29 ms·
Mimicking a device is becoming almost impossible
- gostsamo 5y agoBeing pretentious without googling results in Rumi being announced as turkish poet. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rumi
- uniqueuid 5y agoBrowser automation is an arms race between fraud detection and criminals, with users and some legitimate use cases (cough science) caught in between. I find it's very useful to think of the problem not as governed by technical possibility, but rather by costs. Good spoofing detection does not prevent fraud, it increases its costs to fraudsters (hoping to render fraud uneconomical). Bad spoofing detection harms legitimate users and is inefficient against capable actors. All of this gets much more interesting and complex when we consider privacy (and privacy compliance) to be part of the puzzle - now fraud prevention incurs a cost to the defender as well. Finally, it's important to consider asymmetric risk/benefit counts. Are you defending against a single major heist, or against billions of tiny events (click fraud)? The trade-off will look different.
- gavanm 5y agoSome other genuine legitimate use cases are: Monitoring (Synthetic Users) Performance Testing (though usually in a separate dedicated environment)
- uniqueuid 5y agoRight, I guess it's important to have some automated way of testing the billions of configuration possibilities and network/device conditions that you could expect, because they are impossible to systematically test in human-driven QA. How else would you test your SPA against millions of different content-modifying browser plugins, for example.
- oauea 5y ago> How else would you test your SPA against millions of different content-modifying browser plugins, for example. You don't.
- evgen 5y agoIf it is your site then you will be able to bypass the fraud detection, and if it is not your site then the site owner probably does not consider these legitimate use cases to be concerned about.
- Nextgrid 5y agoAnother legitimate usage use-case is to wade through bullshit, dark patterns, ads & co in an automated way. See Invidious, Nitter, Teddit, etc.
- uniqueuid 5y agoWhile I love those attempts (kind of like ublock origin on a server), you can easily see how they are stuck between a rock and a hard place. They have all the vulnerability of fraudsters, and none of the benefits of authentic users. That's why most of them seem to be perpetually banned. [edit] Now, if someone would build an onion router that ran on people's end devices and served as a proxy network for these front ends, that would be interesting ... but would probably end up getting lots of people blocked, so please don't take it seriously.
- Nextgrid 5y ago> but would probably end up getting lots of people blocked These scum companies rely on "engagement", so they can only block people if it's a minority. If _everyone_ participates, they have no choice but to accept it (or maybe change their product so there's no incentive to run these unofficial front-ends in the first place).
- kfichter 5y ago> Bad spoofing detection harms legitimate users and is inefficient against capable actors. On a somewhat related note: I used to write sneaker buying bots and captcha was one of the best things to happen to the bot industry. Captcha was easily "bypassed" by services that had humans sitting at computers generating tokens. Recaptcha tokens are valid for two minutes by default, so you'd be able to generate tokens up to two minutes in advance and have dozens of tokens available when the product in question became available for purchase. Real buyers had to wait for drop and then spend 15s+ filling out the captcha. Bots would take most of the stock in less than a second. I always felt like this was a fantastic example of a bot prevention mechanism that actually actively harmed "legitimate" users.
- paulpauper 5y agoIf the landing page generates unique captachaa that are random how does this help unless the hashes are valid globally
- rapsey 5y agoRecaptcha sends the same image to multiple browsers at the same time and it gets solved by consensus I think.
- colejohnson66 5y agoYou’re thinking of reCaptcha “v2”. That was when it was about digitizing books. One distorted photo of a word had a known spelling, and the other didn’t. If you spelled the known one right, it let you through. If enough people spelled the unknown one the same way, it would “learn” how to OCR that word (of sorts). If you had time to spare/waste, you could spell the first one right, and put garbage for the second one. About half the time, it would let you through. Not sure how reCaptcha “v3” (the photos of streets one) works. It could work the same way, but just with more known and unknown (unclassified) pictures? It’s also a lot more harsh if you get it wrong: artificial delays, switching to the “click until no more remain” mode (with more delays), and more. Sometimes, it just refuses to let you through no matter what: https://youtu.be/zGW7TRtcDeQ https://youtu.be/zGW7TRtcDeQ It’s extremely frustrating.
- Siira 5y agoScraping user-generated data should be made a legal right. It’s not like the companies paid for the data they collected from users, and the whole thing is anti-competitive as well, and hurts the economy.
- judge2020 5y agoUGC can range from a Facebook post about tacos to intimate details about one’s private life or medical history. Blanket statements like yours do nothing to help the conversation.
- luffapi 5y agoYou can get only scrape data you are allowed to access. If your eyes can see it, you should be able to scrape it. The analog hole is always there.
- EMM_386 5y agoThis gets very tricky when you think about JavaScript. What if you only pop up important information via an onBlur event in a dynamically created div element that is overlayed on the page, only after asynchronously querying a REST endpoint to get information from a database? How would a crawler even know that this element is shown when you leave a specific input field? How would it know to wait a second while the database is getting the data? Like it or not, we're well past the days of complete HTML documents being served for a request.
- luffapi 5y agoI don’t understand why programmatic access is being equated with fraud. Device identification is never a benefit for end users. Lack of privacy, waste of resources, hostile ux… we’re basically talking about DRM.
- tovej 5y agoYeah, HTTP should be a protocol that users can use freely (as long as they don't use it for Denial of Service). I don't see why I shouldn't be able to fetch a website, scrape it for information and reassemble that information in the way I want it to be presented.
- chii 5y ago> reassemble that information in the way I want it to be presented site owners want the advertising that was embedded to be seen and thus make revenue from it.
- megous 5y agoNot all of them, some just want to sell stuff, but make it positively terrible to search for things. Some site owners provide you service, like banks, or chat services like Slack, or Jira, but the user interface is again a turd. Some just publish info on a blog, but you can expect it to go away, so why not save it for later. Slack limits the amount of searchable messages to 10k, so if you save them regularly to local DB, you can search without limits. All kinds of owners don't sell/show ads, or care about scraping.
- mike_hearn 5y agoIt's because programmatic access on websites with anything social, or with user generated content, is very strongly correlated with spam, and spam is quite often linked with fraud of various kinds. Like 99%+ of the time if something is posted by a bot outside of any officially provided APIs, it will be unwanted by other users.
- 5y ago
- emodendroket 5y agoIt seems to me that one way through this challenge is just automating the browser itself. Internet Explorer was particularly friendly to this but since it's out of support maybe browser extensions would be the way to go.
- captainmuon 5y agoI think we are trying to solve a social problem with a technical solution. Can we make an unbeatable spoof detector? I think we probably could, but we shouldn't. Locking down things takes the fun out of them. Ideally, you could get rid of every captcha and just have an open API for everything. Somebody wants to create lots of email addresses to send spam? Remove the incentive to send spam. Somebody posts thousands of manipulative tweets? Maybe the "feed" model of social media is wrong. Don't assume every random account is equally important. Better just have a simple social network where you can connect with your friends. Or even better, design your society such that it's decisionmaking is more resilient and can't be gamed. The really hard but worthwile problem is not in tech, it is how we evolve our society along with the tech.
- jpttsn 5y agoPeople hurt each other? Just remove their reasons. Not enough food? Just stop being hungry. But how?
- asdadsdad 5y agolol
- KirillPanov 5y agoThis was the original attitude of the Old School Internet. Unfortunately a new generation has come along that believes advertising-supported business models are their birthright.
- zahrc 5y agoI’d honestly rather pay a (higher) fee to a service I like and is transparent. A service where my money is paying for the uptime and development and I give consent, and not where some “evil” AI is tracking my every step and then has the audacity to recommend me ads of things totally irrelevant to me. I respect that services have running costs and I’m happy to cover my usage, but I have to understand that the average consumer doesn’t give a crap, or is simply ignorant and doesn’t know.
- navierstokes 5y agoThe recent Microsoft signed rootkit has specific requests for collecting CPU-ID. That says something about the state of device fingerprinting, but I'm not sure exactly what that is. https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/microsoft-admits-to-signing-rootkit-malware-in-supply-chain-fiasco/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/microsoft-adm...
- shakkhar 5y agoCPUID is just a bunch of flags used to discover the capabilities of your CPU: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CPUID https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CPUID
- 10000truths 5y agoUltimately, no matter what you do on the client side, the server only knows what the client tells it. You don't need advanced emulation of JavaScript features to spoof an agent, you just need to mimic the requests a normal agent would make.
- uniqueuid 5y agoIn theory, perhaps. But in practice, that's too simple: What, for example about certificate pinning? If you have a safe certificate on the client, spoofing becomes (prohibitively) hard. Try, for example, to disassemble Facebook's APK or disable pinning via FRIDA (https://github.com/frida/frida https://github.com/frida/frida). It's not exactly easy, and with frequent releases, it's a moving target.
- bbarnett 5y agoYou can never trust anything on the client though. You must assume everything the client says is a lie, the browser itself, the OS, everything.
- tyingq 5y agoThe stealth plugin for Puppeteer Extra gives a pretty good idea of what you need to cover today. Maybe it's not rocket science, but it's not trivial either. https://github.com/berstend/puppeteer-extra/tree/master/packages/puppeteer-extra-plugin-stealth https://github.com/berstend/puppeteer-extra/tree/master/pack...
- buro9 5y agoDown to TCP handshake, TLS handshake and ciphers selected, timings, HTTP headers (case, order, whitespace, which ones are sent), HTTP session characteristics (concurrent stream count, behaviour of QUIC windowing, behaviour of closing the underlying connection, does the client read all of the response), etc. At some point the only way to not be spotted as a spoof is to run the real thing. If you think people aren't detecting spoofs like this then you are mistaken. From ad-spoofing detection, to e-commerce bot detection, this is very routine for companies to look at, it's not new it's just becoming more available to everyone. Spoofers would do better running the real things and learning tricks from poker bots by reading the video output and controlling computer inputs. This is fine by a lot of people as it has increased the cost on the spoofer side.
- KirillPanov 5y ago> a website cannot show captcha to mobile devices Wait, what?
- xtanx 5y agoWell, the actual quote is: > Who can stop people from utilizing device spoofing if a website cannot show captcha to mobile devices even if some rate limits are exceeded, or if a company offers specific discounts or products only to some types of devices?
- KirillPanov 5y agoOkay but I'm still confused by the part I quoted. Aren't CAPTCHAs shown to mobile web browser users all the time? Is there some law against showing them CAPTCHAs in the Peoples' Republic of WestArctica?
- yosamino 5y agoI think that makes sense in the context of the whole sentence: > Who can stop people from utilizing device spoofing if a website cannot show captcha to mobile devices even if some rate limits are exceeded, or if a company offers specific discounts or products only to some types of devices? The "cannot" is not meant in technical, but rather organizational sense - somebody decided that they don't want to show captcha to mobile users ( one reason might be that the user experience was deemed too bad). The same way they decided to offer specific discounts only to some other class of device.
- est 5y agoOP is yet to discover Chinese simulators designed to spoof all kinds of devices. Or even better, real device bot farms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_pRsSM_sXQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X_pRsSM_sXQ
- baybal2 5y agoGoogle has secretly installed a trojan that sent cellphone tower IDs to them. Remember this: https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locations-even-when-location-services-are-disabled/ https://qz.com/1131515/google-collects-android-users-locatio... ? A passing birdie told me that it was an internal antibotting sting.
- KirillPanov 5y agoThese guys are awesome. Why? Because they get it: Options for Paypal and credit card payments (you can choose one of the alternatives): * Send us a copy of an ID, issued by your Government, which clearly shows your name and picture. The file will be completely deleted after the verification process * Pass a video interview with our customer support representative Options for Bitcoin: * We don’t ask to verify Bitcoin payments
- perryizgr8 5y agoI don't get this. I would have thought it would be the other way around. Paypal and credit card companies do a lot of KYC and other checks on their users. Bitcoin does none. If you need to verify a user's identity for some reason, you need to do it more if they pay by Bitcoin!
- KirillPanov 5y agoYou've got it all backwards. Bitcoin doesn't need identity to prevent fraudulent payments. It uses math for that. The legacy banking system has no real, complete solution to fraudulent payments. So instead they bodge on this identity-checking nonsense, which maybe sorta works sometimes, with very high overhead. Privacy is collateral damage here. KYC for cryptocurrencies is like horse-buggy manufacturers requiring a whip and manure-scooper in every automobile. The horse-buggy industry is very desperately trying to convince you that this requirement is for your own good. And that without it, the terrorists will win.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoYou have it all mistaken. It's for AML, not for fraud.
- ectopod 5y agoIf this business is concerned about AML, why do they accept anonymous bitcoin payments? They care about chargebacks, not AML.
- baybal2 5y agoBig botters simply the browser in a VM. You can't do anything about that. And yes, even WebGL fingerprinting was defeated nearly completely.
- notduncansmith 5y agoNot that you can’t do “anything” about it, but you need to analyze the actual behavior instead of just user agent. Soon it will become an AI arms race between behavior analysis and behavior synthesis.
- swiley 5y agoOr just accept that user agents are robots acting on the user's behalf and build your stuff so that it can tolerate robots.
- aphroz 5y agoWhile proving you are a human becomes more and more difficult. And I am really tired of having to recognize cars, boats and bikes for every website I visit.
- valvar 5y agoIs the main purpose of these really to prove that you are human, or to improve their ML datasets?
- prirai 5y agoYeah, its actually for their dataset.
- Razengan 5y agoWhichever saves/makes them more money.
- rcxdude 5y agoNeither. Nowadays it is only one part of a large scoring system using a bunch of device and user fingerprinting, and it's primary use seems to be tarpitting bots who score low on the other metrics (as well as any users unfortunate or privacy-conscious enough to be misidentified as a bot).
- 411111111111111 5y agoI'm pretty sure that's sufficiently shown by the fact that captcha v3 doesn't even have any inputs.
- taneq 5y agoYou'd think that with the number of 'click all squares with traffic lights' type challenges we've had to endure, Waymo would be running entirely on camera feeds by now.
- aphroz 5y agoI take these tests very seriously, I don't want a car to crashes because I missed a traffic light.
- paganel 5y ago> instead of using his thumb, index and middle fingers (as Germans do), he uses his ring, middle and index finger. I'm not German but I also find the "thumb, index and middle" method to be the most natural, curious why people in the Anglo world have a different way for doing this.
- ducktective 5y agoObligatory https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cznppzkyqa0&t=97s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cznppzkyqa0&t=97s
- gavanm 5y agoI find that if you lead with the thumb-as-1 - then I can't use my little finger held down for 4. I naturally use my thumb to hold down the other fingers leading with index-as-1. I'm not sure what the thumb-as-1 does for 4 though. Since the thumb is the first digit on the hand (depending on the way you go) I can see it being a logical choice - but not necessarily the most convenient once you get to 4.
- toxik 5y agoIf I count things, I tend to extend the thumb first, then the index finger, then the long finger, etc. This I think naturally leads you to make 3 by extending the thumb, index and long finger.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThat's OK, but can you then extend the ring finger but not the pinky to make a 4? For me it's almost impossible.
- toxik 5y agoFairly easily yeah, on either hand
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gavanm 5y agoI work in performance testing, and in the web space you essentially have two different main approaches: * Protocol Testing - where you use servers to generate lots of HTTP/S traffic that is correctly structured to simulate user traffic. Generally, this is focused on capacity and server response times. * Browser Based - where you need the complex logic present in SPAs and Javascript to accurately create test traffic. This also allows for as-close-to-possible real user response times. This is essentially "headerless browsers" of varying types. This requires more performance test compute to process - so often a combination of both types are used together. I find that Testing application security is one of the most technically challenging aspects of performance testing. Often some parts of the security infrastructure have to be disabled to allow testing to occur. For example, Rate Limiting by source IP, any form of Captcha, 3rd party (OpenId etc) services have to be disabled - which increases the risk to application availability because sometimes there are components that haven't been tested exactly the way they will work for actual users. Luckily most the 3rd party services we use are already significantly tested by their vendors - but it is something that I worry about.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geon 5y ago> If you have ever used a mobile browser (of course you have), you know you cannot resize the browser window. It’s always opened, maximized, covering the whole screen. Not true. What about splitscreen?
- Tenoke 5y agoYeah, I'd bet most people with widescreens, and nearly all with ultrawides dont stay full-screened all the time. I certainly don't.
- lgvld 5y ago> mobile browser I think he refers to these kind of UI features on smartphones: https://www.samsung.com/au/support/mobile-devices/using-split-screen-view/ https://www.samsung.com/au/support/mobile-devices/using-spli...
- geon 5y agoAlso ipad: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207582 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207582
- 0x191919 5y agoI haven't noticed any significant differences in how popular websites and CAPTCHA perceive my identity when am surfing the web from Cloud VMs
- oauea 5y agoThen your regular identity must be tainted as well, because the difference is night and day.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"Although he wears a Nazi uniform and speaks German well, he gives himself by a minor detail: his fingers." I thought perhaps the author was going to discuss comparison to real world fingerprints. Here's are a few questions for readers: First, how much can a "device fingerprint" be used to identify a person. Is it identifiying a device, or only the person who is using it. How do we know who is that person. Second, is a "device fingerprint" like a real world one where someone can chop off someone else's finger and, as seen in popular TV/film entertainment, use it to gain entry into some highly restricted area. Third, assuming the answer is yes, what stops the collector of a "device fingerprint" from mis-using it. As long as she can make network connections appear to be coming from a plausibly genuine IP address, how would anyone distinguish a fraudulent user of the "device fingerprint" from an "authentic" one. (For example, the collector of the fingerprint could use it to impersonate the true owner of the device.) At least with real world fingerprints, they are physically attached to our person. Neither copying and re-using them nor stealing someone's finger is trivial. And generally online advertising firms are not in the practice of collecting real world fingerprints; those taking real world prints are often government agencies. We may have certains protections under the law against the government. We cannot make the same claims about "device fingerprints". As a user, I have not found that very many websites/endpoints that I use require any sort of complex fingerprint. I can retrieve the data I want without using a bloated graphical browser, running Javascript or sending a bunch of gratuitous HTTP headers. I send only two: Host and Connection. I cannot remember the last time this did not work. I never see any ads. As such, I struggle to understand all the fuss about "device fingerprints". This is voluntary data transfer to advertisers. If we send all sorts of data to websites/endpoints every time we make a simple HTTP request, then obviously that data is going to be used for something. The user generally has no legal/contractual control over how the data will be used. For example, the user may see ads as a result. Whereas if we keep requests brief and do not send heaps of gratuitous data, it stands to reason we would see less advertising, and certainly less targeted advertising.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoNo answers just a couple of downvotes. If cookies can be stolen, so can cookies that contain "device fingerprints". "Identity theft" keeps getting easier through no fault of the consumer.
- NoblePublius 5y ago“I’m not accusing Microsoft of having spied on users or abused its data-gathering capabilities.” I am. The changes to Windows over the last year are designed to do this. For starters, if you install Windows without a Microsoft account (which is only possible if you lie to Cortana during setup and click “I don’t have internet access”), the modals and update flows that pop up after you complete installation represent a dark UX pattern designed to make you create an account anyway. Windows has also been updated several times over the last year to default Edge over your preferred browser (going so far as to actually force the Edge icon onto your task bar AND desktop AND force you to go through a “set default browser as edge” flow). Most recently I was auto signed up for a news ans weather widget (with ads) on my taskbar. MacOS isn’t much better these days because even a brand new Mac is loaded with Apple Bloatware (do you want to pay for iCloud? Apple News? Apple TV+? Fitness? All music? All together in one package? Also here’s a new Finder format which defaults you to save to iCloud and hides your OneDrive).
- weinzierl 5y agoI'm using a RasPi running Debian as my daily driver at home. It works pretty well except that I have to solve way more captchas with it than with any other computer on my home network. Switching to a more common user agent recently helped only a little bit. At least that is what I believe, unfortunately I haven't done any measurements. It might well be that it helped not at all. The irony is also that I'm permanently signed in to more services on this computer than on any other one in my household and that it is the only computer where cookies don't get purged regularly. Also, I never used the RasPi for any automated tasks or anything else that could be interpreted as bot traffic. The worst offender is Yandex, which is pretty much unusable because it let's me solve the captcha every few mouse clicks. Any ideas how make a RasPi useable as a work computer?
- Inhibit 5y agoI use a allow-only javascript setup. I've found that for the web browsing I do that cuts out essentially all extraneous junk. YMMV.
- swiley 5y agoThat's pretty odd, I doubt it has anything to do with the architecture and more to do with weather or not you're logged into a Google account. I don't have a google account and use a desktop Linux-based OS on my phone. I have to solve the same captchas there as on my desktop.
- fddddd 5y agoi run non default browser settings (disable canvas and force my fonts) i see captcha everywhere. and try to avoid when i can. basically if it is a comercial site, bye. but gov sites are using it too now. from time to time i even get into captcha hellban. which should be criminal since they are used in gov sites. hellban is specially cruel as your entire IP is served the same 10 round of images infinitelly.
- aidenn0 5y agoI wonder how hard it would be to write a bot that would reliably hellban an IP. Then one could just drive around and get every open WiFi hellbanned.
- prussian 5y agoStarting to wonder if the techniques like those outlined in this article are why I'm constantly presented with a captcha asking if I'm a bot. I suppose the future is now.
- anakimluke 5y agoI couldn't figure how does the emoji image hashing works. Would somebody elucidate me?
- crazygringo 5y agoIs there really a ton of effort being put into anti-spoofing by websites? The examples of people trying to spoof are: > People or bots who want to get more elements specific to certain devices, or who want to break out of so-called ‘device ghettoes’ (eg they don’t want to have restricted possibilities due to being a mobile device) OK, but does the website owner really care if a tiny fraction of people do this? Restrictions by device are usually for performance and ease of use reasons. (And when content is limited to certain devices for legal reasons, like HDCP, this is accomplished with cryptography, not with device detection.) > Likewise, some threat actors want to take advantage of the fact that some security measures are not as tight for some devices. Seems like it would be better to patch the security hole instead? Or else deprecate support for old devices (e.g. stop serving HTTP, only HTTPS). Anti-spoofing seems like a terrible solution to security. > Who can stop people from utilizing device spoofing if a website cannot show captcha to mobile devices even if some rate limits are exceeded... Since when do CAPTCHA's not work on mobile devices? And if yours doesn't... switch to one that does? > or if a company offers specific discounts or products only to some types of devices? That's kind of a dark pattern anyways. I mean, the article's interesting, and device detection is (sadly) super-necessary for progressive enhancement, as feature detection doesn't work in every case -- but you can assume honest users in that case. If they spoof their user agent and the site breaks, then the problem's on them. But it seems a little bizarre to me to put development effort into anti-spoofing measures rather than addressing your actual problem directly. Is there a use case I'm missing where anti-spoofing really is the best or only possible approach?
- skybrian 5y agoIt’s not my area of expertise, but It seems like spoofed devices might be used for fraudulent ad clicks and companies like Google are going to devote substantial resources to defeating them. Also fake reviews. Who uses multilogin anyway?
- slugiscool99 5y agoYeah, would be interesting to see more examples of how spoofed devices are used nefariously. I'd bet people try to get around quotas or rate limits by spoofing different devices. Maybe ad fraud as well?
- gxs 5y agoMore and more the web is turning into cable TV. The other day youtube was showing me ads, without exaggerating, every ~20 seconds. This would happen for 3-4 minute stretches before they got less infrequent. This may not sound like much but when you're watching a 15 minute video they add up. I looked and looked for ways of blocking youtube ads on my iphone. Morality aside, what struck me when I looked into this wasn't that I specifically could not find software to block ads (which was disappointing), but rather the larger point that came across as I browsed forums looking for a solution - how hard it is to hack your devices - even android devices. Most articles ended up with having to root your device, which is fine, but even then the solutions were unreliable. Curious to see what ends up happening in the long term.
- vxNsr 5y agoAdguard will block 95% of YouTube ads on your iPhone for the time being, sometimes you’ll need to reload the page for the video to play, but for me at least that’s a better experience than 2 30sec ads
- _e 5y agoOn Android, people have reverse engineered the youtube app to eliminate ads -- https://vancedapp.com/ https://vancedapp.com/
- grugq 5y agoThere’s a paper that addresses this fundamental problem: https://www.freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/oakland2013-parrot.pdf https://www.freehaven.net/anonbib/cache/oakland2013-parrot.p... @inproceedings{oakland2013-parrot, title = {The Parrot is Dead: Observing Unobservable Network Communications}, author = {Amir Houmansadr and Chad Brubaker and Vitaly Shmatikov}, booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2013 IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy}, year = {2013}, month = {May}, www_pdf_url = {http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~amir/papers/parrot.pdf}, www_tags = {selected}, www_section = {Communications Censorship}, }
- fukd 5y agoBack in 2018 i crawled 200Million urls of single site by using just freely avilable proxies on the internet to evade rate limits. i do not think it can be repeated today. CDNs are blocking even my genuine requests.
- lykahb 5y ago> For example, Netflix supports hundreds of different video formats in various resolutions for each device, from mobile devices to smart TVs. Without device detection, how would that be possible? Device detection is different from content negotiation. This statement is similar to a statement that ignores the HTTP Accept-Language, and claims that location access is necessary to build internationalized websites.
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoI'm currently typing this on a build of Chromium 93 (official Chrome is at v91) running on Mac OS X Mavericks (released in 2013, incompatible with Chrome 69+), running on a self-built PC with an Intel 4790K. I replaced Mavericks's default AppleColorEmoji font with an updated version from Big Sur, but my system font is of course Lucida Grande. I have a working copy of Widevine. I would expect most websites to assume that my machine can't exist. But I don't have any problems with captchas.