4 ms·
there's a difference between the US treating TikTok or WeChat differently even compared to American companies vs the fact that China just has an entirely differ
by Barrin92 5y ago
there's a difference between the US treating TikTok or WeChat differently even compared to American companies vs the fact that China just has an entirely different legal framework. Facebook or Twitter aren't banned because they're American, they're banned because they're not willing to comply with Chinese law at all, which Chinese companies themselves are subject to. Bing operates in China, as do a bunch of other large American tech firms.
- vmception 5y agoChinese law is incredibly anticompetitive. These companies are willing to comply with Chinese laws but these laws just screw them so they exit the market, then the Chinese censors block access to their domain names as it is impossible that they are complying on the information side of things. Separate and nuanced issue, as you pointed out. But not complete.
- ethanbond 5y agoI’m absolutely not a fan of China’s behavior here (and in many other areas), but if it’s true that these companies “exit the market,” then getting blocked by the firewall doesn’t mean anything. What they mean by “exit the market” is to still actually participate in the market but not take on any of its obligations (again, despite my own disagreement with the “obligations”)
- Barrin92 5y ago>These companies are willing to comply with Chinese laws They're really not. This is why Google exited China. The reason why some American tech firms don't operate in China isn't because they can't handle regulatory compliance (they obviously can given their size and resources), they don't operate in China because complying with Chinese laws would create absolutely bad PR in the United States. Which means this is not an issue of free-trade but of internal US politics between domestic companies and the public. The United States states isn't treated unfairly, it's just for the first time experiencing what it means to not be able to enforce American standards abroad.
- mcwhy 5y agoFacebook is 100% willing, zuck even sold his kid to them trying to get in.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoI want to downrank this but even more I want to ask what exactly your thesis is here
- ectopod 5y agoFWIW, I assume the GP is referring to this: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/china-s-president-xi-jinping-turns-down-mark-zuckerberg-s-request-to-name-his-unborn-child-at-white-house-dinner-a6679156.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/china-s-president-...
- jazzyjackson 5y agoAha, well if Page Six says so… Thanks for the link
- canadianfella 5y agoExplain
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vmception 5y agoAgain, just like doing business in the US or Europe isnt a single factor, its not a single factor in China either You finally brought up Google, we didnt. Google is the primary example of the anticompetitive nature, where the state used its mandatory backdoors to steal IP from Google and give it to Baidu. Mmm bad PR ok, possible a factor
- pclmulqdq 5y agoChinese law is extremely hostile to foreign companies, forcing them to give up their IP and have a large operating presence in China (including a political arm of the CCP within the company). No other country is so hostile to foreigners, and international pressure should be applied to get then to change this behavior. It is antithetical to free trade and free markets. It is completely understandable that foreign companies are staying out of China, because China effectively bans them from operating unless they are local companies.
- dumb1224 5y ago> ..have a large operating presence in China (including a political arm of the CCP within the company) I've never heard of this, do you have examples? I'll be happy to read about it. Normally there will be some PR/communication office under marketing sure, but I don't know what a 'political arm' could be.
- yorwba 5y agoIt's article 19 of the Company Law of the People's Republic of China: http://mg2.mofcom.gov.cn/article/policy/China/201910/20191002905610.shtml http://mg2.mofcom.gov.cn/article/policy/China/201910/2019100... Article 19: In a company, an organization of the Communist Party of China shall be established to carry out the activities of the party in accordance with the charter of the Communist Party of China. The company shall provide the necessary conditions for the activities of the party organization. However, I don't think think this can be filed under "hostility to foreigners", since Chinese companies are subject to the same requirements.
- dumb1224 5y agoI agree. It doesn't read anything like a 'political arm' requirement. A chinese page for explanation: http://www.gongsifa.net/jieshi/gongsizhongdegongchandangzuzhi.html http://www.gongsifa.net/jieshi/gongsizhongdegongchandangzuzh... It simply means a company should allow party members to form smallest units (if >3 people) and organise events according to party rules.
- 5y ago
- hulitu 5y ago> there's a difference between the US treating TikTok or WeChat differently even compared to American companies vs the fact that China just has an entirely different legal framework. This is pure propaganda. There is absolutely no difference. Both steal your data, both will cause you trouble at border control ( see obligation to give your phone for searching at US border some years ago).
- ethanbond 5y agoAh yes, overzealous intelligence agencies exist (who can be and do get sued) and borders exist, therefore there’s “absolutely no difference” between US and Chinese law. All global superpowers sometimes ban cartoon characters for hurting their leaders’ feelings! No differences. https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-china-blog-40627855 https://www.bbc.com/news/blogs-china-blog-40627855 The claim there is absolutely no difference is self-evidently untrue. There’s no member of the CCP who would claim such a thing. The US and China are very different places with very different cultures, which gets reflected in their respective laws.
- nirav72 5y agowhile I've heard of few incidents of devices being searched..I've never had any such issues where U.S CBP wanted to search my phone or laptop when entering the U.S.