5 ms·
The unions also buy off politicians to disastrous effect. In California, you can’t win an election unless the teachers union or the police union backs you, whi
by hedora 5y ago
The unions also buy off politicians to disastrous effect. In California, you can’t win an election unless the teachers union or the police union backs you, which has led to all sorts of insane policies.
Even with that, teachers and police officers are terribly underpaid and also mistreated by the California government.
Unions might be the answer. However, the US has a closed shop system where a few unions have a monopoly on labor relations.
As a result, the existing national unions have repeatedly demonstrated that they’re not interested in improving working conditions for their members.
- ramesh31 5y ago>As a result, the existing national unions have repeatedly demonstrated that they’re not interested in improving working conditions for their members. It always comes down to this. And you can argue endlessly about the various failings of modern organized labor. But ultimately it's all we've got. The capitalists have demonstrated for centuries over and over again that left unchecked they will always take capitalism to a level of borderline subsistence for the working class to maximize profits. Your boss is not looking out for you; ever. To have an organization with funding and influence that has at least professed to defend your rights gives a more realistic chance of having your voice heard, no matter how slight.
- esyir 5y agoSo if they say they'll help and then make things worse, you'd gladly support them? Because that's the impression I get from the other comments that you're responding here; That they have negligible impact on member welfare, but introduce a pile of corruption and bureaucracy into the mix.
- virtue3 5y ago> That they have negligible impact on member welfare That is some -really- strong hyperbole, especially against teacher and police unions as the parent is referring to. I would argue that the benefits teachers get and the relative job security of police offices is a good indicator of a strong labor union for both roles. Sure, pay sucks, but teachers would probably be treated worse than amazon workers at this point if they didn't have them. Source: worked for ed tech startup that supported teachers. Also dated a few.
- esyir 5y agoI'm not American, so I've little personal interaction with these. This is just the impression I get from here, as well as other American core communities I frequent. That I frequently hear how public school teachers are unable to do anything about literal abuse and such does give them credence though.
- teclordphrack2 5y agoWhat type of person puts words in someone else's mouth? Nothing you say seems to have any basis in reality.
- ElViajero 5y ago> I get from the other comments that you're responding here You should be better off ignoring comments from people you do not know, with unknown agendas, and without sources. Amazon is well known for astroturfing and creating "fake" profiles: https://boingboing.net/2021/03/30/twitter-bans-fake-amazon-workers-praising-company.html https://boingboing.net/2021/03/30/twitter-bans-fake-amazon-w... That does not mean that your fellow commenters are Amazon infiltrates or the like, but they can just be repeating misinformation from Amazon anti-union campaigns.
- a3n 5y ago> The unions also buy off politicians to disastrous effect. Any sufficiently entrenched bureaucracy is indistinguishable from corruption. With apologies ...
- Spooky23 5y agoI was a union member for many years. I’m in management now in the same org and am no longer represented. Everyone rags on unions. But you know, I have great healthcare at a fair price, salary is good, protection from management fads like stack ranking, etc. The only real downside IMO is the focus on seniority. The big argument is usually that unions breed mediocrity and incompetence. My staff and colleagues are good at what they do and deliver. I regularly work with contract and consulting companies… they don’t consistently outperform our folks. My sister works at a big tech company. Her negative experiences with idiots, bad managers, etc are pretty similar, and consistent with my past Fortune 50 experiences. Big orgs always have that.
- silexia 5y agoWhen you can't fire bad apples, you end up with problems like the police force having violent cops or racist cops that make everyone look bad. Or you have teachers that refuse to go back to work even though there are vaccines available to them. I think unions make sense in circumstances where a company has a monopoly granted by the government... For example Boeing. Boeing has completed a regulatory capture that makes it nearly impossible to launch competing airline building companies. Unions do not make sense where they do not have a counterparty to negotiate against... Basically there should be no unions for government employees because politicians generally already are willing to do the will of the workers over that of the best interests of the citizens. Unions also do not make sense in highly competitive spaces where if a company underpays or mistreats its employees, those employees can just switch jobs immediately.
- germinalphrase 5y agoI’m a union public school teacher. I am not protected from being fired, I simply must be given a PIP and I can request a Union lawyer help represent me in disciplinary meetings. This is after several years of at-will employment. If my boss wanted me gone next year, I would be.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoThe statistics in New York at least are not encouraging: https://www.the74million.org/article/investigation-nyc-tried-to-fire-154-teachers-for-incompetence-or-misconduct-75-were/ https://www.the74million.org/article/investigation-nyc-tried... Going off-tangent: collective bargaining for teachers is also correlated with decreased lifetime earnings for males: https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20170570 https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/pol.20170570
- coryrc 5y agoThey are not terribly underpaid. They take home about twice the median income after retiring as early as 50 years old! https://californiapolicycenter.org/evaluating-public-safety-pensions-in-california/ https://californiapolicycenter.org/evaluating-public-safety-...
- whyenot 5y agoVoters like police unions and teachers unions, but what they don't like is paying more in taxes. As a public employee, I make $74k a year while living in the Bay Area. I'm at the top of my salary band. Sure, I've got pretty good health insurance, but no better than I would get in tech. I've got a pension, but it will not be enough to live on, and CalPERS has huge liabilities because the voters are unwilling to actually fully fund it. I get three weeks of vacation. I guess that's pretty OK. The one thing I have (besides a job I absolutely enjoy doing), is job security and stability, and that is thanks to my union. It sure would be nice to have a higher salary, but someone has to be willing to pay for it, and nobody wants to do that. Instead, public employees get things that only indirectly cost money, or that don't have to be paid off until sometime in the distant future when the politicians and union bigwigs who agreed to all this stuff are no longer around.
- mycall 5y agoThe union I'm in repeatedly demonstrate they ARE interested in improving working conditions for our members in California. Perhaps AFSCME and AFLCIO are different than the unions you are talking about.
- missedthecue 5y agoTeachers and police officers in California make salaries well above the state median and are entitled to eye-watering pensions as well
- bildung 5y agoThe average income for teachers seems to be $67k in California? That doesn't really sound eye-watering.
- baud147258 5y agoI find the idea of closed shops insane, like all employee have to be union members and there can only be one union
- bildung 5y agoThen you'll be glad to hear these were forbidden in the US in 1947.
- baud147258 5y agoAnd so where are coming from the "closed shop" the parent was talking about?
- bildung 5y agoNo idea, I can only imagine they redefined the word. Closed shops were made illegal by the Taft-Hartley Act. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taft%E2%80%93Hartley_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taft%E2%80%93Hartley_Act
- prepend 5y ago> Even with that, teachers and police officers are terribly underpaid and also mistreated by the California government. The average police salary is $104k in California [0], 35% above the national average. In 2018 at least. And then the pension is 50% after twenty years or service or 90% after 33 years [1], in LA at least. This is one of the best jobs in the country, pay wise. So it’s unusual to hear someone say that police officers are underpaid. [0] https://www.careerexplorer.com/careers/police-officer/salary/california/ https://www.careerexplorer.com/careers/police-officer/salary... [1] https://www.lafpp.com/post/tier-5-pension-plan-information https://www.lafpp.com/post/tier-5-pension-plan-information