4 ms·
my input is that I've been involved with GRAIL since the beginning and I think they've actually done something. We don't have the data to say one way or the o
by dekhn 5y ago
my input is that I've been involved with GRAIL since the beginning and I think they've actually done something. We don't have the data to say one way or the other.
I am not arguing with most of your points, it's just that you're not being epistemically humble. I find it's far better to just act humble even when you aare schooling people who persist on believing in magic.
- jacquesm 5y agoFair enough. I sincerely hope that this test will drive down the cost of testing and that they will get the kinks ironed out, I think it is a major development and I'm actually afraid that those that oversell it will cause it to end up being tainted, as has happened with many other cancer related diagnostics and potential treatments. Cancer seems to bring out an emotional response rather than a rational one, typically because almost all of us have direct knowledge of one or more people in our environment that succumbed to it. A lot of work has been done since this development was first announced and there are still quite a few kinks that will need to be ironed out. The whole idea - such as promoted in this thread by some - that this makes cancer a matter of 'simply looking at the right organ' is so laughably oversimplifying reality that some balance is required, and I think at some point my irritation got the better of me. So thank you for pointing that out. And to add to that: It definitely is not my intention to suggest that this test is without value.