13 ms·
This article is heavy on quotes but very light on actual data. This is a trend that I see in media (mainstream and otherwise), where they take something that is
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
This article is heavy on quotes but very light on actual data. This is a trend that I see in media (mainstream and otherwise), where they take something that is by nature very difficult to study, find some researchers or limited studies that fit their narrative, and then report it as gospel. It's really not that hard as a reporter to essentially start with the conclusion you want to end with and then to back into that with cherry picking supporting research.
And I really take issue with the racial angle that feels like it is basically part of every single NYT article these days. A lot of the issues reported here feel valid, but just zooming back out (maybe pun intended?) for a second, this reporter seems to be arguing that actual face-to-face interactions are so fraught with racism that minorities need to be "protected" by remote work to be on equal footing. If that is the case then we should address the root cause, not put everyone in their home office "safe space".
And to clarify, I'm not even commenting on the pros/cons of in-person interactions. I'm just commenting on yet another media piece that cherry picks some research and quotes to make their own opinion sound like it has more backing than it actually does.
- sneak 5y agoIt bothers me a lot that the paper of record has declined so much in quality since I’ve been watching. As someone who loves New York and worked every day right across 40th st, it hurts my heart.
- wonderwonder 5y agoI think all forms of journalism essentially started to die as soon as pay per click marketing was created. Its all just a war for eyeballs and ad dollars now; content is irrelevant outside of those parameters.
- throwkeep 5y agoTo illustrate how easy it is to inject a racial angle into anything, here's Brandeis University on why "picnic" is oppressive language: https://www.brandeis.edu/parc/accountability/oppressivelanguagelist_violent.html https://www.brandeis.edu/parc/accountability/oppressivelangu... [edit] They just removed it. Here's what they had previously: https://archive.is/NR0Zj https://archive.is/NR0Zj
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoLol, even the phrase "Trigger warning" is too triggering!
- lallysingh 5y agoPicnic's not on the list?
- bumbledraven 5y agoIt’s in a snapshot from earlier today: https://archive.is/NR0Zj https://archive.is/NR0Zj > The term picnic is often associated with lynchings of Black people in the United States, during which white spectators were said to have watched while eating, referring to them as picnics or other terms involving racial slurs against Black people.
- mattbk1 5y agoSnopes disagrees, maybe why they removed it: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/picnic-origin/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/picnic-origin/
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThe "rule of thumb" etymology is also bullshit but it's still there: https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-1998-04-17-1998107056-story.html https://www.baltimoresun.com/news/bs-xpm-1998-04-17-19981070...
- lallysingh 5y agoReading that, it wasn't established last, but I didn't find any other definition for that term in the article. I'm pretty groggy, did I miss it?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
- ferdowsi 5y agoHallway conversations are exclusionary by their very nature. It's biased towards extroverts who have access to the physical levers of having their ideas heard (location, same office space). It encourages the loudest, most gregarious, most "in" people in the room to spread their ideas above others.
- stcredzero 5y agoIntroverts are supposed to be better at quieter, more deeply introspective one on one conversations. That's a different class of serendipitous face to face interactions, but one which may be just as valuable, or even more so. Think Lex Friedman in a one-on-one vs. Joe Rogan with 2 guests at the same time.
- sergiomattei 5y ago...then what do you want? If introverts aren't voicing their ideas, what are we supposed to do, read minds?
- regularfry 5y agoPivot to a written-first culture. It's the natural endpoint of remote orgs.
- throwaway98797 5y agodoesn’t that hurt folks who aren’t great at writing?
- andrewflnr 5y agoWriting is a skill that can be learned. You don't need to write deathless prose, just be clear.
- alisonkisk 5y agoSo is speaking.
- hnews_account_1 5y agoThere is only one agenda in this article, which is that return to work is an oppressive measure imposed by CEOs on employees. The NYT writes exactly what will sell. You and I are simply not its audience. The racism etc is just being co opted. They want all their middle income job readers to feel comforted by the arguments made and studies cited. It's a shitty transition to go back to an office. I'm sure a lot of workplaces are going to abuse that notion and provide very bad workspaces. But you generalize on scale for such topics only when you know your audience is absolutely not discerning.
- kesselvon 5y agoIt might be the narrative but it's not incorrect. It's just another front in the continual war between labor and management
- spookthesunset 5y ago“Labor vs. management?” Tech workers get paid salaries that literally put them in the 1% income bracket. Like give me a break people. We do work. Work isn’t all roses and sunshine. I always suspected tech people live in an extremely privileged bubble but holy cow did this last year really open my eyes to how detached they are.
- mkr-hn 5y agoThe highest paid tech worker is still closer in class to the janitor than they are to the VCs paying their salary, even if they think themselves better than both.
- gnicholas 5y agoIt's true that the salary of a tech worker making $400k/yr is closer to that of a janitor making $40k/yr than it is to a VC making $4m/yr. However, the lifestyle of the $400k/yr worker is probably closer in most important aspects to that of the VC than the janitor. Both drive expensive cars, live in expensive houses, and can set up their kids for success. They don't worry about the cost of food (even organic/local/etc.) or worry much about health care. Put another way, there are probably some $40k/yr janitors who would give their left arms to be making $400k/yr. But I doubt there are any $400k/yr tech workers who would give their left arm to be making $4m/yr.
- kbuchanan 5y agoWholeheartedly agree. I can't help but feel with each new article like this that many journalists are watching _their own WFH opportunities_ slip from their fingers. (FWIW, I'm a fan of fully remote companies; this article just doesn't pass as anything but opinion.)
- spookthesunset 5y agoWork is work, my dudes. And in a tech company that means teamwork and collaboration. I don’t care what anybody says, zoom and slack are not even remotely close to face to face interactions. Sure it may not always seem that way to a developer who just wants to write code and not care about anything else, but there are lots of important roles besides developer in any tech company worth its weight. Not many of those roles are very amenable to working from home full time. Even developers working on a team, I’d argue, can't contribute 100% working purely from home. Good developers do way more than just write code. They mentor, help shape the product with UX and business people, etc. All that requires face time. If devs want to work remote, I highly recommend becoming a contractor / consultant. Remote and contract work go together like peas and carrots. You get fed largely spec’d work, don’t really need to care about office politics, etc… There are plenty of cons… you also become your own collection agency cause dudes can take months paying you. But if remote is what you want, contracting is the best. Anyway, this became kind of a ramble.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI cannot agree with your thesis. There are fully remote companies (using Zoom and Slack primarily) with hundreds of people generating well over $100M in ARR worth billions of dollars. You are free to your opinion, but the data doesn’t support your conclusion. Teamwork and collaboration can and does work fully remote, whether you’re in engineering, bizops, product, or customer experience. Entire legacy enterprises went remote virtually overnight due to COVID and continued to hum along for well over 15 months. Remote skills are the new “computer skills.” If your org sucks, yeah, remote isn’t going to work. That’s not an issue with a remote operating model, it’s because your org sucks to begin with (whether that’s due to ineffective line managers, failure of executive leadership to cultivate the appropriate culture, what have you). If your org sucks, I recommend voting with your feet.
- LordHumungous 5y agoYeah and we still have video conferencing in remote world. I'm not sure why racism would cease to be an issue over zoom.
- truffdog 5y agoDo people still turn their video on? I feel like it has been months for my team.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoDoes it require scientific study? If your company has their shit together then they already have data on how this affects their bottom line. Ask the people who work in that area then. It's not "science" but it's not useless either.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Does it require scientific study? Yes. There are smart people with compelling anecdotes on both sides of the debate.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI was more talking about the article itself. Does it require a scientific study to poll experts and distill into an article?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI think it's a good thing to study it scientifically, but also to be extremely conservative in the application of results. Some very thorny problems just off the top of my head: 1. Monitoring/counting "spontaneous interactions" is extremely difficult. 2. Simple "counting" of spontaneous interactions seems like exactly the wrong approach, because one would probably expect that 99% of interactions would be mundane but then 1% would be important. 3. How do you define "innovation"? 4. One might suspect that the benefits of in-person interaction would show up on longer timescales rather than shorter timescales. For example, this article is long on pointing out that how in-person interactions can be detrimental to minorities and women, but my opinion (not fact, just opinion) is that basically all of my closest business connections were formed in person. Now that I'm late in my career remote vs. in-person is not as critical to me because I have a strong network, but right out of college it was critical, and my career would have suffered greatly had I not forged those relationships early. I got every single one of my jobs after my first through my network that started in my first job (not necessarily directly, but often times through the "hey, I heard from someone they are looking for XYZ, and I heard you might be looking" channel).
- dougSF70 5y agoKarl Popper would be disappointed with this journalistic approach.
- robscallsign 5y ago> This article is heavy on quotes but very light on actual data. This is a trend that I see in media (mainstream and otherwise), where they take something that is by nature very difficult to study, find some researchers or limited studies that fit their narrative, and then report it as gospel. Sounds a lot like masks.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI know you are trolling, but it's basically the exact opposite of masks, which (now) have lots of data supporting their effectiveness, and which are much more easily studied (i.e. the outcome you are looking for, e.g. "got Covid or didn't", is much more concrete than looking for "innovation"). If you care to open your eyes the data is easily locatable from reputable sources online. One overview article: https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02801-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-02801-8
- commandlinefan 5y ago> basically part of every single NYT article these days I don't even click on NYT articles any more (and no, I didn't read this article either, just curious about the comment section).
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoThis has been a trend for a long time, five W’s reporting is time consuming and expensive it seems, so it’s been mostly replaced by opinion pieces and human interest stories.
- stcredzero 5y agoThis article is heavy on quotes but very light on actual data. Here's the thing: Data on serendipitous meetings is going to exist primarily in the form of anecdotes! Fundamentally. And I really take issue with the racial angle that feels like it is basically part of every single NYT article these days. A lot of the issues reported here feel valid, but just zooming back out (maybe pun intended?) for a second, this reporter seems to be arguing that actual face-to-face interactions are so fraught with racism that minorities need to be "protected" by remote work Historically, here's how it has worked throughout history: To break into a field as a member of an under-represented identity group in that field, you had to be "So good, they can't ignore you." In fact, there are many areas of human endeavor where "So good, they can't ignore you," is just the regular price of entry. It is, in fact, the standard price of entry for those entities known as "startups." Is this, in an absolute sense, fair? No. There are always going to be proxies to actual merit used in evaluation. That's just the reality of how non-omniscient beings work. We can only strive to make things as fair and accurate as we can. That certainly does not mean seeing that the lever is thrown one way, then wrenching the lever the other way. The lever needs to be changed from being a dumb lever and hooked up to meaningful data.
- wolverine876 5y ago> And I really take issue with the racial angle that feels like it is basically part of every single NYT article these days. Maybe racial issues are that present? Should the NYT hide them or report them? Many believe (without putting too fine a point on who) racism has always been that present, but was ignored by those who could ignore it, who it didn't affect, or who didn't care or wanted to perpetuate it. In part, that was because the media, from news to entertainment, could ignore it and didn't want to annoy its white consumers. That perpetuated ignorance - white people rarely talk to black people, especially about racism; they rarely see it in their media; and therefore they didn't know how bad the problem was. Then, when it's reported, white people think it must be exaggerated, because it doesn't match their prior mental model - a viscous circle. That's my experience: I had no idea how omnipresent race issues were until some experiences in my life (unrelated to mass media) changed that. Then I realized it was being covered up, with varying degrees of intention and ignorance. Note also that it's a common response to issues of racism: Do nothing about the racism and attack the messenger. That's arguably the biggest way it's perpetuated. So let's not focus on reporting on racism; what do we do about the much larger issue of racism itself? The former seems discussed on HN much more commonly than the latter.