4 ms·
> It turns out that Google's knowledge graph algorithm somehow falsely associated my photo with the Wikipedia article about the serial killer. Which is also sur
by tzs 5y ago
> It turns out that Google's knowledge graph algorithm somehow falsely associated my photo with the Wikipedia article about the serial killer. Which is also surprisingly strange because my name isn't special or unique at all; there are literally hundreds of other people with my name, and despite of all that, my personal photo ended up being associated with a serial killer. I can't really explain to myself how this happened, but it's weird. In any case, I am now in the process of reporting this Knowledge Graph bug to Google.
I believe that there is a simpler explanation.
The Wikipedia article is there in that side box because it is the top hit for "hristo georgiev" on Google's main search page. The picture is there because it is the top hit for "hristo georgiev" on Google's image search page.
- inimino 5y agoYes, but: the text snippet is clearly labeled "Wikipedia" and is in the same box with the photo. Combined with the Wikipedia article being the first result, this would certainly give the average person casually searching the impression that the data in the box comes from Wikipedia, which tends to be a reasonably accurate, conservative source on living persons. The idea of mashing up the first image search result with the wikipedia snippet with no indication they are from totally unrelated sources seems pretty careless and irresponsible.
- hermitdev 5y agoOne might be so inclined to label Google a peddler of fabricated misinformation... I seriously can't believe that the sources of the image and text aren't labeled with their respective sources. Doing so seems basic, obvious and trivial. Not doing so seems to be a blatant attempt to hide expected inaccuracies and make meaningless combinations of information seem more authoritative than it actually is. While I think this individual would have a hard time in any court system, let alone the US court system, could Wikipedia perhaps have a claim of damages for libel (or something to this effect) due to misattributed information and reputational damage?
- Breza 5y agoWikipedia is taking a different approach to Google et al scraping their data. They're creating a for-profit spinoff to sign licensing deals.
- joe_the_user 5y ago"That explanation is the same explanation" Or rather, all the knowledge graphic does is stuff not much more complicated than associate picture to name to article. But what is pernicious is that presents itself as a knowledge graph and sometimes appears to have knowledge and so it seems to people to be a somewhat authoritative statement. And that causes people not-critically-thinking people to reach false and destructive beliefs.
- cwkoss 5y agoThat the explanation is simple doesn't make the result any less obscenely defamatory.