enterprise. My memory of the details is fading, thankfully, but I think side loading was disabled for 8.0 and 8.1 (without a key), and the restrictions were removed or relaxed in 8.2.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fffrantz 5y agoWhile this is indeed worrisome, I’m not really sure Microsoft is any better than Amazon from a pure end-user point of view. Microsoft has been a telemetry champion and has been collecting troves of personal data through Windows 10, all the while making it almost impossible for the average user to disable it (and re-enabling it with every major update). So if Microsoft goes the same route as Amazon (resigning every app), it’s just a matter of choice between a rock and a hard place. On the other hand, even if they allow for the app developer to keep its signature, Microsoft is still probably very capable of gathering data and telemetry through their Android implementation. Either way, and until it becomes illegal to collect data without explicit consent, I’m pretty sure we’re screwed…
- JMTQp8lwXL 5y agoThe telemetry for Windows is a frequent topic here, could anyone clarify/compare the story for Mac OS?
- umanwizard 5y agoIn the Apple ecosystem you are asked once when setting up a new device if you would like to enable telemetry.
- sneak 5y agoApple devices still phone home constantly with things that amount to telemetry when you use them, even with analytics disabled. Opening the App Store app, for example, sends your hardware serial number. Macs and iOS both maintain hardware-serial-linked 24/7 connections to Apple's push servers, too. There aren't opt out UI settings available for the majority of Apple's phone-home.
- tgragnato 5y agoThe situation is a little better compared to Windows, but it's not perfect. I always disable telemetry, but iphonesubmissions.apple.com:443, radarsubmissions.apple.com:443 and securemetrics.apple.com:443 are still contacted. People messing with ocsp.apple.com:80 (https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts/issues/1460 https://github.com/StevenBlack/hosts/issues/1460) also need to be aware of ocsp2.apple.com:443. The iAdSDK setting is somewhat respected, but all the Siri subdomains are pinged even if Siri is turned off.
- k__ 5y agoGood questions asked. In the short term, breaking the App/Play Store duopol will be a good thing. But what will happen after that?
- spideymans 5y agoGood things for developers. Good things for power users. However I'm concerned about the impact on "normal" users that just want their stuff to work. There's little stopping a Facebook App Store from taking similar measures, for example.
- tored 5y agoOnly thing that can compete with native app stores is the web, this means making the web standard even more bloated. If you could install a store inside your browser and then buy web apps from there instead, your apps is no longer tied to the operating system, only to the store (that requires a compatible browser) But I don't think it will happened because it doesn't benefit the two major players on operating systems, Microsoft and Apple. What probably will happen is just solidifying the Android based native app as the dominant application platform, now you can develop against the Android SDK and cover 80-90% of the market, both desktop and mobile. If you don't know Java already, it is time to learn. Welcome to the future - poms, jars, classpaths and AbstractFactoryFactory nightmares everywhere, buggy and slow Android apps running over a virtual machine with a user experience not adapted for mouse and keyboard. There will be Hacker News threads about how they miss good ol' Electron apps.
- AlexAffe 5y agoIsn't it time to just ditch "Stores" all together? We were way past that concept on the PC for decades, how on earth does it help to introduce it to desktop? Let ppl download there apks from the dev sources directly, and... oh wait... I'm just describing 'installing a program' as it has been for ages. Maybe this will at least help normal users to wake up and wanting to escape their jails. (oh sorry, I forgot, it's for their own good! o7)
- johannes1234321 5y agoinstalling applications from "wild" sources leads to possible virus injectiins etc. I sleep better knowing my parents won't br able to simply install things. I like Android, where the default is the play store, but i can sideload or use f-droid as well.
- AussieWog93 5y agoMalware exists on the Play store too. My grandmother managed to download some aggressive adware bundled in a sudoku app. Interestingly, she's avoided viruses on Windows for decades. I think thats because she wouldn't trust random apps from dodgy websites in the way she'd trust Google Play.
- takluyver 5y agoMalware certainly exists on the Play store, but when Google spot it, they can unilaterally remove it. IIRC, they also have the ability to remove it from devices where it was already installed. The app store model probably also delivers security updates to legitimate apps more effectively than every developer managing their own distribution. My parents are also very cautious with what they install on Windows, and I think that's a pretty good approach. But it's pretty clear that plenty of people aren't so paranoid, and it's not always easy to tell a dodgy site from a legitimate one.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>when Google spot it, they can unilaterally remove it. Microsoft can achieve the same goal already through Windows Defender. My app was recently flagged as a trojan (false positive) and it would be wiped from users' computers before they could even run it. >they also have the ability to remove it from devices where it was already installed. That Microsoft can't do, but I'm not really sure that it's a good thing... >The app store model probably also delivers security updates to legitimate apps more effectively than every developer managing their own distribution. Citation needed there.
- webmobdev 5y agowe don’t modify and distribute your application code without your knowledge and approval º Notably, this person used “don’t” and “will not”… as opposed to “can’t” and “cannot” º So the next stage in the plan for the tech giants is to now take control over all our software applications and really lock them down too? With locked iDevices and smartphones that don't allow you to install the system software you want, that can be crippled and made unusable by the manufacturers, and have nearly unrepairable hardware (with lobbying opposing right-to-repair legislations), the tech giants have ensured that we have already lost control over our hardware devices. Today we only "own" them in name. The article highlights a real worry - It is not at all far fetched to believe that by wrapping apps with their own proprietary codes, the tech giants can control and steal our app data (a very likely goal of all the tech giants) and even modify the apps to cripple them or convert it to a malware (at the behest of over-reaching governments). This just adds to my worry, and ire, at App Stores, and provides a new perspective of them I had never considered before. º https://commonsware.com/blog/2020/09/23/uncomfortable-questions-app-signing.html https://commonsware.com/blog/2020/09/23/uncomfortable-questi... .
- HKH2 5y agoHey, people want things fast and convenient, not so much secure, private or customizable. Those tech giants just appeal to that short-sighted mindset. It's like trying to have a functional democracy with people who want it to be easy so it can get out of the way. Big-tech control is just a side-product of atomization, as far as I can see.
- shadilay 5y agoAlso, rapacious greed.
- akagusu 5y agoUncomfortable questions nobody asks because everybody is afraid of the answers.
- varispeed 5y agoOr they are worried losing sponsorships. Every company seems to be moving towards walled garden rent seeking data harvesting business model, so if they start asking question, they may start hitting the bottom line of many businesses.
- akagusu 5y agoYou are right about companies looking for rent seeking. Rent seeking is a global trend unfortunately, and I'm pretty sure this trend will end bad for us.
- varispeed 5y agoSmall anecdote: I needed a software suite for work and the cost was around $2800. I took a bank loan as I thought I could pay ~$300 a month until it is paid off and I didn't want to spent this much at once. I bought it. Few months later the company decided to embrace subscription model and you no longer find perpetual license on their site. That wouldn't be the end of the world, until my licenses started acted funny few months later (showing I don't have a license for some parts of the suite I paid for). The support said that they no longer support the version of software I have and they can only advice me to buy a subscription. They said they'll give me few months free for inconvenience. I was shocked!
- moksly 5y agoIt’s been an interesting decade to be an Enterprise Organisation that’s been happy with Microsoft for more than 30 years. We went into the cloud before Azure was a thing. AWS was a thing on the US when we did it, but back then no one in the Danish public service would’ve put our data into an American cloud. We instead rented iron instead of buying it, which sort of amounts to the same thing except it isn’t in your basement, but in someone else’s. Perfectly fine when the business case is there, which it was, and it helped us immensely for the world of today since we began getting everything virtual back then. Anyway, a decade later and now the move is going toward Azure (it could just as easily be AWS if Amazon had Office365) but it’s not like we want to move away from Microsoft as such. Yes we are idealists who want more open source in the public sector, but we’re also realists who have a staff of 30 to deal with the IT needs of 10.000 employees, some of which can’t tell support if the device they need help for is an iOS or Android device. We also don’t pay our IT staff enough to hire equal level talent for Linux systems, because that talent mass is just so much smaller. Getting back to my point though. Over the years we’ve gone from using different Kanban and planning tools to using Microsoft teams and planner. We’ve gone from using different document sharing systems (and the strict control over these) to using OneDrive for business. We’ve gone from using Cisco software phones to using Skype for Business and teams. We’ve gone from using dreambroker to using the video tools in windows and teams for presentation. We’ve gone from having different ways of running the scripts that maintain our org data, and BI tools that present them, to using azure services and powerbi. We started our using Softomotive as our Robotics platform and became the leading public sector organisation with it, and Microsoft just bought it. The list goes on. In short, we’ve gone from buying software from 30 different countries to simply using what Microsoft is now supplying through its platforms. We know it’s maybe not the best strategy, but it’s hard to defend not doing it when it’s both cheaper, easier for the organisation and what our IT staff wants because it gives them CVS that can be used almost every where. Maybe this is just Microsoft being very good at spotting trends in the European public sector, but they are just so much better at it than agencies like Gartner, Deloitte, E&Y and even their competitors in the form of IBM and Amazon. Although as far as legalisation goes, Amazon has them beat by a lot despite starting slow.
- zahrc 5y agoAdd CRM and ERP Systems as well, Dynamcis365 grants incredible bang for buck.
- gchokov 5y agoThis is an epic mess. Trying to catch up with iOS on Mac (ehmm..) but having a sub system over a subsystem .. I don’t think this will play out well.
- jayd16 5y agoIts just a built in VM with (hopefully) better perf and some nice file system interop. Where's the mess?
- dehrmann 5y ago> Trying to catch up with iOS on Mac Maybe, and barely. You've only been able to do this since November, and only on new Macs. When Windows 11 ships, assuming the TPM requirement isn't an issue, a bigger share of Windows users will almost immediately have this feature, rather than having to buy new hardware.
- rewgs 5y agoFor real. Microsoft's attempts to compete with the Apple ecosystem kind of feel like DC trying to catch up with Marvel -- super rushed, half-baked, zero vision. It's especially strange since .NET is a great cross-platform framework.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bogwog 5y agoThe Amazon Appstore on Microsoft Windows 11: A match made in hell. This is all really concerning to me. Microsoft's embrace-extend-extinguish tactic[1] is now targeting both Linux and Android. This is all so over-the-top evil that it would be funny if it wasn't so god damn depressing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embrace,_extend,_and_extinguis...
- grogenaut 5y agoThis post for info purposes only having worked with the Amazon app store team and does not reflect my opinions at all, I haven't spent time thinking about if it's good or bad: The resigning stuff is because they alter the apps to fix dependence on Google play apis and gsuite apis. Developers were not interested in rebuilding their apps for fire and other devices without those apis baked in and this was a good solution to ease uptake for fire/Amazon app store. Also note that ms will control this android os, so they already control the signature verification method. They could do this without you knowing very easily by just with something like carrying a second sig and hash of what they modified and the original partial sums from the original app. Google and amazon or any os supplier can. Signature verification is only as strong as the verifier code. Glad to burn karma to put data out there.
- teraflop 5y agoSure, there are any number of ways Microsoft could break their own security model. For example, they could stop verifying signatures entirely. The fact that they're not doing worse things doesn't make what they are doing less bad. If the problem is that app developers don't want to fix dependencies on Google services, but Amazon has a tool to fix them automatically, why can't they just release the tool and let developers sign the output themselves? Sure, some devs might be too lazy to do it, but how does that justify forcing everyone to give up control over their signatures?
- cptskippy 5y ago> If the problem is that app developers don't want to fix dependencies on Google services, but Amazon has a tool to fix them automatically, why can't they just release the tool and let developers sign the output themselves? I would imagine the tool rebinds the Google APIs to Amazon's equivalent APIs rather than neutering them. Since Apps are relying on the API responses. I don't imagine Amazon wants Apps distributed outside their Store using their APIs and getting a free ride. Am I missunderstanding things? Isn't the purpose of App Signing primarily for Google's software running on your device to verify Apps running in your device against public signatures Google holds on it's servers? I understand there's a chain of custody and a developer can upload their App, then download it from the store and be confident it's what they uploaded. But Google now allows you to put your signing keys into their KeyStore on their servers. I guess you still have a copy and can verify an App is signed with your Key but since you didn't do the signing that isn't enough to ensure it was signed without modification.
- makecheck 5y agoWith both Mac and now Windows supporting these mobile-forced-to-desktop apps, I worry a bit about the poor UIs in our future. On the one hand, maybe tablets will improve a bit because mobile apps will have even more incentive to spruce up their large-screen experiences. On the other hand, literally every app I have seen auto-ported to desktop in this way has been awkward at best. Usually at least a few standard platform things just don’t work, like universal keyboard navigation. Having mobile UIs appear unaltered on the desktop is just jarring, at the very least requiring unnecessary scrolling and controls that do not resemble anything else. And I am not convinced that this will improve with time; on the Mac side some of these pseudo-apps have had years to get better but they are still packed full of UI quirks.
- f6v 5y ago> With both Mac and now Windows supporting these mobile-forced-to-desktop apps, I worry a bit about the poor UIs in our future. The operating systems aren't the only ones to blame here. Haven't you seen desktop sites using hamburger menu? That abomination came to life thanks to mobile web.
- topicseed 5y agoThanks to the paradigm "write once, publish everywhere". As a publisher who recently redesigned one of our websites, using the hamburger menu across devices and screen sizes was strongly considered. It is very annoying on larger screens but these represent such a small traffic share that it is what it is... We still did not go ahead with that, but it was close...
- wyldfire 5y ago> Will Amazon agree to distribute Android apps unmodified from what developers upload, with the original signatures intact? Amazon’s behavior is policy, and policies can be rescinded. Removing signatures by design in the face of a recent huge impact supply chain attack? Hopefully US Gov can leverage some simple purchasing controls (that don't require 'an act of congress') to convince Amazon to stop this behavior.
- Terretta 5y agoHere’s another uncomfortable question not mentioned there… I wonder if this alliance will quell handwringing about Apple having some sort of “monopoly” simply by its choosing the contrarian path of designing, building, and marketing a full experience for those seeking one. Dominant desktop platform + dominant mobile platform + dominant online commerce platform & cloud platform … versus a firm doing it differently: FAANG becomes FANG aligning against the odd A. Quick, don’t let the market decide, ban Apple’s UX design model and the business model that sustains it? Could be there’s room to let this one play out with Apple back to its innovation integrator chasm-crosser zone as niche underdog, rather than trying to preemptively pop the zeitgeist bubble stressing people out.
- qwertox 5y agoFinally I can start buying free apps again, which will needlessly spam my Amazon shopping history. Other than that, I'm so happy that my Fire HD 8 bricked itself, and the Fire 7 is about to take its last breath, because there is absolutely nothing which I managed to like about Fire OS. Never again, and I hope that MS doesn't start to try to nag me into using it.
- efitz 5y agoI used to work at Microsoft in the Windows team, and think that the product is a lot better than many people give it credit for. That said, why exactly do I want even more kitchen sink functionality in my OS? In a world trending towards devices and services, we should see general purpose OS trending more towards slimmed-down, tailored-for-use implementations - maybe the same code base supports a game console and a streaming media device and a phone and a tablet, but each instance stripped until it's just what is needed. Why do I want bloat exactly?
- liquidpele 5y agoFor the same reason solitaire is an online app with ads now.
- IIAOPSW 5y agowait really? what's next? social media integration? The unironic irony of social solitaire.
- poisonborz 5y agoBecause Microsoft would be stupid to provide a barebones OS. What would an average user do with that? They install an OS and then spend days with hunting down different apps and configure them so that they can actually start using their device? MS (and honestly, any software company) has all the reasons and ability to provide a (more) complete solution. The only complaint one may have is to have ability to remove/disable the things you don't need - which you, as an experienced user, can do (eg. WSL is optional). I'm not saying this results in a healthy industry (monopolies using their monopoly to get into a much wider field) but if you see the world from an average user on one end, and a profit oriented company on the other, it's rather obvious how things happen.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoAlso, all the apps they provide tie in with services they want to sell like M365.
- 5y ago
- enos_feedler 5y agoThe most uncomfortable question about Windows using Amazon Android store is related to developer app signing? How about: How does a company that absolutely dominated PC app market somehow need to embrace Android app compatibility? How were they not able to use dominance to capture the adjacent app market in mobile? This question is more uncomfortable because it attacks a character trait of Microsoft: arrogance.
- ineedasername 5y agoI side-load the Google Play store on Kindle devices. I wonder if that will be possible here. If so, it's one way to avoid Amazon's app wrapper, and probably appealing for many more users than that sort of thing would usually be due to the Play store having a much wider selection.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoWeren't they merely using the Amazon app store as an example?
- mdoms 5y agoThe entire article hinges on this one premise, > However, there is a dark cloud with all of this: the primary source of Android apps for Windows 11 users appears to be the Amazon AppStore for Android. Is there any evidence of this? There's no linked article and it's entirely unsourced. I for one would NEVER install software that Amazon has had any hand in.
- ttam 5y ago> "I can think of a number of countries who would love to convince Amazon to modify Facebook Messenger to bypass end-to-end encryption, for example." How exactly can this be done?
- nhumrich 5y agoWell, if you can modify the client, then you simply, dont encrypt the messages.
- phendrenad2 5y ago"Amazon modifies all those apps to be different than what the developers intended to ship" But... the developer put the app on the Amazon store. They trust Amazon to redistribute it any hacky way they want. It's okay to say "I don't like Amazon tracking me" but it's not okay to lie and confuse the issue by saying that Amazon is doing app devs dirty.
- tadfisher 5y agoIt's also fairly trivial to decompile an APK to verify they haven't done something as obvious as adding or replacing classes. In the Play Store case, they are doing some extra asset minification and are serving split APKs with only the assets needed for the target device, which is certainly welcome as an end user with limited storage. I would, however, enjoy a scheme where I could trace the Play Store's signature back to the key I used to sign the app bundle for upload. Like if I could sign their key with mine.
- kaptain 5y agoWhat's interesting to me is that the discussion so far has emphasized: security and freedom. It's clear that consumers care very little about these two ideas in the ways that the technological elite (i.e. HN) do. If I don't understand a technology and don't have an interest in doing so, I certainly don't want to manage it. So the values that these "uncomfortable questions" raise are irrelevant. The way the average consumer views "security" is: "Is this a trusted brand?". As of today Microsoft and Amazon are trusted brands. Western Digital not so much. So instead of trying to understand how Windows 11 running wrapped Amazon Store Android executables might be insecure, users see the words "Microsoft" and "Amazon" and feel secure. (as a side note, security is really just a feeling anyways...) With regard to freedom, what's freeing to the common consumer is the freedom to have access to functionality they care about. They don't care that someone else is tracking them or that they are limited to apps on these stores. So, really, these uncomfortable questions are only uncomfortable for people who aren't the target audience of this feature.