14 ms·
Political trolling twice as popular as positivity, study suggests
- vorpalhex 5y agoI was very ready to suggest this must be an old article, but no it really is only six hours old. I suppose doing good statistical work takes time, but this feels like the obvious truth that every single product manager has known since KPIs were invented for social media engagement - anger and fury are the best for engagement. This isn't news either. Ryan Holliday's "Trust me, I'm lying" talks about this in depth and was published in 2012. I am quite sure folks before him discussed this as well. We could fix social media tomorrow if we disabled resharing/retweeting/whatever and removed likes, make timelines/feeds strictly linear time based. You want to be an epic troll? Fine, copy and paste your content in. That's enough of a barrier that social media would go back to being reasonably decent.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago> We could fix social media tomorrow if we disabled resharing/retweeting/whatever and removed likes, make timelines/feeds strictly linear time based. There is too much revenue to be made in not fixing the problem. Witness the pushback with Apple “only” warning users about tracking data and the force with which Facebook tried to push back. I don’t believe there is a solution. Social media companies have weaponized fundamental rights (freedom of speech) and human emotion for profit. You can’t minimize the harm without infringing on those rights, and social media will fight to the end to enable what engagement looks like on their terms. https://www.cnet.com/news/facebook-vs-apple-heres-what-you-need-to-know-about-their-privacy-feud/ https://www.cnet.com/news/facebook-vs-apple-heres-what-you-n...
- nixpulvis 5y agohttps://youtu.be/Hag2JWC8qZ0 https://youtu.be/Hag2JWC8qZ0 @1:50
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mrDmrTmrJ 5y agoThe 'abundance of revenue' is why banning reshares/retweets change will only happen if forced through via legislation. Tobacco companies would sell cigarettes to kids if we let them. Car manufactures fought mandatory seat belt regulations for decades too...
- mindvirus 5y agoI think the solution is a legal one. I think laws around users being able to delete their content, around tracking, and protecting people's jobs from social media pile-ons would go a long way in detoxifying the internet.
- travisgriggs 5y agoJust tax ad revenue. Really really tax it. Outlawing/prohibiting things in the west is too hard. But we're good at lobbying and taxing things.
- chasd00 5y agoIf you keep using taxes as punishment then people will perceive being taxed only as being punished.
- NullPrefix 5y agoNext thing you know there will be an ad industry bailout, like the California $100 million weed bailout.
- proc0 5y ago> There is too much revenue to be made in not fixing the problem This is always the excuse, but it's really not true. Once you put ethical constrains on business, new soutions arise and then people start to see the difference. This is what's happening with renewable energy. Social media needs to start innovating in this area.
- XorNot 5y agoThat's for anyone who's not in advertising. Advertising and marketing are perhaps some of the scummiest businesses on the planet at the low end because they plain do not care about anything but user-response rates. And however you slice it, Google, Facebook and Twitter are all in the advertising business - that's where they make the bulk of their money. Amazon, ironically, kind of isn't (but has been more then happy to not fix it's SKU/fakes problem for years). At the end of the day when someone wants to make a change at any of those organizations, it's the advertisers who are pointing to charts of potential lost revenue and reminding everyone who's salary is paid for by who.
- proc0 5y agoGood point, but I can still see the possibility of somef feature where people are at least warned about or have to go through some disclaimer when posting on certain subject matters, and this causes the whole platform to be more positive, open minded, and improving the lives of people in significant ways. All current major platforms are getting a lot of heat for being so corrosive to society in some form or another, I think soon there should be more demand for more wholesome social media sites that do some innovation in terms of how they reward attention, but I agree, advertising is the lowest form of business model or whatever it is.
- sokoloff 5y agoI’m pretty sure I’d find that way less appealing than the current situation. I want to see a curated feed of what’s most interesting (as gauged by any system that can approximately judge for me, and a good one is what other people engaged with). I discover other Twitter accounts to follow via sharing/commenting/follower graphs. It’s why I read the top news (/news) here and not /newest. I don’t want to miss my cousin’s cute baby pic or my niece’s graduation pics or other popular posts just because trolls forced a order by id desc onto a weak product owner. If other people get wrapped around axles over political, religious, or cultural posts, so be it. I go to social media to see interesting things.
- AgentME 5y agoYeah I tried using Mastodon for a while (decentralized Twitter clone that happens to only show posts in linear time order), and I quickly got sick of it because I almost purely saw the posts from the most active people I followed, and almost never the meatier posts from the people I followed who posted less often. I have this issue much less on Twitter with its algorithmic feed so I went back to Twitter. I'm baffled by how often I see people espouse linear timelines over algorithmic timelines like it's obviously superior; if they've actually tried it and liked it then they must follow a very different kind of mix of people than I do.
- JoshTriplett 5y ago> I almost purely saw the posts from the most active people I followed I'm very careful to select people to follow who won't drown out my timeline. Sometimes I come across someone with interesting content, but they tweet several dozen times a day, so I just don't follow them.
- TheTester 5y ago> That's enough of a barrier that social media would go back to being reasonably decent. When has social media been "reasonably decent", I think that "boomers, karens, nontrolls and the moderate" crowd have forgotten how the internet really was before social media gave them everything they wanted. SOrry but just no like the actual things that you used to see on the old internet were too much compared to today's mild trolling just as an evidence see all the left and right wing pundits pruned from leedit. SOcial media was never supposed to be a calm place, it was supposed to be dangerous and fun. If anything we dont have to make the internet like that, instead we require a solution analogous to this https://www.outsideonline.com/2360451/make-driving-dangerous-again https://www.outsideonline.com/2360451/make-driving-dangerous...
- amadeuspagel 5y ago> We could fix social media tomorrow if we disabled resharing/retweeting/whatever and removed likes What about votes? How are upvotes different from likes? It's just different terminology.
- vorpalhex 5y agoSo HN's system is unique since only you can see your "score", and a post maxes out at -4. I think it works well since you can derive some info about how useful a post is, and downvotes are rare. It can still lead to people trying to maximize score instead of content. With a system like reddit which is mostly visible, brigading and using downvotes as a weapon is much much more prevalent and probably could do with either tweaking or removal. There is some feedback you want from votes, which is something like the upvote to downvote ratio as a measure of controversy for a given post.
- amadeuspagel 5y ago> So HN's system is unique since only you can see your "score" That's true for individual comments, but there's a total karma score that everyone can see. And even for individual comments you can see when they're downvoted. > and a post maxes out at -4. A tweet maxes out at 0. You can't have negative likes. > It can still lead to people trying to maximize score instead of content. Sure. You have that tradeoff in any system. If you don't have anything that is in some sense a "score" at all, people might not particpate at all, or not put any effort into it, if you do have a score then people might try to maximize it in ways you don't like.
- genmud 5y agoSurely you jest.
- mpartel 5y agoMany similarly depressing results: https://ledger.humanetech.com/ https://ledger.humanetech.com/
- dukeofdoom 5y agoPeople take the internet too seriously. So its easy to troll them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- seanwilson 5y ago> "You can call it trolling, some people call it 'dunking'," Mr Rathje said. I remember when first using internet forums, a "troll" was someone who posted stuff in discussions for no other purpose than to wind people up, as if it was a sport. "Feeding the trolls" was heavily frowned upon because replying to trolls made you part of the problem. Trolling only works when people engage and post about how outraged they are. It's interesting how people were wise to trolling before social media. It's made even worse now with the media, even misusing the world "troll" in their articles while they help to feed them and create careers out of trolling. When was the original definition of troll forgotten along with the "don't feed the trolls" mantra? How do we bring it back so people realise they're part of the problem when they reply to obvious trolling?
- redisman 5y agoThe trolls became professional opinion havers on Twitter and millions of fools started amplifying their message
- wnevets 5y agoHow do professional opinion havers on Twitter make a living? Normally "influencers" get paid to feature products/services on their social media or YouTube adverts, I don't see that happening with these trolls. Someone must be funding them.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI assumed they were all freelancing.
- TheTester 5y agousually "journalism" An example of this was gamergate were a lot of people that nobody cared about started spouting unhinged opinions with the clear intention of getting hateengagement from gamers, as a result they could cry and take money from progressives for their "projects" and also get nice positions in places like Kotaku because they knew how to get those hate clicks, just like vice. Turns out a lot of modern journalism consists on writing clickbait that gets engagement so a lot of those trolls just had to do the same and add some writing to pretend they actually care about issues
- daenz 5y agoThe mistake would be to assume that the outcomes of this study will be used to heal political discourse. Knowing social media companies, the takeaway here will be to focus on facilitating political trolling, since it will make their platforms more popular.
- nixpulvis 5y agoI stopped reading after this: > Social media posts are twice as likely to go viral if they are negative about politicians they oppose rather than positive about those they support, a Cambridge University study suggests. Which rectified my original problem with comparing "trolling" to "positivity". Anyways, this seems like non-news to me. Let's see those upvotes!
- mrDmrTmrJ 5y agoFascinatingly, a similar effect shows up in science. "Science Studies Most Likely to Be Wrong Are the Most Widely Read": https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2021-05-24/science-studies-most-likely-to-be-wrong-are-the-most-widely-read https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2021-05-24/...
- keyb0ardninja 5y agoVeritasium made a video about this: https://youtu.be/42QuXLucH3Q https://youtu.be/42QuXLucH3Q
- koheripbal 5y agoThey make a great point that modern media is about generating addiction. ...Outrage --> Hate --> Gratification --> Outrage --> Hate... Step 1. Outrage: Strike the audience with some gross injustice - true or not - it's always useful to exaggerate. Make sure to use an echo chamber so no one can diffuse the emotion with a different perspective. Step 2. Hate: Define a target. Demonize this target to create an emotional investment by the reader. Pile on ancillary "facts" to give the illusion of rigor. Truth is irrelevant as few will research independently. Step 3. Follow up with some form of "justice" (usually better to do this at a later update). It doesn't matter if the subject was really hurt, as long as you can make it appear that the "bad guys" actually won in some way. repeat.
- heresie-dabord 5y agoFrom the first paragraph of the usnews article: > Studies that can't be verified and may be untrue are much more likely to be cited in the media because they tend to be more interesting "Interesting" -- ha! A media business knows its clientele and shovels useful fodder to fill the clients' daily trough. The difference today is that people carry a portable trough with them everywhere. What is "interesting" to people varies, but what is profitable to media business is clear: purveying ignorance is more lucrative and sustains marketshare. This may be the biggest socio-political problem of the era. Democracy depends on the success of education and social discourse. I think people _do_ want education and healthy discourse... but their worse impulses are being nourished. Even old-style media companies knew how to turn nonsense into profit. There is a clientele for prepackaged, facile ignorance. It's the art of propaganda. Social media has revealed that significant numbers of people proudly maintain and propagate brutish thinking. The modern educational system seems helpless to counteract this phenomenon. Using modern portable tools, it has become easier than ever to propagate ignorance. It's not just the people, though. It's the people and the "corporate citizens" who are looting civilisation.
- EGreg 5y agohttps://rational.app https://rational.app
- OGforces 5y agoIncorrect uses of “trolling” many times more popular than accurate ones, several headlines for years have suggested
- akomtu 5y agoIt's because insulting the rival camp prompts insults in the opposite direction and now the first camp feels obliged to respond. The art of trolling is finding a topic that offends the biggest number of participants. The curve of engagement, i.e. the number of agitated people over time, probably looks like a gaussian. This would be an interesting topic to research, something that would make social studies a science.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> insulting the rival camp prompts insults in the opposite direction and now the first camp feels obliged to respond In my experience, the two (or more) camps are often not communicating. A totem of a position representing the other side is attacked, with the trolling responses imputed versus observed. A good fraction of the politically-oriented meme communities on Reddit, for example, could happily continue through the heat death of the universe without ever requiring any input from the "other side."
- LAC-Tech 5y agoOne big thing I've noticed is that the language used is also completely different. The words different camps use simply do not mean the same thing. Yet people try and communicate (argue) regardless.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoYeah, successful trolling more than anything is about being in the right place at the right time. A good troll casts a spark on a pile of dry leaves, a bad troll takes a blowtorch to a pile of damp logs.
- ElViajero 5y agoWhen I was a kid, TV was full of content like "Beyond 2000" were the general population was introduced to possibilities for the future, to what technology will bring to our lives, to what possibilities were out there. There were many problems, probably more than nowadays, but there was a big space for hope. Where all that content has gone? I have found many YouTube channels that show this kind of futuristic content, but views are in the 100K never millions. Do people have lost hope? Do people want to just watch negative content? I do not think so. My guess, and it is just a guess, is that people want to see high-quality content that gives them hopes for the future. But, as choosing fried food over a salad, there is a short term reward that changes that decision. You could go for the salad, you decided at home that today you will choose a healthy fresh salad, but once in the restaurant you choose fried chicken and fries. When I was a kid, people loved these programs that offered a glimpse into possible futures, kids wanted to be astronauts and technology was magical. Ironically, with so many options today, people chooses things that are bad for their mental health. But, I do not know how to change that.
- Afforess 5y agoyes. people have lost hope. the US life expectancy is declining year over year. wealth accrued by young people is declining compared to prev generations. housing is unaffordable nationwide now. education, healthcare, and housing costs are eating all productivity gains. people choose "vices" because poverty is literally painful. fix the material conditions and people will want the future again.
- goatse-4-u 5y agoAs always, the truth is at the bottom on HN.
- nine_zeros 5y ago> Do people have lost hope? Do people want to just watch negative content? Most people are too tired of the never ending rat race. They use content to escape from reality of their lives. The alternate fantasy world where everything is blamed on incompetent leaders is appealing. And deservedly so.
- anoncake 5y agoKim Jong Un is a great leader. The North Korean people couldn't wish for a better one. This wouldn't be considered trolling but positivity by the study, would it?
- chaostheory 5y agoThis mixed with the widening gap between the haves and have nots, and a potential giant economic correction are signs of a great disaster.
- gerash 5y agoTools like Twitter have turned into an outrage sharing machine, perhaps unintentionally. Everything is a snippet, a short context and evidence free photo or video followed by lots of anonymous outrage. There is also this virtual lynching on such platforms of often unlucky people without any due process, very primal. It's addictive but not healthy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- camillomiller 5y agoDo we need any other proof that the model on which Facebook based its success is not connecting people but rather selling hate? How long shall we still indulge Zuckerberg’s denial?
- heavyset_go 5y agoI think tragedies like this[1] one really drive this point home. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
- noisy_boy 5y agoTrolling/gossiping etc are basically junk food for the mind; its not something that should be encouraged, is not good for the health, can be somewhat liberating when done in moderation, is difficult to control, feels great when you are doing it and feels shitty later.
- amadeuspagel 5y ago> Social media posts are twice as likely to go viral if they are negative about politicians they oppose rather than positive about those they support, a Cambridge University study suggests. This paragraph seems a lot more neutral then the headline. A pretty straightforward explanation for this is that if there are more then two politicians competing in a race, a negative post about a politician is going to be liked by supporters of all other politicians, but a positive post is only going to be liked by supporters of that politician. For example, in the 2016 race, Sanders and Trump supporters might have liked negative posts about Hillary Clinton, Sanders and Clinton supporters negative posts about Trump, etc..
- SNosTrAnDbLe 5y agoWhile Facebook and Twitter are definitely to blame, we should also look at the smartphone for creating this dystopia. Today, the smartphone makes it very easy to go the internet and shout at someone just because you had a bad minute or a bad second. It also makes it very easy to produce and consume multi media. Maybe its just me but I feel like the Internet used to be more wholesome in the pre smartphone era. A big reason that I keep coming back to HN is that it does not allow any images and videos.
- jmiskovic 5y agoIt is easy to understand why social networks promote such content, user engagement is the simplest metric for optimization. But why do readers prefer negativity? It comes down to ego. Confirming the bias that "they" are wrong, stupid and corrupted gives "us" right to feel superior. Not sure what could help here. Maybe teaching children to recognize their own biases?
- rdiddly 5y agoAnother day, another word (trolling) stripped of meaning.
- olivermarks 5y agoAnonymous free communication platform tools with a potential audience in the millions combined with sophisticated bot trolling algos have resulted in disaster. I'm guilty of hounding politicians on Twitter in an attempt to reform the US Democratic party and need to get a healthier attitude. I think it's the combination of sheer frustration and the ability to react to the latest bureaucratic idiocy via the keyboards that are on my body far too much of my life...That and the meteoric drop in standards and credibility of the old media despite corporate TV's crushing and inexplicable hold over people as a credible 'news' source.
- oxymoran 5y agoProof that most people are a-holes
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]