19 ms·
> Did you know him? Did you ever even see him once? We're going to need to rewrite an awful lot of history if our standards for judging people are "knowing the
by smoldesu 5y ago
> Did you know him? Did you ever even see him once?
We're going to need to rewrite an awful lot of history if our standards for judging people are "knowing them and seeing them even once"
- Stupulous 5y agoI think very little history is about passing judgment on historical figures.
- CRConrad 5y agoI think history is hardly about anything but passing judgment on historical figures.
- Stupulous 5y agoI'm a determinist- I believe that if I were in an identical environment with an identical brain, I would behave identically. Reading social media, I see a lot of value judgments on people that rub me the wrong way- this person should be hated, that person was evil, etc. Extrapolating from my premise, I feel like those judgments apply to me and it stings a little. Reading history, I encounter statements about what people did and about what motivated them to do it in a way that is aligned with my deterministic outlook. I never find myself bristling at a historical biography the way I do in, eg., this thread. The author might want me to judge someone, but they don't tell me to do so or even express directly that that is their belief. I don't think a rule like, "you can't say someone is good/bad if you didn't know them," would result in a change to any history texts I've read, though I expect there are exceptions that I have not seen.
- CRConrad 5y agoYeah, sorry, unclear: Not for the author to pass judgment, but the reader.
- 1123581321 5y agoWe would only need to rewrite the bad history books, which are, to be fair to you, an awful lot of them. :)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- antris 5y agoHistorians do document public figures' personal lives all the time. It's a regular part of the research and not at all uncommon.