5 ms·
A rediscovered lost memoir about John Locke
- enkid 5y agoHeroes never live up to their reputation. Remember, they were people with pluses and negatives, and most likely were extremely lucky in becoming the protagonist in some historical narrative instead of a bystander.
- civildude 5y agohe amused himself with trifling works of wit, a real scandal!
- dlsa 5y agoI suspect many more people now also amuse themselves with trifling works of Twitter.
- cies 5y agoMy gripe with Locke is more that his "equality" was only for the non-slaves of his nation state. That's not equality, that's a good starting point for tyranny/oppression.
- throwaway210222 5y agoSigh… My gripe with modern politicians is that their definition of "equality" is only for the adults of our nation state. Men old enough to drive three ton SUVs, fight wars, and father children are denied the right to vote. Hell, in one famous democracy they cannot even buy a beer. You and I are John Locke.
- cies 5y ago> Men old enough to drive three ton SUVs, fight wars, and father children are denied the right to vote. No idea what you're trying to say here dear thowaway. > You and I are John Locke. And here neither.
- throwaway210222 5y agoReally? No idea, none, nada, completely in the dark? OK then: the OP was belittling the ethics of John Locke because he failed to measure up to the posters 21st century western values. [Its a popular modern past-time]. Hell, slavery was so embedded that slaves thought it was normal. [Much like we treat work today]. Saudi Arabia only came around to the consensus that owning people was bad in 1961. Your great grandparents didn't think women should vote. So I was pointing out that there are still many edge-cases in the OPs/our own society - from where he/she judges, that are a similar [but, yes, not identical] blind spot. On which he/she is completely silent. Why EXACTLY, should high-school students not vote? [But, I suspect you actually did work all this out yourself]
- cies 5y ago> Hell, slavery was so embedded that slaves thought it was normal. There was Jesus teachings right? And many others who were frowning upon it. This "it was embedded" is merely a way to retroactively make it sound not as bad as it is. Condoning slavery in Locke's time was also bad. And, ihmo, especially looks bad on "mr equality" himself. > Why EXACTLY, should high-school students not vote? I totally agree. But highscholers at least will someday vote + have parents and hence get included. Slaves on the other hand get 100% exploited. Still I dont get your references.
- throwaway210222 5y ago> This "it was embedded" is merely a way to retroactively make it sound not as bad as it is? No, why on earth would you think that of me? Don't be a dick. Its just a historical fact. Wierd and awful as it may seem to us. Which is why Mr Locke could not see it. Here is a crutch to help you get there: 1. we currently - and rightly - hate racial discrimination in apparently all its forms, but 2. we (via our governments) think it is perfectly ok to make some visitors to our countries get expensive restrictive visas, whilst others are welcomed with open arms 3. compare and contract the international border experience of citizens of EU, USA, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, with ANY African country 4. hell, there are job adverts demanding 'a passport that can travel'. Now ask yourself how much sleep most of the Western progressives lose over this. They just cannot see it. Later generations might. Should they smugly dismiss us?
- Daishiman 5y agoCan I say this doesn't really surprise me at all? Philosophy almost by definition requires a good ability to skip work to just sit down and think deeply about things, something you can't really do expediently or while busy with life. If you go merrily about doing whatever needs doing you're like not unhappy enough with the state of things to ask yourself some big questions. It also requires a good ability to repackage ideas, many of which have been ill-presented by original authors or far ahead of their time, to an audience in a manner that makes them receptive to them. Most philosophers spend far more time engaging in dialogue with existing ideas instead of making their own.
- smitty1e 5y agoIt's interesting that this bit of offhand notes is taken as gospel. Quite possibly it's valid, but it seems as though the certainty of TFA could be overplayed.
- briefcomment 5y agoUnrelated, but I once came across a post claiming TFA stood for "the f**ing article", and I now can't unsee that. I wonder for a split second, before I remember what it actually stands for, why the poster is so angry.
- maxerickson 5y agoThat's likely the original meaning, with 'the fine article' being someone squeaming.
- briefcomment 5y agoOh, I thought it was "the featured article"
- nemosaltat 5y agoBased on usage here, I’ve come to understand TFA as “the FULL article.” For me, this comports with the spirit of HN rules. Used in that sense, it allows for the possibility that another commenter may have skimmed, or even read the article, but may have missed a detail that the FULL article addresses.
- libraryofbabel 5y agoI think it comes from the exhortation to read the manual: "RTFM!". This has been around in technical circles for over 40 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTFM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RTFM
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- libraryofbabel 5y agoThis is a summary by a journalist in the Guardian; the original scholarship is in the Journal of Modern History (paywalled)[0]. tldr: scholars have never been able to say very much concrete about John Locke's intellectual relationship to Thomas Hobbes, despite these two dudes being the most important 17th-century English political philosophers. Locke's work often appears to be responding to Hobbes, but he conspicuously never mentions him by name. But wait! This new manuscript is a (third-hand) account saying that Locke read Hobbes's Leviathan closely earlier in his life and even recommended the book to others, but later would deny that he ever read it. (Also the manuscript says some other mean things about Locke which are of maybe less scholarly interest.) It's an interesting sort of find, although 17th-century intellectual history was not my specialty when I was a historian so it's hard to say how really important it is in terms of reorienting that sub-field. Bigger picture, I suppose it depends on how much you care about what Locke thought of Hobbes. [0] https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/714068 https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/abs/10.1086/714068
- sdwr 5y agoReading about the character flaws of public figures is fascinating to me, in (I'm assuming) the same way people like paparazzi photos of celebrities getting coffee in sweatpants. Bleary-eyed, frumpy, regular-sized, basically normal. Part of the attraction is a kind of zero-sum ego trip. Bringing stars down to earth lets me believe that I'm closer to having "made it" in some vague, ill-defined way, without ever having to leave the couch.
- modified001 5y agoOh, I just remembered Lost
- TX0098812 5y agoThe guardian is constantly negative. It's like their job is to attack and discredit people and institutions they don't like. Often based on insinuations or flimsy or no evidence. More knowledge and less lobbying please.
- cafard 5y agoSomehow Locke managed to qualify as a physician, teach (as I recall it) classics at the university, and write the Essay Concerning Human Understanding. Not half bad for a lazy man.