5 ms·
Why does the HN headline say “landfill” while the original article says “artificial land”? To me “landfill” implies trash/refuse disposal and “artificial land”
by sokoloff 5y ago
Why does the HN headline say “landfill” while the original article says “artificial land”?
To me “landfill” implies trash/refuse disposal and “artificial land” implies infill of formerly wet/low areas. Not nearly all of the latter is the former.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- greyface- 5y agoThe URL slug says "landfill", too. The title was probably changed by the publication after it was published.
- Scoundreller 5y agoThe URL slug is fun. You can put whatever you want before and after the number and it redirects back to the original URL: For example this link redirects back to the OP's URL https://theweek.com/trump/murder/1001964/miami https://theweek.com/trump/murder/1001964/miami I always find CMSs lazy hacks for a clean URL fascinating.
- toast0 5y agoI've built these... The basic idea is you've got some canonical url that you'd love to have links to, but people (and tools) love to mess everything up, so whatever comes in, as long as it's got the number, gets 302'd to the right place and call it a day. I personally put the number as close to the domain as I can get away with, because the farther away it is, the more likely it is to be truncated, and I don't care how nice the partial URL looks, if it's missing the number, I can't get your content. And no, I'm not building it for just slugs no numbers, because I've seen what happens to those.
- tialaramex 5y ago> And no, I'm not building it for just slugs no numbers, because I've seen what happens to those. There was some poor site owner seeking assistance on the Let's Encrypt community site because (of course) even though they swear they haven't changed anything now mysteriously Let's Encrypt stopped working and so it must be a bug in Let's Encrypt. They're using http-01, so the magic files need to be exposed from a /.well-known/ directory and others have got them to try a test file named "test". When you ask for the test file though, what you get is a 30x redirect to some unrelated blog post. Well, it looks unrelated at first, and then what I realise is, that post is about Testimonials. Sure enough when I ask for a file named 'chris' instead I get redirected to a blog post about Christmas... I don't think that user ever figured out what their problem actually was, it's a little frustrating but you have to let them go do their thing.
- wumpus 5y agoI always thought it was to improve SEO in the face of headline rewrites?
- fortran77 5y agoTitle character limit. I posted the link and did my best.
- saltedonion 5y agoCould have remove the “the” or subbing American with “us” lol
- dragonwriter 5y agoI suspect the HN headline, the URL slug, an (from those two, I assume) the original source headline befoe a correction all result from someone using “landfill” where just “fill” or “fill land” (which is the relevant kind of “artificial land”) would have been accurate.
- fpoling 5y agoThe article implies it was sort-of landfill: This literal trash foundation is unfortunately how big parts of numerous American cities have been built.
- rsj_hn 5y agoNot only American cities. If you talk to any archeologist, they will attest that building cities on trash is common all over the world.
- caymanjim 5y agoSome of the oldest settlements in the world are literally trash heaps. There are tells all over the Middle East that are tens of meters tall, representing generations of trash piling up and built over.
- davidebaldini 5y agoTo my knowledge those accumulations of material are composed of eroded debris of adobe, mud or stone bricks from preexisting buildings or towns after centuries of erosion.
- antognini 5y agoIt's an unfortunate name collision, but landfill is frequently used to describe "artificial land" as well as a dump site.
- r00fus 5y agoI think it's on purpose for this article. They talk about "trash foundations". In this case, I feel building on wetlands is the bigger problem.
- ortusdux 5y agoIt seems to be a language issue. A 'landfill' is a trash dump, while 'land fill' is a form of reclamation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation
- initplus 5y agoArticle says that some reclaimed land was filled with literal dumped trash in the past. “At worst, they are made by throwing some dirt over the top of a pile of garbage, and building more city on top of it”
- swiley 5y agoThere current title is pretty confusing without a hyphen. Artificial-land problem? Or is it an Artificial land-problem caused by poor zoning (or is it both?)