12 ms·
The Miami condo collapse is a reminder of America's artificial land problem
- MattGaiser 5y agoThis seems highly speculative at this point.
- gumby 5y agoI don’t think so; the article correctly starts with the collapse but doesn’t jump to a single-issue conclusion, then cites notable other examples including the Kansas Osaka airport and San Francisco
- tolbish 5y agoThat was my initial reaction but the second paragraph makes the author's case.
- sokoloff 5y agoWhy does the HN headline say “landfill” while the original article says “artificial land”? To me “landfill” implies trash/refuse disposal and “artificial land” implies infill of formerly wet/low areas. Not nearly all of the latter is the former.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- greyface- 5y agoThe URL slug says "landfill", too. The title was probably changed by the publication after it was published.
- Scoundreller 5y agoThe URL slug is fun. You can put whatever you want before and after the number and it redirects back to the original URL: For example this link redirects back to the OP's URL https://theweek.com/trump/murder/1001964/miami https://theweek.com/trump/murder/1001964/miami I always find CMSs lazy hacks for a clean URL fascinating.
- toast0 5y agoI've built these... The basic idea is you've got some canonical url that you'd love to have links to, but people (and tools) love to mess everything up, so whatever comes in, as long as it's got the number, gets 302'd to the right place and call it a day. I personally put the number as close to the domain as I can get away with, because the farther away it is, the more likely it is to be truncated, and I don't care how nice the partial URL looks, if it's missing the number, I can't get your content. And no, I'm not building it for just slugs no numbers, because I've seen what happens to those.
- tialaramex 5y ago> And no, I'm not building it for just slugs no numbers, because I've seen what happens to those. There was some poor site owner seeking assistance on the Let's Encrypt community site because (of course) even though they swear they haven't changed anything now mysteriously Let's Encrypt stopped working and so it must be a bug in Let's Encrypt. They're using http-01, so the magic files need to be exposed from a /.well-known/ directory and others have got them to try a test file named "test". When you ask for the test file though, what you get is a 30x redirect to some unrelated blog post. Well, it looks unrelated at first, and then what I realise is, that post is about Testimonials. Sure enough when I ask for a file named 'chris' instead I get redirected to a blog post about Christmas... I don't think that user ever figured out what their problem actually was, it's a little frustrating but you have to let them go do their thing.
- wumpus 5y agoI always thought it was to improve SEO in the face of headline rewrites?
- fortran77 5y agoTitle character limit. I posted the link and did my best.
- saltedonion 5y agoCould have remove the “the” or subbing American with “us” lol
- dragonwriter 5y agoI suspect the HN headline, the URL slug, an (from those two, I assume) the original source headline befoe a correction all result from someone using “landfill” where just “fill” or “fill land” (which is the relevant kind of “artificial land”) would have been accurate.
- fpoling 5y agoThe article implies it was sort-of landfill: This literal trash foundation is unfortunately how big parts of numerous American cities have been built.
- rsj_hn 5y agoNot only American cities. If you talk to any archeologist, they will attest that building cities on trash is common all over the world.
- caymanjim 5y agoSome of the oldest settlements in the world are literally trash heaps. There are tells all over the Middle East that are tens of meters tall, representing generations of trash piling up and built over.
- davidebaldini 5y agoTo my knowledge those accumulations of material are composed of eroded debris of adobe, mud or stone bricks from preexisting buildings or towns after centuries of erosion.
- antognini 5y agoIt's an unfortunate name collision, but landfill is frequently used to describe "artificial land" as well as a dump site.
- r00fus 5y agoI think it's on purpose for this article. They talk about "trash foundations". In this case, I feel building on wetlands is the bigger problem.
- ortusdux 5y agoIt seems to be a language issue. A 'landfill' is a trash dump, while 'land fill' is a form of reclamation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation
- initplus 5y agoArticle says that some reclaimed land was filled with literal dumped trash in the past. “At worst, they are made by throwing some dirt over the top of a pile of garbage, and building more city on top of it”
- swiley 5y agoThere current title is pretty confusing without a hyphen. Artificial-land problem? Or is it an Artificial land-problem caused by poor zoning (or is it both?)
- melling 5y agoA landfill is where trash goes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landfill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landfill Parts of Boston and Manhattan are built on reclaimed land. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/Boston-landfill-maps-history https://www.nationalgeographic.com/culture/article/Boston-la... https://gizmodo.com/watch-new-york-city-s-boundaries-expand-over-250-years-496440467 https://gizmodo.com/watch-new-york-city-s-boundaries-expand-...
- ycom13__ 5y agoSame is true in the Netherlands
- ortusdux 5y agoPer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reclamation, landfill != land fill.
- slipframe 5y agoYou're correct and should not be downvoted: > Land reclamation, usually known as reclamation, and also known as land fill (not to be confused with a waste landfill)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rich_sasha 5y agoWarsaw in Poland is built on sand. Everything moves, buildings subside, but don’t collapse out of nowhere. Seems like building on unstable land is a bit of a solved problem. Of course very sorry for all the victims and their families, no matter what the root cause.
- throwawayboise 5y agoAgree. Unstable land/foundation may be a contributing factor but my guess is that shoddy/cheap concrete work will be the root cause.
- genocidicbunny 5y agoShoddy concrete work seems to be a running gag in the south. I had a related experience when the NOLA Hard Rock Cafe collapsed onto the street seconds after I walked down said street. It wouldn't surprise me if the concrete work in the collapsed condo was of a similar (lacking) level of quality.
- gerdesj 5y agoIf you mean this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1031_Canal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1031_Canal that is rather different - a non catastrophic, partial collapse of an unfinished structure. This was a catastrophic collapse of a well used structure. People died in both so please don't think I am trivialising the NOLA tragedy but it was different. When you use concrete in large amounts you take standard samples called cubes as you pour and these are subjected to standard tests. In the UK we use a 10x10x10 cm cube and then it's allowed to cure for a standard time in standard conditions and then crushed. There's a bit more to it than that but basically, it is quite easy to demonstrate "standard" concrete and there is not much money to be made with rubbish materials. There are exciting possibilities involving admixtures but that is down to workmanship. Shoddy concrete (whatever that is) is very unlikely but a popular meme. Conc. for a structure like that may be pre-stressed or at least reinforced. Pre stressed is where you put rods or creatively shaped steel through it and literally squeeze it. Conc is great in compression (pushed/squeezed) but rubbish in tension (pulled apart). Imagine a beam supported at both ends and think of pushing down on it in the middle. It will try to bend in a curve. The top surface will try to get smaller and hence is in compression and the bottom will try to stretch and is in tension. If you drill a hole along the length of your beam near the bottom and stick a steel rod through it and put some washers and nuts on and crank on some compression you now have a sort of model for pre stressed concrete. The steel rod is ace in tension and gives the concrete beam a lot more strength. Embedding steel mesh ("rebar" or reinforcement bars and the like) have a similar effect but ... The thing about pre stressing over adding mesh/rebar is that you are locking away a huge amount of energy into a static structure. There is a huge gain to be had in reduced thickness of conc and hence weight which means its a double win but you also need to ensure that the "rods" (in our model, not quite reality) never fail. If they do fail then it's normally rapid not just a gradual fail. The effect of prestressing can happen by accident in "normal" meshed conc. Most digger drivers that have used a pile driver attachment to break large chunks of conc. will have tales to tell of large lumps of conc suddenly exploding. Fishermen often tell tales of the one that got away ... 8) However it can happen. So I hope I've shown that shoddy concrete itself is unlikely. There are far more ways for a structure to fail than that. Workmanship is possible but for my money the ground basically dropped away from under the structure and it sort of exploded and imploded simultaneously. I can't put this any other way but it seemed to fail completely in every way possible, simultaneously. It is the most horrible thing to watch and will haunt us forever.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- saltedonion 5y agoIt’s probably more likely that salt air corroded the steel rebars. This is a known issue.
- tomarr 5y agoIs it? Spalling is usually noticed a lot more, you would probably see some yielding or signs of progressive collapse first. The pictures I have seen make foundational failure look more likely.
- saltedonion 5y agohttps://www.wsj.com/articles/what-we-know-about-the-miami-area-building-collapse-11624563665?st=c43h3sccam79low&reflink=article_copyURL_share https://www.wsj.com/articles/what-we-know-about-the-miami-ar... Talks about it in this article
- piinbinary 5y agoDo building designs have to be certified in a way similar to how cars have to be crash-tested?
- Rapzid 5y agoYes
- cardiffspaceman 5y agoI believe a Professional Engineer with correct certification has to sign off on if you go above two stories, before the authorities will allow it to be built.
- ska 5y agoThis is all jurisdictional of course, but typically something like that. More complex the project, the more levels of review.
- Shadonototro 5y agoit's none of that it's people preferred to still profit as much as possible from this dying building instead of renovating/repairing it that is what you get for building a civilization where profit has higher priority than safety of your people
- fennecfoxen 5y agoWho exactly is profiting? It's a condo building, you understand, and most units were owner-occupied. Upkeep was paid by the tenants as part of their condo dues. This is organized by the condo's board, an entity which is operated for the benefit of the condo owners. At best you could say, "These residents lacked foresight," but that doesn't really support your premise that capitalism caused this. Having an ideological axe to grind like this one is a major risk to your intellectual integrity. It can blind you to reality, or worse, it can make it so you don't actually care what is real anymore.
- Shadonototro 5y agoThe people who knew about it and didn't engage with renovations They knew about it and let it happen so insurance can help them with financial support The result of the investigation will be: "natural cause" > Having an ideological axe to grind like this one is a major risk to your intellectual integrity. It can blind you to reality, or worse, it can make it so you don't actually care what is real anymore. Yup yup, i am so blind that i don't even have to work anymore, i abused this civilization and made insane profits, i no longer have to worry about needing money anymore Yup yup, i am blind, i don't care waht is real anymore Yup yup, enjoying my life as a king in thailand
- fennecfoxen 5y ago> They knew about it Again, you're positing this shadowy "they" who somehow saved a lot of money — but the building was owned by the people who lived there, and I'm pretty sure if the condo owners actually knew about the renovations that needed doing, they'd have spent the money to make the repairs, rather than getting crushed to death in their sleep. There is no one enjoying ill-gotten gains here. > Yup yup, enjoying my life as a king in thailand I see. A tyrant.
- Scoundreller 5y agoI’m going to wait for AvE’s foul-mouthed explanation of what happened before listening to anyone else’s. Here’s his video on Miami’s bridge collapse in 2018: https://youtu.be/KtiTm2dKLgU https://youtu.be/KtiTm2dKLgU Written about here: https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/fiu-bridge-collapse-mystery-explained-by-foul-mouthed-canadian-youtuber-10186504 https://www.miaminewtimes.com/news/fiu-bridge-collapse-myste...
- slipframe 5y agoI hope Tyler Ley does a video about it. He's a professor at Oklahoma State University who's all about concrete. He did a video about the I35 bridge collapse a few years ago that was pretty good: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57pi53hBByA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57pi53hBByA His video production quality is a little rough, but nonetheless his videos are quite interesting. I never knew concrete was so fascinating before coming across his channel.
- dboreham 5y agoThe Italian cable car analysis video was excellent.
- djmips 5y agoThat one seemed rather blatant. I was shocked to hear a mechanic disabled the emergency brakes!
- unearth3d 5y agoThere's usually a man in the middle, like the CTV building in Christchurch NZ; the engineer was a severe bully, and no one challenged him. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CTV_Building https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CTV_Building, for quick reading go-to Royal Commission.
- doggodaddo78 5y agoI haven't heard of any major collapses in Foster City. Plenty of fill there. The only collapse in recent memory was a section of SF that liquified in an earthquake. Maybe all buildings over 3 stories need more frequent and detailed periodic structural fatigue/engineering assessments, eh?
- fennecfoxen 5y agoI seem to remember Foster City being mostly short single-family homes, two stories, maybe three at the most. There might have been one or two apartment complexes, but not tall condos like this one.
- dyingkneepad 5y agoLet's start some conspiracy theory fake news right here right now: Big Condo took down this building down so the value of every property around it would plummet for a few years, giving them the opportunity to buy everything around it and sell years later when the value moves back to normal. Let's see how long it takes until my aunt shares this with me over Facebook :).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 5y agoMiami Beach is at sea level. It already floods during high tides. There aren't too many years of property value left.
- ehw3 5y agoFrankly this is a pastime of mine. Whenever anything even vaguely mysterious comes up in the news I make up conspiracy theories to tell my wife and laugh about, always leaving it slightly vague how serious I might be, just to keep her on her toes. :)
- sonicggg 5y agoWhat's the point of reclaiming land in a country that has vast amounts of land to be used, like the US? I can understand why Singapore does it.
- massysett 5y agoThe vast amounts of land are in boring locations, like Kansas prairie, not near the beach in Miami.
- rsj_hn 5y agoA good chunk of San Francisco -- and the entire SF Bay area -- is landfill used to expand the size of the city. When they built the metro subway going under market street they discovered a shipwreck and bulldozed through it. There's also a bar - The Old Ship Saloon - built inside a shipwreck https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-old-ship-saloon-san-francisco-california https://www.atlasobscura.com/places/the-old-ship-saloon-san-... All of Mission Bay and the Marina used to be underwater: https://www.smallcarbigtimetours.com/san-franciscos-original-shoreline/ https://www.smallcarbigtimetours.com/san-franciscos-original...
- ghaff 5y agoMuch of Boston is also land fill. The original part of central Boston (basically Beacon Hill and the North End) was all but an island only connected to other land by a thin isthmus.
- cardiffspaceman 5y agoLocation. It's no different from Singapore. The people accomodated by any reclaimed land of Singapore could always go somewhere else.
- ska 5y agoAll land is not of equal value. Coastal land near ports and rivers, is particularly rare.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago2mm/year sounds like a very small number to me... compared to eg. thermal expansion during day/night and summer/winter cycles, that is practically zero, and even after 40 years of sinking, surely there'd be massive warning signs (eg. growing cracks) before such a collapse.
- tmh88j 5y ago> surely there'd be massive warning signs (eg. growing cracks) before such a collapse. There were. I'm not a civil/structural engineer and I don't know how common this kind of thing is. > One condo owner sued the unit association for failing to fix the cracks in the outside wall of her unit in 2015, according to a lawsuit filed in Miami-Dade County. The condo owner, who could not be reached for comment, said the cracks led to water damage that cost $15,000. The court documents noted that because the cracks were a structural issue the building association was liable for the expense. > The condo owner had previously filed a lawsuit against the building association in 2001 due to a similar issue. The two sides settled outside of court, but that kind of cracking is described as “of interest” in the county’s Structural Recertification Form. I read another article about a resident complaining about cracking near the pool deck. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/cause-miami-condo-collapse-unclear-experts-say-barrier-islands-present-n1272316 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/cause-miami-condo-colla...
- btilly 5y agoThe problem is that the 2mm is probably not even over the building. If one corner is subsiding significantly more than the other, eventually one corner of the building is being held up by shear forces from the rest of the building. But concrete isn't very good with handling shear stress. So then it breaks, drops, hits the ground and you have a building collapse.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tzs 5y agoFrom aerial photographs, the building appears to be about 100m in its longest horizontal dimension. It was 12 stories tall, so maybe 40m? Assuming it was made with a steel frame, then the expansion going from that area's record low temperature to its record high temperature would be about 40mm horizontal and about 16mm vertical. Presumably it was designed to handle that, with a decent safety margin. That is indeed much more than the 2mm it was sinking each year. But wait...the temperature swings of the frame, and other interior parts of the building, is going to be a lot less than the outside temperature. That's going to cut that 40mm horizontal and 16mm vertical expansion way down. Also normal thermal expansion alternates with normal thermal contraction, so wouldn't it average out to close to zero net movement over the course of each year, with a small net expansion due to climate change (Florida average temperature is up under 0.5℃ since that building was built)? Sinking, on the other hand, is usually cumulative. 2mm/year over 40 years is 80mm. So you've got a building designed to expand and contract, staying within some range, having a net vertical movement imposed on it that is a lot larger, and probably a lot less uniform.
- rmason 5y agoThe collapse may be as much a local government failure as anything else. The building was constructed in 1981. By the early nineties scientists found the building was sinking at what they called an 'alarming' rate. What was the problem? Local government rules stated that foundations were inspected every forty years. So the first inspection of this building was 2021 and had just begun when it collapsed. Why not inspect building foundations every twenty years (or sooner) if significant sinking was found?
- gerdesj 5y ago"The building was constructed in 1981 ... building was sinking" Sinking isn't always a problem - look at Venice! I studied Civ Eng at Plymouth Poly (now a university, Devon not MA) back in 1989ish. Back then concrete cancer was all the rage ... and gabions (but I digress.) The failure of the building in Miami was catastrophic and not gradual. I don't think that monitoring would have worked but it is possible that stresses/strains built up over time - we'll have to wait and see. If it was gradual then there is a good argument in favour of fitting buildings like that with strain gauges as many bridges are. I do a lot of IoT stuff and I estimate that something like £20,000 would get you strain gauges and a monitoring system for a structure like that. It might be £10,000 or £100,000 but a building that size in Miami is worth quite a lot. I'll bet rent on a flat was something like $2,000pm or more. Inspection of foundations is a tricky one. I am not a Civil Engineer but I trained for it but I don't have X ray eyes and nor do Miami's engineers. That's absolutely the wrong way to go about this sort of thing. I'm not even sure what an "inspection" even means. There was a fundamental error made at the initial design stage in my opinion. I don't know what but probably relating to the parameters of the ground that was built on. By that I mean that the architects/struct engrs. were promised certain properties of the geotechnics/geophysics - that basically means they were told how the ground would work in holding their structure up. When you design a structure, it needs to support itself and crucially, the thing it sits on needs to be able to support that structure. You also have to work to a timespan, so you use standard tables for wind strength, earthquake etc. You work to a 1 in n years events. This building collapsed catastrophically in seconds without warning. I think this will become a real lesson for Civ Eng and not a simple "I told you so" thing and certainly not "shit concrete".
- musicale 5y agoReminds me of San Francisco's massive liquefaction zone.
- grp000 5y agoIs that related to the Millennium Tower sinking?
- dredmorbius 5y agoYes. Much of the Financial District / SOMA are on fill. Pictured in red on this map, generally the north and eastern sides of the city. https://escweb.wr.usgs.gov/nsmp-data/Presentations/san_francisco_array/san_francisco_array_map.gif https://escweb.wr.usgs.gov/nsmp-data/Presentations/san_franc...
- gerdesj 5y ago"Big chunks of American cities are built on man-made land that is a climate catastrophe waiting to happen" I live in Somerset, UK. Just north of where I live is the "Somerset Levels". About 400 years ago a bunch of cloggies (Dutchmen) were engaged to drain the marginal lands for farm land etc. King's Sedgemoor Drain was built later etc. This is the land of Glastonbury (the festival actually happens at a farm in Pilton). The Neths have centuries of experience of dealing with marginal lands. Your swamps are not going to faze them any more than ours.
- virtuabhi 5y agoDefinitely, "Neths" spread their engineering across many continents. However, their engineering practices are now considered a prime reason behind the environment catastrophe that many cities like New Orleans are facing.
- brnt 5y agoThey are not. The prima reason that many cities like N. O. are failing is poor engineering practices. Dutch companies even offered free consulting after Katrina, which was refused by the Americans. Now, many poorer places cannot afford the measures that are taken in the Netherlands (if you ever live in Amsterdam and are annoyed with your watership bill, be happy that it is used to fund your continued dry feet!). Americans however seem to not want to pay for it, and seem to not want to understand what sustainable watermanagement and new land develooment is like. Hurricanes are bad, but they don't need to be Katrina-bad.
- gerdesj 5y agoPlease feel free to cite some sources or give details. Engineering solutions rarely cause climate change. I'll grant you that enough concrete pouring might be nasty but I doubt a very small country in Europe, next door to Germany is responsible for all of it. Piss off.
- vernie 5y agoEvery story is a climate story huh?
- mempko 5y agoTurns out the climate doesn't care about borders and kind of affects everything in our lives.
- mtnGoat 5y agoI wonder how this collapse is going to affect insurance rates for other buildings build on terribly unstable land. Engineers are well aware of this risk, but now that it’s happening and it’s real, they will calculate it differently, I think.
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoInsurance is an industry that's usually driven by real data. So the likelihood of claims just went up for all similar buildings. This translates pretty directly into increases in premiums, or even cancellation of policies. This is true for areas that are earthquake or fire-prone. But especially areas that are vulnerable to sea-level rise due to climate change. If nobody else is going to act, on climate-change (act = change how they do business), it will certainly be the Insurance companies who will act. They have a great deal to lose. And they do not profit by buying in to the big lie.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThis would make for very interesting and worthwhile applied economics research.
- science4sail 5y agoWouldn't an alternative approach be price caps on insurance policies and/or government subsidies for insurance in these areas? Those options might not be economically viable, but they would be politically popular. Example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Program https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Flood_Insurance_Progr...
- dredmorbius 5y agoI don't see liability caps as the sensible approach here. Liability caps are used in specific instances where losses might otherwise prove catastrophic to the insurer. The two areas which come immediately to mind (and no, I'm not versed in the industry though I did in fact study it, lightly, in school), are major disaster property insurance (flood, hurricane, earthquake), and liability caps (general liability, medical malpractice). Both are specific to how insurance works, at least in theory. The most usual basis of insurance is risk pooling, largely for uncorrelated and individual risks. Premiums covering house fires, automobile property and liability damage, workplace injury, or shipping, tend to cover (from the perspective of the insurer) relative small claims which tend to occur predictably and independently. Where caps are imposed, either predictability or correlation tend to be less manageable. The insurance sector has long lobbied against tort policies favouring claimants, and argued that tort liability claims have been skyrocketing. I studied the tort liability crisis of the 1980s in particular, and have kept an eye on this issue in the decades since. In truth, the 1980s crisis owed far more to the inflation surge, and remission, of the late 1970s and early 1980s. With inflation came higher (nominal) returns on investment returns, which is where insurance companies invest premium payments pending payouts. While the industry was screaming "out of control court judgements", the reality seemed far more to be one of getting whipsawed by the (pre-inflation) pricing of policies, the (high investment returns) period of low premium rates (subsidised in effect by investment returns), and under the Volker inflation controls and tight-money policies, falling investment returns whilst claims increased, largely in step with inflation. Caps on payments would in this case address the inflation/investment risk side of the business. Correlated claims is the other situation. Individual risks --- automobile crashes, house fires, accidents, structural collapses --- tend to be independent of one another. In major widespread events, a large number of correlated claims occur, and can stress the capabilities of even large insurers or the industry as a whole. Floods, earthquakes, hurricanes, major wildfires, tsunamis, ice storms, and drought can affect large areas, ranging from major portions of a single city to regional or continental regions. Though the events are distributed across time, when they occur, they occur everywhere at once, at least within the affected region. Payouts in this case require limitation. Virtually all insurance policies include exclusions for acts of war or civil disturbance. As with natural disaster, these occur in unpredictable and widespread manners, and are poorly handled by commercial insurance. Depending on the underlying mechanism for the Surfside building collapse, there might or might not be correlated risks. If the principle cause is in fact climate-induced geological undermining which could affect large low-lying coastal regions, then yes, it's possible that those zones could simply become uninsurable. If the principle cause is poor building methods or design, then the risks would be limited to, say, construction by the contractors or designs by the architects in question. If the principle cause is poor maintenance and inspection processes, then the risks would apply to the specific geopolitical domains affected by those inspections. Surfside, Miami-Dade County, or the State of Florida as a whole might be affected. Here it's likely that the insurance industry, through property owners and residents / tenants of such buildings would be able to impose reforms to the inspection and remediation processes, which gets at another mechanism of insurance itself: of actively managing and mitigating risks, not merely pooling them.
- Nasrudith 5y agoThese types of articles strike me as downright ghoulish - shoving in their pet cause well before the facts have been established. It would be one thing to say make an article listing potential hypotheses but I find the blend of speculation and advocacy is deeply offputting.
- williesleg 5y agoNo surprise it dropped into the ocean. When are you going to learn america?
- djrogers 5y agoHey, this horrible thing that happened might be related to something I’m on a soapbox about, so I’m going to rush to judgement and point fingers. As long as it helps my narrative, I don’t need to wait for ‘facts’.
- joering2 5y agoSerious question: 40,000 lbs bomb exploded by Navy few days ago close to FL shore, wouldn't that kind of underwater shockwave speedup the process of building deterioration? "The United States Geological Survey recorded the explosion as a 3.9 magnitude earthquake about 161 kilometers off the coast of Florida." https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/whoa-u-s-navy-releases-footage-of-40000-pound-bomb-explosion-off-east-coast/ https://www.wavy.com/news/military/navy/whoa-u-s-navy-releas...
- ergwwrt 5y agoClear the rubble, run a seismic radar, detect any airpockets, install constant underground radar across the entire island, create a museum on the site educating locals about geology/sinkholes. You can have the best engineers in the world, more frequent inspections, but if the foundation is ignored it will not matter.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kanyewestmerch 5y agoKanye west Merch Official Shop for real fans and Jesus is king merch. Get up to 50% discounts on all Hoodies. Fast Shipping around the world. https://www.kanyewestmerchandise.net/ https://www.kanyewestmerchandise.net/
- dredmorbius 5y agoI've gone back and forth on leaving this comment, but my fundamental concern is that it is far too early to be drawing conclusions about the likely cause of this incident especially for anyone pushing a specific agenda, regardless of how much one might agree (or disagree) with that agenda. Clearly, there are a set of previously underappreciated risks here. Geology is very much a possible candidate, though other factors might also be at stake. Armchair analysis at a distance and with a specific cause to advance is probably the worst addition to the discussion at this point. (That's not to say that causes aren't often fairly immediately evident, as with, say, the 737 MAX incidents. But without clear basis for belief, even hunches eventually proved correct are unfounded conclusions.)
- fortran77 5y agoMy first thought, too. He's blaming it on "climate change." I'm certainly no climate change denier, but the real immediate cause of this collapse could just be substandard engineering and maintenance.
- watertom 5y agoMiami has been very lucky when it comes to hurricanes. I wonder how Miami fares if they take a direct hit from an Andrew force hurricane, or a hurricane that drops 40+ inches of rain?
- echoradio 5y agoThis is a grit-your-teeth issue every time a storm comes near, especially with the building boom in South Florida (Palm Beach, Broward, Miami-Dade Counties). Before Hurricane Andrew hit in 1992, the region had not been impacted by a significant storm in years and there was a very lax attitude toward building codes. Many places built in the 1980s we’re not always constructed with the most sound practices [1], builders were taking shortcuts and local government turned a blind eye to the issue. Andrew changed everyone’s thinking after the “new” neighborhood of CountryWalk was flattened [2]. Some of the strictest building codes in the nation were implemented — and enforced — after Andrew. But the lax attitude has returned. For instance, in the past decade, I’ve seen new multi-level residential buildings constructed with wood (instead of concrete) above the second floor, wondering how such construction even receives approval given the building code. But it is happening, and the majority non-native, transient population has no clue the overpriced real estate they’ve purchased may not be suited to handle a major storm. They will face a reckoning if this day ever comes. I would advise anyone looking to buy down here to do your due diligence. Hire a good inspector and engineer to examine your potential purchase, as well as a lawyer to make sure all repairs or improvements were all done above board. [1] https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/miami-beach/article252385083.html https://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/community/miami-dade/... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Country_Walk,_Florida#History https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Country_Walk,_Florida#Histor...
- cafard 5y agoBack in the 1970s, the author John MacDonald, best know for his Travis McGee mysteries, wrote the novel Condominium, about a badly-built condominium building on the Florida coast. It was made into a TV movie in the early 1980s. I didn't read the book, and only saw a trailer for the movie, but my recollection was that a hurricane was the instrument of the disaster. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/937723.Condominium https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/937723.Condominium
- Hstylesmerch 5y agoHarry Styles Official Merch Store For real Harry Styles fans. Get Amazing Harry Styles Hoodies, SweatShrits, Tshirts and more. UPTO 50% OFF https://www.hstylesmerch.net/ https://www.hstylesmerch.net/