5 ms·
> there is no superfluous data inside, The Dutch government disagrees. Their app implementation will have the ability to generate two codes, one for events wit
by jeroenhd 5y ago
> there is no superfluous data inside,
The Dutch government disagrees. Their app implementation will have the ability to generate two codes, one for events within the borders and one for the EU pass.
The reason behind this is that the Dutch QR code only contains the bare minimum of personal information to identify you. By default this means the day and month of birth and your initials, unless you share those among many other citizens. In that case, more data may be added, such as your full first name or year of birth.
While the amount of personal data exposed through the QR code is small and not a privacy risk in my opinion, it does have some points where it can improve. Still, it's not a bad system from a technical point of view.
My problem with the entire system is that this code is basically a free pass for all the old people we've stayed inside for a year for to go on holiday, while everyone else gets to go through all the same hoops they've been going through for months. If the vaccinations were spread randomly across the population, I'd be perfectly okay with such a system, but in real life all the old people got their shots first. Things may be different in other countries, but here the vaccinations are still going, with only half the population having had a first shot.
The underlying message is clear, there's no solidarity between the age groups. I had to pause my social life to protect the people aged 50+, but those people aren't willing to put off their holiday for me in return. I'm sure the underlying reason for implementing this system is economic, it's the EU after all, trying to save tourist-oriented economies and all that.
I'll get my pass somewhere near the end of August (two weeks after my second shot), past the holiday period. Parents will have to wait for even longer if they want to travel with their kids, because kids are all the way at the end of the vaccination line if they even get them at all.
With the Indian covid variant ravaging Portugal and the seasonal effect, I do wonder how long this system will last. It's only a matter of time before some mutant shows up that's resistant to a certain vaccine and we start from scratch.
- float4 5y ago> By default this means the day and month of birth and your initials, unless you share those among many other citizens. In that case, more data may be added This sounds like k-anonymity, in which case the k is usually made public. Any idea what value they chose?
- La1n 5y agoIt's the opposite isn't it? k-anonymity would remove data until you are the same as k others, whereas this adds data (such as first name), so you are not the same as many others?
- float4 5y agoThere's the privacy-utility tradeoff in data anonymisation, but most algorithms focus primarily on privacy. There usually are no parameters that promise any kind of utility, only parameters that promise privacy. In this case it looks like they want a guarantee on both, which makes sense. (So yeah, you're right, this definitely isn't just k-anonymity)
- Tepix 5y ago> My problem with the entire system is that this code is basically a free pass for all the old people we've stayed inside for a year for to go on holiday, while everyone else gets to go through all the same hoops they've been going through for months. I don't understand. Why does it bother you if someone else is allowed to meet her friends again after being vaccinated and you are not? If they sit alone at home instead, how does it benefit you? The reason why they had to isolate themselves (being at risk of dying and infecting others) is gone. That means there is also no legal legitimation to restrict the people's basic human rights any longer than necessary.
- cr1895 5y agoThe vaccine QR code only matters for large events or travel abroad, so the example about meeting friends makes no difference whether you’re vaccinated or not. In any case, while it is certainly nicer to be vaccinated, it’s possible to get free PCR tests for the equivalent access.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoSo no football games with friends, and no friends abroad? PCR test cost around 100eur in slovenia, and take a day or two. Fast tests (HAT) are free, but the waiting lines are 1-3hours, because of all the groups that have to do mandatroy testings each week.
- cr1895 5y ago>So no football games with friends, and no friends abroad? No, that's not true. I've mentioned it in a few comments now, but for events within Netherlands there is no cost - you can either have your (free) vaccination check or you can get a free PCR test and have a time-limited entry code. PCR tests for this purpose are always free in NL. And the Netherlands is covering the cost of PCR tests for travel through July and August, by which point any adult who wants a vaccine can have had one.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago
- iSnow 5y ago> It's only a matter of time before some mutant shows up that's resistant to a certain vaccine and we start from scratch. That's not a given. There's an evolutionary space for mutations the virus that isn't endless. It seems far from clear that it can generate escape mutants that are resistant to the current vaccines, for that it would have to turn into a completely different virus. >We emphasize, however, that enhanced transmissibility, rather than immunoevasion or greater lethality, would be considered the most potent path for the virus to become more fit and viable. >Indeed, more-fit variants can be expected to emerge over time [...], but we believe that these will not continue to emerge indefinitely: nothing is infinite in nature, and eventually the virus will reach its form of ‘maximum transmission’ https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-021-01421-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-021-01421-7
- Pyramus 5y agoThat's exactly right. As of today, some virologists think that we are already seeing early signs of convergence among virus variants, i.e. the same mutations appearing in different variants. It's early speculation and there is no guarantee, but it's certainly not given that there will be a variant that forces us to start from scratch.
- cr1895 5y agoIt’s an unfortunate reality but why shouldn’t people who are protected be able to take advantage of that? It’s older generations in broad strokes, but also people who were at higher risk, healthcare workers, people who’ve been vaccinated already abroad, etc. It’s not so simple as old vs young and even if it were I don’t see the solution as keeping everyone at a disadvantage because you are bitter that others got vaccinated sooner. Furthermore, it is possible to take advantage of everything a person with a vaccine pass can do with a (free!) PCR test. It’s even paid for by the government for July and August for travel abroad. Also, it’s definitely far from certain that some mutation will evaporate all of the progress made. It’s not helpful to speculate like that.
- novaRom 5y agoGermany here. Life of many children has become a nightmare. Good luck with any travel with PCR tests, 120 Euro each, and you need at least 2 per child. There's no vaccine for children under 12, and it's officially not recommended for those who is healthy under 16. Many families are now struggling. Even getting a non-PCR quick test which is free requires lots of additional time (this is required for any indoor activity).
- cr1895 5y agoThe context of the above was Netherlands, where there is no widespread quick testing-on-entry as there is in Germany. There is largely no restriction in day-to-day life in the Netherlands (and even less in the coming weeks), with or without a vaccine QR code; the code would apply for access to large events or travel. Also in Netherlands the government is paying for travel PCR tests through July and August. These countries have taken quite different approaches. You do raise an excellent point that this vaccine system excludes children.
- morsch 5y agoYou can currently travel (and return) freely to loads of places without a vaccination, a test, or a document, or anything. Seems a bit disingenuous not to mention that. Also, PCR tests are available for way less than 120 EUR. That's not to say the past year wasn't particularly difficult to families with children and young people in general.
- akie 5y ago> My problem with the entire system is that this code is basically a free pass for all the old people we've stayed inside for a year for to go on holiday, while everyone else gets to go through all the same hoops they've been going through for months. Would you have preferred to be one of the people whose lives were in danger because of this disease? There's a good reason they got the first vaccinations.
- jeroenhd 5y agoI'm not opposed to vaccinating the weak and elderly first, but the choice to also give them their freedoms back first leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I'd like for everyone to be healthy, but also for everyone to be subject to the same restrictions. The youth sacrificed a year of their lives for the elderly, and in exchange they'll have their freedoms restricted for longer while the elderly they've sacrificed their time for get a free pass to holidays and concerts.
- distances 5y agoYou get the same freedoms with free covid tests, right? Except when traveling abroad and having to pay for the same test. This is only about convenience as far as I see, greatly helping the tourism industry. What would be your ideal solution, requiring the same tests from everyone?
- mhitza 5y agoI don't know where you live but in most countries PCR tests aren't free. There are some EU countries that will have you take one if you didn't bring your result along (and it will be free of charge), but then you might need to spend a day or more in self isolation till the test result is reported back.
- distances 5y agoYes, cross-border traveling is definitely harder and more expensive without vaccinations. Easier domestically. I'm just not convinced that we should require the same tests even after vaccinations even if it now leads to uneven amount of hassle.