8 ms·
I'm so torn on this. On the one hand Amazon and its bad labor relations and squeezing the last drop out of everyone and discarding ones who have no juice left.
by mc32 5y ago
I'm so torn on this.
On the one hand Amazon and its bad labor relations and squeezing the last drop out of everyone and discarding ones who have no juice left. Looking the other way on fraud in their marketplace. Copycatting brands and underselling them with inferior copies (the camera bag[1] for example but many others).
On the other hand, organized labor and its infamous corruption, bullying, and drive to have everyone do as little as possible (sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you) totally undermining progress, improvement and development.
It's hard to pick sides on this one. Both are quite bad and unlikable.
[1]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26545421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26545421
- ticviking 5y agoAmazon could avoid this by not squeezing so hard. Over squeezing labor leads to pushback.
- spodek 5y agoIn this community, I think you can say, "The more you tighten your grip, Bezos, the more star systems will slip through your fingers."
- bpodgursky 5y agoAmazon _has_ avoided this by not squeezing so hard. They have no unionized employees. The latest vote lost by a 75-25 margin, humiliating the union organizing the process. The Teamsters wants to force this issue in the political arena because they can't win votes.
- GavinMcG 5y agoThere are a lot of reasons not to take much away from the Bessemer vote. Well ahead of the vote there were lots of signs that the organizers hadn't, you know, organized.[0] Humiliated, absolutely, but by their own ineptitude. [0] https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/bessemer-alabama-amazon-union/ https://www.thenation.com/article/activism/bessemer-alabama-...
- bpodgursky 5y agoReally? This was national news for weeks. President Biden flew down there and talked to them! I cannot possibly imagine what more organizing could have accomplished.
- smegger001 5y agoi think the public media publicity campaign was well organized but the on the ground campaigning to the actual warehouse workers themselves was not. IE there were more interested in a national story and just assumed they had the workers in the bag.
- GavinMcG 5y agoOrganizing involves building close relationships amongst a larger and larger network of people. The President flying somewhere doesn't do that. The article describes this. The Democratic party often confuses activism and media presence with organizing, and focuses on get-out-the-vote and media strategy without having done the work of organizing strongly-tied networks on the ground. The Obama campaign was the exception, because Obama had worked as an on-the-ground organizer.
- zdragnar 5y agoIf they can't organize a vote campaign, do you really want them negotiating your employment terms against a company like Amazon?
- GavinMcG 5y agoYes? Organizing is very very hard. There are lots of people bad at organizing who still are capable negotiators and who understand my interests as a worker and how to protect them.
- zdragnar 5y agoThe union in this case isn't some cash-poor startup with people filling multiple roles that they aren't qualified for. They certainly have more than enough resources and experience to do much better... or, as the case may be, to start with a different location that would have been more receptive.
- triceratops 5y ago> sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you Honest question. If you're paid hourly and have job security, what's wrong with saying that? Pros don't work for free, right?
- mc32 5y agoSo if I'm not in a union (salaried or hourly) I can do someone a favor or someone can do me a favor. Union members get "ratted out" by others if they go "above and beyond". There is no flexibility.
- triceratops 5y ago> There is no flexibility. That's fair. The "I only sweep floors, if you want mopping it's another department" type of union inflexibility is terrible for productivity. But I think your scenario is an example of inflexibility that's completely warranted.
- jtdev 5y agoWhat you describe is a fallacy... it's more like: "I'm a heavy machinery operator, not a welder; if you need a weld, you'll need to requisition a welder."
- bluGill 5y agoI've been in places where you can't move your PC to the other side of your desk.
- dugmartin 5y agoA long time ago in grad school I had a administrative assistantship in the university's physical plant. My boss (basically the head of IT for the department) and I moved a couple of computers between buildings as they had actively used applications on them (this was before the web) and we couldn't wait for someone from building services come and do it. The next day I was in his office when we got a nice visit from the Teamsters steward flanked literally by two huge guys glaring at us. The steward told us not to do it again. He did back off when we told him we walked the computers between the buildings - if we would have drove them between buildings he said they would have filed a union grievance.
- btown 5y ago> undermining progress, improvement, and development An honest question - whose progress? Whose development? Do workers benefit by turning that screw at 5:01? There are many companies where laborers do benefit by having the freedom to work outside the box to benefit their careers, learn, take pride and ownership in a long-term project, foster their own creativity, and in aggregate lift the local community. I’d fully understand your point in such circumstances, and agree that certain unions work against those less-tangible benefits for their members, at times in excess. But Amazon specifically has designed itself to destroy alignment between warehouse workers and company goals. Promotion from the warehouse floor is actively discouraged (this is well documented), turnover is expected and encouraged well beyond industry norms, tasks are rote and automatically fed, no project is long enough to foster ownership, no operating procedure or penny of local profit not controlled by corporate from afar. Does this sound like an a situation where labor and company interests are at all aligned? Amazon will not change this status quo at the behest of any single individual at any level; it sees no strategic value in empowering any such individual. Organizing is the natural consequence of such a situation.
- cycomanic 5y ago>An honest question - whose progress? Whose development? Do workers benefit by turning that screw at 5:01? Yes these sort of tropes are being brought out repeatedly, is there any evidence they actually exist? Let's talk teachers union who people like to criticise a lot. There's still plenty of excellent teachers around who go above and beyond for their students (and if you are invested in what you're doing teaching is definitely not a 9-5 job). So they are not prevented by their union from doing that? I think this is all from the expectation of employees to go above and beyond for their employers. Just do this 10min extra unpaid work because it really needs to be done... On the other hand, no company or contractor will do that, they will charge you handsomely.
- bluGill 5y agoDepends very much on the locations. I've worked in union shops where I wasn't union, and I was warned to ensure nobody is watching when I plug in my test equipment for the embedded system I was working on. In a different location for the same company the union guys were cool and would pretend not to see me do that (same union, just different workplace culture in different cities).
- ElViajero 5y ago> sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you Alternative view: "I have a life outside work, now I am free to enjoy that life as a normal human being." It is devastating to me to see people thinking that to go home and take care of yourself and your loved ones is "undermining progress, improvement and development". Your family and friends are important, your company is going to fire you just to make share price go up before the end of the quarter. Even if firing you is hurting "progress, improvement and development" of the company in the long term.
- bluGill 5y agoWhich is why I sometimes leave early. The union guys who finish early stand at the door until the 5:00 bell rings because they are not allowed to leave early even if their work for the day is done, while as a non-union employee if I'm done a bit early I get to leave. Sometimes I work until 5:30, sometimes I'm out at 4:30. It all works out.
- CPLX 5y agoWe are talking about Amazon warehouse and logistics workers here. They wear location tracking smartphones and get fired by text message if their bathroom breaks are too frequent.
- cowsandmilk 5y agoYou are describing the difference between hourly and non-hourly employees, not union vs. non-union. Many companies won’t let hourly employees work past the end of your shift because of overtime rules regardless of whether or not there’s a union.
- lpolovets 5y agoI'd err on the side of Amazon because the free market is more likely to address their practices. My hunch is that corruption, bullying, etc don't go away. Organizations don't stop doing those things unless they lose their power. On the other hand, if a company like Amazon is treating workers poorly, then a competitive environment should fix that in the long run. E.g. if Amazon overworks its people while other companies don't, either Amazon has to pay more and more if its working conditions are worse and worse (relative to peers), or it'll have to improve working conditions to keep its workers.
- orthecreedence 5y agoUnions are the product of free markets.
- mc32 5y agoSo there were no unions in the Soviet Union and no unions in North Korea? That’s good to know.
- orthecreedence 5y agoYou're being obtuse. Unions in the USSR and unions in a free market capitalist system serve different purposes. There is some truth to what you're saying though: unions exist where there is a struggle between labor and private ownership. The existence of them in a "socialist" mode of production (barring some kind of syndicalist setup in which economic governance happens specifically through unions) seems superfluous and suggests that private ownership had not been abolished but was relegated to the state/bureaucracy instead of wealthy holders of capital.
- cmckn 5y agoExcept the harm is not theoretical, and such a market correction doesn’t happen overnight. People don’t deserve to be ground to a pulp while your simulation plays out.
- 5y ago
- cestith 5y agoIf it's an emergency, pay overtime for that screw. If you regularly need a second shift, hire one. Understaffing is a problem caused by management and it's not the worker's fault or their family's fault if you can't make 40 hours of use out of them in 40 hours or pay a little overtime.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoThe 5:01 is probably exaggerated a bit, most people won't be too anal about doing a little overtime if they're nearly done for the day. But having those protections in place is important, because an employer may start taking advantage of it - slippery slope argument, but bear with me. A common example - not just in the US but on my side of the pond as well - is closing time. There's a lot of people that get paid until closing time (e.g. 9PM in the DIY store I worked at as a part-time job during my college days), but, nobody goes home until the last people are out and the day's take is put in the (time locked) safe (and there'll be a security guy waiting outside to make sure it's safe, then he'll drive around back to make sure everybody's out and safe). If all goes smoothly, that's 20 minutes of unpaid overtime - but it can be more. That's just one example, but I'm sure it's relatable to a lot of people. Think kitchen staff who work until close, but have to clean up and prepare for the next day outside of their normal working hours. TL;DR: Don't work for free, your employer is not your friend, your time is worth more to you than his and his business is.
- adriancr 5y ago> sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw If you're getting paid for 9-5 with no overtime, why should you put in unpaid effort if you don't want to?, if you want to, all on you. Rephrasing would be: what would happen if your boss asked you to work a few more hours overtime unpaid?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jtdev 5y ago> "corruption, bullying, and drive to have everyone do as little as possible" <-- this exact same verbiage could be used to describe the current state of affairs sans unionization.
- Frondo 5y ago> sorry, it's 5:01 and You are entitled to your time. If you're set to work til 5, then your employer should pay you a minute's overtime if they need you to turn that screw. Why would you volunteer for someone else's money-making venture?